Google rejects Meta's app store age-verification push
As Europe cracks down on online content for minors, Google argues Meta's solution would create new dangers instead of solving old ones.
American tech heavyweight Google on Friday reiterated its opposition to verifying the age of a device's user through the app stores built into operating systems, calling a proposal from Facebook and Instagram parent Meta 'ineffective'.
Age restrictions and the European regulatory push
Limiting access to age-restricted content online is a live issue in Europe, with France battling pornography sites over its newly-introduced requirement that they check users' ages.
Paris is also one of several capitals pressing Brussels to introduce Europe-wide regulations cutting off access to social networks for under-15s over concerns including addiction, cyberbullying and hate speech.
Basing age verification on details from a device's app store 'would require the sharing of granular age band data with millions of developers… who don't need it', such as producers of uncontroversial apps like flashlights, Google wrote in a blog post.
Risk to children
'We have strong concerns about the risks this 'solution' would pose to children,' it added.
The search giant's Play Store is a part of the Android operating system, by far the most widely-used around the globe.
Google said that using app store data to verify ages would also leave major ways people access content online unprotected for the underage, such as desktop computers or shared family devices.
ALSO READ: Google takes issue with Competition Commission market inquiry report
Apple — whose own App Store is loaded on every device running its iOS operating system, such as iPhones and iPads — has also pushed back against Meta's proposal.
The back and forth
'The right place to address the dangers of age-restricted content online is the limited set of websites and apps that host that content,' the iPhone maker said in a February document.
'Implementing age verification at the operating system or app store level will help ensure that we create an ecosystem that's safe for teens,' the Facebook owner's safety chief Antigone Davis told Euronews in February.
Meta has since launched a campaign for European regulation to require the measure.
Europe's Digital Services Act (DSA), which came into force last year, says it is up to platforms like Meta's to verify the age of their users — not providers of operating systems or app stores.
Google said that changing to the latter system — which has also been pushed by Pornhub parent company Aylo — would mean 'reengineering the protocols that have defined the decentralized web in ways that are hard to fully predict'.
NOW READ: WATCH: Meta Teen accounts launched in SA
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
eNCA
13 hours ago
- eNCA
Spain economy minister urges fair, balanced EU-US tariff deal
Spanish Economy Minister Carlos Cuerpo said a tariff pact between the EU and Washington should be "fair and balanced," although both sides remain far from a deal as a July deadline approaches. "There is still a long way to go to reach an agreement, but there remains the will to do so," Cuerpo told AFP in an interview on Thursday. His comments came on the sidelines of a trip to Houston, Texas, as he sought to reassure Spanish businesses rattled by US President Donald Trump's wide-ranging tariffs. Trump has slapped a 10 percent tariff on almost all trading partners including the European Union since returning to the presidency in January. He also threatened to impose heftier duties of 50 percent on the bloc, although pausing the higher rate until July 9. For now, Trump's existing tariffs, including 25 percent US duties on imported automobiles and 50 percent levies on steel and aluminum, are affecting European companies, Cuerpo said. Pressure is mounting as July approaches. US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick told CNBC this week that an EU deal will likely be among the last that Washington completes, even as he remained optimistic that both sides would reach this goal. Arriving at a deal by July 9 would be ideal as it signals "certainty and confidence," Cuerpo said. He maintained that things are "progressing," stressing that "there is unanimity among the 27 member states to reach a fair and balanced agreement." - No 'overreaction' - He added that while Europe has prepared a response package to Trump's tariffs, Brussels is holding off implementation so that it cannot be "interpreted as an escalation in this tariff conflict." It is critical that the EU gives a "very clear signal" that it wants to strike a deal with the Trump administration, he said. "The fundamental thing is to avoid any element of overreaction," he added. Besides the EU, higher US tariffs on goods from dozens of economies including Japan and India are also due to take effect in July. Trump has taken an especially harsh stance on China as Beijing pushed back on US levies, with both sides engaging in an escalating tariffs war that has only been temporarily rolled back. The Spanish minister expects Trump's tariffs to have limited effect on his country's economic growth this year, given its smaller exposure to the US market. But he warned that certain sectors like olive oil and wine are at higher risk as more of such exports head to the United States. In the interim, Cuerpo noted the importance too of the Mercosur agreement, a trade deal between the European Union and four South American nations including Brazil. Asked if a new global trade order is emerging, Cuerpo said: "This feeling is widely shared." "We are witnessing a rebalancing of these trade relations at the international level and what nobody knows is what's the new point we will reach," he added. By Moisés Ávila
