Louisiana files lawsuits alleging pharmaceutical giant CVS deceived customers in text messages
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Louisiana filed several lawsuits accusing pharmaceutical giant CVS of abusing customer information and using its dominant market position to drive up drug costs and unfairly undermine independent pharmacies, the state's attorney general said Tuesday.
Attorney General Liz Murrill began investigating CVS after the company sent out mass text messages to thousands of residents on June 11 to lobby against legislation that took aim at its business structure. The texts warned that medication costs could go up and all CVS pharmacies in the state would close.
The lawsuits, which were filed Monday in central Louisiana's St. Landry Parish, seek 'injunctive relief, civil penalties and restitution,' Murrill said.
CVS 'abused customers' sensitive information to push a political message,' Republican Gov. Jeff Landry said Tuesday at a press conference.
He noted CVS had lobbied his wife over text via the same messaging chain normally used to notify her about picking up a prescription drug or other healthcare-related matters.
One lawsuit argues that the text message lobbying constituted 'unfair or deceptive acts' in violation of state trade law.
CVS has denied any wrongdoing.
'Our communication with CVS customers, patients and members of the community was consistent with the law,' CVS said in an emailed statement. 'We believe it was important for people to know about a potential disruption to where they get their medicine.'
Two other lawsuits allege that CVS artificially inflates prices for consumers and independent pharmacies.
CVS serves as a pharmacy benefit manager — essentially an intermediary that buys medication from manufacturers and distributes drugs to pharmacies.
CVS and the mail-order pharmacy Express Scripts dominate the market by processing about eight out of every 10 prescription drug claims, according to the Federal Trade Commission, which warned in a 2024 report that this allows for 'inflating drug costs and squeezing Main Street pharmacies.'
Because CVS also owns a vast network of retail pharmacies — including 119 in Louisiana — it sets the terms for how prescription drugs are sold to customers there.
The proposed law that sparked the text messages from CVS had sought to ban pharmacy benefit managers like CVS from owning drug stores. The law failed to pass, but Landry has stated he will seek to revive it.
In the state's litigation, Murrill alleges that CVS business structure and practices allow the company to 'manipulate prices, restrict competition and channel profits internally.'
One lawsuit accuses CVS of 'systematically under-reimbursing independent Louisiana pharmacies to the point of economic hardship, while routing patients to CVS-owned facilities.' The lawsuit alleges that CVS imposes 'unethical, unscrupulous, and exorbitantly high fees on independent pharmacies.'
CVS said that it should not have to pay higher rates for 'less efficient pharmacies' and that this would lead to 'higher costs for consumers.'
'Importantly, CVS Pharmacy remains the lowest cost pharmacy and a critical partner in lowering prescription drug costs for Louisianans,' the company said.
Another lawsuit argues that CVS uses its market control to exclude lower-cost drugs for 'high-rebate, high-price brand drugs' and other practices that 'distort the drug market' and 'drive up costs for the state's public health programs and its citizens.'
CVS said that its business structure allows for 'better access, affordability, and advocacy for those we serve.' The company said that removing CVS pharmacies from Louisiana would increase costs to the state by more than $4.6 million.
Landry said he would seek new legislation targeting CVS if existing laws were insufficient to win in court.
