Soccer has changed, but the drama and dynamics of penalties remain
Which is, of course, nonsense. Four of the five penalties that were scored were excellent, hit firmly into the corners, and the other, the kick that turned out to be the winner, was smashed sensibly and without fuss, straight down the middle by Lucy Bronze as the goalkeeper Jennifer Falk dived out of the way. Two nights later, as Germany beat France in a shootout, 12 of the 14 penalties were scored. In the Women's Super League last season, 90.32% of penalties were converted. Nobody has used those examples to suggest moving the penalty spot further away to give goalkeepers more of a chance.
Related: Ann-Katrin Berger follows up biblical miracle with penalty heroics for Germany | Jonathan Liew
It is one of the great fascinations of soccer that, since penalties were introduced in 1891, the spot has remained 12 yards from goal as the size and shape of the penalty area has changed. It turns out that being one-and-a-half times further from the goal than the distance between the posts creates a scenario that feels fair and has a remarkable balance. That may in part be the result of familiarity, but at almost every level of the game in the 135 years since, roughly three-quarters of penalties have been scored. That is to say, the contest between striker and goalkeeper remained constant – a relative lack of power in the striker at junior level, for instance, matched by a lack of size in the goalkeeper.
Before the Germany v France shootout on Saturday, only 12 of 29 penalties had been scored at the Euros – 41.38%. After the shootout, that percentage had risen to 57.14%. With small datasets there's always a danger of interpreting random variations as patterns, but it did seem that panic had set in. Even before the high tension of England against Sweden, Norway's former Ballon d'Or winner Ada Hegerberg had missed two penalties in the tournament, including, critically, in her country's quarter-final defeat to Italy.
That, perhaps, was enough to plant a seed of doubt, which blossomed in England and Sweden's shootout, when both sides suffered a collective loss of nerve. Anxiety is contagious and far from unknown in penalty shootouts: it happened, for instance, to Barcelona as they missed four out of four in a shootout against Steaua Bucharest in the 1986 European Cup final, and to Manchester United as they missed four out of five against Sunderland in the 2014 League Cup semi-final. The England-Sweden contagion then seemed to escape the confines of its own shootout, as Spain missed two penalties in beating Switzerland on Friday and Germany missed a penalty against France in the 90 minutes.
Related: England's Hannah Hampton hits the headlines in latest act of unlikely career
The shootout is perhaps the area of soccer in which psychology matters most. In the 2006 World Cup, Germany's goalkeeper Jens Lehmann made great play of consulting notes he had scribbled on hotel notepaper and hidden in his sock before each Argentina penalty in the quarter-final. It turned out that, of the seven players he had jotted down, only two actually took penalties, but the belief he had specific knowledge was enough to unnerve Argentina, who lost the shootout 4–2.
Goalkeepers increasingly have data to help inform their decisions. Germany's keeper on Sunday, Ann-Katrin Berger, had notes taped to her water bottle. On TV, the names of only two French players were clearly visible: Amel Majri and Alice Sombath. In both cases, Berger was advised to dive left. She did and on each occasion saved the kick. Given Berger's notes were shown clearly several minutes before the end of normal time, could somebody have informed the French staff who could then have passed on the message for at least some of their takers to change plan? Or would asking a player to vary from their preferred method of conversion itself make them more likely to miss? That's part of the glorious game theory of penalties.
At the moment, it feels like an arms race. VAR set goalkeepers back for a time, denying them the skip forward they habitually took as the penalty was taken. But goalkeepers have now worked out how to advance with one foot, the other remaining in contact with the goalline. As strikers have learned how to stagger their run to wait for the keeper to move first, so keepers have more data and can predict such subterfuge.
In the Premier League last season, 83.13% of penalties were converted, which is on the high side historically, but actually a drop of just over 6% from the previous season. The season before that, only 74.75% were scored. In fact, what is striking when looking at penalty conversion rates over the past three decades is how little pattern there is – from a low of 65.75% in 2001–02 to the high of the season before last, and all points in between.
Penalties are missed, penalties are scored, the taker's cause is developed, and then the keeper's, and sometimes panic sets in, yet somehow the proportion of penalties scored largely remains at 75-80%. Balance remains.