The Citizen
18 hours ago
- The Citizen
Google rejects Meta's app store age-verification push
As Europe cracks down on online content for minors, Google argues Meta's solution would create new dangers instead of solving old ones. American tech heavyweight Google on Friday reiterated its opposition to verifying the age of a device's user through the app stores built into operating systems, calling a proposal from Facebook and Instagram parent Meta 'ineffective'. Age restrictions and the European regulatory push Limiting access to age-restricted content online is a live issue in Europe, with France battling pornography sites over its newly-introduced requirement that they check users' ages. Paris is also one of several capitals pressing Brussels to introduce Europe-wide regulations cutting off access to social networks for under-15s over concerns including addiction, cyberbullying and hate speech. Basing age verification on details from a device's app store 'would require the sharing of granular age band data with millions of developers… who don't need it', such as producers of uncontroversial apps like flashlights, Google wrote in a blog post. Risk to children 'We have strong concerns about the risks this 'solution' would pose to children,' it added. The search giant's Play Store is a part of the Android operating system, by far the most widely-used around the globe. Google said that using app store data to verify ages would also leave major ways people access content online unprotected for the underage, such as desktop computers or shared family devices. ALSO READ: Google takes issue with Competition Commission market inquiry report Apple — whose own App Store is loaded on every device running its iOS operating system, such as iPhones and iPads — has also pushed back against Meta's proposal. The back and forth 'The right place to address the dangers of age-restricted content online is the limited set of websites and apps that host that content,' the iPhone maker said in a February document. 'Implementing age verification at the operating system or app store level will help ensure that we create an ecosystem that's safe for teens,' the Facebook owner's safety chief Antigone Davis told Euronews in February. Meta has since launched a campaign for European regulation to require the measure. Europe's Digital Services Act (DSA), which came into force last year, says it is up to platforms like Meta's to verify the age of their users — not providers of operating systems or app stores. Google said that changing to the latter system — which has also been pushed by Pornhub parent company Aylo — would mean 'reengineering the protocols that have defined the decentralized web in ways that are hard to fully predict'. NOW READ: WATCH: Meta Teen accounts launched in SA
Eyewitness News
18 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Mass lay-offs at Lesotho garment factories as US tariffs bite
On 2 April, Jane*, a worker at Leo Garments clothing factory in Lesotho was sent home. She is one of many workers left sitting at home as Lesotho faces a potential 50% tariff hike from the United States. Until the Trump administration introduced a 10% tariff, Lesotho exported duty free to the US under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). An additional 40% tariff was suspended, pending negotiations. But as US buyers weigh the prospect of an imminent hefty tariff, new orders have dried up, forcing many garment factories in Lesotho to suspend production lines. 'Firms that we met are planning a three-month closure, but if there's no change by September, they may pull out completely,' warns United Textile Employees Union (UNITE) secretary-general Solong Senohe. 