logo
Retargeting needs a creative reboot

Retargeting needs a creative reboot

Time of India2 days ago

For every customer who visits a brand's website but leaves without making a purchase, retargeting ads have long been the go-to strategy for marketers aiming to convert them. However, once the go-to for converting warm leads, retargeting is slowly losing its edge. As it reaches a plateau, marketers must reconsider where their approach may be falling short.
But before we dive into the cracks in the system, let's take a moment to understand what retargeting involves.
Unlike typical banner ads, retargeting ads are a form of online
advertising
served to people who have already visited a brand's website or are in contact with the brand.
According to Criteo, only 4% of site visitors end up making a purchase. This leaves marketers with a pressing question: How do you convert the 96% who left without buying? Retargeting.
However, as the saying goes, 'Retargeting works, until it doesn't.'
While the concept seems foolproof on paper, real-world execution is fraught with challenges.
Let's break them down one by one.
Dynamic Landing Pages
As an increasing number of Indians join social media to connect with their friends and family,
Meta
and
Google
have become the top advertising platforms for retargeting customers. They dominate retargeting by leveraging vast user data to serve ads based on browsing behaviour, past purchases and search history.
Every time a customer clicks on a retargeting ad, they are directed to a landing page (web page designed to receive traffic from that specific ad. These platforms use static ads (fixed content pieces that remain the same regardless of context) that work well for categories like e-commerce and retail, but have limited applicability for more complex categories like insurance, where dynamic, personalised content is essential to engage users and drive conversions.
Rohitesh Sahu, associate vice president -
digital marketing
, PolicyBazaar, pointed out this mismatch and said, 'Imagine visiting an e-commerce app to view a pair of shoes. That product page looks the same for everyone and no personal inputs are needed to see the price.
In contrast to e-commerce, customer journeys in insurance are highly personalised. Quotations and policy details depend on individual data, such as age, health status, smoking habits and more.'
Conventional retargeting ads offered by Meta and Google rely on audience pools, where customers are segmented based on predefined triggers like site visits or cart abandonment.
These ads are usually templated and automated, directing customers to static landing pages (look the same for everyone). Serving a dynamic landing page on these platforms is not a straightforward task as insurance products often involve a longer and more complex decision-making process.
Consumers typically go through several steps, reading about plans, comparing quotes and sometimes speaking with agents, before making a purchase. Because of this fragmented journey, showing a perfectly tailored landing page based on just one ad click becomes challenging, as it's hard to pinpoint exactly where the user is in the buying process.
Moreover, platforms like Meta and Google have limited the use of PII (Personally Identifiable Information) due to privacy concerns.
Dynamic landing pages often rely on personal customer data to tailor content. For insurance products, tailoring based on age, health conditions, or income could raise compliance flags or breach privacy norms.
The challenges of serving dynamic landing pages make it significantly harder for categories like insurance to run effective retargeting ads.
Diminishing Returns
When a customer browses a shirt on an e-commerce site but doesn't purchase, they're often overwhelmed with static retargeting ads, nudging them to buy.
These ads typically showcase the shirt, its price and discounts, but their static nature can feel repetitive and saturating. This lack of dynamism risks being ignored by customers. Dynamic ads offer a solution, but the challenge remains: are there truly 50 unique ways to advertise a single shirt? Likely not, and this is where marketers face a dilemma.
Manan Bajoria, group VP - growth marketing, Ixigo, elaborated on the challenge and said, 'There's little room for creativity in retargeting ads. Even with videos or GIFs, the core message stays the same: the shirt and its price. This repetition is what makes retargeting ads feel monotonous.'
When creatives remain largely unchanged, the customer experience becomes monotonous and intrusive. For instance, a user might search for a product, see related ads, return later to make a booking and then search again, only to be shown the same ads all over again. This repetitive cycle continues because the creative content doesn't evolve meaningfully over time, making the retargeting feel stale and overbearing.
What remains to be seen is how technologies like agentic AI can enable brands to present a shirt in 50 unique ways during retargeting.
Frequency Caps
Have you ever felt annoyed scrolling through social media, seeing the same ad from a brand over and over again?
