Fine may be cheaper than parking cost
Under council budget proposals, it would cost drivers £25.50 for stays longer than six hours on Fridays, Saturdays and during events.
Liberal Democrat councillor Andrew Hollyer said it meant it was more expensive for motorists to pay to park than to be charged the £25 for a fixed penalty notice paid within 14 days.
But Kate Ravilious, the Labour councillor responsible for transport, said: "Penalty charge notices remain in place to act as a disincentive to those who consider flouting the law, something we'd strongly discourage."
"It's shocking that it will now be cheaper to commit a parking offence and pay the fine instead of actually paying to use the city's car parks," Hollyer said.
"You couldn't make it up.
"Obviously we don't suggest taking this approach, but it does demonstrate the extent to which residents and visitors are being squeezed by this Labour council."
Hollyer also criticised the council for putting forward the price increases before a city-wide review of parking, which was scheduled to take place next year.
Ravilious said the fixed penalty notice cap in England had not increased in 25 years, which she said "explained why parking charge costs over longer stays are catching up" with the cost of a fine.
Council leader Claire Douglas said the council relied on money generated from parking in the city.
But she said the council would "keep an eye" on parking charges if the increases were approved to assess the impact.
"We will have to wait and see," she said.
"If there are significant changes to visitor numbers or the income to the city, we are going to have to look at the cost of parking."
Joanna Sambrook, who was visiting York to celebrate her husband's birthday, said the situation was similar near her home in Cheshire.
She said: "My husband mistakenly parked on double yellows near home and we realised it was cheaper [to pay the fine than paying for parking], but we're not temped to do it again.
"We play the game, pay our charges and don't stay too long deliberately.
"Parking is limited, so giving everyone a chance to park is only fair."
Charlie Manning was parking at Marygate car park before viewing a house he plans to move in to when he starts studying in York next year.
He said his budget as a student was tight, so he could understand why someone might be tempted to take the fine to save money.
But Mr Manning said the overall car park pricing structure - and next year's planned increases - might encourage him to use public transport instead.
"Luckily the house I'm looking at is just outside the city centre. I would probably get the bus in," he added.
Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North or tell us a story you think we should be covering here.
Parking fees could rise during Christmas market
Plan to increase parking fees when city is busiest
City of York Council
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
6 hours ago
- Yahoo
Apple adds fresh $100 billion to US investment pledge
STORY: TRUMP: "...this is the largest investment Apple has ever made in America." U.S. President Donald Trump announced on Wednesday that Apple will spend another $100 billion in U.S. investments... with CEO Tim Cook standing by his side in the Oval Office. TRUMP: 'The company is also unveiling its ambitious new American manufacturing program, which will bring factories and assembly lines across our country all roaring to life. // And Apple will massively increase spending on its domestic supply chain for the iPhone and will build the largest and most sophisticated smart glass production line in the world." The move brings the technology giant's total investment commitment to the country to $600 billion over the next four years. COOK: 'American innovation is central to everything we do. Our products are designed here. We are hiring and growing here, and we support 450,000 jobs with thousands of suppliers and partners in all 50 states.' The decision comes as Trump pursues an aggressive tariff and trade agenda aimed at moving some manufacturing back into the United States. Related videos 2.6 million people to be stung by savings tax Budget 2025 predictions: When is it and which taxes will Labour raise? Labour urged to come clean on exit tax This superb FTSE 100 passive income stock now generates a stellar 8.1% dividend yield! But it could take decades to set up the kind of production capabilities in the U.S. that currently exist overseas, if it's even possible at all, says Craig Moffett, founding partner and senior research analyst at Moffett Nathanson. "It's certainly not realistic to think that they can start making iPhones in the United States. I will offer what I think is a really telling example, which is about a year ago when they were ramping up production of the iPhone 16 Pro, they needed to increase production in China. In the span of less than a month, they were able to add 50,000 employees at the rate of about $3 per hour in order to ramp up production. They were able to do that in what... literally about two weeks, There's simply no possibility that you could do something like that in the United States at any price." Apple said the new investment will include an expansion of its partnership with Corning that will lead to the production of glass in the U.S. for every iPhone and Apple Watch sold around the world. The technology giant said in February it would spend $500 billion in U.S. investments for a massive factory in Texas for artificial intelligence servers while adding about 20,000 research and development jobs across the country. Apple has also been shifting production of its devices bound for the U.S., sourcing iPhones from India and other products such as Macs and Apple Watches from Vietnam. Shares of Apple closed up five percent on Wednesday. Error while retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Rachel Reeves must raise taxes to fill £51bn black hole, warns think tank