___
Brook is a corps member for The Associated Press/Report for America Statehouse News Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit national service program that places journalists in local newsrooms to report on undercovered issues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Politico
2 hours ago
- Politico
Pritzker to run for a 3rd term
Happy Wednesday, Illinois. New York's ranked choice voting has us interested. TOP TALKER HE's DOING IT: Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker is set to announce on Thursday that he'll seek a third term in 2026, leaving open the possibility that he could also run for president in 2028. The Democratic governor, who's been on a media blitz criticizing President Donald Trump's administration, will make the announcement at events starting Thursday in Chicago before traveling to Springfield and across the state in the coming days, according to two people in the campaign. Pritzker is seen as a shoo-in to win the Democratic primary in March. Republicans have yet to step up with a challenger. Illinois does not have term limits for its statewide offices, though there hasn't been a three-term governor since Republican Gov. Jim Thompson, who won four times and held office from 1977 to 1991. Pritzker's campaign kick-off comes after months of speculation about whether the state's top Democrat would run for re-election at a time of budget uncertainty — and then run for president in 2028, too. Watch for that to be a Republican talking point. Pritzker has headlined numerous national speaking engagements in recent months, fueling the buzz about a presidential run. In an interview with POLITICO, Pritzker insisted he's just trying to bring attention to Illinois and highlight the Trump administration's tariffs and cuts to his constituents. The big question for Thursday's announcement is whether he will also bring out a running mate. We hear that's not likely. Watch him announce his No. 2 down the road, allowing for another media bump. Current Lt. Gov. Juliana Stratton, who has served with him both terms, is now running for the U.S. Senate seat held by the retiring Sen. Dick Durbin. Pritzker self-funded his past two campaigns — spending a combined $350 million to do so — and will do the same this time around. THE BUZZ GETTING INTERESTING: State Rep. Kam Buckner, former County Commissioner Richard Boykin and SEIU's Anthony Driver Jr. are considering running for Congress in the IL-07 District now represented by Rep. Danny Davis. They join a growing list of potential and declared candidates who are tip-toeing around Davis as he has yet to reveal his future political plans. We hear he'll announce in early July. It's starting to irk some folks who wonder if Davis is just holding out to make it hard for candidates to start a campaign, allowing him to open a lane for an anointed candidate. Davis' chief of staff insists the congressman is just 'assessing' his next move. 'More people are telling him to run than telling him not to run,' said Tumia Romero. Our assessment: Davis is 83. His back hurts. And he's facing a political moment of increased scrutiny on age. Meanwhile, potential candidates are waiting in the wings. Buckner is the Illinois speaker pro tempore and co-leader of House budget negotiations and an education and transit modernization advocate. Boykin is a former Cook County commissioner who previously worked as Davis' chief of staff for nearly 10 years. He's an attorney and president of Bridge Builders Consulting and Legal Services. Driver is executive director of the SEIU Illinois State Council and president of the Community Commission for Public Safety and Accountability, which works to improve police oversight and public safety. Driver, Boykin and Buckner are still just 'considering' a run and won't jump in until Davis makes an announcement. Announcing Thursday: Marine Corps veteran and Chicago comedian John McCombs, who served as a public affairs officer at Camp Lejeune in North Carolina and currently works at the Naval Station Great Lakes training new sailors. He's also traveled the world doing stand-up comedy, something he started while in college. Politics is part of his show, says the 34-year-old McCombs, who describes himself as progressive. 