Repeated exposure can lead to ad fatigue or worse, push your brand into the customer's blind spot, where they become indifferent to your messaging. To prevent overexposure, marketers use frequency caps to limit ad displays. These caps ensure brands don't overwhelm customers.
Sounds simple to implement? It's not.
As per Vishal Agrahari, VP -
digital
paid media, Bcwebwise brands typically allocate 5% to 10% of their campaign budgets to retargeting, yet often fail to achieve the desired results. A key reason, he explains, is that marketers tend to overexpose customers to retargeting ads. They repeatedly bombard users with the same creatives, failing to implement proper frequency caps—believing that more impressions equate to better recall, without realising this can lead to negative brand perception.
Sharing an example of a failed retargeting campaign by a D2C brand, he said, 'A D2C apparel brand in the last quarter of 2024 had executed an aggressive retargeting campaign on Meta and Google. The campaign budget was INR 15–20 lakh per quarter allocated for retargeting, as the audience pool for remarketing was around 4 lakh users. Since they were offering discounts on products, they wanted to reach out to everyone who visited their website.
But the retargeting campaign failed miserably. ROAS dropped from 3.6 to 1.4. Conversion rate went below 1%. Where they went wrong was, the audience saw the same creatives over 10 times without any frequency caps.'
But why is implementing frequency caps so difficult?
Here are two reasons:
'Different teams manage different channels: someone runs paid ads, another handles CRM (Customer Relationship Management) and WhatsApp, and a different team manages the call centre. It is challenging to tie one customer across these platforms and track all communications from each channel while implementing the frequency caps,' Sahu (PolicyBazaar) articulated.
Highlighting the fragmented nature of digital marketing, Kedar Ravangave, EVP - marketing, Kotak Mahindra Bank, said, 'Digital marketing operates in a fragmented ecosystem, where consumers encounter ads across independent platforms like Instagram, YouTube, or news websites.
This disintegration complicates tracking a user's cumulative ad exposure, as some of these platforms operate in isolation, making it difficult to manage frequency effectively. A user might encounter the same ad across Instagram, YouTube and Facebook, with no unified system tracking these repeated exposures.'
Incrementality
When evaluating retargeting, it is important to take into account the incremental cost—the additional expense required to achieve results that wouldn't have occurred otherwise. While retargeting may appear to be a fraction of the cost of new user acquisition, it can sometimes be up to 'ten times' more expensive when factoring in these hidden incremental costs.
To demonstrate how retargeting often ends up being more expensive than new user acquisition, Bajoria conducted an experiment at Ixigo five years ago.
Explaining the experiment, he said, 'When I joined the company, we were investing heavily in retargeting campaigns, spending significant budgets to re-engage users who dropped off in the funnel. To evaluate the impact of retargeting, we ran an incrementality test, dividing our audience into a target group and a control group. The test withheld ads from 20% of users while showing them to the remaining 80%, running the campaign for two weeks to compare conversion rates between the two groups.
The control group, which didn't see the ads, had a 5% conversion rate, while the group exposed to ads converted at 5.5%. This meant that only 0.5% of conversions were incremental, with the remaining 5% occurring naturally, regardless of the ads. Despite Meta attributing the full 5.5% to our campaign, making the cost per booking appear favourable, the actual cost per booking was 10 times higher, revealing the inefficiency of our retargeting efforts.'
To put this into perspective, imagine you run a travel website and show retargeting ads to 100 people who visited but didn't complete a booking. You spend INR 300 per booking, which seems like a bargain compared to the INR 1,000 it typically costs to acquire a new customer.
However, if only 10 of those 100 bookings actually happened because of the ads and the remaining 90 either would have booked later as they were still planning their travel or didn't book at all—your real cost per incremental booking is actually INR 3,000. That's three times the cost of acquiring a new customer, not one-third as it initially appeared.
Armed with these insights, Ixigo decided to halt all retargeting campaigns on Meta and Google.
Now the question arises: if the actual cost of retargeting is so high, why do marketers continue to ignore the incremental cost of retargeting?
'Many marketers either aren't familiar with incrementality or know the term but don't fully understand how to measure it. They may not go the extra mile to decode its real value or simply lack the tools to do so.
Often, performance metrics focus on user acquisition at low costs, making retargeting appear efficient. Without the intent or capability to dig deeper, most marketers do not want to take the bold call of just shutting down a channel,' Bajoria resolved.
