Vancouver Islanders call for better access and environmental oversight of private forest lands
Mosaic Forest Management, which oversees roughly 550,000 hectares of privately owned forest land between Victoria, Sooke and Campbell River, reports that the survey received over 7,600 responses and the feedback was clear: open the gates.
According to Mosaic's website, the company has over 20 gates on the Island that it can open and close to control recreational use — including those controlling access to popular hikes like Century Sam in Comox and Mount Arrowsmith near Port Alberni, and front-country camping sites like Nanaimo Lakes.
Access to the areas is often limited to weekends between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m.
Steve Mjaaland, Mosaic's manager of forest protection, says the company would like to enhance recreational access, but gate closures are often necessary for safety and to prevent wildfires.
"It's a working forest. There are a lot of high-risk hazards, especially hauling on the roads, which would probably be the biggest risk with traffic," he said.
Among those calling for better access: Jenn Holland, who currently chairs an alliance of almost 30 grassroots groups on the Island called the Vancouver Island Private Managed Forest Land Action Alliance.
"There's gates everywhere and people can't get to beloved waterfalls or lakes or camping sites that they used to be able to access," she said.
Holland says the issue goes beyond recreation.
"We can't get in there, and we can't see what they're doing back there. We can't see if there's been a landslide. We can't see if a water course has been logged. We can't see that they've logged an entire watershed," she said.
"It's not just access for recreation, but it's access for accountability that's missing."
WATCH | Hikers call for greater access to the Island's backcountry:
Issue goes beyond the gates, say conservationists
Holland says that while hiking access is something that the public can easily grasp, she's focused on bigger issues, like conservation, private forest landowners and the province, that go beyond Mosaic's control of the gates.
Dave Weaver, a retired forestry worker who now volunteers with the Beaufort Watershed Stewards, one of the groups that make up the Vancouver Island Private Managed Forest Land Action Alliance, says he takes issue with the Private Managed Forest Land Program, which was established in 2003 under the Private Managed Forest Land Act.
According to the province's website, the program works by setting out management objectives for forest landowners, who in turn develop management strategies most appropriate for their land.
Weaver says the act sets a low bar for forestry practices, especially in comparison to regulations for public forest lands, which have more restrictions on harvesting and clearcuts, and greater requirements for public accountability.
"We need to have these difficult conversations very soon, with all the parties involved — with the provincial government, with the landowners," he said.
WATCH: Vancouver Island groups call for forestry reform on private land:
In 2019, the province undertook a review of the Private Managed Forest Land Act, where Weaver says extensive feedback was collected from the public, local government and First Nations.
The province published its findings, which show there was a recurring theme of concern about the sustainability of forestry practices and the effects on things like watersheds on privately managed forest land — but Weaver claims no tangible change ever came from the review.
In an emailed statement, the Ministry of Forests said it's working to modernize the act following the 2019 review, and that "many of the issues raised during the review are being addressed through the government's work to make sure forestry supports ecosystem values."
But Weaver says he believes even that review would be out of date by today's standards and is joined by the alliance in calling on the province to undertake a new review.
In a statement, Mosaic said it would be willing to work with community partners toward a sustainable strategy.
"Mosaic supports enhanced collaboration between private forest landowners, First Nations, the Province, and communities to ensure responsible forest management plays a key role in BC's economic, reconciliation and climate strategies," said Karen Brandt, the senior vice president of public affairs and partnerships at Mosaic Forest Management.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Summerside approves new family shelter, but more services still needed, says non-profit
A path has been cleared to allow for the construction of a new family emergency shelter geared toward women and their children in western P.E.I. Summerside council voted unanimously Monday night to rezone a portion of the city to allow LifeHouse to expand its services by building a new five-bed shelter. Shelby Pitre, the outreach co-ordinator for the organization, said the current shelter is often at capacity. LifeHouse, which is run with support of BGC Summerside, had to turn away around 80 women in 2024 because it was full. "This rezoning for the shelter is absolutely incredible," Pitre said. "It just provides safety and security to women who wouldn't have had it otherwise." Pitre said the expansion will add the shelter's first accessible room, and will offer both transitional and permanent housing options. 'Sad statistic' JP Desrosiers, Summerside's chief administrative officer, said he was surprised to hear how many women had been turned away from the shelter last year. "As a resident and a representative of the City of Summerside, it's a sad statistic," he said. "I'm glad to see a local community group like the BGC to step up and provide services." While the city hasn't opened shelters itself, Desrosiers said council has been supportive of the operators that have. "I think, generally speaking, they're all doing a good job," he said. "I think that's noticed by the nearby residents, when we have a rezoning like [Monday] night and virtually no commentary to the contrary at all." Elysha Whitlock, executive director of The Village Summerside, a non-profit dedicated to helping the vulnerable and unhoused population, echoed Derosiers' sentiments about LifeHouse. "It's absolutely heartbreaking to hear that high volume has been turned away," Whitlock said. "They can only do what they're able to do, and with the high volume they have helped, it's completely understandable that they just don't have the space." She said The Village Summerside recently helped a woman and her child with a damage deposit on a rental home after they'd spent 18 days at a motel. "You don't necessarily see unhoused families in park settings. Just because we're not seeing it, does not mean it's not there," she said. "Everybody's really struggling right now, and we've had to accept the fact that we've started assisting with damage deposits." Whitlock said Summerside needs to have different types of support. She's advocated in the past for low-barrier shelters that serve people in active addiction, but said that can't always be possible "Ideally in the future, perhaps there could be an option to open a low-barrier, strictly women's shelter for those females who aren't necessarily comfortable in a shelter environment," she said. "For now, I think we've made great strides... and I am absolutely thrilled to hear the news of the new family emergency shelter opening up." Staff with LifeHouse said they aren't sure when the new shelter will open, but that ideally they'd like to have it up and running by next year.