'My experience as a Marine was to fight and win battles, and as a standup comedian it's to communicate in any room.' He joins state Rep. La Shawn Ford and businessman Jason Friedman, who also have filed to run along with fellow Democrats Kamaria Kali and Jerico Brown. Others still considering: Chicago Ald. Walter Burnett Jr., who serves as vice mayor and is the longest-serving West Side elected official next to Davis; Chicago City Treasurer Melissa Conyears-Ervin, who ran for the seat in 2024; Forest Park Mayor Rory Hoskins; and Metropolitan Water Reclamation District President Kari Steele. You counted right: That's 12 candidates. If you are Danny Davis, Playbook would like to hear from you! Email: skapos@ WHERE'S JB No official public events WHERE's BRANDON At Arie Crown Theater at 9 a.m. for the Chicago Fire Department firefighter and EMT graduation Where's Toni At the Cook County building at 10 a.m. to launch the next phase of the Cook County Down Payment Assistance Program Have a tip, suggestion, birthday, new job or a (gasp!) complaint? Email skapos@ BUSINESS OF POLITICS — IL-09: The progressive 314 Action Fund is endorsing Evanston Mayor Daniel Biss for Illinois' 9th Congressional District. 'He's a proven leader, delivering results rooted in facts and data. As Trump and Republicans try to strip millions of their health care to give tax breaks to billionaires, Daniel will work tirelessly to protect the district,' said Shaughnessy Naughton, the group's president, noting Biss' experience as mayor, state legislator and local activist. 314 Action is a national nonprofit that recruits, trains and helps elect STEM candidates up and down the ballot. — Speaking of IL-09: State Sen. Mike Simmons is considering a run for the congressional seat now held by Rep. Jan Schakowsky. Simmons is taking part in a candidate forum Sunday with other announced candidates. Details here — IL-06 REMATCH: Republican Niki Conforti is running for the seat held by Democratic Congressman Sean Casten. The two faced each other in 2024, too. 'With our strong foundation from the 2024 election and my background in business and policy, I am confident we can flip this seat in 2026,' Conforti said in announcing her campaign. 'People feel disenfranchised. Something needs to give, and I am the change agent.' — Nick Uniejewski has been endorsed by Dick Simpson, the former Chicago alderman and political consultant, in his bid for the 6th District state Senate seat. Uniejewski is a Democrat primarying state Sen. Sara Feigenholtz. THE STATEWIDES — New Illinois laws: Gas tax, hotel offerings set for changes on July 1, via NBC 5 — CDC confirms Illinois' first human case of West Nile virus this year, by USA Today's Hannah Hudnall — Challenges persist for women, minorities breaking into Illinois' skilled trades, by Capitol News' Maggie Dougherty TAKING NAMES — Janice Jackson is stepping down as founding CEO of Hope Chicago, a nonprofit that offers debt-free college scholarships and wrap-around services to students and their parents. She's exiting 'to pursue other career opportunities, effective Aug. 1,' according to a statement. Jackson, the former head of Chicago Public Schools, has been mentioned as a potential 2027 mayoral candidate. — Michael O'Grady has been named chair of the Civic Committee. In his day job, O'Grady is CEO of Northern Trust. He succeeds Jennifer Scanlon, president and CEO of UL Solutions, by Crain's Brandon Dupré. CHICAGO — City mum on what documents it provided ICE in Streets and Sanitation subpoena, by the Tribune's Alice Yin — Bucking policy trend, public access to video of CPD Officer Krystal Rivera's fatal shooting is delayed, by the Tribune's Madeline Buckley and Sam Charles — After objections, Chicago Police agree officers won't search vehicles based on smell of raw cannabis, advocates tell judge, by WTTW's Heather Cherone — New Jersey solar company Nautilus relocates headquarters to Chicago, by the Sun-Times' Abby Miller — Woman charged with driving car through downtown anti-ICE protest, by the Sun-Times' Cindy Hernandez — 'Danke Schoen": Ferris Bueller vest sells for $279,400 at auction, by the Block Club's Gwen Ihnat COOK COUNTY AND COLLARS — Suburban lawmakers, Democratic and Republican, address concerns about political violence: 'It's unfortunately a real consideration that any time I am going to have a public event I have to think about what the security situation is,' said Democratic state Rep. Bob Morgan. 'The temper and tone of political rhetoric has been out of control for quite some time,' added Republican state Rep. Marty McLaughlin, by the Pioneer Press' Daniel I. Dorfman. — DuPage to establish community land bank, trust to incentivize more affordable housing, by the Tribune's Tess Kenny — OPINION: Cook County stands with public servants as feds purge workers, Toni Preckwinkle writes in the Sun-Times Reader Digest We asked who you're hoping the Bulls get in the draft. Brian Caminer: 'Derrick Queen of Maryland.' Rev. Tyrone McGowan: 'Anyone other than another guard.' Ron Michelotti: 'Rasheer Fleming of St. Joseph's College. He's 6-8 and can shoot threes.' Omari Prince: 'Ace Bailey is definitely out of the picture, but I hope the Bulls land Will Riley or Danny Wolf.' Timothy Thomas: 'Another University of Illinois veteran to join Ayo Dusomo, specifically either Kasparas Jakučionis or Will Riley.' Noah Walch: 'Derik Queen