Trump and Putin in Alaska: How a strange relationship took shape
ADVERTISEMENT Their first summit meeting in seven years kicks off with the surprising and symbolically significant choice of Alaska as the venue for talks between the US and Russian presidents. As they meet to discuss ending the war in Ukraine, the Kremlin's suggestion to hold it in a US state that once belonged to Russia hints at Putin's sly strategy to appeal directly to Trump's real-estate instincts and seal a grand bargain cutting others out.
Over the years, Putin has been the object of fascination for Trump, who praised his 'genius' when Russia invaded its neighbor in 2022. The two appear to enjoy an easy, even playful rapport (Putin often refers to his American counterpart simply as 'Donald').
In his first term, Trump made no secret of his admiration for the strongman leader and has spoken to him at least six times since returning to the White House. "Putin went through a hell of a lot with me," he told Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy in their infamous Oval Office clash.For his part, Putin is known for switching from mischief to menace in a flash. After his 'little green men' annexed Crimea in 2014, his answer to a pensioner asking him to take Alaska back was typical of his trolling style: 'Why would you need Alaska?' he said. 'It's cold out there as well. Let's not get worked up about it.'The world has changed dramatically since the calamitous 2018 summit in Helsinki, when Trump sided with Putin against his own officials on Russian election meddling in the 2016 presidential vote. Second-term Trump is a visibly more confident president and he's grown frustrated with Putin's delay tactics. Putin has been in power for more than a quarter of a century but the protracted conflict in Ukraine has dented his air of invincibility.
ADVERTISEMENT If the memorable moments from their past encounters are any measure, Friday's summit promises compelling political drama whatever the outcome. Here are some of the highlights.
Hamburg, Germany: Group of 20, July 2017
ADVERTISEMENT The biggest issue hanging over Trump and Putin's first major meeting was the role Russia played in interfering with the 2016 election that polls showed Hillary Clinton was favored to win. US intelligence agencies saw evidence of a Russian disinformation campaign aimed at boosting Trump, who was irritated that the legitimacy of his victory was being questioned. Moscow officials said Trump accepted Putin's denial of any Russian role.Russia's incursions into Ukraine, which at the time were confined to Crimea and the eastern part of the country, were a minor topic in a bilateral that lasted more than than two hours.
ADVERTISEMENT Things took an unusual turn at the dinner for leaders and their spouses at the Elbphilharmonie concert hall on the banks of the Elbe River. At the end of the meal, Trump walked over to Putin and the two spoke informally for an hour. No notes. No aides.The only record of this conversation came from the Kremlin's Russian interpreter. Trump later criticized reports that characterized this second encounter as secretive, although it was only disclosed after other dinner participants recounted what they observed.
Da Nang, Vietnam: APEC, November 2017
ADVERTISEMENT Putin's main motivation for traveling to Vietnam — rather than sending a lower ranking official — was to sit down with Trump. The Kremlin only found out on arrival that Trump had decided to cancel the meeting. The US president later agreed to meet 'on the fly.' Putin bristled at the slight.He blamed the failure of a more robust chat on a scheduling conflict and sent a warning. 'This had to do with Mr. Trump's schedule, my schedule and certain protocol formalities which our teams, unfortunately, failed to coordinate,' Putin said. 'They will be punished for that.'In Moscow, some pointed the finger at Trump's team for trying to make up for the political fallout from the controversial dinner in Hamburg. Others recognized that Trump was under pressure not to appear too accommodating to Putin as US lawmakers and intelligence agencies continued to investigate Russian influence in the 2016 election.
Helsinki, Finland: Summit, July 2018 After speaking with Putin for roughly two hours, Trump shocked even members of his own party by saying he believed Putin over his own intelligence agencies in their assessment of Russian election influence. He returned home to nearly universal rebukes of his performance. Republican Senator John McCain said 'no prior president has ever abased himself more abjectly before a tyrant.' There was bipartisan pressure to tighten US sanctions on Russia.Moscow, on the other hand, cheered both the tone and the outcome of the talks. Putin said the two leaders had 'begun the path toward positive changes.' During the meeting, Putin secretly offered Trump a proposal to hold a referendum in the parts of eastern Ukraine held by Russian separatists. Trump later rejected the idea publicly, although Putin went ahead anyway after his full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 when Trump was no longer in office.In Helsinki, Trump also invited Putin to Washington later that fall. That meeting, however, never happened.
Paris, France: WWI Armistice Ceremony, November 2018 There was rampant speculation about whether Trump and Putin would have a substantive meeting on the sidelines of an international commemoration of the 1918 armistice that ended World War I. John Bolton, then Trump's national security adviser, said the two did plan to meet. The Kremlin publicly played down the possibility of talks with Trump, even though Putin had met with Bolton several weeks earlier. It was a rainy weekend. Trump and Putin took their own motorcades, skipping the soggy and somber walk to the Arc de Triomphe with other world leaders. When Putin arrived for the group photo, he first shook the hand of French President Emmanuel Macron, then German Chancellor Angela Merkel — then he shook Trump's hand, with a brief thumbs-up. Trump declining to meet separately with Putin was seen in Russia as a slight, but forgivable snub.
