‘It can't just be a competition on price': Why Seaspan didn't bid on BC Ferries contract
It comes as BC Ferries faces public pressure over its recent decision to award a multi-billion-dollar contract to build four new major vessels to a Chinese shipyard.
No Canadian company bid on the contract, and while the decision will save the company $1.2 billion over going with a European yard, it has hit the choppy waters of growing nationalism and a global trade war.
B.C. shipyard Seaspan did not bid on the deal.
2:15
BC Ferries criticized over decision to award contract to Chinese-owned shipyard
Senior vice-president of strategy, business development and communications Dave Hargreaves told Global News that's in part because while it has the capability, it doesn't currently have the capacity.
Story continues below advertisement
The company is essentially fully booked through the end of the decade, building Coast Guard and Canadian Navy ships.
But the company said the BC Ferries procurement process — which was heavily tilted towards price — would have essentially ruled it out anyway.
'The fact of the matter is that their labour costs in their shipyards is probably seven to eight times cheaper than ours, so not like 10 per cent cheaper,' Hargreaves said.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
'That labour cost differential is big. And so it's hard to see that we would ever get to cost-competitive with China, or for that matter like Korea, or some Eastern European countries, or places like that.'
Hargreaves compared the BC Ferries contract to its deals for major vessels with the federal government, which he said have a 100 per cent overall Canadian content requirement.
It's a political calculation, he said, that acknowledges a higher up-front cost, but comes with downstream benefits.
2:15
BC Ferries new vessel federal funding controversy
Those high-paying jobs return income taxes to the provincial and federal government and have indirect economic effects through consumer spending, he said.
Story continues below advertisement
Expanding the shipbuilding sector drives innovation, grows the skilled workforce and expands the wider marine ecosystem, he added.
'Some of our subcontractors are already exporting things,' he said. 'You don't get any of that if you go and build the ferries in China.'
And there is the strategic benefit of domestic control of shipbuilding capacity.
'Having a sovereign capability to do shipbuilding in Canada, I mean, we still are one of the world's longest coastline countries with huge maritime areas,' he said.
'So the ability to build ships kind of seems important.'
While Premier David Eby has said he wants to see vessels built in B.C., the province won't force BC Ferries to drop the China contract — citing the urgent need to get the vessels into service, and the desire to keep ferry fares down.
On Thursday, Deputy Premier Niki Sharma toured the Seaspan shipyard.
2:10
BC Building Trades expresses disappointment in BC Ferries decision
'This multi-billion-dollar success story is possible thanks to the key role Ottawa plays in supporting the national shipbuilding strategy,' she said of the Navy and Coast Guard work underway.
Story continues below advertisement
'We are determined to continue this work with the federal government to support Seaspan to do the same for civilian ships. Expanding B.C.'s capacity and getting B.C. shipyards ready to successfully bid on more Canadian ship contracts will create more good jobs in this community and the communities that supply them.'
That's the kind of talk Hargreaves said will be necessary if future ferries are to be built in B.C., adding the provincial government will need to be fully on board.
'That does have to include some much stronger preferences for B.C./Canadian content. It can't just be a competition on price, it has to take into account all the other benefits that accrue from building here … has to be seen as an investment for B.C.,' he said.
'BC Ferries doesn't really have that flexibility to make that decision by themselves, right? It has to be the province that comes to the table there.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
an hour ago
- Global News
Full steam ahead for Toronto Tempo as WNBA team readies for inaugural season
With the 2025 WNBA season well underway, the debut of the Toronto Tempo is fast approaching and the month ahead promises to be a busy time for team president Teresa Resch. She recently hired the team's first general manager, Monica Wright Rogers, a move which will take some of the spotlight off of Resch, who has pretty much been the face of the franchise since MLSE chair Larry Tannenbaum was first awarded the franchise in May of 2024. 'When I got this job, I didn't realize I'd be getting to talk to so many people like yourself, journalists telling the story of the team, because I'd worked for the Raptors for 10 seasons, and it was always the players and the coach and even our GM who was telling the story about the Raptors,' Resch told Global News' Eric Sorensen. But team meetings remain pretty small for the Tempo as they still need to hire a coach and fill out the roster. Story continues below advertisement 'We'll have a coach probably at the end of the W' season in the fall, in October, November,' Resch offered. 'And then we'll have players starting in the wintertime. So we'll an expansion draft likely in December, January. We'll have free agency in January, and we'll (have) a college draft in April. So then those people will really be truly telling the Tempo story.' While the roster remains unfilled, a few famous female faces with wildly different backgrounds have bought into the team, including Serena Williams, Lilly Singh and Sukhinder Singh Cassidy. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'It's incredible to have that level of female leaders connected to our team,' Resch said. 'They're invested in this. They have invested their own dollars into this and believe in it.' Story continues below advertisement Williams immediately chipped in with the hiring of the team's general manager, and the former tennis star, who was also known for her style, has offered to assist in other areas. 23:49 WNBA in Canada: Teresa Resch hopes Toronto Tempo will 'inspire an entire new generation' 'Serena is passionate about design, so she's going to help us with uniforms and maybe a collection,' Resch explained. 'She was involved in interviewing Monica Rogers, our GM.' YouTube star Singh also brings a different offering to the table. 'Lily has been incredible,' the team president said of the Canadian media star. 'She has the title of 'Chief Hype Officer' and boy, oh boy, does she embody that. And I cannot wait for her to really tell our story in a way that only she can' And while Singh Cassidy may not be quite as famous as the others, the southern Ontario native has been a Silicon Valley star for years, having worked with Google and StubHub before becoming CEO of Xero. Story continues below advertisement Resch said that she appreciates the opportunity to pick the tech mogul's brain at times. 'Just her insights being able to mine her and she's available to provide insights for us as we're building this organization,' she said. 'She's done it before so it's incredible to have that type of talent and intellect helping us.' –with files from Global News' Eric Sorensen