This is an extract from Soccer with Jonathan Wilson, a weekly look from the Guardian US at the game in Europe and beyond. Subscribe for free here. Have a question for Jonathan? Email soccerwithjw@theguardian.com, and he'll answer the best in a future edition.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
10 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Fabrizio Romano confirms GREEN light for Liverpool to sign Alexander Isak
Liverpool aware of 's wishes to leave Newcastle and it is a genuine possibility that the club could make another formal approach for him, despite his extraordinary transfer cost. He's been the Reds' main transfer target all summer and the chance to sign him is too good to ignore. LFC Kits Shop Now LFC x New Era Shop Now LFC Signed Merch Shop Now LFC x Titleist Shop Now So while a lot of fans might have considered Liverpool's striker hunt to be over since Hugo Ekitike has been signed for £79m, a record shattering move for Isak remains very much on the cards. And while we can all point to Liverpool as the main suitors for him, whether Isak actually wants to move to Merseyside was in doubt up until now, but his intentions have now been formally revealed. Isak's priority is Liverpool According to Fabrizio Romano, who initially broke the news that Liverpool were still interested in Isak, despite the Ekitike transfer, personal terms with the Swedish striker are unlikely to be an issue. He said: "Once again: Alexander Isak wants Liverpool, it's his priority as reported. "No talks with Al Hilal, Chelsea or Manchester United." So while it felt unlikely that anyone else really had a chance of signing Isak, it's now been confirmed that no one else has approached the player or Newcastle since his intention to leave was announced. That is an enormous piece of information that we previously didn't know. The player remaining a target for Liverpool was one thing, but for the interest to be reciprocated is massive for our chances.
Yahoo
10 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Breakthrough as Bayern Munich prepare IRRESISTIBLE offer for Luis Diaz
Liverpool's record-breaking transfer window shows no signs of slowing down. Having already added Florian Wirtz, Hugo Ekitike, Milos Kerkez, Jeremie Frimpong and Giorgi Mamardashvili - the Reds are pressing on with a bid for Alexander Isak. Richard Hughes has already overseen around £265m worth of spending - with more to come not only on Isak but perhaps a centre-back too. LFC x New Era Shop Now LFC Signed Merch Shop Now LFC x Titleist Shop Now To finance any further spending, it's likely that sales will be required. Liverpool have got the likes of Federico Chiesa, Ben Doak, Harvey Elliott and Tyler Morton potentially available for transfer this summer. But the two heavyweight departures who could go a long way towards guaranteeing Isak's arrival are Darwin Nunez and Luis Diaz. Bayern ready to sweeten Diaz deal Nunez, 26, has got interest from Saudi Arabia and could be on his way if Liverpool receive around £70m. Bayern Munich, meanwhile are the frontrunners for Diaz - with Liverpool thought to be holding out for €80m for their Colombian winger. The Bavarians have been reluctant to go that high - with the latest reports from BILD indicating that a deal reaching €75m could be sanctioned. However there is a crucial TWIST in Bayern's latest offer - according to the same source. In order to make up the shortfall, Bayern are now willing to insert a Saudi sell-on clause. Diaz is attracting interest from Al-Nassr this summer but would probably prefer to remain in Europe at this stage of his career. But should the 28-year-old opt to pursue a deal in the Saudi Pro League a little further down the line then Liverpool will be there to cash in. Bayern propose "Saudi sell-on" to Liverpool 'SPORT BILD learned: Before Liverpool FC left for their trip to Asia on Sunday, Diaz's agent Raúl Costa was in Liverpool for several days to negotiate and sound out the possibilities of a deal,' a report reads. 'Bayern Munich aren't willing to go as high as €80 million for a transfer fee. Internally, a threshold has been set for Díaz's transfer fee and salary. The transfer fee is expected to be around €75 million. 'However, various models are being discussed. One is to include a sell-on clause in Díaz's contract with Liverpool. 'This means that if he is sold to Saudi Arabia in, say, three years (Diaz is to receive a four-year contract), Liverpool can participate. The fact is: Bayern are very optimistic that the deal can be completed in the next 7 to 10 days!' And so we enter a crucial period for Diaz's future. If Bayern can get this deal over the line - it will add a crucial €75m to the mix for Isak. And then, if and when Diaz heads off to Saudi Arabia, the club will cash in again.
Yahoo
10 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Fresh Milan bid for Doue expected to be under 25m
Milan are expected to make a new offer to Strasbourg for right-back Guéla Doué, even if it is still well short of the €30m asking price. The 22-year-old emerged as the first choice for coach Max Allegri, who preferred to back off from Marc Pubill in favour of a raised bid for the Ivory Coast international. They have seen two previous proposals rejected, reported to be worth €15m and €20m plus bonuses. Guéla Doué is first choice for Milan MILAN, ITALY – FEBRUARY 15: Rafael Leao of AC Milan battles for possession with Guela Doue of Stade Rennais FC during the UEFA Europa League 2023/24 Knockout Round Play-offs First Leg match between AC Milan and Stade Rennais FC at Stadio Giuseppe Meazza on February 15, 2024 in Milan, Italy. (Photo by) Now suggest a new formal figure is being handed over worth just under €25m including add-ons. It is still quite a way off the asking price set by Strasbourg, which is at roughly €30m, but it does fit with the way that Milan have been working on the transfer market this summer. Doué was purchased by Strasbourg from Stade Rennes only last summer for €6m, so his value has already sky-rocketed in the space of 12 months. That is thanks to his performances last season, with one goal and two assists in 34 competitive games for Strasbourg.