B.C. solicitor general says Opposition operative took mentally ill man from care home
VICTORIA — British Columbia's Solicitor General is accusing the B.C. Conservative Party of involvement in removing a man from a mental-health facility against the wishes of his family as the Opposition party sought evidence of irregularities in the October provincial election.
Garry Begg says in a court filing that the man was found in a state of "psychosis" after being reported missing, and that the vehicle that took him away from Argyll Lodge care home in the riding of Surrey-Guildford in January was located by police outside the law office of the defeated Conservative candidate who is pursuing allegations of irregularities.
Begg's filing, dated Tuesday and signed by his lawyer, says the man was admitted to a hospital emergency room under the Mental Health Act and he remains hospitalized in a secured unit.
The woman accused of acting on behalf of the Conservatives was identified in Begg's filing as Jatinder Sodhi.
'He has lost his home and his independence as a result of the interference of Ms. Sodhi on behalf of the petitioner and the Conservative Party of B.C. in his care,' says Begg's response, released by the NDP on Thursday.
The allegations are among duelling narratives presented by the B.C. government and the Opposition about Argyll Lodge, which is at the heart of Conservative allegations of voter irregularities in the election.
Begg's legal filing is in response to a petition by Conservative candidate Honveer Singh Randhawa, who is asking the B.C. Supreme Court to invalidate Begg's 22-vote election win in Surrey-Guildford that gave the NDP a one-seat majority.
Randhawa and the Conservatives have made a series of allegations of voting irregularities at Argyll Lodge, a community residential facility for adults with mental illness.
The Conservatives, meanwhile, cited an affidavit by the Green candidate in the riding, Manjeet Singh Sahota, which says that when he tried to campaign at the facility, a caregiver told him the residents do not vote.
The BC Green Party confirmed the existence of the affidavit, saying in a statement that the party will refrain from drawing conclusions until all evidence has been examined.
"Because of my conversation with the caregiver, I was left with an impression that no one votes from the lodge, so I believe I did not leave my campaign materials there either," Sahota's affidavit says, according to a news release from the Conservatives.
"A few days later I was canvassing in the same neighbourhood, and I did not revisit the house because earlier I was told that the people living at the lodge do not participate in voting.'
Conservative Leader John Rustad on Thursday renewed calls for a public inquiry about the alleged irregularities at Argyll Lodge as he described Sahota's affidavit.
"We now know from the other affidavits that those members in that lodge voted, that they all voted by mail," Rustad told reporters.
In January, Elections BC suspended its review of the Conservative complaint over potential violations after the party said it had evidence of 45 suspicious votes in Surrey-Guildford. Elections BC said the review was suspended until the courts had ruled on Randhawa's petition.
Begg's filing cites affidavits from lodge staff and a resident's relative.
It says Sodhi was warned by RCMP to stay away from Argyll Lodge after she began visiting residents starting in November last year, giving them cash and accusing relatives of not caring for them.
The filing says the facility's director and family members were concerned Sodhi was "a scam artist" trying to exploit two residents, unaware that she "was in fact assisting the Conservative Party of B.C. in gathering information for the petition," the response says.
Begg's response says in spite of the police warning Sodhi took two residents to open bank accounts and also took them to a lawyer to sign statements about the election that "they could neither read nor understand."
The response says one resident was allegedly moved out of the facility by Sodhi despite his son's request for a restraining order or peace bond against her.
It says the black truck that took the resident away was later located by police outside the Randhawa's law office.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Feb. 27, 2025.
