Political favour not a factor in appointing Mantashe's son
Minister of Higher Education, Science and Innovation, Dr Nobuhle Nkabane, has denied allegations that political connections influenced the appointment of individuals to leadership positions within the Sector Education and Training Authorities (Setas) — including the son of ANC chairperson Gwede Mantashe and a former Mpumalanga premier.
Speaking during a presentation to parliament's portfolio committee on higher education on Friday, Nkabane stressed that the selection of chairpersons for Seta boards was grounded in legal compliance and merit-based evaluation.
'No candidate was given any preference or suffered any prejudice due to political affiliation or association with any political party,' she said, citing the constitutional right to freedom of association and political choice.
From nomination to backlash
The minister's remarks followed a firestorm of public criticism over the initial appointments, particularly after it emerged that Gwede Mantashe's son, Buyambo Mantashe, and former Mpumalanga premier Refilwe Mtshweni-Tsipane were among those recommended.
According to the minister, the process began with a public call for nominations in November 2024. This was outlined in Government Gazette 51625.
A selection and evaluation panel reportedly reviewed more than 500 candidates, assessing them against criteria such as leadership experience, qualifications (minimum NQF Level 8), and demographic representation.
Nkabane stated that, following consultation with the National Skills Authority (NSA), the panel's recommendations were forwarded to the minister on 6 May 2025.
She said the NSA responded with an advisory note supporting the appointments on 8 May.
However, days later, outrage followed the revelation of politically linked appointees.
ALSO READ: Department scrambles to fix curriculum chaos at Gauteng school after delayed start
Reopening the process
Acknowledging the backlash, Nkabane confirmed she had reopened the process.
A new call for nominations was issued on 23 May and will remain open until 13 June.
'Taking heed of the public call and concerns, the nomination process has since been reopened […] to afford stakeholders reasonable time,' she told MPs.
The DA welcomed the withdrawal of the appointments, stating it was a necessary reversal of cadre deployment.
However, the party insists the minister must still be held accountable.
Parliament's portfolio committee also cautioned that the withdrawal 'does not absolve the minister' of accountability.
ALSO READ: Gauteng education announces 2026 school admission dates: Here is what you need
Integrity and oversight
Nkabane reiterated the importance of integrity and impartiality in appointments, asserting that the process followed the Skills Development Act and the King IV governance principles.
She added that consultation with the NSA does not equate to seeking approval.
'The decision to appoint the chairpersons and boards ultimately rests with the executive authority, the minister,' Nkabane explained.
She reaffirmed her commitment to transparent governance, stressing that all future appointees will undergo induction to ensure they fully understand their roles and responsibilities.
NOW READ: Higher Education and Nsfas vow action amid Durban student protests
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Communities rally against the Draft Mineral Resources Development Bill, fearing increased marginalisation
The Mining Affected Communities United in Action (Macua) says the proposed draft Mineral Resources Development Bill, 2025, betrays the transformation objectives fought for during the liberation Struggle. Image: Supplied As South Africa is preparing to commemorate the Marikana Massacre, the Mining Affected Communities United in Action (Macua), says communities are still excluded from crucial decision-making related to mining and its impact on their lives, and that the proposed draft Mineral Resources Development Bill, 2025, would further perpetuate the assault. This exclusion perpetuates a cycle of marginalisation and inequality, where communities bear the brunt of mining's negative impacts without benefiting from the resources extracted from their land. The Draft Bill was published for public comment on May 20, 2025, with a submission deadline of August 13, 2025. The Bill aims to ensure policy and regulatory certainty, enhance investor confidence, reduce bureaucratic inefficiencies, and improve turnaround times for mining rights, permits, and regulatory approvals, as well as formally recognise artisanal mining and advance transformation in the mining sector. However, Macua said the Bill, as currently drafted, betrayed the transformation objectives fought for during the liberation Struggle. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad loading The organisation said instead of advancing democratic participation and justice, the amendments entrench the power of mining companies and marginalise the voices of communities. Macua, which is expected to make a submission today (August 13), added that Minister of Mineral and Petroleum Resources Gwede Mantashe and his department are failing in their constitutional duty to ensure meaningful consultation, participation, and protection for communities directly affected by extractive activities. 