Onerous regulations frustrating delivery of infrastructure, NED told
Ireland's complex regulatory environment is frustrating the delivery of badly needed infrastructure, the National Economic Dialogue (NED) event in
Dublin Castle
heard yesterday.
In one of the breakout sessions on infrastructure,
Dublin Chamber
's Aebhric McGibney made a forceful contribution on the need to streamline regulatory processes to aid the delivery of housing, water and energy projects.
'In many cases, we've decided what we want to do, but we're preventing ourselves from doing it because of the high level of bureaucracy we've built into the system,' Mr McGibney later told The Irish Times.
[
Failure of EU-US trade talks would have immediate ramifications for budget, Taoiseach warns
Opens in new window
]
In particular he highlighted the high level of documentation required by different agencies.
READ MORE
'Lots of projects like the Eastern and Midlands Water Supply project have been well assessed and diagnosed for the guts of 20 years' but have still to start.
The project is seen as critical to the delivery of housing in the capital.
'There seems to be a spinning plates process to various projects under the
National Development Plan
[NDP],' Mr McGibney said.
'In other words the authorities say, look it's going ahead but not quite yet,' he said, noting that more and more companies do not believe that capital projects under the NDP will happen.
'The range of projects that we're saying are going ahead when they're not making any progress is considerable,' he said.
The
Small Firms Association
(SFA) said a recent survey indicated that 77 per cent of Irish SMEs had not applied for any State contracts in the last two years, reflecting the onerous level of paperwork and bureaucracy involved.
Jeromin Zettelmeyer, director of the Bruegel think tank, meanwhile, warned that 'economic nationalism' posed the greatest threat to Ireland's corporate tax boom.
International tax co-operation and the move to minimum global rate had triggered an additional boom in receipts here as corporations moved their IP to low-
tax
countries with substance to offer such as Ireland, he said.
But the
United States
is no longer happy to be undercut in tax terms and may end up deciding to compete with Ireland directly (on tax), posing a risk to the current tax base, he said.
Oisín Coghlan of climate advocacy group Environmental Pillar said most representative groups at the NED 'start by saying what they think the Government should spend more money on'.
'This year, the Environmental Pillar's first advice to Government is what not to spend money on,' he said.
'Don't spend €8 to €26 billion on the bill we currently face for missing our climate pollution targets,' Mr Coghlan said, citing the potential costs awaiting Ireland if it misses its climate abatement targets, contained in a recent
Fiscal Advisory Council
report.
'Invest now in improving the quality of life in Ireland rather than waste billions in public money buying carbon credits from other EU states in a few years time,' he said.
'The fiscal council calculated the Government could reduce our climate bill by €14 billion by urgently implementing what's promised in the Programme for Government: 'decisive action to radically reduce' our reliance on expensive, imported fossil fuels,' Mr Coghlan said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on the State selling out of AIB: competition in banking is now the issue
The State's long withdrawal from the banking sector after the post-crash bail-outs has reached another milestone, with the sale of its remaining shareholding in AIB. Warrants, which give the State the right to buy some shares, are now likely to be effectively bought out by the bank. AIB will finally return completely to private hands. The direct financial cost to the State of the AIB bail-out was €20.8 billion and – including the cash for the warrants – the total amount returned over the years to the exchequer is likely to fall around €700 million short of this. While the return of the bulk of the funds is welcome, the total costs of the banking collapse to the State were, of course, much greater than the cash cost of bailing out these institutions. The banks were not solely responsible for the financial crash, but they were an important part of it. The tighter regulation, restructurings and restrictions on executive pay that followed were entirely appropriate. So was the bank levy, which should remain. With the pay cap in Bank of Ireland now lifted after its return to private ownership – even if a limit on bonuses remains in place – it was inevitable that the same would happen at AIB. In this context, there seemed little point in maintaining the pay cap at Permanent TSB, where the State still holds a 67 per cent stake. READ MORE With the two main banks now in private hands, State policy needs to focus not only on regulation but also on encouraging competition. As well as the financial and economic costs, the crash also led to the departure of a number of banks from Ireland – most notably Ulster Bank – severely limiting competition in many parts of the market, to the disadvantage of consumers. New entrants have provided competition in some areas, but often on a limited scale. The soaring profitability of the banks reflects not only the strength of the economy, but also their large market share. Their large deposit books remain a competitive asset. The more recent entrants to the market are welcome, but more is needed.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Carl O'Brien: ‘Third level's best kept secret?'