Globe and Mail
an hour ago
- Globe and Mail
Retire Rich: The family ties of a financial plan
Good morning. I hope you found some time to relax during this week of Canada Day celebrations – maybe even in the sun. Today, we're digging into how our family backgrounds can shape the way we think about, and plan for, retirement. I've been thinking a lot lately about how culture influences our financial decisions, especially when it comes to retirement. It's not just about how much we've saved or when we want to stop working. For many people, it's also about family, their legacy and obligations. New data from Fidelity Canada's 2025 Retirement Report back that up. For example, nearly 60 per cent of people born outside Canada say financially supporting their children is holding them back from retiring when they'd like. That's almost double the rate of those born in Canada. And the financial commitment doesn't stop when the kids leave school. More than half of foreign-born pre-retirees expect to continue supporting their adult children in some way through retirement. Among Canadian-born respondents, that number drops to 39 per cent. There's a similar gap when it comes to the importance of leaving behind a financial legacy: 56 per cent of immigrants said it matters to them, compared to 46 per cent of those born in Canada. Taken together, the data paint a clear picture: Retirement isn't a one-size-fits-all experience. Cultural expectations and intergenerational ties can significantly shape what it looks like, and when it begins. But numbers only tell part of the story. I want to hear yours. Have you supported or been supported by family across generations? Did your upbringing influence how you think about retirement? Whether you or your parents were born in Canada or elsewhere, send me a note at mraman@ Past financial mistakes can delay major life goals. It might sound dramatic, but many Canadians say it's their reality. Forty-one per cent of Canadians aged 30 to 44 say previous money blunders have delayed major milestones, such as paying off debt or buying a home, according to a new survey from Why it matters: Money mistakes don't just hurt in the moment, they can cast a long shadow. Survey respondents said these past choices made it harder to save, tackle debt, plan for retirement or simply live the life they want. Yes, but: Everyone makes money mistakes. What matters is what you do next. With some smart planning and consistency, it's entirely possible to get back on track. Can we renovate our basement and still retire in a decade? That's the question Romesh, 54, and Gayle, 52, are asking. Let's break it down. The numbers: The Toronto couple earns $150,000 a year, has $2-million in assets, and carries a $475,000 mortgage. They're planning a $125,000 basement renovation, with maybe another $50,000 to add a rental unit. Their goal is to retire in about a decade with $8,000 a month in after-tax income. The good news: They're in solid shape. A financial planner says they can reach their goals, even with the renovation, as long as they make a few smart moves. Key steps, from a financial planner: Plus: A rental suite could boost their net worth by 11 per cent, but they'll need to weigh the potential tax impact and whether they want to be landlords later in life. 🚨 Traditional retirement is changing. The idea of working until 65, retiring and never working again is fading. Many people are retiring earlier, then starting businesses, freelancing or even becoming influencers. We want to hear about what your second act is. Tell me about it at mraman@ ☀️ Will Canadian snowbirds in Florida go extinct? Florida just isn't the sunny escape it once was for many Canadian retirees. Rising costs, a shaky loonie and growing U.S.-Canada trade tensions have prompted some to stay north or even sell their winter homes altogether. A new law may ease the pressure by helping condo owners with rising maintenance fees, but for many, the Florida dream is starting to dim. 🩺 The 101 on preventing falls as you age. Falls can be dangerous at any age, but they're especially serious for older adults. In Canada, they're the leading cause of injury-related hospitalizations for those over 65. The good news? You can lower your risk with simple preventative measures, such as balance-focused exercises and regular strength training. 🏡 Cheaper housing could lead to a retirement crisis. That sounds intense, but opinion writer John Turley-Ewart could have a point. Many Canadians rely on the equity in their homes to fund retirement. If housing prices drop, that nest egg shrinks. With just 38 per cent of today's work force covered by employer pension plans, more people are depending on home sales to finance their later years. 🤑 Gen Z is better at saving for retirement than you might think. A New York Times article dives into how American Gen Zers are contributing to their 401(k)s more than millennials did when they first entered the workforce. DIY investing and easier access to financial knowledge through social media could be a big reason why. 📱 Stop paying roaming fees on vacation. If you're headed out of the country this summer, don't just turn on roaming and hope for the best ... that's a fast track to a hefty phone bill. Instead, call your provider before your trip and ask about travel plans or perks (many have options they don't advertise). Or, consider getting an eSIM, a digital SIM card already built into your phone. Services like Airalo, aloSIM and Global YO let you buy international data packages before you even leave.