seems like the consensus answer and would be fine with me, but something about the height and rawness of Yang Hansen appeals to me. Otherwise, cross your fingers Khaman Maluach falls to 12.' NEXT QUESTION: What do you like or not about ranked-choice voting? THE NATIONAL TAKE — Mamdani topples Cuomo in NYC mayoral primary: It was a race about affordability v. fear and affordability won, by POLITICO's Jeff Coltin and Joe Anuta — Dems struggle to respond as Trump's Iran strikes sow chaos, by POLITICO's Elena Schneider and Nicholas Wu — Rubio credits president for pushing NATO allies to increase spending, by POLITICO's Felicia Schwartz — White House sends Dr. Oz to calm Senate nerves, by POLITICO's Adam Cancryn TRANSITIONS — Paula R. Worthington has been named senior policy adviser at the Civic Federation. She's a long-time senior lecturer at the Harris School of Public Policy at the University of Chicago. EVENTS — July 1: Screening of 'Drop Dead City,' a documentary about New York City's financial crisis in the 1970s. It's presented by the Chicago Policy Center, Civic Federation and Better Government Association. Their pitch: 'What New York fixed with courage and oversight, Chicago can fix too, if we learn from history.' Details here TRIVIA TUESDAY's ANSWER: Congrats to Barbara Flynn Currie for correctly answering that Jeanne Hurley and Paul Simon were Illinois House members (not Senate) who married each other. TODAY's QUESTION: What year did Mayor Richard M. Daley first suggest closing Meigs Field? Email skapos@ HAPPY BIRTHDAY Former state Sen. Mike Jacobs, The Strategy Group partner Aviva Bowen, Globetrotters Engineering CEO Ajay Shah, philanthropy pro Francee Harrington, Fisher Broyle Deputy General Counsel Jayne Reardon, blogger John Kass and Tribune political reporter and POLITICO alum Olivia Olander -30-
San Francisco Chronicle
2 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Daktronics: Fiscal Q4 Earnings Snapshot
BROOKINGS, S.D. (AP) — BROOKINGS, S.D. (AP) — Daktronics Inc. (DAKT) on Wednesday reported a loss of $9.4 million in its fiscal fourth quarter. On a per-share basis, the Brookings, South Dakota-based company said it had a loss of 19 cents. Earnings, adjusted for non-recurring costs, came to 18 cents per share. The video display maker posted revenue of $172.6 million in the period. For the year, the company reported a loss of $10.1 million, or 21 cents per share. Revenue was reported as $756.5 million. _____
CNBC
2 hours ago
- CNBC
To land Meta's massive $10 billion data center, Louisiana pulled out all the stops. Will it be worth it?
On a massive, 2,250-acre site about 250 miles north of New Orleans, hundreds of construction workers and tons of heavy equipment are turning former soybean fields into what will be the largest data center in the Western Hemisphere. And in the process, officials say, they are transforming Louisiana's economy. "It put us on a scale that has a lot of people, not just domestically, but internationally, sort of rethinking Louisiana," Secretary of Economic Development Susan Bourgeois told CNBC. Meta, the parent company of Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, announced in December that it had chosen Louisiana as the site for its largest data center to date — a $10 billion hub for its rapidly growing artificial intelligence operations. The announcement set off the public phase of a sprawling, real world experiment in the promise and the peril of data centers — which have become among the most sought-after trophies in the battle between the states for business. Data centers are essentially giant collections of computer servers, which are needed to process enormously complex operations for things like artificial intelligence and data storage. They typically take up massive spaces and use huge amounts of power and water, but they employ very few people. Meta's newest data center will ultimately create just 500 permanent jobs, though employment will briefly swell to about 5,000 during construction. Nonetheless, Meta found itself with no shortage of suitors willing to meet its demands. "We set out looking for a place where we could expand into gigawatts pretty quickly, and really get moving within that community on a large plot of land very quickly," said Rachel Peterson, vice president of data centers for Meta. "We looked at finding very, very large contiguous plots of land that had access to the infrastructure that we need, the energy that we needed, and could move very, very quickly for us." Louisiana was one of the few states that could deliver a site as large as Meta needed — the equivalent of about 1,700 football fields. The state had already purchased most of the land, in rural Richland Parish, back in 2006 in hopes of luring an automotive plant that never materialized. As for the energy — the Meta site