Supreme Court ruling has ‘changed landscape' of Peggie tribunal
The nurse, who has worked at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy for 30 years, was suspended by NHS Fife after she complained about having to share a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton.
She took the health board and Dr Upton to an employment tribunal, lodging a complaint of sexual harassment or harassment related to a protected belief under Section 26 of the Equality Act 2010.
The visit to Holyrood also came shortly after a letter from Sex Matters to the Scottish Government threatening legal action if they did not implement April's Supreme Court judgement on biological sex in equalities law.
The ruling stated said the words 'woman' and 'sex' in the Equality Act 2010 refer to a biological woman and biological sex, which has implications for access to single-sex spaces.
Asked how the judgment had affected the ongoing tribunal, Ms Forstater said: 'I think it's really changed the landscape. You can't ignore it.
'But in practical terms, it was only about people with Gender Recognition Certificates (GRCs), and the doctor in this case didn't have a GRC.
'So, what NHS Fife was doing was unlawful before the Supreme Court judgment (and) it's definitely unlawful now. And I think everyone can see that.'
She said of Wednesday's meetings that it had been 'important' for politicians to hear what Ms Peggie had been through as as result of 'bad policies that NHS Fife, NHS Scotland and the Scottish Government (are) still sticking with'.
She went on: 'All the politicians we met really understand the human impact of this on women.
'That Sandie's rights at work were abused because of bad policies, bad decisions, right from the top.
'And what they heard was the real human impact on her.'
She added that there was 'really no excuse' for delaying the implementation of the Supreme Court judgment.
'The law is clear from the moment that the Supreme Court gave their judgment, the Scottish Government, all public bodies, all private employers, were obliged to act,' she said.
Ms Peggie's solicitor Margaret Gribbon also took part in the visit.
Afterwards she said: 'Politicians needed to hear directly from Sandie to understand how the sheer depth of the discrimination and harassment she and women like her have endured in workplaces – in her case, as a nurse with 30 years' unblemished service, simply because she objected to having to undress in front of a man.
'We were grateful for the politicians' time and welcomed the opportunity to share insights into how misguided actions by public bodies such as NHS Fife have devastating real-life consequences and come at great expense to the Scottish taxpayer.
'We had productive meetings, and the door is always open for any politicians who were unable to meet Sandie today.'
Tribunal hearings took place in February and it will resume in July.
Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay was one of the politicians that Sandie Peggie met during her visit.
Commenting afterwards, he said: 'It was a privilege to meet Sandie Peggie and to hear a first-hand account of her appalling ordeal.
'It is outrageous that a dedicated NHS nurse's career has been destroyed and her life consumed by a suffocating legal process simply because she stood up for women's rights.
'Sandie has paid a massive price for her brave and principled stand against the SNP Government's promotion of gender politics which now infects Scotland's entire public sector.
'NHS Fife should stop squandering vast sums of taxpayers' cash on this nonsense and every state agency in Scotland must now respect the law and women's rights.'
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The Scottish Government has been clear that we accept the Supreme Court judgment.
'We are reviewing policies, guidance and legislation potentially impacted by the judgment.
'This will prepare us to take all necessary steps when the regulator of the Equality Act 2010, the Equality and Human Rights Commission, publishes its revised Statutory Code of Practice and associated guidance for services, public functions and associations.
'The EHRC is currently consulting on this revised Code of Practice.
'The Scottish Government's approach is aligned with that of the UK Government and Welsh Government in awaiting the EHRC's revised Statutory Code of Practice.
'We will respond to the letter in due course.'
The spokesperson added that it would be inappropriate to comment on Ms Peggie's case while judicial proceedings in an employment tribunal are ongoing.
