Is it worth paying a real estate agent to sell your house?
Photo:
123rf.com
You might pay a real estate agent $30,000 or more to sell your home. But is it worth it?
Analysis by property data firm Cotality suggests it might be.
Each year, a small number of people opt to sell their homes privately - from a low of 3.1 percent in 2021 to 8 percent in 2016. Last year, it was 7.6 percent.
But Cotality head of research Nick Goodall said agents seemed to sell properties more quickly and effectively.
"The sales success rate is higher for agent sales - by an average of 11.5 percent over the 10 year period."
Roughly 76 percent of agent-listed properties in the past 10 years were successfully sold, compared to 65.1 percent of privately listed properties.
Last year 65 percent of agent listed properties sold, compared to 52.8 percent for private sales.
Goodall said real estate salespeople would often have an understanding of which buyers might be in the market for a particular property and could target them more effectively than a private seller might.
"The typical days on market for agent sales is also most often shorter. In 2021 - the market peak - the median days on market for agent sales was 24, while it was 40 for private sales. Interestingly last year was the one year to buck that trend, with agent sales taking a median of 75 days, compared to 71 days for private."
He said the median sales price for properties sold by agents was higher, too, but that could reflect a different mix of properties being sold.
"Vendors may be more likely to sell their property privately when it's a lower value property, whereas owners of more expensive property might be more likely to use an agent."
He said last year's higher rate of private sales could reflect vendors being aware that prices were not strong and looking to save money where they could.
"Nonetheless, for the record, the median sales price of properties sold by agents this year is $740,000, compared to $662,500 for private sales. Last year the respective figures were $735,000 for agents and $704,000 for private."
Goodall said the data was not definitive enough to say whether agents were delivering enough extra value to pay their commission. At Barfoot & Thompson, for example, a $750,000 sale would incur $23,978 in commission. A $1 million sale would mean just under $30,000.
"The figure for this year is almost $100,000 so I'd say that would justify it if it was like-for-like properties. But the year before was closer so you might be sort of borderline there."
Goodall said people selling privately would also need to account for the time they would need to spend on the process.
"Having to take time off work or the opportunity cost or what else you could be doing if you have to spend all that time preparing to sell a property on your own, you know that might bring the calculation a little bit closer as well."
Real estate agent Brooke Gibson said she could understand why people would sell privately. She did it herself before she entered the industry.
But she said she could see that agents would add value for most people, particularly when it came to negotiating.
"You could actually easily kill the deal because you know, if someone comes up to you and you're opening up your house to them and they go 'how much do you want?' and you say $1 million and he thinks it's worth $700,000 for example, he's going to be like 'nah not interested."
Wellington salesperson Mike Robbers agreed. He said agents would also often present properties a bit better than private sellers would, with professional photography and home staging.
"Private sellers often start out with a very high price in mind, then reduce it over time when there's no interest, but by then the listing has gone 'cold'. Agents tend to use their market knowledge to get the pricing strategy right from the outset, so the listing doesn't sit as long on the market."
He said some buyers also expected to pay less for a private sale because the seller did not have to cover commission.
Real Estate Authority chief executive Belinda Moffat said whether it was better to sell privately or through an agency would depend on the seller's specific circumstances, the property itself and the seller's knowledge and experience.
"Licensed real estate professionals are trained and experienced in working on behalf of homeowners to help them navigate property transactions with confidence and are legally required to seek the best outcome for their client."
She said all real estate salespeople were required to follow the standards in the Code of Professional Conduct and Client Care and meet their obligations under the Real Estate Agents Act 2008.
"If a person works with a licensed real estate professional, and an issue arises with their professional conduct, the person has the option to make a formal complaint to REA and/or to raise the issue with their agency."
Agents should provide a current market appraisal (CMA) of what a property might sell for before they signed an agency agreement.
"(CMA) of what they think the property might sell for before the seller signs an agency agreement. The CMA must be informed by comparable recent sales in the area and can be helpful in understanding what the property may be worth. They will also prepare a proposed marketing plan which the seller can discuss, amend and agree to.