National Observer
2 hours ago
- National Observer
The Conservative war on EVs is bound to fail
You might think the 2025 federal election would have taught the Conservative Party of Canada a few lessons. Chief among them would be the need to break with Trumpism and avoid investing their political capital in an issue — like the carbon tax — that can be eliminated with the stroke of the prime minister's pen. Instead, Pierre Poilievre's party seems destined — and determined — to learn these lessons again. Its renewed attack on the federal government's electric vehicle mandate is a case in point here. In an email sent to supporters last month, CPC co-deputy leader Melissa Lantsman said that 'the radical Liberals are planning to make your gas-powered vehicles ILLEGAL. They will FORCE you to buy an expensive electric vehicle.' This is obvious nonsense, since existing gas-powered vehicles sold up to 2035 would be allowed to operate for as long as a mechanic could keep them on the road. And while it's true that the up-front cost of electric vehicles is still higher than gasoline-fueled ones, that won't be the case for long. The ongoing developments in battery technology mean that so-called 'up-front price parity' — that is, an equivalent cost, without subsidies, for electric and gasoline versions of the same vehicle type — is a question of when, not if. That may arrive far sooner than Canada's Conservatives want to believe. Chinese automaker BYD and its ultra-low-cost EVs absolutely dominate the ever-expanding Chinese market, and it's rapidly winning hearts and market share in places like Europe and South America. Its new generation of solid-state batteries could lead to both a major increase in range and a major decrease in price. It's not alone in developing these new batteries, either: Nissan Canada has said that solid-state batteries can be produced 'at a lower cost than conventional lithium-ion batteries,' while Toyota and Volkswagen are also betting heavily on them. In time, then, and not that much of it, electric vehicles could enjoy an up-front cost advantage over gasoline-powered vehicles. That's without factoring in the far lower costs of operating an EV, which can amount to thousands of dollars per vehicle per year, according to the Canadian Automobile Association. If Canada follows through with its electric vehicle mandate, it's expected to save Canadians approximately $36.7 billion in costs by 2050. So why are Canada's Conservatives picking this particular hill to fight on? In part, it's because it allows them to play their greatest hits and try to recapture some of the political energy they generated with their campaign against the consumer carbon tax. Andrew Scheer, for example, got to break out his ample supply of political tinfoil in claiming that the EV mandate — one designed and implemented by the previous prime minister — is really a sop to Brookfield, the company Carney chaired before entering politics. 'Brookfield is heavily invested in the EV supply chain. If this prime minister refuses to reveal his financial interests or self-admitted conflicts — isn't it true that this isn't about the environment, this is about the bottom line for Brookfield?' More importantly, they're also doing this because Canada's Conservative movement remains incapable of tacking against the political winds of Trumpism. As Trump has turned ever-more aggressively against electric vehicles, and particularly the ones sold by his former best friend Elon Musk, so too have leading Canadian Conservatives like party leader Pierre Poilievre and Melissa Lantsman. It seems almost inevitable now that electric vehicles will become part of the ongoing culture war there, and that any rational attempt to help the automotive industry adapt to the changing global landscape will be subsumed into Trump's fight with Musk. It seems almost inevitable now that electric vehicles will become part of the Conservative Party of Canada's ongoing culture war, writes Max Fawcett. It's reasonable, and maybe even rational, to re-assess some of the near-term targets in Canada's EV regulation, given the threats posed by Trump to the very existence of Canada's auto sector. But the longer-term objectives here should remain in place, and the Carney government should be willing to fight hard for them. The transition away from fossil fuels and gasoline-powered vehicles is a question of when, not if. As the New York Times reported recently, 'auto executives are nearly unanimous that, even in the United States, electric and hybrid vehicles will eventually displace gasoline-powered vehicles.' Just ask Musk, who shared a post about Norway's June car sales figures — 97 per cent of which involved EVs — and added his own commentary. 'Combustion engine cars will be like the steam engine — quaint, but primitive.' On this, at least, he's correct. Not even Donald Trump can stop the global transition to electrification, and Canada needs to remain focused on the longer-term trajectory here, both for its domestic auto sector and the consumers who buy their products. The Conservative attack here is the very definition of a rearguard battle, one that confirms its enduring loyalty to the oil and gas industry and its economic interests. It's also another reminder that the leadership team that blundered away a 20-point lead heading into the last election might not be fit to win the next one.