Buenos Aires, Argentina: G-20, November 2018 With no trip to Washington and no bilateral in Paris, Putin was confident that he would see Trump in Buenos Aires. Trump confirmed that plan, but then he canceled the meeting via a social media post from the plane, citing Russia's capture of Ukrainian ships and sailors near Crimea.Russian officials were taken aback by Trump's affront – his second nixed meeting with Putin in less than a month – with one describing it as 'really bad.' Publicly, Putin's foreign policy adviser Yuri Ushakov insisted there was 'no offense taken,' even after the Kremlin had previously talked up the Argentina meeting.
Osaka, Japan: G-20, June 2019 Putin would have to wait until the following year's G-20 summit in Japan for his next sit-down with Trump on a day the US leader also met with four other heads of state. Speaking with reporters before the meeting, Putin noted that they hadn't met since Helsinki. Trump lauded past meetings and said 'we've had a very, very good relationship.'This meeting came just two months after US Special Counsel Robert Mueller released his 448-page report on Russian election interference. He indicted two dozen Russians for social media activity and hacking Democrats. Mueller said hecouldn't charge a sitting president with a crime, according to Justice Department policy. When asked in Osaka if he would tell Putin not to meddle in the 2020 US election, Trump said, 'Yes, of course I will.' He grinned and pointed at the Russian leader and gave a light-hearted warning: 'Don't meddle in the election.' Putin played along. They also joked about fake news, with Putin smilingly telling Trump in English: 'Yes, we have it too.'Putin invited Trump to Moscow to mark the 75th anniversary of the Allied victory in World War II in 2020. That meeting never happened.
By the time 2020 came, the world was locking down as the Coronavirus pandemic took hold. Trump was voted out of office and Putin went into deep isolation, emerging with a much more hostile view of the West.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Deccan Herald
14 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
UK PM Keir Starmer joins ‘Coalition of the Willing' talks over Russia-Ukraine conflict
Starmer praised the American President's efforts, which he said had 'brought us closer than ever before to ending Russia's illegal war in Ukraine' and reiterated Europe's 'unwavering support' for Ukraine.
Hindustan Times
14 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Putin Returns to Moscow With Air of Triumph After Summit
ANCHORAGE, Alaska—Russian President Vladimir Putin couldn't have scripted his first visit to the U.S. since 2015 much better. The Russian leader strutted along a red carpet at a U.S. air base and posed smiling with President Trump, who had weeks earlier been expressing mounting frustration with him and threatening to hit Russia and its trading partners with sanctions. He met with Trump under a sign that read 'pursuing peace.' When they emerged 3½ hours later, the leaders said they hadn't reached a deal. Instead, Putin used the stage to press his demands on Ukraine. Neither Trump nor Putin, who is facing an international arrest warrant for war crimes, took questions from the U.S. press. Putin, by clinching a long-awaited summit with Trump, scored a win. The Kremlin leader, has staked his legacy on dismantling the post-Cold War world order and resurrecting Russia's great-power status to put it on par with the U.S. 'Putin achieved exactly what he wanted: He simultaneously preserved his relationship with Trump, avoided additional sanctions, and received the blessing to continue his war,' said Andrey Kolesnikov, a Moscow-based political analyst and a columnist at New Times, an independent Russian-language magazine. The summit gave Putin a platform to turn longstanding narratives about the Ukraine war on their head, emphasizing that the U.S. and Russia are neighbors separated at their closest point by just over 2 miles of water. Meanwhile, he has tried to paint Europe and Ukraine as the two biggest obstacles to peace, while stepping up recent attacks on Ukrainian cities. Putin and Trump emerged from talks Friday without having a deal. Trump spoke to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky and European leaders in the days before the summit to understand better their red lines in negotiations with Russia. But the images of the two leaders in Alaska were certainly unsettling on the continent. Trump rolled out a red carpet for Putin on the taxiway of the U.S. air base, applauding as the Kremlin leader approached. After a firm handshake, Trump invited him to ride in his armored limousine to the meeting. 'Putin loves trolling and rubbing Europeans' noses in the fact that there is a strong relationship with Trump,' said Andrew Weiss, who worked on Russian affairs in George H.W. Bush's and Bill Clinton's administrations. Hours after arriving back in Moscow, Putin gathered his top officials inside the Kremlin to tell them the summit had been a resounding success. 'We have not had direct negotiations of this kind at this level for a long time,' he said to an array of officials, including the defense minister, the chief of staff and intelligence chiefs. 'I repeat once again: We had the opportunity to calmly and in detail once again explain our position.' To be sure, Trump said in the days before the summit that he didn't expect any major breakthroughs and said he hoped he could clinch a cease-fire and lay the foundation for a lasting peace process. But in the hours after the summit, previous calls for an immediate cease-fire evaporated. Meanwhile, Trump's own language mirrored that of the Russian side, calling in a post on Truth Social for an overarching peace agreement as opposed to a halt to fighting first. That effectively gives Putin the green light to continue the fighting to capture more land in eastern Ukraine, where Russian troops are making gains. 