By allocating the money spent on retargeting to new user acquisition and targeting customers via email and WhatsApp, Ixigo's retargeting budgets have decreased by 90% compared to their previous levels, thanks to the shift to CRM channels such as email, SMS and push notifications.
Vague Intent
While retargeting is already a complex challenge for D2C brands, requiring a deep understanding of customer behaviour, it becomes even more challenging in the B2B space, primarily due to the lack of clear buyer intent signals.
Describing this challenge, a source told ETBrandEquity, 'A major hurdle in B2B marketing is the absence of clear intent signals. Marketers often rely on vague indicators or market whispers that suggest a potential customer might need their solution, but where do you find these signals? They're rarely available in a real-time or easily accessible format.
If you're trying to sell to a B2B customer, how would you even know which product they are actively exploring? Without behavioural or contextual signals, retargeting becomes a shot in the dark.'
Closing The Loop
Another challenge that adds to the fatigue of customers is when these static ads pop up even after the product has already been purchased. But why do customers keep receiving these ads after purchasing?
Explaining, Sahu said, 'When campaigns are created, they typically involve both a targeting list and an exclusion list. For instance, if a user visits your website, brands may choose to target them with ads for the next seven days. However, it's critical that after those seven days, the user is automatically removed from the targeting list.
Marketers sometimes fail to establish clear rules for exclusion lists and overlook the importance of excluding users who have already reached a key milestone in the customer journey. Without a defined and automated exclusion process, these users continue to receive ads, leading to wasted ad spend or worse, pushing the brand into the consumer's blind spot.'
To manage this, PolicyBazaar structures campaigns around the customer's buying cycle. For example, in the case of car insurance, the brand knows that most purchases occur about a week before the due date. Therefore, it aligns its campaigns accordingly and avoids targeting beyond this window.
A Tech Challenge
Marketing professionals highlight a key gap in the current retargeting infrastructure: 'If I need to track specific customers, analyse historical data and estimate the potential dollar value from retargeting them, there's no solution that consolidates all campaigns, target bases and expected outcomes for me in one place,' says one of them, who prefers to stay anonymous.
He stressed the need for a smarter, goal-oriented system.
'When I input a desired conversion rate or KPI, the system should interpret that goal and recommend the exact set of actions required to achieve it. Today, this entire process is manual,' the anonymous source added.
He also pointed out the limitations in operational efficiency in retail, where a team member typically reviews past data and plans actions for the following week. If that person is on leave, the entire process can fall apart.
Asking for a more intelligent, automated solution, he said, 'We need a customised tool that predicts potential revenue from retargeting specific cohorts—and suggests the right campaigns to execute.'
Ad Fraud
Retargeting is already a capital-intensive marketing exercise—now imagine the frustration of being taken advantage of in the process. Retargeting frauds exploit advertisers' efforts to reach users who've previously visited their website.
Bots are programmed to mimic human behaviour, such as browsing product pages or adding items to a shopping cart. The advertiser's retargeting mechanisms then prompt the ad server to serve more ads to these fake 'leads,' ultimately draining budgets and wasting valuable impressions.
Recalling an experience of retargeting fraud, Ravangave shared: 'This was a case from my past marketing experience during a large-scale retargeting campaign we were running with a major publisher. The goal was to deliver a high volume of clicks through specific messaging. As soon as the campaign went live, the publisher started reporting a significant number of clicks. But none of this traffic was reflected on our site.
Had the team not set up hourly monitoring, we would have ended up wasting the entire campaign budget in just a week because it was a short-duration sale campaign. We quickly flagged the issue and reached out to the publisher. That's when we discovered the numbers were being manipulated by bots. What was reported as a million clicks was, in reality, just around a thousand.'
Ravangave emphasises that ad fraud will continue to evolve, but the most effective countermeasure is building a solid, in-house measurement framework.
After reviewing the challenges, let us now explore the solutions.
Sequential Storytelling
Retargeting efforts plateau beyond a point due to ad fatigue, audience saturation (a customer may fall in the retargeting pool of multiple brands in the same category) and privacy limitations.
