Recognising Palestinian state now would only serve to embolden extremists who want to bring terror to UK streets
No one could fail to be appalled by the suffering of Palestinians being beamed across the world.
5
5
The conflict was triggered by the massacre, rape and hostage-taking of Israeli civilians by Hamas terrorists on October 7, 2023.
But Israel's response to eliminate the threat of Hamas is taking a terrible toll on ordinary Palestinians.
Some of the most gruesome pictures of malnourished children seem to be manipulated by the Hamas propaganda department, but nearly everyone involved agrees the food shortage in Gaza is real and acute.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer is clearly personally deeply moved by the unfolding tragedy and is also being pressured by many of his own Labour MPs to follow the lead of French President Emmanuel Macron, who wants France and others formally to recognise Gaza and the West Bank as the nation state of Palestine at a UN conference on the issue in September.
Yesterday, Sir Keir appeared to give in to that pressure. After an emergency cabinet meeting, the Government announced that the UK will recognise Palestine as a state — unless Israel meets a list of conditions before the conference.
Embolden the extremists
You might be forgiven for thinking the Government's announcement could give a desperate situation a helpful push at a critical time.
After all, the UK and the rest of the international community have long believed that the only way to secure peace and justice for Israelis and Palestinians is to create an independent state of Palestine alongside Israel.
As a former chair of Labour Friends of Israel, I have long campaigned for a 'two-state solution' to replace the perpetually unstable, messy situation that has developed since the establishment of Israel in 1948.
But right now? Definitely not.
Sir Keir must urgently think again, or he will squander what little influence Britain has on this dire situation.
Israel announces 'tactical pause' in fighting in parts of Gaza as IDF sets up 'designated humanitarian corridors'
Those who have pushed for the UK to make the gesture of giving Palestine full democratic recognition now tend to believe Israel is squarely to blame for the unfolding humanitarian disaster in Gaza.
They ignore the reality that Hamas systematically diverts aid from its own people.
Many are taken in by the grotesque lie that Israel itself wants a genocide of Palestinians.
When in fact the country is threatened by genocidal terrorists committed to wiping Israel off the map.
Jews who survived Hitler's attempt to wipe them out promised themselves they would never again rely on the rest of the world to keep them safe.
So they think the UK should do whatever it can to stop Israel in its tracks.
But even if you believe the anti-Israel falsehoods from Hamas, recognising Palestinian statehood now would do nothing whatsoever to influence Israel's approach.
Jews who survived Hitler's attempt to wipe them out promised themselves they would never again rely on the rest of the world to keep them safe.
If their allies abandon them like this, they will just knuckle down and shut us out of the conversation.
Israelis would understandably view premature recognition of Palestine — before the hostages are returned home, before critical and intensely difficult security questions have been agreed — as contemptible posturing from countries whose days of empire are over.
Countries whose existence is not on the line, unlike Israel under constant rocket fire from Iran and its terrorist proxies.
Israelis would be deeply hurt by the sense their friends are moving against them while Hamas still holds living hostages or is withholding their remains.
But if it goes ahead, this gesture of official recognition while conflict is raging would be worse than futile. It would be actively harmful — including potentially increasing the risk of future Islamist terror attacks.
One British cabinet minister yesterday suggested the Palestinian people should be 'rewarded' by Britain recognising their state.
In fact, the people who would trumpet this as a reward would be Hamas terrorists, and their Iranian puppet masters who are bringing terror to British streets.
And it would embolden the extremists who have tarnished Gaza marches on an almost weekly basis with chants calling for the annihilation of Israel.
Some Labour MPs might be worried they will lose support from Muslim voters and left-wingers unless the Government sounds more pro-Palestine.
Pressurise real culprits
But the party should worry more that Nigel Farage and his new wave of Reform councillors will have a field day if it looks like Labour is caving in to the angry intolerance disrupting British cities.
And if Labour MPs look like they are obsessed with a foreign conflict when their constituents have so many pressing problems at home.
Sir Keir should focus on putting pressure on the real culprits — Hamas terrorists — instead of blaming Israel and sidelining Britain.
If the PM wants to shape the debate on how to find a credible roadmap to an independent Palestine alongside a secure Israel — great.
But the goal of two states cannot be imposed by Britain. It will only be achieved through a negotiation between two sides — Israelis and Palestinians.
And right now, the terrorists ruling Gaza are still holding Israeli hostages, and the Gazans under their control are going without food.
So Sir Keir should focus on putting pressure on the real culprits — Hamas terrorists — instead of blaming Israel and sidelining Britain.
John Woodcock is an ex-Labour MP and independent adviser to the Government on political violence and disruption.