"They also understand and can advise on the important legal disclosure obligations a seller has when selling a property, including in relation to defects and unconsented alterations. If a seller knowingly fails to disclose relevant information to buyers, they could be in breach of the terms of their agreement with any buyer, meaning the sale could fall over or the buyer could seek compensation and take court action."
She said vendors might be able to negotiate commission.
People choosing to sell privately should research the process so they understood what was require, she said.
Moffat said confidence in the industry had lifted from 70 percent in 2021 to 82 percent last year.
Goodall said there was demand for property but there remained high numbers of listings.
"I think if you're willing to be very, very flexible on that price then it's probably not that difficult to get a sale, but it's all about you know, your expectation, what you want to do, if you're buying in the same market, if you're moving elsewhere..."
He said some people were still hung up on the prices being paid at the peak of the market and were finding it hard to adjust their expectations.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NZ Herald
a few seconds ago
- NZ Herald
New World Pt Chevalier to open next to derelict building and abandoned tyre site
Next door is a third of a hectare ex-Magnum Motors corner site, also fronting 8 Parr Rd North but looking in very poor shape. New World Pt Chevalier, Auckland nearing completion. 22 July 2025 New Zealand Herald photograph by Jason Dorday The contrast between the two sites could hardly be greater. How did such a situation arise and what do council and local board people say about it? The state-of-the-art supermarket is aiming to draw tens of thousands of shoppers weekly in the suburb, which currently only has a small Woolworths. The unsightly empty site next door is owned by New Zealand-registered company Hobson One. Its director is Zhengzheng Guo of Remuera. Derelict buildings in front of and around the New World Pt Chevalier which is planned to open in August. Photo / Jason Dorday He has applied for resource consent for apartments to be built in blocks beside the New World. But he is yet to succeed. 'An application was lodged in December 2024 for a three-storey mixed-use building - retail and residential,' a council spokesman said. The application was now on hold, awaiting further information, the spokesman said. Advertising showed he did try to sell the site two years ago, before downscaling plans. In June 2023, he advertised it with Bayleys. 1150-1160 Great North Rd, Pt Chevalier, Auckland, outlined in red. This was in 2023 when Bayleys' agents were marketing the property for sale. Since then, the New World Pt Chevalier has been built on the ex-RSA site next door (above the red line). Photo / Bayleys The big lot was marketed as a development site, with a 177-unit resource consent. Bayleys agents Gerald Rundle and Marty van Barneveld marketed it but were unsuccessful in selling it. Derelict buildings in front of and around the New World Pt Chevalier which is planned to open in August. Photo / Jason Dorday 'The development potential of the site under the zoning has been greatly enhanced by an approved Resource Consent for an eight-level [including basement] development of 177 apartments and three ground-level commercial units over approximately 18,000sq m according to the consented plans,' Bayleys said. Construction progresses at the site of the new New World Pt Chevalier on Great North Rd, Auckland. The store, developed by Foodstuffs North Island and designed by Wingate Architects, is due to open later this year. Photo / Jason Dorday The new supermarket has been set back from the street, with a partly covered walkway now being finished beside the Kumho Tyres building, short-stay parking out the front and a big underground basement for parking. Auckland Council documents describe buildings on the Hobson One site: '1150 and 1158 Great North Rd are occupied by a vehicle workshop, tyre shop and paint and panel beaters. Plans for apartments on Great North Rd beside the new $73 million New World Pt Chevalier. Photo / Auckland Council consent documents 'Built development within these lots comprises two-level industrial style buildings located centrally with a canopy extending over the forecourt in front, a double garage and electrical transformer at the rear of number 1150, and concrete/asphalt driveway and parking areas across the remainder of the land,' the council document says. A larger scheme was once planned. Consent was granted non-notified on February 20, 2023, for an eight-storey apartment block, with basement parking, three commercial units and 177 dwellings, the council noted. Derelict buildings in front of and around the New World Pt Chevalier which is planned to open in August. 22 July 2025 New Zealand Herald photograph by Jason Dorday But the market changed and now only about 50 units are planned. 