NHS Fife has been approached for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Female student who fled Afghanistan finds 'second home in Scotland'
Muzhda Iqbal said she had 'lost all hope' after the Taliban banned women from university education. A woman who fled Afghanistan to pursue her childhood dream of becoming a doctor has said Scotland is now her second home. In August 2024, she joined 18 other women who were brought to Scotland to study medicine as part of a scheme by Scottish charity The Linda Norgrove Foundation, along with the UK and Scottish governments. The 27-year-old met up with her fellow Afghans in Edinburgh at a reception hosted by Scotland Office minister Kristy McNeil. Ms Iqbal said she has 'experienced such wonderful kindness' since moving to Dundee, where she now studies. Omulbanin Sultani attends a reception at the UK Government's Queen Elizabeth House in Edinburgh (Image: Craig Meighan/PA Wire) She said: 'My hope was telling me just go and continue your education, and the future you always dreamed of. 'So, I made this decision and my family encouraged me to become a doctor because it was my childhood dream.' Ms Iqbal said her aunt had died in Afghanistan while pregnant because her family did not allow her to see a male doctor while there was a lack of female doctors. 'It was the hardest, disappointing, most heartbroken day in my life that I lost my auntie because of lack of female doctor,' she said. 'And it made me strong in my decision to become a doctor.' She said she hopes to go back to Afghanistan one day when it is safe. Until then, she is enjoying her time in Scotland. 'I've experienced such wonderful things,' she said. 'The kindness. The people are very friendly, kindly and they welcome me warmly, and they make me feel like I belong here. 'It's a very positive thing that I experience here because I'm far away from my family, even though sometimes they're not giving me the sense that I'm away, I have a family here and second home in Scotland.' READ MORE: Omulbanin Sultani said Scotland has given her opportunities that are not available for her in Afghanistan. The 22-year-old, who studied at St Andrews, wants to become a dermatologist and, one day, move back to her homeland. She told PA she misses her family – who she has not seen since July 2024 – 'so much' but manages to contact them over the internet most days. Ms Sultani is safe now in Fife but she said it was not easy to leave the Taliban's rule. 'We were not allowed to get out without a male partner,' she said. 'It was challenging to deal with the conditions where you're not certain you'll be able to do the opportunity you can only get once in your life. It was difficult.' The student said it was after she finished her second semester at university in her home country that women were banned from education. Six months later, the Linda Norgrove Foundation stepped in. 'It was a great feeling,' she said. 'When you lose something, and you know how valuable it was, and you get it again, you get that feeling.' Ms Sultani said she had heard while in Afghanistan that Scots were 'famously friendly'. Staying here for the past year, she says that has proven to be true. She said: 'When we first came here we were walking around Edinburgh and it was an atmosphere of friendly people, a place where everyone is respected and here where we are in St Andrews it's so international and friendly.' The medical student even enjoys the Scottish weather, saying: 'It's unusual but I love it. Where I come from it's hot and when you come to this weather, you like it. I hear people don't like it but I love this weather.' Scotland Office Kirsty McNeill (left) with Afghan medical students (Image: Craig Meighan/PA Wire) Kirsty McNeill, a minister at the Scotland office and MP for Midlothian, said it was important to celebrate the 19 Afghan women landing in Scotland a year ago on Monday. She said: 'This will be transformational for the 19 students involved. 'Of course, they had lifelong dreams to be doctors, and here in Scotland we're helping them to fulfil them. 'We can't solve every problem, but the problems that we can solve through schemes like this, we will always try to.' Ms McNeill said the first year had been a success, with all 19 women continuing their studies into second year. She added: 'We've given all the support we can and they're still here and they're thriving. 'They're incredibly resilient women, as of course you'd have to be.'
Daily Record
3 hours ago
- Daily Record
Scottish Government failing Lanarkshire stroke survivors according to leading charity
Figures released by Public Heath Scotland this week as part of their Scottish Stroke Improvement Programme revealed the country is falling unacceptably short of its own target of 80% of stroke patients receiving an inpatient bundle which aims to ensure the best chance of survival and recovery. The Scottish Government has failed stroke survivors in Lanarkshire according to a leading charity. Figures released by Public Heath Scotland this week as part of their Scottish Stroke Improvement Programme revealed the country is falling unacceptably short of its own target of 80% of stroke patients receiving an inpatient bundle which aims to ensure the best chance of survival and recovery. The bundle, which includes aspirin, access to a stroke unit, brain imaging, and swallow screening was given to just 52.9 per cent of Scotland's 11,341 stroke patients. Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland (CHSS), the country's largest health charity, is urging the Scottish Government to make stroke care an urgent priority as well as demanding widespread improvements for the delivery of thrombectomy, a potentially life-changing procedure. Stroke is still one of the biggest causes of long-term adult disability in Scotland, and the quality of care is crucial for recovery. Allan Cowie, chief operating officer at Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland, said: 'Unfortunately, once again, the statistics laid out by Public Health Scotland make for grim reading. 