Marcy Nicholson, The Canadian Press
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
43 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Farage's Reform will ‘let the SNP in', Badenoch warns
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has warned Scots that Nigel Farage's Reform will 'let the SNP in'. She said 'Scottish people deserve better' than another five years of John Swinney's party in power at Holyrood. Hitting out at Reform – which claimed on Friday to now have 11,000 members in Scotland – she said for Mr Farage's party, the union between Scotland and England is 'just not that important'. In contrast, Mrs Badenoch stressed the Conservatives will 'always be proud' of the union. 'Our party will always be ready to protect Scotland's place in the United Kingdom,' she added. She claimed for Labour and Sir Keir Starmer, belief in the union is 'negotiable', like 'every so-called promise' the Prime Minister makes. Speaking at the Scottish Conservative Party conference in Edinburgh on Friday, Mrs Badenoch said: 'We know that when it really matters, like on gender or free speech or taxes, Labour will fold and vote with the SNP.' She went on to say: 'In April this year, Nigel Farage said he would be fine with the SNP winning another five years in power. 'He's fine with another five years of higher bills, longer waiting lists, declining school standards, gender madness, and ultimately, independence.' Addressing her first Scottish conference since taking on the top job, Mrs Badenoch claimed: 'Reform will vote to let the SNP in, Conservatives will only ever vote to get the nationalists out.' Her speech came just over a week after a Holyrood by-election in which the Tories came fourth, well behind Reform in third. Meanwhile an opinion poll has suggested Mr Farage's party could come second in next May's Holyrood election. In that ballot, Mrs Badenoch said Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay will 'put forward a different way of doing things to the SNP and Labour'. She promised the Tories will fight the election on a platform of 'positive new policies to fire up economic growth, create opportunities for workers and businesses, reward aspiration with lower taxes, and improve school standards'. Mrs Badenoch told the conference: 'Under my leadership, and with Russell Findlay in charge in Scotland, my party knows where it stands. 'With your help, we will renew Conservative policies with common sense.' She accepted in her speech the Tories in power at Westminster 'didn't always get things right'. But Mrs Badenoch insisted her election, coupled with Mr Findlay taking over to head the Scottish party last year, mean they are 'under new leadership'. She told supporters the Tories will 'once again represent everyone across Scotland and the United Kingdom who believes the same things that we do'. Adding that she is 'renewing this party', she declared: 'This speech isn't about looking back. It's about the future. Our future.' 🗣️ @KemiBadenoch: "The Conservative & Unionist Party is ready to fight for a common-sense future for Scotland and an even stronger United Kingdom."#SCC25 — Scottish Conservatives (@ScotTories) June 13, 2025 Part of that 'positive vision of the future' includes 'standing up' for the North Sea oil and gas industry, with Mrs Badenoch claiming that by increasing the energy profits levy – also known as the windfall tax – the Tories had introduced, Labour is 'killing the oil and gas industry'. Speaking about the levy, she said: 'Frankly if it is allowed to remain in place until 2030, as is Labour's current plan, there will be no industry left to tax. 'Thousands will have been made unemployed and all the while we import more gas from overseas – from the very same basin in which we are banned from drilling.' She called on the UK Government to remove the energy profits levy, as she added that the Tories would also 'scrap the ban on new licences' for oil and gas developments that has been imposed since Labour came to power. 'We will champion our own industry,' Mrs Badenoch told supporters. 'We will let this great British, great Scottish industry thrive, grow and create jobs – ensuring our energy security for generations to come and making Scotland richer in the process.' She also pledged the Tories will spend more on defence, saying this is crucial as 'our world becomes even more dangerous'. Citing conflict in the Middle East as well as in Ukraine, Mrs Badenoch said it 'becomes even harder to understand why Labour didn't use the spending review this week to set out a clear plan to get to 3% on defence spending'. The Tories, she insisted, will 'stand by Scotland's defence industry to build the security equipment and systems that keep us safe'.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
SNP's wish to ‘throw open our borders' would risk security
Tory leader Kemi Badenoch has claimed the Scottish Government's stance on immigration would risk the country's security. Writing in the Daily Mail ahead of the Scottish Conservative conference in Edinburgh, Mrs Badenoch said the SNP's position 'is not remotely serious'. The Scottish Government is much more liberal than both the UK Labour Government and the Tories on immigration, repeatedly calling for more people to be allowed to come to Scotland, but Holyrood does not have the powers to make changes. Ministers have pushed for a shift in the system on a number of occasions, going so far as to propose a separate Scottish visa in 2020 under Nicola Sturgeon – a pitch which was quickly rejected by the Conservative-led government of the time. Mrs Badenoch wrote: 'We need a new, sustainable system that only admits a strict number of people who come here legally, do the right thing, and who contribute to society. 'That means we must introduce a strict numerical cap on legal migration, ensure there is zero-tolerance for foreign criminals, and pass the Deportation Bill to remove those who should not be here. 'The left-wing parties at Holyrood – not just the SNP, but also Labour and the Lib Dems – don't believe tougher action is necessary. Scottish Conservative Party Conference is now in full swing. Follow along to see how @RussellFindlay1 is bringing common sense to Scottish politics 🏴🇬🇧#SCC25 — Scottish Conservatives (@ScotTories) June 13, 2025 'On immigration, those parties have policies student politicians would be ashamed of. 'The SNP's stance, in particular, is not remotely serious. 'If they ever got their way, they would put our citizens' security at risk. It's the nationalists' view that we should just throw open our borders, without any checks or limitations on who comes into the country.' The Scottish Government has been contacted for comment.