'Given the changing demands of the market, the applicant wishes to achieve a similar development in terms of land use, albeit on a much smaller scale in terms of the height of the built form, but also notably the depth and volume of earthworks required will be significantly less,' the council document said. Kendyl Smith, chair of the Albert-Eden Local Board, said the site was private property which the council had boarded off. Smith was aware of safety and crime concerns. New World Pt Chevalier, Auckland nearing completion. Photo / Jason Dorday 'The council is actively working to maintain safety in and around this site, which involves working with the property owner to determine the next steps,' Smith said. The board had completed a review of crime prevention through environmental design in the wider area, Smith said. That identified safety-related improvements for Pt Chevalier. New World Pt Chevalier, Auckland nearing completion. Photo / Jason Dorday 'There are also ongoing patrols of the area from the council's community safety wardens, working with NZ Police,' Smith said. 'We're also looking forward to the new modular library, with full library services, joining the town square this October.' The New World opening would provide a welcome addition for locals and for the wider village, Smith said. Kāinga Ora has also developed new social housing in the town centre. This shows work on the block, long since finished. These are the new state homes in Pt Chevalier. Photo / Michael Craig On the corner of Great North Rd and Pt Chevalier Rd, a block of apartments was imported fully built from China. That is for people aged 55-plus moving into or from existing state housing. Kāinga Ora contracted Tawera Group and Teak Construction on this job. They assembled the 61-unit block of single-bedroom new units. Kāinga Ora said the modular homes were all one-bedroom apartments to cater for high demand for those types of places. They are single, factory-built modules. Last year, when New World Pt Chevalier was being built, and the home next door. Photo / Jason Dorday A man in his 90s is yet to find a buyer for his home next to the new supermarket. The Herald reported last year on 12 Parr Rd North. That has been in Albert John Andrews' family for 70 years. Foodstuffs said last year it had been working closely with the family, other neighbours and the community throughout the build process. Anne Gibson has been the Herald's property editor for 25 years, written books and covered property extensively here and overseas.


NZ Herald
2 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Auckland supermarkets and liquor stores under fire for selling ‘mega strong' beers
Secretary Grant Hewison said the beers essentially represent a loophole, with RTDs being limited to 6% ABV and no more than two standards per beverage. 'We would describe these products as court cases in a can, especially when they reach past 12%.' He said with these beers, essentially one can leave you intoxicated and unable to drive. Hewison said they're more problematic than other high alcohol products like wine or soju as they're carbonated, so they're consumed quickly. He said the products are sold in single 500ml cans for as cheap as $6, which can be easily stowed in a pocket. Maori Warden Thomas Henry says the super strong beers are part of the public drinking problem in South Auckland Photo / Jason Oxenham Auckland District Māori Wardens chair Thomas Henry said high-alcohol products worsened things for people already struggling with homelessness and mental health issues. He said the beers are part of South Auckland's public drinking problem, creating issues such as an Ōtara playground being removed . Henry said they've been trying to educate liquor stores against selling the beers to vulnerable people. He said it's been frustrating, with owners telling him it's not their job, to tell people what to do. New Zealand supermarkets are taking differing approaches to high-strength beers. Photo / NZME, File Foodstuffs said they work closely with their store owners to ensure alcohol is sold responsibly, including regular staff training and robust ID checks. 'We continue to monitor our range carefully, taking into account legal obligations, customer demand, and community feedback,' a spokesperson said. Woolworths said it removed single cans of more than 7% ABV from all stores after consulting with regulatory agencies and community groups, but continues to sell multi-packs of high-strength beers. Brewers Association Executive Director Dylan Firth is calling for a grounded discussion on the products. Photo/Supplied Brewers Association executive director Dylan Firth said beers over 5% ABV make up only 11% of all sold in New Zealand in the year to March. He said the industry's total volumes of high strength beers has also declined by a third since 2022. Firth said stronger beers are typically specialty or craft offerings intended for moderate consumption. Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee said she's aware of concerns about high-strength beer. Photo / Mark Mitchell Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee said she's aware of concerns high-strength beer and the potential harm irresponsible consumption posed. 'I'm continuing to engage with stakeholders and consider how regulation can reduce alcohol-related harm and contribute to the Government's target of 20,000 fewer victims of violent crime by 2030.' Lachlan Rennie is an Auckland-based Multimedia Journalist for Newstalk ZB covering science, defence, technology, community issues and general news.