To overcome this challenge, Pragya Bijalwann, head of marketing, Voltas, suggests marketers explore strategies such as sequential storytelling and creative experimentation. These approaches help sustain engagement, expand reach to new audiences and drive conversions without relying solely on personalisation.
Sequential storytelling is the practice of developing modular creatives that evolve with the consumer's journey, where each ad feels like a natural continuation rather than a repetitive nudge, creating an experience that resonates with consumers.
Kotak Mahindra Bank utilises its in-house photo studio to create diverse, tailored campaign messages for every stage of the customer journey.
Explaining this practice, Ravangave said, 'Our product stories have evolved from broad thematic narratives to focused messaging that highlights how a product solves problems or enhances a consumer's life. From there, we integrate bottom-funnel elements like creator endorsements, targeted offers and location-based nudges.
We use signal-based sequencing (using browsing behaviour, purchase history and engagement patterns) to deliver relevant messaging tailored to each stage of the customer journey. This approach increased conversion by three to six times for customers exposed to a full-funnel strategy compared to traditional retargeting methods.'
Sharing an alternate strategy to prevent retargeting from reaching a plateau, Amit Chaudhary, digital marketing head, Orient Electric, said, 'We continuously refresh our audience pools and watch for buying signals across categories. For instance, a bulk lighting buyer often signals home renovation—we can then remarket fans or geysers to such users. And this would work even better if we could tell the user our brand story. The conversion likelihood in retargeting is higher when brand trust has already been built through an intense narrative exposure.
We have seen that when users are exposed to a strong brand narrative, our overall performance marketing, including retargeting, performs significantly better, as it's no longer just a push, it's part of a bigger story.'
A MadTech Approach
If marketing teams could openly complain about one aspect of retargeting, it would be the diminishing reach of various channels.
Bajoria also noted a significant decline in the reach of CRM channels. For example, push notifications now reach only about 50% of users, as more customers choose to opt out of receiving them.
'SMS has been overused to the point where people rarely read them unless it is an OTP or a bank alert,' Bajoria added. 'WhatsApp remains a viable option, but it comes at a cost—approximately 80 paise per message. Moreover, WhatsApp imposes limits on the number of marketing messages a user can receive each week. Once this threshold is met, additional messages are simply not delivered,' Bajoria added further.
The saturation of traditional CRM channels has led many marketers to see Meta and Google as more appealing options for retargeting.
However, the high cost of retargeting on these platforms has created a dilemma: should marketers continue investing in Meta and Google at a premium, or shift focus to the more cost-effective CRM channels for their retargeting efforts?
Bajoria believes that CRM channels such as emails, push notifications and SMS remain a better bet for retargeting due to their lower cost, and the dollars saved on retargeting on Meta and Google can be put to new customer acquisition.
As a result, marketers are increasingly exploring new ways to retarget customers. One emerging approach involves retargeting the followers of micro and nano-influencers after running influencer campaigns with them—an audience known for significantly higher engagement rates.
'This strategy has proven highly effective because micro and nano-influencers have a strong presence within their communities and tend to drive much higher engagement. You're far more likely to trust a mother from your neighborhood promoting homemade pickles than a celebrity,' an anonymous source revealed.
Dynamic Creative Optimisation
The challenge of little to no variations in retargeting creatives causes fatigue, so what can brands do?
PolicyBazaar is currently in the process of leveraging agentic AI and generative AI for personalised marketing communication, especially in banner and video formats. They are iterating and testing it on a small scale.
'While we believe it will not necessarily lead to dramatically different outcomes in terms of performance uplift, it should provide incremental benefits. Such as improving creative variety, reducing manual workload and enhancing operational efficiencies,' Sahu noted.
The question of whether to retarget or not lacks a straightforward answer. It depends on factors like the brand's category, the length of the consideration period, and whether static ads effectively serve your audience or risk annoying them.
Before launching campaigns, marketers must prioritise KYC—Know Your Customer—to build detailed customer profiles for strategic retargeting. Nevertheless, retargeting strategies must be re-evaluated with customer fatigue in mind to ensure better ROI (Return on Investment).

