He got Kikau off at the judiciary. Now he wants NRL to overhaul the system
The lawyer who successfully challenged Viliame Kikau's dangerous contact charge at the judiciary on Tuesday night has called for an overhaul of the system to provide discounts to representative players or those participating in the finals series.
Kikau was facing an $1800 fine with an early guilty plea for his challenge on Parramatta kicker Mitchell Moses, but the Bulldogs elected to contest the charge despite Kikau not being in danger of missing a match through suspension.
The club feared the prospect of the guilty plea going on his record, increasing the likelihood that a future misdemeanour could result in the Kikau missing a big end-of-season game.
The decision to contest the charge proved a masterstroke, with Kikau's lawyer Paul McGirr earning a rare victory in just his second appearance at the judiciary. McGirr was able to convince the panel that Kikau didn't put Moses into a dangerous position, and that the Eels star was playing for a penalty.
'Players are very wily and will try to gain any edge,' McGirr said on Wednesday. 'Is it gamesmanship? Possibly. But the judiciary and match officials need to be turned on to that and not fall for the trap. It's a fine line.'
McGirr felt the bigger issue was the practice of players not contesting charges of which they believed they were innocent, for fear of copping a greater sanction at Rugby League Central. He said that pleading guilty to minor matters 'can come back and haunt you' if subsequent offences resulted in time on the sidelines.
'At the time, you think, 'It's only a fine, we'll pay for you, who cares?'' McGirr explained. 'But it goes on your record and then when you need your good record, you think about how sad that could be going into the finals.
'That would be Kikau's second strike. Not that he's planning on offending, but it could prove the difference between playing in a grand final or not. Ironically, you get done on a double points weekend and you think 'Why did I plead to that when I wasn't even guilty?'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
2 hours ago
- News.com.au
Western Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge says Sam Darcy is not the answer to all their problems
Western Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge insists his team isn't living in 'fantasy land' regarding the prospect of 21-year-old Sam Darcy automatically turning things around for his team despite a fantastic return from injury on Thursday night. Beveridge said Darcy should also prepare for a 'fair bit of attention' from the opposition and could need a better go from umpires as he emerges as one of the AFL's most threatening players. Darcy had 19 disposals (11 contested), nine marks (four), three goals, a goal assist and nine score involvements to be one of the most influential men on the ground during the Dogs' 72-point shellacking of St Kilda at Marvel Stadium. The Bulldogs held down the fort reasonably well while Darcy was rehabilitating his injured knee, winning three out of six games, but their 1-6 record against top-eight teams is what is front of Beveridge's mind as he strives for more consistency from his charges in the second half of the season. 'We're living in the real world here and not in fantasy land around the fact that we've dropped six games against probably the established better teams in the competition at the moment,' Beveridge said. 'And some of those games have been with Sam in the team. 'I mean, he makes a difference, there's no doubt about it, but our challenge is going to be now to stay on a keel and to gain some momentum in the season week to week and not come off our better work. 'We won't come out of Marvel Stadium tonight kicking up our heels … ultimately we're middle of the pack. 'We know Sam will help but we've still got to spread the load and that'll be our mandate week to week now.' Beveridge suggested that Darcy was unfairly treated by the umpires in his comeback game but he would have to learn to cope with the extra physicality opposition teams would continue to send his way. 'Obviously, they (St Kilda) paid him a fair bit of attention,' Beveridge said. 'It's something that he's going to have to deal with from week to week I think. 'As long as he's just treated like every other key forward, that's all that matters. 'But he fought through that and I think it's difficult when you're in so much physical contact, and he's obviously long and stay disciplined and no free kicks away and that sort of stuff, especially when you're not getting any yourself. So he needs to just temper that.' When pressed further on the way his young superstar was treated, Beveridge declined to elaborate. Darcy was one of 13 Bulldogs goalkickers on Thursday night, and the coach was rapt with the potency of the forward structure. 'It's where we need to be and so I'd have to say that it worked reasonably well,' Beveridge said. 'I think we got six goals from forward-half turnovers. It's a pretty good result. We haven't been getting that and our forward-50 tackling was a bit better.' Captain Marcus Bontempelli was shut down effectively by gun St Kilda tagger Marcus Windhager, and it made the Bulldogs' dominant midfield performance all the more pleasing for Beveridge. 'The mids spread the load through there, they really did,' Beveridge said. 'Marcus (Bontempelli) played a really selfless game tonight, and it meant other teammates capitalised on that.'
