Trial courts shouldn't summon anyone as accused without proper reason: Delhi HC
Trial courts must not causally issue summons to an individual as an accused without good reason, the Delhi high court said while quashing the summons issued to a man in connection with a ₹ 98 lakh cheating case. The man in this case had approached the high court against a trial court's September 28, 2013, order summoning him as an accused. (HT Archive)
A bench of justice Amit Mahajan observed that issuance of summons is a serious issue and the summoning order must reflect application of mind.
'Issuance of summons is a serious issue and it is imperative that the summoning order shows due application of mind and examination of the facts of the case as well as the evidence on record,' said justice Mahajan in his June 23 ruling. 'Merely taking note of the facts and recording prima facie satisfaction, without giving any reasons for the same, is insufficient.'
The man in this case had approached the high court against a trial court's September 28, 2013, order summoning him as an accused. The case had stemmed from a complaint filed by a company, M/S Indiabulls Securities Limited, which trades stocks, under Section 420 (cheating) of the Indian Penal Code.
The company had alleged that the man dishonestly induced it to open an account in his name and availed the facility of margin trading, where investors borrow funds from their broker to increase their purchasing power and potentially amplify their returns, to buy shares but failed to repay the same despite multiple margin calls.
The man's plea before the high court said that the allegations levelled against him were absurd and improbable in nature and the order was passed mechanically without appreciating the ingredients of the offence. It said that the company had caused losses to him by selling his shares worth ₹ 7 crore without his express instructions.
The company had argued that the plea was frivolous and not maintainable since it was filed seven years after passing of the order.
Justice Mahajan remarked that the summons were issued without due application of mind, appreciating or scrutinising the material and the company sought to give a criminal cloak to civil proceedings for recovery of dues.
'The impugned order is unreasonable and summons have been arbitrarily issued against the petitioner. Although the learned magistrate has recorded its satisfaction about the existence of prima facie case in the impugned order, however on a bare perusal of the complaint as well as pre- summoning evidence, the said observation seems to be without any application of mind,' the judgement said.
It added that the allegations did not disclose an element of criminality and continuation of the criminal proceedings against the man would amount to abuse of law.
The judge also sounded a note of caution against the misuse of criminal proceedings. 'Criminal proceedings ought not to be misused to wreak vengeance or harass the other side,' the court maintained.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Karnataka HC declines to quash proceedings against man in ‘suicide abetment' case following live-in partner's death
The Karnataka High Court has declined to quash proceedings against a man in connection with the alleged abetment of his live-in partner's suicide, observing that the facts of the case had to come out in a trial. The order was passed on Wednesday by a bench consisting of Justice M Nagaprasanna after the accused approached the high court to quash the proceedings against him under the Indian Penal code and sections of the Information Technology Act. 'The nuances and textures of this tragic narrative must be unfolded in a full-blown trial,' the court stated, adding, 'It cannot be forgotten that a young life has been extinguished in a manner that raises grave concern.' The accused and his partner had been in a relationship for three years and the man had allegedly promised to marry the woman. However, the woman died by suicide in December 2023, following which her father filed a complaint against her partner. The counsel for the accused argued that the statements referred to in the complaint, such as 'go and die' or 'do whatever you want', could not alone be considered as abetment to suicide. He also argued that the deceased had been suffering from depression due to loss in investments and health issues. The opposing counsel stated that the investment losses faced by the accused and the deceased were beside the matter, and alleged that the accused had blackmailed her for money from time to time using her nude photographs which were in his possession. He also pointed out that the Forensic Science Lab had retrieved the images from the accused's phone, stating that a sum of Rs 51 lakh had been extorted. The court stated that this was a matter that had to come out in the trial. It said, 'It is the submission of the learned Additional State Public Prosecutor that the petitioner has blackmailed or threatened the deceased to part with close to Rs 50 lakh through credit card or otherwise for his business or business of both…' '(It) is a matter of trial as laptop and mobile phone of the petitioner is full of pictures and videos between the deceased and the petitioner, all taken during the live-in relationship of the petitioner with the deceased,' it added. Refusing to quash the criminal proceedings, the court stated, ' …the contents of the phones, the FSL report and the testimonies recorded, do not allow this Court to step into the shoes of the trial Court. The plea that this is a case of mere scorned affection or a casual taunt cannot be countenanced when placed against the backdrop of deliberate humiliation and alleged extortion.'
