Is Bihar's high replacement rate a consequence of poverty?
According to the Sample Registration System report for 2021 released by the Registrar General of India on May 7, the Total Fertility Rate (TFR), which is the average number of children that a woman is expected to have in her childbearing years, in India was 2.0 in 2021, the same as in 2020. While Delhi and West Bengal reported the lowest TFR of 1.4, Bihar reported the highest at 3.0.
Is Bihar's high replacement rate a consequence of poverty? We discuss the question here.
Guests: Saswata Ghosh, Associate Professor at the Institute of Development Studies, Kolkata; Prasenjit Bose, economist and activist
Host: Shiv Sahay Singh
You can now find The Hindu's podcasts on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and Stitcher. Search for Parley by The Hindu.
Write to us with comments and feedback at socmed4@thehindu.co.in
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Proposed air enclave in Thiruvananthapuram will give a fillip to Coast Guard presence in southern region, says Coast Guard Director General
Coast Guard Director General S. Paramesh on Saturday (June 7, 2025) described the long-pending proposal for an air enclave for the maritime law enforcement agency in Thiruvananthapuram as a 'work in progress.' Once all the approvals are secured and it gets commissioned, the enclave will give a fillip to the Coast Guard's charter of duties including search and rescue (SAR) operations in the southern region, he said. According to him, the enclave will permanently station helicopters, considerably enhancing operational preparedness and response to emergencies out at sea. 'Fixed-wing aircraft can come here on detachment and operate from here,' the Flag Officer told The Hindu after inaugurating a new, 76.7 metre-long jetty for Coast Guard vessels at Vizhinjam. Although the Coast Guard station at Vizhinjam is equipped with fast-patrol vessels and interceptor boats, air support has to come from Kochi, where the Coast Guard has its regional headquarters. The commissioning of a major seaport at Vizhinjam, SAR related to fishing vessels and maritime emergencies such as the recent sinking of the Liberian-flagged container ship MSC Elsa underscore the need for the increased presence of the Coast Guard in the southern part of Kerala. Expanded Coast Guard presence in Thiruvananthapuram district will definitely help during incidents such as the sinking of MSC Elsa since it is the first responder to maritime emergencies, Mr. Paramesh said. 'It (the sinking of MSC Elsa) is a very unfortunate incident. The matter is being investigated by the Director General Shipping. Once they finish the investigation, we will come to know the reasons that caused the ship to flounder and sink,' he said. Operational preparedness The new Coast Guard jetty at Vizhinjam is expected to enhance the Coast Guard's operational preparedness significantly, the Flag Officer said. The construction of the jetty, though started in September 2019, had been delayed on account of the presence of a half-submerged tug at the site. Work was resumed in April 2024. The jetty is 76.7 metres long, eight metres wide and four to six metres deep. Earlier, Coast Guard vessels in Vizhinjam were forced to depend on commercial berths, which was seen as a major handicap considering the agency's growing responsibilities in the region. 'The new jetty is a very important piece of operational infrastructure for us. We are the first responders to any issue in the maritime arena be it search-and-rescue, medical evacuation or matters related to coastal security. So it is very important for us to have the wherewithal on shore for our ships to berth safely and respond quickly to emergencies out at sea,' said Mr. Paramesh.
