
UK: Divided police response to Palestine Action protests exposes 'chaos' of ban
On Saturday, 86 people were arrested under the Terrorism Act for holding signs reading, 'I oppose genocide. I support Palestine Action,' at protests in cities across the UK, including London, Manchester, Cardiff and Derry.
The government passed legislation banning Palestine Action as a proscribed group on 4 July, making membership of and support for it a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison.
A bid by the group to apply for interim relief to temporarily block the ban pending a judicial review was rejected by the High Court on Friday.
But according to the campaign group Defend Our Juries (DOJ), the policing response to the protests varied widely across cities, with police in Kendal and Derry making no arrests, while in Cardiff, the South Wales police treated the protest as if 'it were a serious terrorist incident'.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
DOJ reported that the South Wales Police conducted 13 arrests under the Terrorism Act Section 12 and held them in custody for an extended period after a superintendent authorised an extension of precharge detention beyond the maximum of 24 hours.
The police also raided the arrestees' homes, breaking down front doors and seizing posters, books and technology. According to DOJ, two of the 13 arrestees were Quakers, aged 78 and 80. They reported that their food cupboards were tested for radioactive material.
The group added that in London and Manchester the 'approach was somewhere in between', with protesters arrested under the Terrorism Act Section 13 - a much lesser charge than Section 12 - and were quickly released on police bail.
'The Chief Constable of South Wales police has got carried away with his new powers, treating peaceful protestors with cardboard signs like al-Qaeda operatives. Is this absurd diversion of police resources what [Home Secretary] Yvette Cooper really intended?' a DOJ spokesperson asked in a statement.
Bringing the law into disrepute
The DOJ said that the "massive variation" in the police response "brings the law into disrepute", and is demonstrative of the "chaos" unleashed by the order to ban the group.
'Like a kidnapping': How UK police are hunting pro-Palestine activists Read More »
"Express your opinion in Kendal or Derry and the police will leave you be. Do the same thing in Cardiff, the police will react as if your cardboard sign is a grave danger to the public, keeping you locked up while they break down your doors and raid your homes."
While DOJ noted that the signs that protesters held in Derry were worded slightly differently so that they read, 'Defend Your Right to Protest' instead of 'I Oppose Genocide', they said this does not explain a different police response, as it is the statement of support for Palestine Action written on the signs that is alleged to violate the Terrorism Act.
Police Watchdog Netpol has previously told MEE about receiving multiple reports of assault against peaceful activists by the South Wales Police, who they described as being "extremely hostile to Palestine solidarity activism".
Netpol also documented multiple incidents of violence by the South Wales police against Black Lives Matter activists in 2021 following the death of Mohamud Hassan in January of that year, shortly after his release from Cardiff Bay Police Station.
The weekend's arrests follow similar actions the previous Saturday, when 27 people were arrested in London's Parliament Square, including an 83-year-old priest, a former government lawyer, an emeritus professor, and health workers.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The National
14 minutes ago
- The National
Blow for Benjamin Netanyahu as ultra-Orthodox party quits coalition
An ultra-Orthodox party has quit Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu 's coalition in a long-running dispute over mandatory military service, leaving his government with a razor-thin majority amid public protests over the Gaza war. The departure of United Torah Judaism leaves Mr Netanyahu with 61 seats in the 120-seat Knesset. If ultra-Orthodox party Shas also quits over the issue, as Israeli media reports suggest they will this week, the government will be left with only 50 seats. The two parties have not said whether they will join the opposition to try to dissolve parliament, which would trigger elections. Their departures will only come into effect after 48 hours, giving Mr Netanyahu a window to salvage the situation. United Torah Judaism's move is the latest in wrangles over whether Israel's growing ultra-Orthodox population should serve in the military, as all other Jewish Israelis are obliged to do. The issue has been a political lightning rod for years, but is drawing particular anger during the Gaza war as Israel's military says it is facing a shortage of personnel. Many Israelis are saying the ultra-Orthodox community is shirking its responsibility. It is also a divisive issue within Mr Netanyahu's far-right coalition, which contains ultra-nationalist Zionist parties whose supporters are disproportionately represented in military units fighting on the frontlines. A spokesman for one of the factions that makes up UTJ said the party was making the decision after the government repeatedly failed 'to fulfil their obligations to regulate the legal status of the dear yeshiva students', referring to ultra-Orthodox Jewish religious schools that focus on the study of Torah and rabbinic traditions. Currently, men enrolled in these schools are exempt from military service. But a court ruled in June last year that this exemption was no longer legal. In response, the community wants the government to legislate on a permanent exemption, but that process has been stalled. Mr Netanyahu has reportedly directly intervened in the drafting of the long-debated bill, which faces stiff resistance from influential politician Yuli Edelstein, of Mr Netanyahu's Likud party. A wave of departures from the coalition was prevented last month after Mr Edelstein agreed to limit some sanctions against draft dodgers listed in an earlier version of the bill. The ultra-Orthodox community also receives significant subsidies to continue its secluded way of life, which many Israelis criticise as an unfair financial burden that encourages its members not to integrate. While some ultra-Orthodox Jews do serve in specialised branches of the armed forces, they represent a tiny proportion of the fast-growing community, whose leaders overwhelmingly encourage men to pursue full-time religious study. Community leaders fear that military life draws men away from the isolated group – significant swathes of which are non-Zionist – and its strict, insular interpretation of Judaism. The Israeli opposition has made military exemption a central issue in its strategy to attack the government. 'We will not forget: while Netanyahu fought yesterday to promote draft evasion, he knew about the three fatalities and the soldier who took his own life,' wrote opposition leader Yair Lapid in a post on X on Tuesday, following news of Israeli soldiers dying in Gaza. Former prime minister Naftali Bennett, a favourite in polls for future elections, said on Monday that as soldiers were dying, 'in the corridors of the Knesset, coalition members are moving heaven and Earth to create a draft-dodging law'. 'This gap is unbearable. We are at war. Our sons are there. In Gaza, in the north, wherever they are needed,' he added. 'This is a disgraceful government, unworthy of our good people.'