RNZ News
7 hours ago
- RNZ News
What's going on with Rocket Lab shares?
Photo: RNZ/ Nate McKinnon Rocket Lab may be recording multi-million-dollar losses, but its share price keeps on going up. Shares in the New Zealand-founded space company have risen more than 800 percent in the past year, to just under US$50 each. In August last year, they were changing hands for less than US$5. In its 2024 financial year, the company recorded a loss of US$33 million to US$35m, from record annual revenue of US$436.2m. Greg Smith, head of retail at Devon Funds, said investors were looking past the lack of profitability, and there was a lot of momentum priced in to its shares. "But the company has been delivering. It is gaining huge credibility through deals with national space agencies and spending here has been ramping up. There's been the recent partnership agreed with the European Space Agency to launch satellites for constellation navigation before December. "And there has been a string of successful launches. A rocket is being produced every 15 days, and [it has] successfully launched its 66th, 67th and 68th Electron rockets." He said the company's upcoming, bigger Neutron medium-lift rocket was another driver of growth. If it was successful, it could unlock US$5.6 billion in National Security Space Launch contracts. "The company isn't profitable yet, so we can't really look at earnings multiples. Even to sales it is looking high at up to 10 times, but if it keeps delivering we might yet see more momentum." Gretjan Verdickt, a lecturer of finance at the University of Auckland, said a significant portion of Rocket Lab's current valuation was based on the promise of a future that was "both exciting and challenging to value". "How much will the space economy truly be worth in 10 or 20 years? How many applications will it lead to? It's difficult for anyone to grapple with. Because of that uncertainty, optimistic investors are willing to pay a very high price today for the potential of a massive payoff down the road. They see a leader in a burgeoning industry and don't want to miss out. "This part of the valuation is precarious. A narrative of explosive growth and future dominance sustains it. If that optimism fades, even slightly, you could see a significant drop. That said, for anyone who got in early, a drop would still leave them with an amazing return." He said the "hype-driven" component of the share price made it fragile. "If you think about it from a behavioural finance point of view, there is a lot of 'fear of missing out' going on too. If you missed the boat at 100 percent, 200 percent... and you jump in late, the prices - because you are willing to buy - the stock price increases more. This leads to a momentum effect." He said the other aspect of the share price was the company's cash flow. "There is a real, tangible business generating real cash flows behind the stock price. "Rocket Lab has already realised tremendous growth. Their revenue has increased significantly over the past few years, and they have a backlog of over $1 billion in signed contracts, providing a clear line of sight into future earnings. "They have two core pillars of growth. First, their proven Electron rocket is a workhorse for the small satellite market. Second, and more importantly for the future, is their upcoming Neutron rocket, which is designed to compete with larger players like SpaceX for much bigger, more lucrative contracts. "Additionally, they're not just a launch company. Their Space Systems division - which builds satellite components and platforms - is their biggest revenue driver. They are strategically building an end-to-end space company, and their pending acquisition of the company Mynaric is another step in that direction." When it came to whether the 800 percent increase was sustainable, the level of share price was probably not, he said. "Unless the company's growth potential is even better than what people are currently thinking. However, the underlying business growth is there. There is a very real and rapidly growing company here. The ultimate test will be whether its fundamental performance can grow fast enough to justify the market's sky-high expectations. That said, if the balloon pops, it can go real fast, real quick."