'We refuse to be treated as spectators to decisions that determine the fate of our land, our water, our health, and our economic sovereignty,' stated the organisation. The department on Monday said it was working on a response. Spokesperson Johannes Makobane on Tuesday said a response was going through internal processes. Macua spokesperson Tholakele Thabane said submissions would be made in five provincial offices of the Mineral and Resources. The provinces include Pretoria (Gauteng), Klerksdorp (North West), Emalahleni (Mpumalanga), Polokwane (Limpopo), and Welkom in the Free State. 'This submission and our collective resistance take place on the 13th anniversary of the Marikana Massacre, when 34 mineworkers were gunned down for demanding a living wage. It also comes just eight months after the state engineered the mass starvation and abandonment of over 100 artisanal mineworkers in Stilfontein, whose lives were treated as disposable,' said Thabane, who added that these moments are not isolated incidents, and that they are part of a broader pattern of the state-backed violence, neglect, and the criminalisation of poor, black mining communities. South Africa will commemorate the 13th anniversary of the Marikana Massacre on August 13, 2025. The tragedy happened at the Lonmin Platinum Mine in Marikana, North West, on August 16, 2012. The event, which involved a police shooting during a strike, resulted in the deaths of 34 miners and injuries to many more. By physically delivering its submissions to the Mineral and Petroleum offices, Macua said it is making it clear that it refuses to be sidelined, ignored, or tokenised. The organisation stated that this action is a collective refusal to accept the ongoing exploitation, marginalisation, and environmental destruction that the proposed Bill threatens to worsen. 'This is not just a symbolic gesture; this is a necessary act of resistance. It is a direct and deliberate intervention by communities to assert our constitutional rights to be heard, to be consulted, and to influence the laws that govern our land and resources. 'We are not merely stakeholders; we are the rightful custodians of the land, and our voices must shape the policies that impact our lives,' said Thabane. The organisation said the Bill also fails to reflect the lived realities of mining-affected communities and was compiled without genuine community participation, adding that it goes directly against the recommendations of the SA Human Rights Commission (SAHRC), which has repeatedly called for the full legal recognition of mining-affected communities and for mechanisms that guarantee community ownership, benefit-sharing, and protection from exploitation. 'Far from advancing transformation, the Bill removes critical protections and omits key obligations that previously existed, such as the requirement for community ownership under the Mining Charter. This exclusion, among others, strips communities of their economic agency and ensures they are left poorer and more vulnerable, while mining companies are further empowered,' said Thabane. He added that the Bill also fails to establish artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM) as a viable and legitimate economic pathway for communities, and will continue with the criminalisation of artisanal miners, enabling state and police violence through laws that mirror operations like Vala Umgodi.
Eyewitness News
15 hours ago
- Eyewitness News
Higher Edu Minister vows to be transparent in the latest SETA board nominations
JOHANNESBURG - Higher Education Minister Buti Manamela has promised more transparency in the latest round of Sector Education and Training Authority (SETA) board nominations. It's the first time he's addressed the media since taking over from Nobuhle Nkabane, who was fired over controversial appointments. Manamela said the post-school sector is fragmented, underperforming and out of step with the economy's needs, while the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS) and SETAs remain under pressure. Briefing members of the media in the City of Tshwane metro on Tuesday, Manamela outlined six priorities, including securing long-term funding from the National Treasury, aligning courses with jobs, tightening governance and creating a unified system. ALSO READ: Political parties not in agreement on whether Nkabane should still account for SETA board scandal When asked about the controversial issue of SETA board appointments, Manamela was quick to dismiss suggestions of irregularity, promising transparency. He said the morale in the department is low, and NSFAS is struggling to get funds to students, and senior vacancies need to be filled at several SETAs. "From those who have been nominated, we will then apply our minds in terms of who fits the positions required. We are going to make sure that people have the skills and capacity to preside as chairpersons of SETA Boards." Over the next year, he wants to pilot autonomous colleges, reform community colleges, introduce new TVET curricula and create a national database for the sector.