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

India-EU FTA will be a great enabler, says Goyal; pitches for stronger economic ties with Sweden
India-EU FTA will be a great enabler, says Goyal; pitches for stronger economic ties with Sweden

India Gazette

time2 hours ago

  • India Gazette

India-EU FTA will be a great enabler, says Goyal; pitches for stronger economic ties with Sweden

Stockholm [Sweden], June 11 (ANI): The proposed India-European Union Free Trade Agreement (FTA) will be a great enabler, Union Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal has said, adding that India will be able to offer greater opportunities for Sweden. Attending India-Sweden Business Delegation meetings in Stockholm, Union Minister Goyal said, India and Sweden complement each other. 'The India-EU Free Trade Agreement is clearly going to be a great enabler... We do hope to be able to offer you a better pathway and greater opportunities in the future... I can assure you that we are making good progress and are deeply committed to strengthening this partnership, working together.' The Minister also highlighted India's growth prospects. 'Today, amongst all the investment opportunities available anywhere in the world, I dare say the market of 1.4 billion aspirational Indians can beat any other opportunity. When 1.4 billion Indians take one step forward, our country takes 1.4 billion steps forward. That is the spirit in which the Indian growth story is powering on,' said Goyal. Inviting the business community to invest in India, Goyal further added, 'We would like to invite all the distinguished business leaders of Sweden to come to India to experience our country. I am sure this tested partnership can really grow beyond the frontiers of what we have achieved so far.' With over 280 Swedish companies in India and 80+ Indian companies in Sweden, the potential for collaboration is immense. H said the proposed India-EU FTA has huge potential. 'There's huge potential awaiting all of us. We complement each other. Sweden and India, working as friends, as trusted partners, can transform the Indian economy; the Indian growth story can support the Swedish plans for the future.' Goyal said India is not only the largest and fastest-growing economy but it will continue to grow for the next 20-30 years. He highlighted that India has one of the lowest inflation rates and strong forex reserves. Citing the favourable business ecosystem, he appealed to the investor community to make investments in India. Goyal reached Sweden after finishing his two-day official visit to Switzerland. Apart from other engagements, he will engage with the Indian diaspora and address media interactions, further strengthening the people-to-people connections and communicating the vision for the India-Sweden partnership. (ANI)

From The Hindu, June 12, 1975: Proposals to attract remittances from Indians abroad
From The Hindu, June 12, 1975: Proposals to attract remittances from Indians abroad

The Hindu

time3 hours ago

  • The Hindu

From The Hindu, June 12, 1975: Proposals to attract remittances from Indians abroad

New Delhi, June 11: The Union Finance Ministry is examining the feasibility of making it obligatory for Indians taking jobs abroad to remit to the country a certain proportion (about 10 per cent) of their earnings every year. The remittances may be made either to their relatives in the country or credited to a bank account maintained in India. This is among the three proposals which the Reserve Bank of India has been asked to examine in detail and comment upon. The other proposals are: (i) The feasibility of permitting non-resident Indians living abroad to maintain bank accounts in India in the unit of a convertible foreign currency, either the pound sterling or the dollar and (ii) permitting them to invest in company shares in India. The Reserve Bank is already stated to have commented on these proposals in detail. The contents of its note to the Finance Ministry are not known, but they seem to be by and large favourable. The Finance Ministry was prompted to consider the question of permitting non-resident Indians living abroad to keep their remittances to India in the unit of account of a foreign currency to protect their savings from any erosion on account of the fall in the rupee value. Under the existing banking laws, this is not permissible.