Hamilton Spectator
11 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Very proud to be Canadian? That's less likely now for supporters of one party, survey suggests
OTTAWA — With U.S President Donald Trump making economic and expansionist threats against his northern neighbours, a new survey suggests that pride in being Canadian has increased among supporters of all federal parties — except Conservatives. The number of Canadians who feel proud of their country has rebounded overall, according to research shared exclusively with the Star from the Environics Institute, with 62 per cent now indicating that they are very proud to be Canadian, compared to 53 per cent who said the same last September. 'This change marks the first time that this measure has increased by more than a few percentage points from one survey to the next, since our tracking first began in 1985,' a report outlining the survey's findings notes. But when the results are broken down by federal party support, Conservative voters bucked the trend posted by Liberal, NDP and Bloc Québécois supporters, who all showed increased pride in their national identity. Seventy-seven per cent of Liberal supporters now say they are very proud to be Canadian, up five points from last fall, while the proportion of NDP supporters who felt the same way grew from 61 to 68 per cent. The number of Bloc supporters who felt very proud of being Canadian, meanwhile, grew from 30 per cent to 42 per cent, although the report notes that the finding should be treated with caution due to a smaller number of responses from those who backed the traditionally separatist party. By contrast, fewer Conservative voters said they were very proud of being Canadian compared to last fall, dropping from 46 to 43 per cent. The current number is the lowest level logged by Conservative-leaning supporters since the research institute first began tracking this question in 1985. The Environics Institute launched the survey after this spring's federal election, which followed a campaign defined by how parties platformed Canada's strengths against the backdrop of Trump's aggression. The institute released the results of a companion survey last week, which suggested that Canadian public sentiment toward the U.S. had plunged to new lows. The new survey was conducted via telephone with 2,000 Canadians from May 5 to 18, with a sample of this size producing a margin of error within plus or minus 2.2 percentage points, 19 times out of 20. Andrew Parkin, the institute's executive director, said pride in Canada has seen the steepest decline overall among Conservative backers. 'The Conservatives today are about half as likely as Conservatives in 2010 to have strong pride in being Canadian,' Parkin said. But he added that the results aren't necessarily surprising, because supporters within the blue tent are contending with an election result for which they don't have much enthusiasm. 'The things that they think are wrong about the direction that the country was heading (in) are not going to change because the government didn't change, or at least the party in government didn't change,' Parkin said. Parkin said a result he did find surprising was that while pride in being Canadian remains lowest in Quebec, the province is the only part of the country where the proportion of Canadians who feel very proud of their country is higher, not lower, than it was in 2010. Compared to 2024, strong pride in being Canadian jumped eight points in Quebec. Alberta, where secessionist sentiment has recently surfaced in some quarters, had a seven-point increase. Also of note, Parkin said, was how strong pride in Canadian identity saw a resurgence in every region of the country, aside from Atlantic Canada, which dropped from 64 per cent in 2024 to 62 per cent now. 'The fact that it's not the highest in Atlantic Canada, where traditionally, going back, it would have been among the highest, I think (is) worth noticing,' he said.