The National
29 minutes ago
- The National
Former UN rights chief Navi Pillay quits Israel-Palestine probe
Navi Pillay, the former UN human rights chief who has headed the world body's Commission of Inquiry into the Occupied Palestinian Territory and Israel since 2021, has resigned. Ms Pillay, a South African jurist, said in a letter made public on Monday that her resignation, effective on November 3, was due to 'age, medical issues and the weight of several other commitments'. Two other team experts, Chris Sidoti of Australia and Miloon Kothari of India, also stepped down. Their resignation letters, addressed to the president of the Human Rights Council, were sent last week. The resignation of the three-member panel comes amid mounting political pressure, including recent US sanctions imposed by President Donald Trump 's administration on Francesca Albanese, a Human Rights Council-appointed expert who has publicly condemned Israeli military actions in Gaza. Ms Albanese, the UN special rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories, called on July 9 for an arms embargo and the severing of trade ties with Israel, accusing it of conducting a 'genocidal campaign' in Gaza. Israel has refused to co-operate with the commission, denying its members entry and repeatedly rejecting their findings as biased. The Commission of Inquiry, established by the UN Human Rights Council in 2021, has no prosecutorial powers but is tasked with documenting abuses and preserving evidence that could be used by international judicial bodies such as the International Criminal Court.


The National
an hour ago
- The National
Syria announces ceasefire in Druze heartland of Sweida
Despite Syrian authorities announcing a ceasefire in the Druze minority's heartland of Sweida after three days of urban warfare, dozens were killed in fighting on Tuesday. Meanwhile, Israel has renewed air strikes on the region after deadly clashes between Druze groups and pro-government forces, who have besieged Sweida, the provincial capital. Sources in Jordan said Israeli drones were flying over Sweida amid strikes against army and police convoys to the west. Israel said the Syrian government has breached demilitarisation arrangements in the south of the country. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defence Minister Israel Katz have ordered their troops 'to immediately strike regime forces and weapons introduced into the Sweida area in the Druze Mountain in Syria for regime activity against the Druze'. A senior source in Jordan said at least 50 Druze fighters and civilians were killed on Tuesday in Sweida city, with defenders of the provincial capital putting up tough resistance against thousands of pro-government troops. The source said thousands of civilians have fled to the Jordanian border, without entering the kingdom. Thousands of troops and auxiliaries entered Sweida city from the west and north after the Druze spiritual leadership, led by Hikmat Al Hijri, announced that the province 'should be spared' further bloodshed, and that security forces should be let into the provincial capital to restore security and stability. Syrian Defence Minister Murhaf Abu Qasra said the government had agreed on a ceasefire with "notables" from the city and that the security forces would only respond if they come under fire. Mr Qasra said only interior ministry forces would remain in Sweida after the army finishes 'combing' the city. But Suwayda 24, a network of citizen journalists, said clashes were continuing in the area. Looting has occurred in neighbourhoods taken by government forces and many residents have fled, it said. Sources in Jordan confirmed thousands had left Sweida and are now in areas on the border with the kingdom. Despite Mr Al Hijri instructing Sweida residents to allow government forces into the city, he later appeared in a video saying the provincial capital continued to come under random shelling and that its people should 'make a stand for dignity'. Mr Abu Qasra was previously a commander for Hayat Tahrir Al Sham when it was an Al Qaeda splinter group in north-western Syria. HTS took power after leading the assault that overthrew Bashar Al Assad in December. Mr Al Hijri has labelled the HTS government 'extremists' who are not interested in building a civil and pluralistic state following Mr Al Assad's downfall. A Druze political figure close to Mr Al Hijri said Syria's authorities had received a 'green light' from Thomas Barrack, the US envoy to Syria, to enter Sweida. Elsewhere, Mr Barrack has been pushing for an extension of government control over parts of east Syria which are under Kurdish-led forces. In the absence of international protection, the Druze have no option except to lay down their arms, the source said. 'This is Barrack's doing. We are being attacked by than 100,000 regime forces,' he said. Sweida is home to most of Syria's registered 800,000 Druze. But many have emigrated, particularly during the country's 13-year civil war, with an estimated 270,000 Druze remaining in the city. The Druze, who follow an offshoot of Islam, are also present in Jordan, Israel and Lebanon. In a failed attempt to ward off the government's advance, Israel launched air strikes on southern Syria on Monday after dozens of people were killed in the fightingbetween allies of the Syrian government and Druze fighters. More strikes followed on Tuesday. About 38 Druze were killed in the clashes on the ground, which began on Sunday. The Defence Ministry said 18 of its troops were among the dead, while an estimated 30 government auxiliaries were also killed. Druze sources said pro-Syrian government militias on Sunday launched attacks on Sweida from Sunni areas to its west as the province came under siege by government forces. A war monitor put the total death toll at 89 on Monday. On Sunday, at least one Druze town was seized by militias from neighbouring Deraa, in the worst violence against the Druze community since clashes in April, sources said. Sweida and parts of eastern Syria, where the mostly Kurdish Syrian Democratic Forces are in control, are the only areas where the government does not fully exert control. The latest clashes in Sweida started last week after Fadlalah Duwara, a vegetable seller and member of the Druze community, was abducted while driving his lorry on the main road from Sweida to Damascus, which is under government control. His tribe responded by abducting a man in a Sunni neighbourhood of Sweida. The area is inhabited by members of Bedouin tribes who moved to the city decades ago from a rugged region on the outskirts.