'While we have seen a slight increase in the number of people receiving the stroke bundle in the Lanarkshire health board there is still work to be done to reach the Scottish Government's 80 per cent target. 'Sadly this is the seventh straight year that the Scottish Government has failed to hit its own targets for stroke care. This government has failed stroke survivors and is failing our NHS colleagues who are doing the absolute best they can with the inadequate resources they're currently being given. 'While we recognise the financial constraints facing the government, the continued underinvestment in stroke care is resulting in significantly higher long-term costs - both through prolonged hospital stays and the extensive support required for individuals living with stroke-related disabilities. This ongoing shortfall is not only economically unsustainable but is also costing lives. Immediate action is imperative.' If you're living with the effects of a chest, heart or stroke condition or Long Covid and are looking for advice and information, please contact Chest Heart & Stroke Scotland's Advice Line on 0808 801 0899. You can also text ADVICE to 66777 or email adviceline@
STV News
5 hours ago
- STV News
Fred MacAulay: 'Thousands of men will unknowingly have a tumour in their prostate'
Scottish comedian Fred MacAulay has said thousands of men in Scotland could be walking around with prostate cancer without symptoms. The 68-year-old revealed in July that he had been diagnosed with the disease, after getting regular checks since his father and brother, Duncan, were both diagnosed with the condition. Both brothers are at a different stage of the disease, with Fred now on an active surveillance programme. He and Duncan are now both encouraging men with a family history of prostate cancer to go to the GP for a simple test that could save their life – even if they have no symptoms. Duncan was encouraged to go to the doctor back in 2017 after a friend noticed he was going to the bathroom more frequently. Despite no other noticeable symptoms, he went to have a PSA test – a blood test that measures the level of prostate-specific antigen in a man's blood 'Then I went in about three weeks afterwards, to see the result of it, and got told I had fairly advanced prostate cancer', he told STV News. Duncan had treatment and went into remission, but a few years later, doctors discovered the cancer had come back and had spread to four sites in his bones – he's now on medication which keeps the disease at bay It was his brother's diagnosis that prompted Fred to be regularly checked. His recent results showed that he, too, had developed prostate cancer, but due to his diligence, it was caught at an early stage. 'If Duncan hadn't told me to go, I probably wouldn't have gone', Fred said. 'I always kind of suspected, but was hoping I'd be lucky not to get it, but thought it was going to be there on the horizon at some point. 'There are literally thousands of men in Scotland who are walking about symptom-free, and many of them sadly will have a tumour growing in their prostate', he added. STV News Professor Alan McNeill said men with one family member with prostate cancer have a one in four chance of developing the disease. Currently, men over the age of 50 are considered to be at the highest risk, with the health service urging them to get tested. Sir Chris Hoy met with the First Minister to discuss his diagnosis – another high-profile figure calling for change to the rules for testing, which is not routinely done. The champion cyclist was diagnosed with the disease last year, before finding out it was terminal. He spoke to the First Minister – along with health secretary Neil Gray – in a roundtable at Swinney's official residence Bute House in Edinburgh on Friday, along with his wife Lady Sarra Hoy and others who have experience of living with prostate cancer. It comes amid his calls for GPs to proactively contact men known to be at higher risk – for instance, due to a family history of prostate cancer – earlier to offer a test. Professor Alan McNeill, consultant urologist, said: 'Men with one family member have a one in four chance, men with two direct family members with prostate cancer have a one in two chance, so it's really worth these guys going and talking to their doctors from the age of 45.' STV News Chris Hoy was diagnosed with terminal prostate cancer last year. Health secretary Neil Gray said it's 'so important' to raise awareness of the diseases' symptoms. He said: 'I thank Fred for his courage in speaking out about this important topic. Thanks to his early diagnosis, Fred is able to receive treatment. This is why it's so important to raise awareness of the symptoms and main risk factors. 'The First Minister and I recently met with Sir Chris Hoy, his wife Lady Sarra Hoy, and doctors, charity leaders and people with experience of prostate cancer. We discussed ways to raise awareness, and approaches to diagnosis, screening and treatment. 'I am so grateful to Fred and Chris for their selfless work raising awareness, which is helping to save lives. 'We published refreshed referral guidelines for suspected cancer last week. These make it easier for GPs to make sure that people are on the right diagnostic pathways at the right time, and set out clear advice regarding the higher risks for those at higher risk of prostate cancer, including black men and those with a family history. 'The most important message remains – if you have any concerns around symptoms, including urinating more often, or with increased difficulty or weak flow, contact your GP without delay. It could be the most important call you'll ever make.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
