Act Party leader David Seymour suggested 'bots' drove 'fake submissions' against his Regulatory Standards Bill
Regulatory Standards Bill
were created using "bots".
The Ministry for Regulation received approximately 23,000 submissions regarding a discussion document about the bill in January.
In summarising the feedback, it found 88 percent of submitters opposed the proposed regulations, and 0.33 percent supported or partially supported them.
But in an interview on this week's episode of
30 with Guyon Espiner
, the newly-appointed deputy prime minister claimed most of the opposing submissions weren't valid.
"You're smart enough to know that those 23,000 submissions, 99.5 percent of them, were because somebody figured out how to make a bot make fake submissions that inflated the numbers," Seymour said.
The figures quoted were "meaningless" and represented nothing more than somebody "running a smart campaign with a bot".
When asked what evidence Seymour had that the submissions were fake, he said it's because "we've looked at them. Because we know what the contents of them is".
In a subsequent written statement to RNZ, Seymour said he was referring to "online campaigns" that generate "non-representative samples" that don't reflect public opinion.
In a statement, Ministry for Regulation deputy chief executive policy Andrew Royle would not address Seymour's claims about bots directly.
Royle said the ministry undertook a "robust process" to analyse all of the submissions received.
"Our approach was carefully designed to reflect all submissions in the final analysis, noting there were many similar points made across most of the submissions," he said.
The ministry's summary shows its process included a "qualitative" analysis of about 1000 individual submissions. Group submissions and submissions over 10,000 words were read separately. The rest were summarised using AI.
There was nothing in the report about bots or other interference in the submissions process.
Watch the full interview with David Seymour on
30 With Guyon Espiner
.
Subscribe to the podcast feed now to get every episode of 30 on your phone when it lands:
On
Spotify
On
iHeartRadio
On
Apple podcasts
Professor in the Faculty of Law at the University of Otago Andrew Geddis said the use of the word 'bots' was disparaging.
"I think he's using bots in that kind of colloquial sense, which is an incredibly dismissive way to refer to individual New Zealanders taking the time to actually engage with his proposal.
"If he means some sort of artificial intelligence, computer-generated filling out of the forms without any human intervention, that would have been reported to him by his officials. There was no such report."
ActionStation director Kassie Hartendorp said Seymour was trying to discredit any opposition to his views.
"If he presents some evidence that there were bots involved, and there's probably ways to be able to do that, if he presents evidence, then fine. But otherwise, it just seems like an outlandish claim that isn't matching up with reality."
Kassie Hartendorp (Ngāti Raukawa, Ngāti Tuwharetoa) is the Director of ActionStation, a community campaigning platform.
Photo:
Supplied
ActionStation and other campaigning organisations from across the political spectrum have previously created templates to help people write submissions.
Hartendorp said those tools were not bots and meant make the submissions process more accessible.
"The purpose of those submission tools is to be able to make it as clear and simple as possible, so that people, who might not ever have submitted before, or who don't have much time, can be involved with the democratic process."
Clerk of the House of Representatives Dr David Wilson said he wasn't able to respond to Seymour's claims as the consultation in January was run by the Ministry for Regulation, but said there are protections in place against 'bots' during a select committee process.
Similar claims
about the impact of automated software were made during the submissions process on the Treaty Principles Bill in January, which attracted more than 300,000 submissions, but no evidence was found to support any such interference.