"Stop singing the same song": Indians rip into Sabeer Bhatia's GDP shame post
"Stop singing the same song": Indians rip into Sabeer Bhatia's GDP shame post

Economic Times

time5 hours ago

  • Economic Times

"Stop singing the same song": Indians rip into Sabeer Bhatia's GDP shame post

Agencies Hotmail's Sabeer Bhatia Hotmail co-founder Sabeer Bhatia has landed in the middle of a fierce online storm after he publicly criticised India's economic celebration. On 10 June, Bhatia took to social media platform X to post:'Instead of hanging your head in shame that 415 million people in India survive on $3.10/day, you brag about being the world's 4th largest economy. Shame on you.'That one sentence lit a match. The platform caught comment came shortly after India marked its economic rise to fourth place globally, overtaking Japan. But instead of praise, Bhatia's remark drew widespread condemnation from Indian users across political and professional backgrounds. Bhatia's post was quickly labelled as bitter, out of touch, and based on outdated data. Many users questioned whether he was aiming his words at India's political class or at ordinary citizens. One user responded, 'For whom was this post? Political leadership of India? If yes then have balls to say so. If it's for common citizens then it's incorrect as they are not bragging.'The sentiment deepened as another said, 'You have made your point. Now, instead of moving on, you sing the same song every day to farm engagement? Shame on you.'Then came the personal attacks. 'Surname badal le phle (change your surname, first),' wrote one user, accusing Bhatia of using his Indian identity only when convenient. Bhatia co-founded Hotmail in the mid-1990s and sold it to Microsoft in 1997 for an estimated $400 million. Since then, his career has included several tech ventures, none of which matched his initial online critics reminded him of this fact.'You sold Hotmail for $400 million in Dec 1997. How many billions have you made since then? ZERO – All your ventures failed miserably. And you are lecturing here on X to the fastest growing economy,' one user fired back, 'Come back to India and make something like Hotmail, i.e., pioneer something under your birthplace. Talents like yours run away on the first one-way flight when green grass is shown. The irony is that India produces such wasteful talents.'Bhatia did not ignore the comments. He engaged. In response to a user who mocked him for relying on social media, saying:'What happened to Rafael? You were supposed to gift the nation. Do something productive in life. As it looks, you are now dependent on Social Media for living,'Bhatia replied, 'Another personal attack. When losers like you don't know how to counter my way of thinking, you resort to personal attacks. Weak minded and insecure.'Another user had questioned Bhatia's understanding of debt and pride, posting:'You're just an idiot. Why are you bragging about being the world's No. 1 economy with $36–37 trillion in debt?'To which Bhatia clarified, 'US never bragged about being the top economy in the world.'The debate only grew louder from there. One comment summed up the anger many felt:'We, Indians living in India, don't need validation or permission from you to feel proud about something. And if you must know, please consult @WorldBank about facts before blabbering anything you wish!'Despite the flood of criticism, Bhatia stood firm. He doubled down. As the post gained traction, he republished the same comment in Hindi, seemingly to reach a wider Indian critics saw it as more provocation. For some, it was another attempt at attention. For others, it was a sign that he believed in what he posted, no matter the fallout.A small but noticeable section of users did agree with Bhatia. They echoed concerns about income inequality and called for greater focus on structural reforms rather than GDP for the majority, the issue wasn't just what Bhatia said—it was how he said it, and from question remains: how much weight should public figures living abroad carry in domestic economic debates? And when they speak, should they listen as much as they post? (Disclaimer: This article is based on a user-generated post on X. has not independently verified the claims made in the post and does not vouch for their accuracy. The views expressed are those of the individual and do not necessarily reflect the views of Reader discretion is advised.)

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store