It sounds too good to be true: a route to a college degree with no need for CAO points and at a fraction of the cost. Tertiary degrees were announced in a blaze of publicity three years ago by then minister for higher education, Simon Harris They were, he said, a 'game-changer' and had the potential to lift the stress on students forced to compete in a highly competitive CAO points race for college places. Simon Harris after announcing tertiary degree programmes three years ago. 'With these courses I want to send a clear message to young people and their parents when considering options after school: you can be an engineer, a nurse, study business or work in ICT without ever having to worry about those archaic and stressful Leaving Cert points.' READ MORE A total of 38 tertiary degrees are on offer this year across business, ICT, arts, engineering, social sciences, early learning & care, agricultural science, sport, construction and nursing. Details on all courses and how to apply are available at the National Tertiary Office . What's the catch? The courses start in a further education course and then progress to the technological university. It means students a nominal cost at the start of the course and regular fees when it moves to university. Yet, three years into the operation of the initiative, the numbers taking part are fairly disappointing. A total of 152 students started courses during the first intake in 2023 across 14 different degrees. Last year the number climbed to 224 tertiary students. By comparison, the CAO this year received a record 83,000-plus applications, up from almost 77,000 last year. Slow take-off So, why haven't tertiary degree options caught the imagination of school leavers? One reason is that quite a number of degree for courses which weren't exactly in high demand in the CAO system The most popular tertiary degree routes so far are for courses in nursing. While it used to attract high points, it has fallen to between 340 and 420 points in recent years. Some tertiary courses have not had any participants. There are signs of change, however. University College Cork (UCC) is the first traditional university to offer tertiary degrees. One of its offerings is a BSc in occupational therapy, which had CAO entry points in excess of 500 points last year. More programmes are now being designed in partnership with industry to tackle skills shortages and equip students for careers in sectors that need them. Today's exams: Thousands of students were again completing Leaving Cert exams in Spanish and chemistry - both exams were broadly well received, but had their challenges. Up tomorrow: Physics (9.30-12mdday) and accounting (2-4.30pm) How are we doing? If you are a parent/ guardian of a Leaving Cert student, we'd love to hear from you. Maybe you have a personal story to share, have a burning question or want to comment on the exams, CAO and further education applications process. Please click the link below to send us your questions or feedback: ingCert
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘A roof over your head is seen as a luxury': Hundreds attend housing protest outside Dáil
Hundreds of people gathered outside the Dáil this evening as part of a demonstration urging the Government to take 'urgent action' to address the housing crisis . Sínead Scully and Luke Murphy attended the Raise the Roof protest as they feel locked out of the housing market. Nearing their 30s, the couple moved in with Mr Murphy's parents after two and half years renting in order to save for a mortgage deposit. With a master's degree and a PhD between them, Mr Murphy said they have another year or two of 'hard saving' before they can move out. 'We're both in very secure jobs and we're in a position to save but we're still not able to afford property in Dublin,' Ms Scully said. READ MORE They don't believe the Government is advocating on their behalf. 'I think they think they're doing a good job, but clearly they aren't,' Ms Scully said, adding that programmes such as the Help To Buy scheme don't have the intended effect when property prices are so high. 'I think it's years and years of successive Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael governments … applying bandaid solutions to long term problems," Mr Murphy said. Protestors at The Raise the Roof rally outside Leinster House. Photograph: Alan Betson / The Irish Times Mother and son Ger Nolan and Evan Sheridan have always regarded housing as a pressing issue for the younger generation. 'It wasn't a worry I had at 16 or 18, but that's the reality nowadays,' Ms Nolan said. 'Housing is where everything stems from. You need people to run services in the country and if they can't afford to pay rent in Dublin, the city doesn't function any more,' she added. Mr Sheridan said 'housing is a basic human right, it's crazy how something as basic as a roof over your head is either too expensive or is seen as a luxury, and for many young people is a luxury'. He believes the Government is making housing out 'to be a lot more complicated than it actually is', citing the €14 billion windfall tax from Apple last year as a reason why 'funding is not an issue'. Photograph: Alan Betson/The Irish Times Bernard Joyce, a representative of the Irish Traveller Movement, said 'it's really important that we're all here together today'. Mr Joye said Irish Traveller women and children are disproportionately homeless, and called for 'culturally appropriate accommodation which meets their community's needs'. Among the speakers were Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald, Labour leader Ivana Bacik, Rory Hearne of the Social Democrats and People Before Profit's Paul Murphy. There was a considerable presence of their supporters at the demonstration. The speakers often emphasised what they see as the interconnected nature of social issues such as the housing crisis, economic inequality, and discrimination against migrants. The demonstration was organised by Raise the Roof, a broad coalition of trade unions, advocacy groups, NGOs, political parties and homelessness agencies. It coincided with a Bill in the Dáil tabled by Sinn Féin, Labour, the Social Democrats, People Before Profit-Solidarity and the Green Party, as well as some left-wing independent TDs. The Bill seeks to implement freezes and caps on rent prices, reintroduce a ban on no-fault evictions, and increase taxes on vacant and/or derelict properties and funding for homelessness agencies.