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Search underway for missing boater off Labrador coast
A search and rescue effort is underway for a missing boater off the east coast of Labrador, a Joint Rescue Coordination Centre spokesperson told CBC News on Tuesday. The missing boater is aboard a 20-foot sailboat, with a last reported position — from one week ago — estimated to be 296 kilometres, or 160 nautical miles, off of Cartwright. The JRCC said the sailor had been updating friends and posting on social media about the trip. The last time they were heard from was on Thursday. A Hercules aircraft was deployed from Trenton, Ont., and the Canadian Coast Guard sent vessels to the area to participate in the search. PAL aircraft are also helping in the search. The JRCC said the person is from Tadoussac, Que., and sailed out of Blanc Sablon with the intention of reaching Greenland. No other details are available. Download our free CBC News app to sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Sign up for our daily headlines newsletter here. Click here to visit our landing page. Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Search for B.C.'s Best Symbol: Round 2 — Nature
For a province so synonymous with trees, and with so many people who love all they provide, it's ironic that the two species British Columbians might love the most carry with them a hint of false advertising. "The Douglas Fir isn't a fir at all — it's part of the 'false hemlock' family," said CBC science specialist Darius Mahdavi, referencing the mighty conifer that can reach heights of 100 metres. "But western red 'cedar' is no better, because it's actually a cypress." Despite the somewhat misleading names, the two types of trees are easily identifiable through much of British Columbia, and have advanced to the second round of the Search for B.C.'s Best Symbol. Now, however, they face off against each other in the ultimate tree tussle to see which one will advance to the semifinals of the nature quadrant of the competition. Mahdavi says both trees have a lot going for each other. "They are absolutely essential to ecosystems across B.C., providing habitat and food and maintaining the environment," contrasting the Douglas Fir's durability with the many ways red cedar have been used by First Nations along the coast. Ultimately though, only one can be the last tree standing. What will you vote for? Four symbols move on, four go home The Search for B.C.'s Best Symbol continues its second round Tuesday with the nature quadrant, with four different matchups that will determine which iconic and historic elements of B.C.'s land will move on to the next round. Douglas fir vs. Western redcedar. Pot leaf vs. gold nugget. Dogwood flower vs. mountaintop. Okanagan cherries vs. Vancouver Island oysters. While it has been mostly top seeds advancing in the friendly competition so far, there are a few small but mighty symbols still in the running — including one from the Okanagan. "Cherries are a perfect bite-size fruit, and when they are abundant and the weather co-operates, they are phenomenal," said Erin Carlson, a cherry grower at the Carcajou Fruit Company in Summerland. It faces the Vancouver Island oyster this round, after defeating Okanagan peaches in round two. The cherry industry is on pace to have a good year — mostly because of better weather, but partly because of the power certain symbols gain in times of political tension. "Canadian Cherry Month [has begun], and the goal is to get more Canadians to buy more B.C. cherries and more Canadian," said Carlson. "[Cherries] out of Washington you would find, especially as you head to Manitoba and beyond, because they try to undercut our market. But this year, there's a lot of optimism that supermarkets across the country are going to be able to stock us." Voting is open until 10 p.m. Pacific time. May the best symbol win!