West Coast Regional Council chief executive calls for more staff as goldmine delays bite
Photo:
LDR
The West Coast Regional Council has conceded it needs to take on more staff, after a raft of complaints about the time it takes to process resource consents, including some from its own councillors.
The council's former chair - and alluvial goldminer - Allan Birchfield released letters last week from a company distressed that its fledgling goldmine had been shut down, and its seven workers and capital put at risk, after waiting 17 months for a consent.
Council resource management committee chair Brett Cummings - also a veteran goldminer - has set out his concerns in a letter to West Coast Regional Council (WCRC) chief executive Darryl Lew, with a long list of questions about how consents are being dealt with.
Both councillors have criticised the council's practice of hiring North Island consultancy firms to process goldmine consents, alleging the planners involved are unfamiliar with the industry, ask for irrelevant information and delay the process by asking what Cummings has called "stupid " questions.
In his case, the wait has been seven months for what should have been a straightforward consent on Ngai Tahu forestry land, which the iwi had approved, Cummings said.
In reply to the councillor's questions, Lew said the council had received 56 resource consent applications this year, and half of them had been outsourced to consultants in Buller, Greymouth and New Plymouth.
Of those 28, two had been approved, 11 were sent back to the applicants because they were "incomplete" and the rest were still being processed, Lew said.
"Similar to the WOF process for a car, when deficient applications are returned, applicants are informed of areas that are required to be enhanced and they can then resubmit the applications for processing."
Of the remaining 28 being dealt with by council staff, 10 had been approved, one had been sent back for more information within the statutory time limit and 12 had been returned to sender as "incomplete".
The rest were still being processed, Lew said.
The council's use of consultants has increased, compared to the same period last year, the figures show.
Between January and April 2024 , the council received 57 resource consent applications - one was publicly notified, 51 were processed in house and only six outsourced to a consultant.
There was little difference in the fees charged to applicants - council staff were charged out at $185 an hour and consultants' hourly rates ranged from $140-192 - all plus GST.
There had been only two council consents staff employed in January this year, joined by a trainee in February, and their availability had been reduced by sick leave, annual leave and training time, Lew said.
Last year, there had been three officers on the job.
"To date, I haven't increased the consents team, however I do believe now is the time. More consents are requiring technical input and we are having more going to hearings, so this is impacting on resourcing, not to mention future demands like the fast track projects."
The council would prefer to use its own staff who had local knowledge, Lew said.
But it would be impossible to do away entirely with consultants because the volume of consent applications and workload was unpredictable.
Consents for alluvial goldmining were much more complex than they were in the early days of the RMA in the 1990s, the chief executive noted.
They now had to be assessed against a lengthy list of national policy statements and environmental standards, including Freshwater Management, Indigenous Biodiversity, drinking water, air quality, greenhouse gases, and management of contaminants in soil to protect human health.
"We await the government changes to these national instruments and the replacement RMA to see if this becomes simpler ... I agree it would be ideal to have consents and application forms as simple as possible. It is a challenge to have them reflect the law and remain simple."
In the meantime, the WCRC consents team was working on new application templates and more guidance for alluvial goldminers, and would bring a paper on this to Council on July or August, Lew said.
The council had complicated the process by trying to impose static conditions intended for subdivisions and septic tanks on alluvial mines, Cummings said.
"An alluvial site evolves as you work your way through it, so you'll start off with your pumps and your pond, and even your access tracks in one place, and as you move along, you move them along as well, but they're demanding maps and trying to include these all things as fixed conditions on the consent. "
Until about a year ago, those details were set out for the council in a separate mine work-programme, which was updated, as the site progressed, Cummings said.
"The compliance staff would have that and refer to it, when they did their inspection visits. They didn't try to cram everything into the consent itself - that makes no sense, when you're dealing with a dynamic system.
"If you move your pond, you're technically in breach."
Hiring more consents staff could help the situation, as long as basic issues were addressed, Cummings said.
LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
How ACC plans to manage the estimated $3.6b cost of compensation for abuse survivors
ACC chief executive Megan Main Photo: Supplied / ACC A significant number of abuse victims could be eligible for ACC compensation following a landmark court ruling that could cost it billions of dollars. But ACC will not immediately be contacting everyone it believes might be eligible, due to fears of retraumatising them and its case managers being overwhelmed. Advocates and a survivor fear the corporation is stalling to avoid paying out. The landmark Court of Appeal decision - TN vs ACC, issued in December 2023 - made more childhood abuse survivors eligible for financial compensation. ACC estimated it could affect 100,000 people and cost it $3.6 billion. Nearly two years since the decision was issued, ACC has decided how it will "fully implement" the ruling from 29 September. Anyone unable to work due to a mental injury arising from childhood sexual abuse can apply for weekly compensation, known as Loss of Potential Earnings (LOPE) payments. Previously, the date of injury for LOPE was the date they first sought treatment for a mental injury and this had to be before they were 18 years old. The 2023 TN vs ACC Court of Appeal decision removed the age limit and changed the date of injury to the date the abuse occurred. In the case of TN, the claimant was abused from the age of two but prevented from seeking help by her family, which meant she could not report the abuse before she turned 18. ACC applied interim measures while it worked out how it would "fully implement" the court decision. Last month, it estimated that about 262 people between June 2023 and April this year had been accepted for LOPE payments as a result of the case , totalling $50 million. At the time, TN's lawyer Beatrix Woodhouse questioned the small number and said many ACC clients were not being made aware they might now be eligible or could apply. Internal documents showed ACC had identified "significant numbers" of clients who were now likely to be eligible for LOPE, but it had decided not to proactively tell everyone. "To avoid unwanted or potentially traumatic contact and unnecessarily raising client expectations, we will only proactively approach clients where we can identify a reasonably high likelihood of LOPE eligibility," a March ACC board paper stated. Only clients with active sensitive claims would be approached to "reduce the risks of retraumatising clients who do not have active psychological support from ACC in place". A "trial screening" - carried out in February 2024 - identified 420 clients most likely to be eligible for compensation and further analysis found some were already undergoing assessments for compensation, while others were not entitled or did not wish to be considered, the paper said. ACC advocate and lawyer Warren Forster described ACC's approach as "quite shocking". Warren Forster Photo: RNZ / Ian Telfer "What ACC is effectively saying is 'we are not going to tell people that they might be entitled to this' even though they've got covered claims. "They've calculated there are thousands of people in this category and they've said they'll only approach 420. That's a concern. "In the context of political pressure on ACC to stop paying and indications from the minister that they might change this approach anyway, it seems like ACC is just stalling." It was not ACC's place to decide what would retraumatise clients and everyone who might be eligible for compensation should be notified, he said. In an interview, ACC chief executive Megan Main told RNZ it knew from experience that clients were likely to be impacted when contacted proactively to discuss financial entitlements. That was why it was taking a "phased approach" and taking its time "to get it right". "We've prioritised working with new clients and clients seeking reassessment who are, by reaching out, indicating they're ready." ACC would start to proactively contact clients it believed were most likely to be entitled to compensation next year. "We'll work with providers, the advocate groups, we'll learn from survivors themselves about how they're responding to this," said Main. The TN decision was difficult for ACC to implement, she said. "This is a significant and quite complex change to how we make decisions about financial entitlements … and these are some of our most vulnerable clients. "It's why we are treading carefully." ACC currently had 15,000 sensitive claims clients and around 800 open applications for LOPE, she said. An ACC client, who only wanted to be known as Lew, said the process of applying for LOPE itself was long and traumatising. Lew suffered from post traumatic stress disorder from being abused as a child in state care. He had never been able to hold down a job for long and now in his 30s was unable to work at all. He applied for LOPE in August last year after learning about the TN decision and has already gone through the two standard assessments to work out his eligibility, but the process was "traumatising" and "challenging", and had made his mental health worse. "This process with ACC has actually affected my mental health so bad that I cannot work at the moment. I'm fighting a multibillion dollar corporation and I don't have a cent." ACC told him in April that he needed a third assessment but due to a shortage of therapists this could not be done until October. He questioned why ACC was choosing not to contact clients it believed may be entitled to compensation. "They