5
5
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
30 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
ANGELA RAYNER: 'National Minimum Wage was a lifeline for me and other low-paid workers'
Deputy PM Angela Rayner writes for The Mirror as the Low Pay Commission begins its annual work to consult with employers, trade unions and workers on the National Minimum Wage Like many Mirror readers, I know what it's like to graft every day just to cover the bills – but still struggle to make ends meet. As a young single mum, I worked long night shifts as a home help on low pay to get me and my young family through the week. That's why the National Minimum Wage - launched by the last Labour government - was such a lifeline for me and for other low paid workers. It put more money in my pocket and gave me the security and opportunity I needed to get on in life. But after 14 years of Tory failure, stagnation and decline that's no longer the reality for millions of hardworking people across the country who simply cannot afford to get by. This Labour government was elected a year ago on a promise to Make Work Pay. Which is why, within weeks of taking office we told the Low Pay Commission to consider the cost of living for the first time when setting the National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage. As a result, more than 3 million workers got an inflation busting boost to their pay packets from April, worth up to £1,400 a year. This helped raise living standards for the lowest paid who are the backbone of our economy. It also delivered a record cash increase for young people and apprentices – our skilled workers of tomorrow. And today, alongside my friend the Business Secretary, I will urge the Low Pay Commission to build on this success by pushing even further to make a genuine living wage a reality. We want to continue narrowing the pay gap for 18 to 20-year-olds as we move closer to setting a single rate for all adult workers in the years to come. This is our Plan for Change in action. This our promise to Make Work Pay. But it doesn't stop there. This is a government on the side of working people. You are at the heart of our landmark Employment Rights Bill, now going through Parliament. This Bill will tackle the low wages, job insecurity and poor conditions that working people face. It will bring stronger protections against unfair sackings, make sure workers get paid sick pay from day one, and stop you being threatened with dismissal for refusing to take lower pay. And it will guarantee hours and make work more flexible and family-friendly – benefits that will support business by creating a healthier, more productive workforce. Unelected Tory and Lib Dem Lords, cheered on by Nigel Farage and Reform are trying to block these rights in Parliament. But this Labour Government was elected by you to deliver them, and we will not let them get away with it. These historic reforms consulted with employers and trade unions are pro-worker, pro-business and pro-growth. So, if you are in casual work without guaranteed hours, if you are working hard on low pay but can't afford the essentials. Or if you want a country that is fairer for working people - then this Labour government is working for you. And we will keep on delivering.
Telegraph
30 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Without real deterrence, any plan to tackle illegal migration will fail
SIR – Once again, Labour is looking at the problem of small-boat Channel crossings from the wrong end of the telescope. Instead of allocating an extra £100 million to the National Crime Agency to target people smugglers ( August 4), there has to be a concerted effort to address the reasons why so many want to come to Britain in the first place. Deterrence must be the starting point. This should include: a reduction in the benefits payable, and immediate cessation if an asylum claim is rejected; strategic and operational action to prevent illegal working; changes in the law to prevent endless appeals against asylum refusal; immediate deportation of failed claimants (as well as visa overstayers); safe but basic housing as an alternative to hotels; and tougher criteria to determine asylum eligibility. Until such action is taken, I confidently predict that the additional funds won't make an iota of difference. Peter Higgins West Wickham, Kent SIR – The Government has pledged more money to help with the 'one in, one out' scheme agreed with France last month, which is still only at the pilot stage. After a year in office, it continues to make things up as it goes along. Sir Keir Starmer's promise to 'smash the gangs' rings as hollow as ever. Charles Penfold Ulverston, Cumbria SIR – I am increasingly alarmed by the Government's handling of mass migration. Britain is absorbing large numbers of people without adequate checks, long-term planning or public consent. British taxpayers are funding accommodation, welfare and legal aid for individuals who, in some cases, have criminal records. Meanwhile, the needs of law-abiding citizens are being sidelined. There is a growing perception that we, the British public, are being unfairly treated for raising concerns. We are scrutinised, silenced and stretched thin, while individuals arriving illegally are afforded leniency and protection. Many no longer feel safe in their own communities, and public services are at breaking point. This is not sustainable – morally, socially or economically. The Government must urgently reassert control of our borders, enforce meaningful vetting and put the rights and safety of British citizens first. Leila Edwards Thame, Oxfordshire SIR – The RNLI has responded to claims that it has been acting as a 'taxi service' for migrants ('RNLI makes no apology for saving Channel migrants in distress', report, July 30). Anyone who has watched the television series Saving Lives at Sea will be aware of the selfless bravery and expertise of RNLI volunteers. In the case of a sinking dinghy, do the charity's critics expect a lifeboat crew just to take one look and turn around? Marilyn Parrott Altrincham, Cheshire
Times
30 minutes ago
- Times
Parents beat Labour's VAT on fees raid by paying £500m up front
Parents of children at Britain's leading private schools may have avoided Labour's tax raid by offering up fees in advance. Hundreds of millions of pounds in fees were paid upfront last year to avoid the 20 per cent VAT, which came into effect on January 1, analysis by the Daily Telegraph shows. Britain's top 50 independent schools received £515 million in advance fees last year, up from £121 million in 2023, according to research of the latest annual accounts at Companies House and the Charity Commission. • More than fifty UK private schools shut since Labour put VAT on fees By handing over school fees before Labour's deadline, wealthy parents may have avoided up to £103 million in VAT, with that sum expected to be even higher when taking into account all of the UK's 2,600 private schools. Parents at some schools tried paying up to five years' fees before the January deadline to dodge Labour's tax, the analysis shows. The large scale of advance payments could impact Labour's plan to raise revenue, tax experts have warned. However, the Treasury says that the Office for Budget Responsibility considered the use of prepayment schemes when making its forecasts for how much money would be raised by the VAT raid. Fees gathered from prepayment schemes, which are used to pay for one or more years of a pupil's education in advance, have risen across the UK's most expensive schools, including Brighton College, which recorded £50.1 million in total prepaid fees last year — an increase of £4.1 million from 2023. Only 86 of its pupils were covered by the school's prepayment scheme last year. That figure jumped to 819 last year as parents scrambled to beat the VAT deadline. Eton College collected £52.7 million in advance fee payments last year, up £16.6 million from 2023. At Winchester College, fees collected in advance rose from £4.4 million in 2023 to £19 million in 2024. Labour maintains that its tax raid is aimed at targeting Britain's wealthiest families and will raise more than £1.8 billion a year for state schools in ten years. However, with wealthy parents forking out large sums to Britain's most prestigious schools, it is the smaller private schools that are likely to be affected the most. The government predicts that 100 schools could shut over the next three years, with more than 50 independent schools already announcing their closures as a result of the policy, the Telegraph reports.