Time of India
8 hours ago
- Time of India
IIT-Madras eyes global top 50 with major expansion plans
NEW DELHI: Indian Institutes of Technology and IISc are unlikely to break into the list of world's top 50 universities unless they run full-fledged medical colleges, IIT-Madras director Professor V Kamakoti has said, revealing that the institution is considering setting up a medical college to overcome this gap in its portfolio. In an exclusive interaction with TOI, Kamakoti said IIT-M has already begun internal discussions on establishing a medical college, which would be integrated with its engineering and science departments, as part of its long-term vision, and is looking for a large hospital. Further, the institution has planned a global outreach through its proposed research centres in Dubai, Malaysia, and Germany and a sustainability campus in Puducherry, another important parameter for global rankings that Indian institutions lag on. In what's an unconventional move, IIT-M has formalised a platform to help its students prepare for civil services exams. 'If you want to come into top 50 (in global rankings), you must have a medical school,' Kamakoti stressed, adding, 'The top-ranked universities all have global campuses, deep-research collaborations, and, critically, medical schools'. He added: 'This is not just about rankings — it's about enabling convergence in areas like AI in healthcare, biomedical engineering, and public health. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 새로 나온 '실손보험' 최적가 비교가입! "월 보험료 줄이고, 보장은 더 든든하게"... 굿리치 보험대리점 (등록번호:제2006038313호) 가입하기 Undo A medical college will amplify our research depth and societal impact'. On the plan for developing a sustainability-focused campus in Puducherry, the director said, 'This campus will be a living laboratory for climate, water, and energy research'. Explaining the move, he added: 'Sustainability is now a global benchmark in rankings. That's why we've started School of Sustainability under School for Interdisciplinary Studies. It's aligned with the UN's Sustainable Development Goals. Every project must resonate with these goals — from green tech to zero-emission housing. Auroville collaborations in Puducherry are a part of this vision'. To expand global footprint, the institution will go for research collaborations and set up satellite centres in Dubai, Malaysia, and Germany. These will encourage Indian researchers to work on global problems and offer Indian students cross-border learning. 'It's called IITM Global,' Kamakoti said, detailing the vision behind the international outreach. 'If you solve an issue for India, you've solved it for the world. Our IITM Global will take these to Malaysia, Germany, Dubai (by this academic year), and beyond.' Kamakoti also highlighted IIT-M's initiative to nurture engineers for civil services. To enable this, institute has created Pragati, a platform to guide and support UPSC aspirants on campus. 'We want our students to start early — during BTech or MTech — with structured preparation, peer interactions, and access to faculty and civil servants who've walked that path,' he said. 'We're not just a tech school anymore — we're shaping India's future in several ways,' Kamakoti summed up.
Hindustan Times
8 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Trial courts shouldn't summon anyone as accused without proper reason: Delhi HC
Trial courts must not causally issue summons to an individual as an accused without good reason, the Delhi high court said while quashing the summons issued to a man in connection with a ₹ 98 lakh cheating case. The man in this case had approached the high court against a trial court's September 28, 2013, order summoning him as an accused. (HT Archive) A bench of justice Amit Mahajan observed that issuance of summons is a serious issue and the summoning order must reflect application of mind. 'Issuance of summons is a serious issue and it is imperative that the summoning order shows due application of mind and examination of the facts of the case as well as the evidence on record,' said justice Mahajan in his June 23 ruling. 'Merely taking note of the facts and recording prima facie satisfaction, without giving any reasons for the same, is insufficient.' The man in this case had approached the high court against a trial court's September 28, 2013, order summoning him as an accused. The case had stemmed from a complaint filed by a company, M/S Indiabulls Securities Limited, which trades stocks, under Section 420 (cheating) of the Indian Penal Code. The company had alleged that the man dishonestly induced it to open an account in his name and availed the facility of margin trading, where investors borrow funds from their broker to increase their purchasing power and potentially amplify their returns, to buy shares but failed to repay the same despite multiple margin calls. The man's plea before the high court said that the allegations levelled against him were absurd and improbable in nature and the order was passed mechanically without appreciating the ingredients of the offence. It said that the company had caused losses to him by selling his shares worth ₹ 7 crore without his express instructions. The company had argued that the plea was frivolous and not maintainable since it was filed seven years after passing of the order. Justice Mahajan remarked that the summons were issued without due application of mind, appreciating or scrutinising the material and the company sought to give a criminal cloak to civil proceedings for recovery of dues. 'The impugned order is unreasonable and summons have been arbitrarily issued against the petitioner. Although the learned magistrate has recorded its satisfaction about the existence of prima facie case in the impugned order, however on a bare perusal of the complaint as well as pre- summoning evidence, the said observation seems to be without any application of mind,' the judgement said. It added that the allegations did not disclose an element of criminality and continuation of the criminal proceedings against the man would amount to abuse of law. The judge also sounded a note of caution against the misuse of criminal proceedings. 'Criminal proceedings ought not to be misused to wreak vengeance or harass the other side,' the court maintained.