The Hindu
2 days ago
- The Hindu
A pillar and a peak that are held most sacred by the Irula tribe
In a lesser known part of Kil Kotagiri in the picturesque Nilgiris, a singular spire rises above the surrounding terrain. Measuring over 400 feet, the spire, known as Rangaswami Pillar, is worshipped by the Irula tribe as a deity. The rock formation, along with the Rangaswami Peak nearby, is one of the most sacred of sites for this indigenous adivasi community. The Rangaswami Peak hosts the annual harvest festival of c in May and June every year. It is attended by the Irulas from surrounding regions; but more recently, it has become popular among non-adivasi members too. The five-week festival ends with a special worship performed only by the Irula community. P. Kannan, an Irula from Kotagiri, told The Hindu that he had heard tales of the cultural significance of the Rangaswami Peak and Pillar from his elders. He said the Irulas celebrate the harvest from their 'millet land' in May and June. 'They will perform pujas for five weeks praying to the deity to ensure another good harvest and good spell of rain in the coming year,' he said. Scaling the peak He added that according to adivasi folklore, a particular head of cattle made its way to the peak leaving behind the rest of the herd, leading to the site being worshipped over thousands of years. Writing in his Encyclopaedia of the Nilgiri Hills, anthropologist Paul Hockings says the Rangaswami Peak is the 'holiest mountain' of the Irulas and 'perhaps the seat of the original, indigenous worship of a mountain god'. He says the name of the god worshipped here is Ranga or Ranganada. Other members of the community highlight the lore surrounding the main idol at the site, which had allegedly been broken by a foreigner during his visit to the site. 'It is said he died soon after he reached his home country,' an elderly member said. 'Several conclusions may be drawn from a visit to the Rangaswami Peak. First, it shows, as do other aspects of the Irula religion, a Vaishnava-Saiva syncretism developed around an indigenous Irula deity.' Mr. Hockings goes on to add that the peak is important for other communities too. 'Third... there is the relationship between the Kotas and the Irulas, as suggested by Richard Wolf. He mentions a legend in which the Nilgiri 'god' revealed himself to a Kota and an Irula walking together. Both the Kotas and the Irulas began to worship the Nilgiri god at the same spot until some quarrel separated them: the Irulas began worship on Rangaswami Peak and the Kotas near their village.' The Rangaswami Pillar, located close to the peak, was the site of an air crash in 1950, in which noted statistician Abraham Wald and 19 others died. 'The air crash enhanced the magical aura of the pillar's divinity,' says Czech Indologist Kamil V. Zvelebil. Photographic records S. Udhayakumar, Director (in-charge), Tribal Research Center, Udhagamandalam, said the site was of interest to researchers. 'The Tribal Research Center, on the State government's orders, has completed the video and photographic records of all six of the Nilgiris' adivasi communities, and is set to publish them soon,' he told The Hindu. The exercise will ensure the preservation of the culture, customs, habits, and sacred sites of the Irulas as well as other adivasis in the Nilgiris. With the growing popularity of the temple atop the Rangaswami Peak, activists have become concerned about the impact of temple tourism. K. Mahendran, an adivasi rights activist, said adivasi temples across the Nilgiris are being increasingly patronised by non-adivasi groups. 'While it is still impossible for non-adivasis to worship at the temples belonging to some groups such as the Todas and the Kotas, it should be a matter of concern that this interest in the temples of the Irulas and the Kurumbas could lead to the indigenous people's traditions and culture — inextricably linked with these temples — becoming diluted over time,' he said. Activists also voiced concern over potential damage to the environment in the area around the Rangaswami Peak due to temple tourism. Officials of the Forest Department said the path to the temple cuts through a reserve forest, and is open only during the festival season. 'Strict rules are also in place to prevent littering and minimise disturbance to the wildlife,' an official said.
The Hindu
2 days ago
- The Hindu
Care home residents in Koyilandy living in fear again
As the dark clouds of the South Western monsoon hover over the skies, members of Asha Niketan, a care-giving home for mentally challenged persons at Nandi Bazar near Koyilandy in Kozhikode district, are living in fear again. The western side of the property was vertically cut for about seven metres without taking scientific or technical precautions for the ongoing construction of the National Highway-66 bypass road linking Nandi and Chengottukavu, claim its authorities. A building standing on the edge of this portion was partially acquired for the work. The remaining part is now on the verge of collapse and is standing in a precarious condition. Asha Niketan is run by FMR (India), a charitable organisation, and there are around 70 inmates at the care home now. O.K. Premanandan, chairman, Asha Niketan, told The Hindu that the contractor and the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) authorities were yet to provide any kind of safety steps to protect the boundaries of their property. 'Portions of the property standing on the edge of the road are now sliding down. Soil erosion is happening because of the absence of any kind of protective wall on either side of the acquired property. This has been experienced during heavy showers for the past few years,' he said. The Asha Niketan functionaries said that when heavy rains lashed the area between May 23 and May 31, the mentally challenged inmates had to be shifted to other buildings for safety. Mr. Premanandan said that the bypass road had divided the property into multiple portions. 'When the land was being acquired, we were promised that the service road to Nandi Bazar would be extended to reach the facility. However, the narrow side road leading to the care-giving home was demolished during the work. There is no access from the main road to the residential buildings and other facilities on the eastern side,' he said. Three of the 10 acres owned by the care home were acquired for the work. The road is now passing through the middle of the property, isolating the eastern portion, which has residential buildings, an administrative office, a workshop, classrooms, and a cow shed, among others.