'Tonight, the president of our great country showed Trump, the president of another great country, that Russia is a party to be reckoned with,' said Alexander Dugin, a far-right politician and a pro-Putin ideologue. 'Therefore, we cannot be forced to do things that anyone wants, be it the West or Trump.' Putin, who has called the fall of the Soviet Union a geopolitical catastrophe, has been working to resurrect slowly Moscow's sphere of influence in parts of the territory that once encompassed the Soviet Union. Ukraine occupies a special place in Russian history. It is where the founding dynasty of the Russian Empire was formed. He is unlikely to sacrifice his ambition to reclaim Ukraine as a part of Russia to improve relations with Washington. But it would be a coup for the Russian leader if he could accomplish both after years of Western isolation sparked by his invasion. 'Both sides want normalization, which has a very strong business aspect that could unlock some money flows for both countries,' said Elina Ribakova, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics. Putin seemed to signal as much on Friday when he signed a decree that could offer Exxon Mobil re-entry into the Russian market through a stake in the potentially lucrative Sakhalin-1 oil field, which it pulled out of after Russia's full-scale invasion in 2022. Whether the takeaways from the summit can translate into a sustainable peace process is hard to determine. In a call from Air Force One on his way home from the summit, Trump relayed to the Europeans the outcome of the meeting and that Putin wanted to keep fighting, according to European officials. Trump plans to meet Monday with Zelensky, who wasn't invited to Friday's summit. Analysts said expectations are low that a road to peace can be found in a war that Russia is slowly winning. 'The bubble of inflated expectations has burst, and the process itself has turned into 'Waiting for Godot,'' said Kolesnikov, referring to a play about endless waiting. Write to Thomas Grove at
NDTV
24 minutes ago
- NDTV
US Suspends Visas For Gazans Seeking Medical Aid After Far-Right Campaign
The US government said Saturday it is suspending visitor visas for Gazans after a far-right influencer with the ear of President Donald Trump complained that wounded Palestinians had been allowed to seek medical treatment in the United States. The announcement came one day after a series of furious social media posts by Laura Loomer, who is known for promoting racist conspiracy theories and claiming that the 9/11 terrorist attacks were an inside job. "All visitor visas for individuals from Gaza are being stopped while we conduct a full and thorough review of the process and procedures used to issue a small number of temporary medical-humanitarian visas in recent days," the State Department, which is led by Marco Rubio, wrote on X. In a series of posts on X Friday, Loomer called on the State Department to stop giving visas to Palestinians from Gaza who she said were "pro-HAMAS... affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood and funded by Qatar," without providing evidence. Loomer's target was the US-based charity HEAL Palestine, which said last week it had helped 11 critically wounded Gazan children -- as well as their caregivers and siblings -- arrive safely in the US for medical treatment. It was "the largest single medical evacuation of injured children from Gaza to the US," the charity said on its website. 'Dangerous and inhumane' "Truly unacceptable," Loomer wrote in another X post. "Someone needs to be fired at @StateDept when @marcorubio figures out who approved the visas." "Qatar transported these GAZANS into the US via @qatarairways," she said. Qatar is "literally flooding our country with jihadis," she added. Loomer said she had spoken to the staff of Republican Tom Cotton, who chairs the Senate intelligence committee, adding that they were "also looking into how these GAZANS got visas to come into the US." Republican Congressman Randy Fine explicitly commended Loomer after the visa change was announced, in a sign of her sway over some US policy. "Massive credit needs to be given to @LauraLoomer for uncovering this and making me and other officials aware. Well done, Laura," Fine wrote on X. The Palestine Children's Relief Fund, a US-based charity, called on the Trump administration to "reverse this dangerous and inhumane decision." Over the last 30 years the charity has evacuated thousands of Palestinian children to the US for medical care, it said a statement. "Medical evacuations are a lifeline for the children of Gaza who would otherwise face unimaginable suffering or death due to the collapse of medical infrastructure in Gaza." Though Loomer holds no official position, she wields significant power, and is reported to have successfully pushed for the dismissal of several senior US security officials she deemed disloyal to Trump. In July, Loomer took aim at a job offer made to a highly qualified Biden-era official for a prestigious position at the West Point military academy. The Pentagon rescinded the offer one day later. Trump also fired the head of the highly sensitive National Security Agency, Timothy Haugh, and his deputy Wendy Noble in April at the apparent urging of Loomer, after she met with the president at the White House. "No other content creator or journalist has gotten as many Biden holdovers fired from the Trump admin!" Loomer posted on X Saturday.