Chancellor Rachel Reeves must raise taxes immediately in order to plug a fresh £50bn hole in public finances, a UK thinktank said on Wednesday. According to the National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR), UK government finances have been hit by slowing economic growth, a weak jobs market and the cost of Labour's U-turns on welfare spending. NIESR recommended "a moderate but sustained increase in taxes" including reform of the council tax system to make up the shortfall. It also suggests that the government could raise revenue through changes to the scope of VAT, pensions allowances and prolonging the freeze in income tax thresholds, which is set to end in 2028. Reeves is now on course to miss her borrowing targets by £41.2bn, NIESR predicted in its report, facing an "impossible trilemma" of big tax hikes, spending cuts or a change to fiscal rules that she has said are non-negotiable. NIESR added that if she also wants to restore the £9.9bn of headroom maintained since last year's budget, she must raise taxes or cut spending by £51.1bn in the autumn budget statement. In its manifesto, Labour promised not to raise taxes such as income tax, VAT or national insurance on "working people". Read more: UK taxpayers 'subsidising' S&P 500, says LSEG boss NIESR nudged up its forecast for British economic growth for this year to 1.3% from its forecast of 1.2% in May. However, it cut its projections for all the following years up to 2030, largely due to the impact of US president Donald Trump's trade tariffs on the global economy. The forecasts are significantly weaker than those of the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), whose projections underpin the government's tax and spending plans. NIESR expects 1% growth in 2028 compared with the OBR's 1.7%. Stephen Millard, NIESR's deputy director for macroeconomics, said the difference between those forecasts and NIESR's £41bn estimate of the shortfall probably lay largely in the think tank's lower forecasts for economic growth. It comes just a year after Rachel Reeves attacked the Conservative government for leaving an alleged £22bn black hole in the public finances. But shadow chancellor Mel Stride claimed the black hole was a result of Labour's 'economic mismanagement'. Stride said: 'Labour will always reach for the tax-rise lever because they don't understand the economy. Businesses are closing, unemployment is up, inflation has doubled and the economy is shrinking. And Labour are refusing to rule out more damaging tax rises on investment.' The news on Wednesday came as separate figures from HMRC showed almost 2.6 million people will be forced to pay tax on their savings this year, up by over 120,000 from 2024. The average saver who receives a bill will pay £2,300, according to analysis by stockbroker AJ Bell. Read more: Trending tickers: AMD, Novo Nordisk, Snap, Walt Disney, Super Micro and Glencore Will the Bank of England cut interest rates? How to reclaim overpaid pension taxError while retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data
Yahoo
12 hours ago
- Yahoo
Cardiff councillor based in England plans to step down
A Labour Cardiff councillor who now represents residents from England plans to step down, according to a spokesperson for the party's council group. Cllr Chris Lay, who represents the ward of Trowbridge in East Cardiff, announced on social media recently that he'd changed address, tagging Telford and Wrekin as the location he was posting from. We approached Cllr Lay and Welsh Labour for more information on his move and how he hoped to represent constituents effectively from another country. It has now been confirmed by a spokesperson from the Labour group at Cardiff Council that Cllr Lay moved after receiving a promotion in his day job. Never miss a Cardiff story and sign up to our newsletter here. READ MORE: Car upside down on 20mph valleys road and driver taken to hospital READ MORE: Girl, three, tragically dies after cardiac arrest The spokesperson said: 'Chris has been a hard-working, dedicated ward member for St Mellons and Trowbridge for over eight years, and chaired our Group up until May this year. 'Whilst we're delighted that he's secured a significant promotion in his professional career, we're sorry that this means that he will have to relocate from Cardiff. 'With his house move now completing we understand Chris will be stepping down in due course. 'Obviously in the meantime Chris and his fellow ward colleagues will continue to be available for residents'. Once Cllr Lay steps down, another by-election will be triggered in Cardiff. One by-election has already taken place in East Cardiff this year, in the ward of Llanrumney, which Labour won. Another is set to take place on Thursday, August 14 in the ward of Grangetown after former Labour councillor Sara Robinson stood down. Under his register of interests on Cardiff Council's website, Cllr Lay listed that he was an area manager for One Stop Stores. The Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) understands Cllr Lay informed Cardiff Council about a change of address, which is a requirement under the members code of conduct that all councillors have to follow. In a Facebook post published by Cllr Lay's profile on Saturday, July 26, he said: 'The move is complete, lovely evening sunshine with a cheeky drink. 'Massive thank you to mom and dad… and my cousin Jude. Me and jess are very grateful for the help and support moving us in.' Two of the other Cardiff Council ward councillor for Trowbridge live at addresses outside of their ward. Under Labour Cllr Michael Michael's register of interests, it states that he is the owner of a property in Fairwater. The other Labour councillor for the area, Cllr Bernie Bowen-Thomson, owns a property in Heath according to her register of interests. Cllr Lay's previous address, which is still listed on his register of interests, was located in St Mellons.