will use roughly twice as much electricity as the city of New Orleans on a peak day — local utility Entergy said it could deliver. "What I see is an opportunity for this industry to grow in a way it hasn't seen in many decades," said Phillip May, CEO of Entergy Louisiana. The company is seeking regulatory approval to build not one, but three gas-fired power plants at the site, at a cost of more than $3 billion. The one piece Louisiana did not have was one that Bourgeois said was non-negotiable for Meta: a program to allow the company to avoid paying potentially billions of dollars in sales tax on the equipment to build and operate the center. Last June, only six months after taking office, Republican Gov. Jeff Landry signed into law a 20-year sales tax exemption for data centers built before 2029. The fact that the state was courting Meta at the time was not disclosed. "The Meta folks made it clear to us from day one that in order for a project like this to happen in any state, that exemption or rebate — whatever the formula is — has to exist," Bourgeois said. "It's one of the things that we look at," said Peterson. "Obviously these are very high investment capital projects for us and any others who are developing data centers and investing them. So, we do look at the overall cost of the project to make sure it's in line with what we'd expect," she added. A recent CNBC investigation found that in just the past five years, 16 states have handed out nearly $6 billion in similar sales tax breaks, and that is just the ones that have been disclosed. More often, the amounts are either undisclosed, or, as appears to be the case in Louisiana, officials don't know the exact cost yet. An analysis by the state's Legislative Fiscal Office in May said the incentive could cost the state "tens of millions of dollars or more each year, possibly through (fiscal year) 2059." But whatever the cost, Bourgeois said the benefits of the project outweigh it. "This wasn't about what the state would win or lose, just that one isolated sales tax," she said. "This was about we want to compete with Texas. We want to compete with Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina, all our Southern neighbors." Meta earned $164.5 billion in revenue last year. There are also concerns about the energy needs of the facility, even though Entergy has committed to generate massive amounts of electricity to support it. The Louisiana Public Service Commission is considering the utility's proposal to build three new power plants. But a citizen's group, Alliance for Affordable Energy, is warning that the project could compromise the state's power grid and increase electricity rates statewide. "While they're building new power plants, they're also adding a huge consumer of electricity," said Jackson Voss, Climate Policy Coordinator for the group. "Which means we're all still facing the same vulnerabilities that we were before, but now with a huge new data center added on." Louisiana has a spotty track record on grid reliability. According to U.S. Department of Energy data analyzed by CNBC for this year's America's Top States for Business study, the average Louisiana customer lost power for 9.7 hours in 2023, the most recent data available, ranking the state in 40th place, though Entergy by itself performed substantially better. Still, as many as 100,000 Entergy customers in the New Orleans area lost power on Memorial Day weekend when the regional power grid became overloaded. Entergy's May said that the added generation capacity for the Meta facility — including 1,500 megawatts of solar power in addition to the gas-fired plants — will make the grid more stable, not less. And he said the project will ultimately reduce electric bills across the state. "We're getting new power plants that will be improving in terms of the efficiency. There will be lower fuel costs as a result of adding incremental, more efficient power plants," he said. Plus, he said, while Entergy will pay for the power plants, Meta will pay for the infrastructure to connect to them. "So, hundreds of millions of dollars of support from this customer that would not otherwise have been there had Meta not come." More important, he said, the project will be a huge economic boost for Richland Parish — one of the poorest areas in the state, if not the nation. "This massive $10 billion investment, coupled with the billions of dollars that we're going to invest ourselves, is going to bring new opportunities for these communities," he said. "500 jobs in Richland Parish, or even in this northeast Louisiana region, is transformational," Bourgeois said. Plus, she said, this project opens the door for more of the same. "I could try to sell Louisiana to the world for a long time," she said. "The fact that [Meta] chose us makes my job a lot easier."