Sydney Morning Herald
16 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Trbojevic knocked back NSW 18th man job to play for Manly. He shouldn't have to choose
Of the 20 teams that have taken the field since the 18th man was introduced into State of Origin back in 2022, only one of those has been in a position to activate the concussion substitute. That came in game one of the 2024 series, when Felise Kaufusi was activated after eight minutes following a head-high tackle from Joseph Suaalii on Reece Walsh which resulted in the NSW debutant being sent off and the Queensland fullback ruled out of the game through concussion. Bulldogs five-eighth Matt Burton will next week be NSW's 18th man for the fifth time in the 11 games since the concussion substitute was introduced. However, the rules stipulate that he is ineligible to play for the Bulldogs against South Sydney this Sunday – the third time will have missed a Bulldogs game for a five per cent chance of being activated by the Blues. NSW sources with knowledge of team selection for game one said Trbojevic was initially selected as the NSW Blues' 18th man for the opening game of the series. Trbojevic, however, declined the invitation because it meant he was made to choose between his state and club. Trbojevic has long been burdened by a guilt that his body has prohibited him from providing Manly value for the money they pay him. It's why he volunteered to take a $750,000 pay cut last year before the NRL intervened and rejected his request due to salary cap reasons. With his team struggling for form and licking their wounds after a round 10 loss to Cronulla, Trbojevic – having already missed four of his side's first 10 games of the year, told the Blues he felt obliged to play for Manly the following week rather than join the Blues in camp for 10 days with no guarantee of playing. The Blues duly called Campbell Graham into the squad as the 18th man, but it should have never come to that. The rules allow the 19th and 20th players in Origin squads to be released from the respective NSW and Queensland camps to rejoin their clubs this weekend. So Keaon Koloamatangi, NSW's 19th player, will go back to South Sydney to try to help them knock off the Burton-less Bulldogs. How is that that fair? Burton is 18th man on game day, not the next in line. When Blues five-eighth Mitch Moses went down on Thursday, NSW called Jarome Luai in to take his place instead of the 18th man who plays the very same position. When Brian To'o pulled up sore, they didn't reshuffle their backline to accommodate Burton – they brought in Jacob Kiraz. The NRL will argue that they are concerned about player workloads. That they don't want Matt Burton having to play on Sunday and then potentially (albeit only a 5 per cent chance) back up three days later for the Blues. But it's OK for the NRL to send five Penrith players on an economy-class, seven-hour red-eye flight from Perth to Auckland to try and salvage their season against the Warriors three days after Origin? No wonder Penrith coach Ivan Cleary is likely to rest them. There's an obvious solution, at least to the 18th man debacle and not the scheduling farce facing the reigning champions. The 18th man shouldn't be selected until the Sunday night before an Origin. Allow the states to pick extended squads as they do now, but send players 18, 19 and 20 back to their clubs. And at the end of the round, having determined everyone's fitness, then decide who Mr 5 per cent should be. Burton misses this weekend's game for the Bulldogs. Next week, they have the bye and he has another week off. By the time he plays again, he wouldn't have played a game of footy for three weeks. In what world is that good for NSW or the Bulldogs?
The Age
16 hours ago
- The Age
Trbojevic knocked back NSW 18th man job to play for Manly. He shouldn't have to choose
Of the 20 teams that have taken the field since the 18th man was introduced into State of Origin back in 2022, only one of those has been in a position to activate the concussion substitute. That came in game one of the 2024 series, when Felise Kaufusi was activated after eight minutes following a head-high tackle from Joseph Suaalii on Reece Walsh which resulted in the NSW debutant being sent off and the Queensland fullback ruled out of the game through concussion. Bulldogs five-eighth Matt Burton will next week be NSW's 18th man for the fifth time in the 11 games since the concussion substitute was introduced. However, the rules stipulate that he is ineligible to play for the Bulldogs against South Sydney this Sunday – the third time will have missed a Bulldogs game for a five per cent chance of being activated by the Blues. NSW sources with knowledge of team selection for game one said Trbojevic was initially selected as the NSW Blues' 18th man for the opening game of the series. Trbojevic, however, declined the invitation because it meant he was made to choose between his state and club. Trbojevic has long been burdened by a guilt that his body has prohibited him from providing Manly value for the money they pay him. It's why he volunteered to take a $750,000 pay cut last year before the NRL intervened and rejected his request due to salary cap reasons. With his team struggling for form and licking their wounds after a round 10 loss to Cronulla, Trbojevic – having already missed four of his side's first 10 games of the year, told the Blues he felt obliged to play for Manly the following week rather than join the Blues in camp for 10 days with no guarantee of playing. The Blues duly called Campbell Graham into the squad as the 18th man, but it should have never come to that. The rules allow the 19th and 20th players in Origin squads to be released from the respective NSW and Queensland camps to rejoin their clubs this weekend. So Keaon Koloamatangi, NSW's 19th player, will go back to South Sydney to try to help them knock off the Burton-less Bulldogs. How is that that fair? Burton is 18th man on game day, not the next in line. When Blues five-eighth Mitch Moses went down on Thursday, NSW called Jarome Luai in to take his place instead of the 18th man who plays the very same position. When Brian To'o pulled up sore, they didn't reshuffle their backline to accommodate Burton – they brought in Jacob Kiraz. The NRL will argue that they are concerned about player workloads. That they don't want Matt Burton having to play on Sunday and then potentially (albeit only a 5 per cent chance) back up three days later for the Blues. But it's OK for the NRL to send five Penrith players on an economy-class, seven-hour red-eye flight from Perth to Auckland to try and salvage their season against the Warriors three days after Origin? No wonder Penrith coach Ivan Cleary is likely to rest them. There's an obvious solution, at least to the 18th man debacle and not the scheduling farce facing the reigning champions. The 18th man shouldn't be selected until the Sunday night before an Origin. Allow the states to pick extended squads as they do now, but send players 18, 19 and 20 back to their clubs. And at the end of the round, having determined everyone's fitness, then decide who Mr 5 per cent should be. Burton misses this weekend's game for the Bulldogs. Next week, they have the bye and he has another week off. By the time he plays again, he wouldn't have played a game of footy for three weeks. In what world is that good for NSW or the Bulldogs?