don't want to contact clients because they don't want to pay them out. They don't give a crap how traumatised these clients are, like myself, otherwise they would have sorted [my compensation] out." In a statement, ACC said multiple assessments were sometimes required which could be frustrating for clients. "The complexity of Lew's case has meant an additional medical assessment is also required. This will help us fully understand how his covered injury is affecting his ability to work," it said. Photo: Unsplash/ Kristina Flour While overall most people would benefit from the TN ruling, some clients would end up worse off. For example, if someone abused as a child had been working, but then could no longer work due to the mental injury arising from that abuse, they currently may be receiving weekly compensation based on 80 percent of their earnings. Under TN, their weekly compensation may switch to LOPE, which was typically 80 percent of the minimum wage. Main said ACC would work with those negatively impacted to ensure they were supported. "So just to be clear, at the moment, we're not making any changes to any of those clients' existing financial entitlements, and we would expect to begin contacting those clients next year. "If we identify that this new court ruling might impact their existing financial entitlements, we'll let them know, we'll help them understand what it means for them, we'd make sure they've got support from their provider to move, to move through that, and that wraparound support is there." There was usually a four-week grace period for people switching between entitlements, but Main said ACC had not yet decided if this would apply to those left worse off by TN. ACC documents said a phased approach was needed to limit the impact on staff and providers. There was a "high risk" an influx of LOPE applications could put a strain on frontline resources, and staff could also be in the firing line as they bear the brunt of unhappy clients left worse off. High case loads of between 100 and 120 active cases per case manager meant some staff had not had the chance to discuss the potential impacts of the TN decision with clients. "There is a risk for vulnerable clients when their expectations are not met (and associated reputational risk for ACC) that will need to be managed through clear and effective communications." Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Average house prices fall - except in the deep south
The latest house price index from Quotable Value showed the national average home value fell 0.5 percent in the three months ended June to $909,671. Photo: Unsplash/ Towfiqu Barbhuiya Property values ticked lower in the July quarter as the winter freeze continues, but the deep south continues to buck the trend. The latest house price index from Quotable Value (QV) showed the national average home value fell 0.5 percent in the three months ended June to $909,671. Values remained almost unchanged versus a year ago, but around 13.0 percent below the peak in late 2021. The biggest rises were in Queenstown-Lakes, up 2.4 percent to $1.86 million, while Tauranga City rose 1.7 percent to $1.03 million. Wellington recorded the biggest fall, down 2.3 percent to $818,274 followed by Nelson City which fell 2.2 percent to $781,443. Auckland values eased 1.2 percent to $1.22 million, Hamilton fell 1.0 percent to $784,642, and Christchurch fell 0.2 percent to $775,030. QV spokesperson Andrea Rush said most activity was occurring at the lower to mid-value end of the market, with first-home buyers and owner-occupiers the busiest in cheaper areas. Rush said market conditions continue to vary by location and property type, with some regional centres experiencing renewed value growth off the back of earlier declines and ongoing demand for affordable housing. "While national value levels have broadly stabilised, the recovery is uneven and fragile. Vendors in many areas are having to meet the market to achieve a sale, while some buyers remain hesitant due to broader economic uncertainty," she said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
11 hours ago
- RNZ News
'Farmluencer' creates online community for female farmers
Anthea Rolfe. Photo: Supplied/Anthea Rolfe A Canterbury dairy farmer has created an online community for other females in farming to share her knowledge and connect with her peers. Anthea Rolfe left her corporate job in the aviation industry in Auckland 18 years ago to get into farming and hasn't looked back. She said she never knew it was even an option for her to farm and now milks 1250 cows, which she juggles with being a solo mum to her 12-year-old son. "I just know what it's like to juggle kids, home, farm, all that kind of stuff, and you end up putting yourself last. "And so I just thought, how can I create a community to help empower people, like women, and try and restore some of that sort of feel-good factor." Rolfe started the Females in Farming social media page a year ago and said it just exploded, gaining a following quickly. She's gone on to expand the brand with a practical and comfortable clothing range for on farm and a farming hub where she shares her knowledge from the industry. "There's really a need for this sort of thing here and it's just evolved into becoming the clothing range and the polished farmer hub," she said. "So yeah, it's been really good, really positive." Rolfe said her favourite part of being a dairy farmer is the cows - they're her favourite animal. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