"Our cybersecurity people were not aware that any of the submissions were made that way, and they do have security in place to alert them to if that was happening," Wilson said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Alcohol sale hours need to be reduced after reform u-turn
Proposed changes would have reduced off-licence sale hours from 16 hours to 12 a day. Photo: ABC News / Mitchell Woolnough The Salvation Army says it sees the harm caused by alcohol every day, and wants the government to revisit plans to tighten the hours bottle stores and supermarkets can sell alcohol. A leaked cabinet paper showed the government scrapped plans to reduce the hours alcohol could be sold to focus instead on making business easier for the alcohol industry. Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee planned to reduce off-licence sale hours - which are now 7am-11pm - to only 12 hours, from 9am, in reforms to the Sale and Supply of Alcohol Act. She said that could have prevented 2400 violent crimes a year, but later versions of the paper showed the reform would now focus on reducing the regulatory burden. Salvation Army social policy and parliamentary unit director Dr Bonnie Robinson said that came as a surprise. "We don't know why we've ended up with a draft cabinet paper, which looks quite different to what we were expecting," she said. "Certainly, the alcohol industry lobbies the government and the alcohol industry does have a lot of resources behind it." Robinson said the u-turn was concerning, given alcohol-related harm currently costs the country $9.1 billion a year. "We're really concerned, if we're not going to take this opportunity to reduce harm from alcohol," she said. "We see the harm from alcohol every single day at our services. "We know that we need to do more to reduce the harm from alcohol, so it will be disappointing, if we miss this opportunity to really take some steps that can do that." The organisation planned to urge government to reconsider. "We'll certainly be writing to the minister and urging her to make the reforms focused on alcohol harm reduction, in particular, if we can get back to that reduction of sales hours," Robinson said. "We'll be talking to other ministers, because this is a public health issue. It's also a crime and family violence issue, it goes across a lot of issues that government is concerned about." More than 20 councils across the country were working on their own local alcohol policies and, so far, three had come into force in Auckland, Christchurch and Hastings, where 9pm closing applied to off-licence sales. Other councils had abandoned plans to embark on their own local alcohol policies, including Grey District, which cited the cost involved and threat of industry challenge. Hamilton City Council ditched plans to change the hours alcohol could be sold, after receiving three appeals, including from Progressive Enterprises. At the time, council said negotiations failed to resolve the issues and it abandoned its policy, after spending more than $200,000 on staff and legal time. In 2022, Hamilton councillors unanimously voted in support of a private members bill, which aimed to put more controls around the sale of liquor. Robinson said a law change reforming the Sale and Supply of Alcohol Act to tighten alcohol sales would take the burden off councils. "It strengthens the arm of councils, when they also want to make adjustments in their communities," she said. "Without that, each council does have to do that policy themselves. "It's very inefficient in terms of lawmaking and, for smaller councils particularly, it can be very expensive for them to do it." She said Rotorua was one example of a city affected by alcohol-related harm, because 60 percent of bottle shops were in the highest deprivation suburbs. Those suburbs represented 11 percent of Rotorua's population, but accounted for one-third of hospital admissions attributable to alcohol. "Behind those stats are real people, who are suffering, because they are being harmed by alcohol and addiction to alcohol," Robinson said. "We do have the opportunity to reduce that harm. It's not going to eliminate it, but we can at least make some dents in that harm, if we do some really good reform, especially around trading hours." She said evidence internationally showed reducing trading hours helped reduce harm, by reducing the availability of alcohol, particularly in vulnerable communities. "The less alcohol is available, the less harmful drinking we have and the less harm from alcohol we have - the research is very clear on this. "That's why we do need to protect these vulnerable communities. We need to make sure there isn't a proliferation of off-licences in them and we need to reduce the hours that the existing off-licences can operate, and that will reduce harm." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Anthony Albanese, Christopher Luxon wrap up bilateral leaders' meeting in Queenstown
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese at the Arrowtown War Memorial Park. Photo: RNZ / Katie Todd Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has laid out his vision for "frictionless" business and travel between Australia and New Zealand, as he wraps the annual bilateral leaders' meeting in Queenstown. Luxon and Australian counterpart Anthony Albanese paid tribute to Anzac soldiers in Arrowtown and took a scenic helicopter flight, before Albanese departed on Sunday afternoon. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese laying a wreath at the Arrowtown War Memorial Park. Photo: RNZ / Katie Todd The previous evening, the leaders met with the heads of major Australasian businesses, including Qantas, ASB Bank and Genesis Energy, after a one-on-one discussion at tech entrepreneur Rod Drury's new private retreat. In a media debrief at Queenstown Airport on Sunday afternoon, Luxon described how the countries could do more to remove the "barnacles from the boat" for businesses straddling the Tasman. "There's a lot that we could actually do to simplify some of the standards across both markets," he said. "There are a challenge within the domestic Australia, between the states, where there's often different regulatory requirements within the states and the point is we want it to be as frictionless as possible." Luxon pointed to recent progress, including harmonising building-product standards and trialling visa-free entry for Chinese nationals arriving from Australia. He said there were further opportunities to explore - like synchronising both countries' approaches to AI and environmental issues, and advancing work on digital IDs and drivers licences , which would be recognised on both sides of the Tasman. Luxon said it was all about getting rid of small "irritants" for travellers, such as Australians having to use their passports for ID at New Zealand bars. "It's those things... that make it frictioned in terms of trying to move between countries," he said. Luxon said previous efforts to achieve entirely seamless cross-border movement - such as trials of passport-less travel - had faltered, due to what he called genuine "nationhood" considerations, but that did not preclude other measures to streamline trans-Tasman travel. Defence was also high on the agenda during his meetings with Albanese, with both countries committed to intensifying defence co-operation and moving towards an increasingly integrated ANZAC force. Asked if New Zealand could join Australia's deal with Japan to build buy 11 Navy frigates, Luxon said "harmonisation in procurement" could benefit both countries. "We want to make sure that we have optionality to join the procurement process. For example, we're in the market for new helicopters - we want to make sure that they're as interoperable as possible with the Australians. "When we go to market, we want to present joint procurement bids for those things that we can tack on the New Zealand requirement and, as a result, lower the cost for each of those individual items for each country," he said. When it came to economic challenges, Luxon said Australia and New Zealand were both trying to improve their productivity. "We both have huge desires to improve economic productivity in our respective countries. It's been a problem for 30 years and both countries actually, under successive governments. "Everyone's working hard, but we haven't able to lift everyone's collective living standards sufficiently." As he bid goodbye to his "good mate" Albanese, Luxon hailed the leaders' meeting as a very successful trip altogether. "We're good friends and that helps a lot, when you have good chemistry with the leader," he said. "It's actually quite nice having a peer support group at times with fellow leaders you can actually talk to." The relationship was in "good heart", he said, although he conceded Albanese's decision to wear a Wallabies scarf on the final stretch of the trip may have been a bit of "trolling." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
3 hours ago
- RNZ News
Green Party's Chlöe Swarbrick calls to rally, get organised for 2026 election
Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick addresses membership at the annual meeting in Wellington. Photo: RNZ/Anneke Smith Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick has urged the membership to rally and get organised for next year's election. MPs and party faithful gathered for their annual meeting at creative campus Te Auaha in central Wellington this weekend. Swarbrick received a standing ovation, after her speech that asked members to "take a deep breath" and action their opposition to the coalition's policy agenda. "I don't really want to just talk about the bad guys and the bad things today, because I know we're angry," she said. "We've got a lot to be angry about, but that anger, while righteous, won't get us anywhere, if we do not channel it into organised action." Swarbrick and co-leader Marama Davidson have visited communities throughout the country this year, as part of a nationwide roadshow. She told membership the Greens' ideas were "immensely popular" and the party's work in the coming year was to "grow" the party's movement. "New Zealanders are hungry for solutions, because - clearly - the current system, it ain't working for them. "That means that there is a country full of people ready to join our movement. We've seen in Auckland Central, in Rongotai and here in Wellington Central that, when we get curious about our neighbours and find our shared values, when we show up for our communities and build our movement beyond traditional circles, we win, the people win." The Green Party has had a relatively steady year, after a tumultuous start to the term that saw several controversial resignations, the sudden death of MP Efeso Collins and Davidson taking time out to fight cancer. Since then, both co-leaders have talked about leading the opposition and setting the agenda, as the party released a swathe of policy, including its own 'Green Budget'. This rhetoric hasn't translated into a boost in support in the polls, with the Greens consistently polling about 10 percent of the general vote. Swarbrick told membership many New Zealanders were "exhausted" and "fed up with politics", but they should still fight to create "the most progressive government Aotearoa has ever seen". "We need to connect the dots on these acts of humanity, building something so big it overtakes and replaces the system of extraction and exhaustion and exploitation. "Now, those making bank from the climate crisis and profiting from deep inequality will invest everything that they have got into telling you that it's impossible, because they need you to believe that they need you fighting your fellow New Zealander," Swarbrick said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