'If the tariffs were only 10%, they say they would have no problem staying in Lesotho and their buyers would not have a problem of placing orders. Now Lesotho has a hanging 50% tariff, and no one knows when it will be enforced.' When Senohe spoke to GroundUp, he had just come from a meeting with Lesotho Precious Garments, who told him no new orders had been placed after the 50% tariff announcement. In a letter to UNITE, Precious Garments stated that it is 'facing a great shortage of orders'. Similar letters were issued last month by TZICC Clothing Manufacturers and Maseru-E-Textile, requesting meetings with UNITE over imminent layoffs. According to Senohe: 'The entire industry is affected … I recently spoke with Nien Hsing International management, and they said that by the end of July, all their American orders would be finished.' '80% of our clothing exports go to the US, while only 20% go to South Africa,' said Senohe. The country already faces extreme unemployment. A 2024 Lesotho Labour Force Survey found that 39% of youth aged 15–35 are unemployed. The garment industry had reportedly already shed 16,000 jobs between March 2018 and March 2024, but with 34,151 jobs officially, it is still the second-largest employer after the public sector. Senohe says the US tariffs have put 20,000 jobs at risk. On television on Monday, Prime Minister Samuel Matekane said US aid cuts and tariffs 'have crippled industries that previously sustained thousands of jobs'. Workers from Leo Garments, Boming Lai Teng and Precious Garments, speaking to GroundUp on condition of anonymity, say unionised workers have been the first targets for the layoffs. EFTU general secretary Tšepang Makakole said they had received reports of discrimination against union members and had approached the Ministry of Labour and the Lesotho National Development Corporation for intervention. Last week, employees at Maseru-E Textile began negotiating with management, demanding half-salaries while at home or severance pay. They had seen workers at other factories laid off without pay. Shop steward Mathuso Tlale said they became alarmed when they learned that some of the Chinese employers were selling fridges, microwaves and general household items. Maitumeleng Saoane, whose job is to record hourly production at the factory, cited a 2023 example when the owners of a factory vanished over a weekend, leaving unpaid wages. On Friday, workers held a work stoppage and eventually walked out. On Monday, they found the gates locked and police cars guarding the premises. Union leaders were allowed in to meet the factory owners. Afterwards, National Clothing Textile and Allied Workers Union secretary general Sam Mokhele told workers they would have to stay home for three months starting July. He said the employers said they had not budgeted for severance pay, but had agreed to pay those who had worked for the company for two years or more, M1,000 (R1,000) per month. Those with short service would be given their annual leave payment. SOUTH AFRICAN ORDERS Kerasemese Rantlhokoane, human resources manager at Lucky Manufacturing, who also oversees operations at Leo Garments and Hong Da, told GroundUp that all three 'cut, make, and trim' factories have been hard hit. 'We are now depending on South African orders, but if South Africa gets hit in the same way, we won't survive,' he said. He said even with reduced operations, factory owners must still pay rent, utilities, and wages. 'That's why some employers vanish or skip paying salaries for months.' He said the owner who bought Leo Garments in February last year 'is working hard to find new markets … But if it does close, workers will be paid their terminal benefits.' Chinese staff selling belongings were lower-level staff who rotate in and out, Rantlhokoane said. Deputy president of the Lesotho Textile Exporters Association Ricky Chang, who is also a director of Nien Hsing Textiles, said US importers are waiting to see if any trade agreement can be reached and at what tariff level. Nien Hsing Textiles produces Levi's jeans in Lesotho. If the full 50% tariff is implemented, Chang said, the factories will close or move to other countries. He said some factories have already planned for this and are in discussion with trade unions. 'Lesotho's textile sector will need the government to act quickly and achieve good results as soon as possible with its US counterparts.' APPEAL TO GOVERNMENT In a letter on 5 May to Prime Minister Matekane, UNITE said, 'Thousands of Basotho workers are facing three months lay-off without pay'. The union called for discussions with government on how to subsidise workers to mitigate their plight. On Wednesday, union representatives met Minister of Trade Mokhethi Shelile and Minister of Labour and Employment Tšeliso Mokhosi. UNITE deputy secretary general Potloloane Monare shared a report on the meeting. The report said the ministers had held virtual meetings with US officials. 'A final decision on the tariffs will be made by July 8, 2025 … But it looks likely that a 10% tariff will be applied to all African countries.' The report said the government said it lacked the resources to provide financial support for workers sent home and would assess options. Meanwhile, thousands of workers like Jane will be sent home when factories complete existing orders. Jane can hardly pay her bills. She is weighing up immigrating to Newcastle. 'I don't want to go illegally, but I'm running out of options,' she said. She has four children to support. * not her real name This article first appeared on GroundUp. Read the original article here.