The Citizen
17 hours ago
- The Citizen
Manamela on Seta board chairperson appointments
Higher education minister said lessons have been learnt with regard to appointing Seta board chairpersons. Higher Education and Training Minister Buti Manamela has assured that the appointment process for Sector Education and Training Authority (Seta) board chairpersons will be transparent, while also defending his deputy minister over her alleged involvement in the ongoing Seta saga. Speaking to the media in Pretoria on Tuesday – three weeks after assuming office following the dismissal of former minister Nobuhle Nkabane – Manamela addressed the controversy that erupted in May when a leaked list of Seta board chairperson candidates had ties to the ANC, including newly appointed Deputy Minister Nomusa Dube-Ncube. Although Nkabane later withdrew the appointments, she faced heavy criticism for misleading the public about the advisory panel she claimed had helped select the candidates. Seta board appointment process On Tuesday, Manamela confirmed that nominations for Seta board chairpersons have now closed after the process was restarted. He indicated that a team within the Department of Higher Education is currently reviewing the submissions to ensure candidates meet the required standards. 'We are going to make sure that people have the skills and the capacity to be able to preside as chairpersons of Seta boards,' Manamela said. ALSO READ: Parliament concludes Seta panel never existed The minister acknowledged that his department has learnt lessons and the process is being closely watched. 'We will not hide anything. What has happened in the past has been exactly that: lessons.' Manamela said nominations were also opened for additional members of the accounting authorities. He added that the department also intends to strengthen oversight of the sector's education and training bodies. 'I have already asked the National Skills Authority to provide advice on what we need to do on some of the Setas they have conducted investigations upon, and in the next few days, we will make announcements to that effect.' Manamela also shrugged off criticism of Dube-Ncube's earlier Seta appointment and her new role as deputy minister. 'I don't know really if we should ask her to defend decisions that were not hers.' Watch the briefing below: Asked whether morale in the department had been affected by the controversy surrounding Nkabane, Manamela said he had met with all officials, including director-general Nkosinathi Sishi. 'I have met with the entire staff and our message is simple and straightforward: we have to get the department working. We have to make sure that the department is responsive to the communities out there. 'We have to make sure that we restore the trust deficit that has been created by what has happened in the past.' Nsfas challenges Manamela acknowledged that the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (Nsfas) has faced significant challenges over the years – from frequent leadership changes to corruption – in response to criticism that it has been failing in its core mandate to provide student funding. 'If we continue in the current form of student funding, we believe this form is definitely going to collapse and therefore, we have relook at the current model.' He said recruitment for a permanent Nsfas CEO and other management posts was underway. 'We need a stable Nsfas.' READ MORE: Nsfas still paying R2.5m for head office, as delays prolong terminating lease Earlier, Manamela said that he wanted to stabilise Nsfas in the next three months. 'I've asked the CEO, the national, and the chairperson of the National Student Financial Aid Scheme to convene an urgent briefing and brief the nation, particularly the students, on the state of Nsfas and some of the challenges that they've been confronted with. 'To support their work, we've already started engagement with Treasury in filling some of the gaps that exist in student funding.' Third, to ensure responsiveness to the needs of the economy, the labour market, and society. Fourth, to raise the quality of provision and learning outcomes. #DHETmediabreifing #PostSchoolEducation — HigherEducationZA (@HigherEduGovZA) August 12, 2025 Investigating UCT discrimination claims Manamela also addressed allegations of racial discrimination at the University of Cape Town (UCT), where the faculty of social development is accused of giving white students higher marks while disadvantaging black students. 'We are looking into the practicalities of all of that. I must emphasise that such allegations are quite concerning and we will not brush them aside. READ MORE: UCT racialised marking claims 'deeply shocking' – Parliament demands urgent probe 'We will go deeper into it because they go into the root of the credibility of the system.' He welcomed UCT's willingness to cooperate. 'The university was prepared to open itself up for an investigation and if there is a need for consequences, they are prepared to make sure those are followed.' Higher education sector 'uneven' Furthermore, Manamela conceded that the post-school education and training sector remained 'fragmented and uneven'. He outlined plans for the next 12 months, including piloting autonomous colleges, reforming community colleges, introducing new Technical Vocational Education and Training (TVET) curriculums, and launching a national database for the sector. 'The intention of the database will be to exclude any of the young people or students who want to benefit from the skills programme, but to ensure that none of them receive the same training more than once.' Manamela said the department will also complete legislative reviews to address gaps and contradictions in existing laws. 'We've already indicated to actors within the system across the board to look forward to engaging with them qualitatively on the pieces of legislative amendments that we will be instituting.' In addition, infrastructure upgrades will be accelerated to improve campus safety. 'We will work together with various other government departments to make sure that our infrastructure is sound and conducive for learning and teaching.' NOW READ: More than half of university students rely on Nsfas
