‘A scrap of paper': Philippine VP Duterte wants impeachment complaint dismissed
MANILA - Philippine Vice-President Sara Duterte has described the impeachment complaint against her as 'nothing more than a scrap of paper' in her formal response to the Senate, saying the case was baseless and should be dismissed for being unconstitutional.
The impeachment, widely seen as a test of political alliances, comes amid an acrimonious falling out between Ms Duterte and President Ferdinand Marcos Jr that has sparked a broader power struggle ahead of the 2028 presidential election.
Mr Marcos, who has distanced himself from the case, is limited to a single term but is expected to groom a successor to run. Ms Duterte, the daughter of former President Rodrigo Duterte, is viewed as a strong rival contender if she avoids impeachment.
'The Vice-President enters a plea of not guilty, without waiving any of her jurisdictional and other objections over the charges,' Ms Duterte said in a submission dated June 23.
She dismissed the accusations against her as baseless, calling them 'exaggerations and speculations that are not supported by evidence' in the 34-page response to the Senate.
In February, the House of Representatives voted to impeach Duterte for betrayal of public trust and high crimes, sending the case to the Senate.
On June 11, the Senate returned the case to the House shortly after convening as an impeachment court. The Senate also ordered Duterte to respond to the allegations in the case, including that she had plotted to assassinate Marcos and others based on a statement she made in November about hiring an assassin.
She is also accused of misusing public funds both as vice-president and during her stint as education secretary.
As well as saying there was nothing substantive for her to answer in the case, Ms Duterte argued the impeachment complaint was the fourth filed against her, with the three earlier ones not acted on by the lower house.
This, she said, violated a constitutional safeguard against more than one impeachment proceeding against the same official within a year, reiterating the arguments she used in asking the Supreme Court to dismiss the complaint. That case is ongoing.
'There are no statements of ultimate facts in the Fourth Impeachment complaint. Stripped of its 'factual' and legal conclusions, it is nothing more than a scrap of paper,' Ms Duterte's reply said.
She faces a lifetime political ban if convicted.
Congresswoman Gerville Luistro, a member of the impeachment prosecution panel, confirmed the lower house had received Duterte's reply to the Senate on Monday.
'The entire prosecution team is currently studying each and every allegation contained in the answer. Certainly, we will be filing a reply within 5 days from receipt as provided in the rules,' Ms Luistro said in a phone message. REUTERS
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
35 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Trump pushes Congress to pass his ‘big beautiful bill' as debate clouds path forward
Republican leaders are pushing to get what Mr Donald Trump calls his 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' through Congress and to his desk before the July 4 Independence Day holiday. PHOTO: AFP WASHINGTON - President Donald Trump urged fellow Republicans in the US Senate on June 24 to advance his sweeping tax-cut and spending bill, as party hardliners and moderates squabbled over proposed spending cuts. Republican leaders are pushing to get what Mr Trump calls his 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' through Congress and to his desk before the July 4 Independence Day holiday. The bill would add trillions to the $36.2 trillion (S$46.3 trillion) national debt. Senate Republicans are at odds over the bill's details. Some want to make fewer cuts to social programmes including Medicaid healthcare for lower-income Americans while hardliners want deep spending cuts to limit growth of the federal deficit. Some lawmakers have said it could take until August to pass the bill. 'This rural hospital thing is really becoming a drag,' Republican Senator Josh Hawley of Missouri told reporters. He was referring to provisions that rural hospitals fear would reduce their funding and perhaps cause some to cease operations. Republican Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina, who faces a potentially difficult reelection 2026 campaign, told reporters a possible proposal to create a $100 billion rural hospital fund wouldn't be enough to keep those facilities fully operating. Another influential Republican, Senator Susan Collins of Maine, who also is up for reelection next year, told reporters she still has concerns about the bill's funding for Medicaid generally. 'To my friends in the Senate, lock yourself in a room if you must, don't go home, and GET THE DEAL DONE THIS WEEK. Work with the House so they can pick it up, and pass it, IMMEDIATELY. NO ONE GOES ON VACATION UNTIL IT'S DONE,' Mr Trump said in a post on social media. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who attended a Senate Republican lunch on June 24, said afterward that Congress is on track to meet the July 4 deadline. 'I am confident that what the Senate passes over to the House will move through the House very quickly,' Mr Bessent said. The emerging Senate legislation would extend expiring provisions of Mr Trump's 2017 tax cuts, fund his crackdown on immigration and boost military spending. The Senate bill would also raise the federal debt ceiling by another $5 trillion, adding pressure for action as the government heads toward an 'X date' for a potentially catastrophic default this summer. 'We're getting close to the warning track,' Mr Bessent told reporters. 'Debt buster' The version passed in May by the House of Representatives could increase the federal deficit by at least $2.8 trillion, despite a boost in economic activity, the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office said last week. Independent analysts predict the Senate version would cost more. 'Republicans know their plan is a debt buster but they don't seem to care,' Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer of New York told reporters. 'They're actually putting this country in the debt with the tax cuts,' he added. 'They know that.' Senate Majority Leader John Thune has said his chamber is on track to pass the bill this week. House Speaker Mike Johnson said his chamber would then take the legislation up quickly. Republicans control both houses of Congress. 'Hopefully, when push comes to shove and everybody has to say 'yes' or 'no,' we'll get the number of votes that we need,' said Mr Thune, citing the legislation's sweeping number of Republican priorities. The debate has been compounded by a string of opinions from the nonpartisan Senate parliamentarian, who is ruling on what elements of the bill comply with the procedure Republicans are using to bypass the Senate's 60-vote filibuster. The bill cannot pass without bypassing the filibuster because solid opposition by Senate Democrats will not allow it to garner 60 votes in the 100-seat Senate. The parliamentarian has blocked provisions that would cut spending for financial watchdogs, allow offshore gas and oil projects to skirt environmental reviews and glean savings from food assistance programmes for the poor and the elimination of green tax credits. Those decisions have caused alarm among House Republican hardliners, who could block the legislation if it returns to their chamber with those provisions absent. 'It looks to me like the parliamentarian is killing the bill. She's taking out all of the conservative spending cuts that we very carefully, with a razor's edge, passed in the House,' said Representative Keith Self, a prominent hardliner. Mr Thune has repeatedly ruled out the possibility of overruling the parliamentarian, whose role is widely viewed by lawmakers as vital to the integrity of the Senate. But Republicans have been able to win the parliamentarian's approval by revising the language of some previously blocked provisions. REUTERS Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
AsiaOne
an hour ago
- AsiaOne
Trump tells Congress that Iran had nuclear weapons programme, contradicting US spy agencies, World News
WASHINGTON — US President Donald Trump told Congress this week that the Iranian sites bombed by the US housed a "nuclear weapons development programme," even though US spy agencies have said no such programme existed. Trump's claim raised questions whether US intelligence backed up his decision to order the strikes on Iran on Sunday. The Republican president made the assertion in a letter dated Monday to House of Representatives Speaker Mike Johnson, a key ally, and it was posted on the White House's website. "United States forces conducted a precision strike against three nuclear facilities in Iran used by the Government of the Islamic Republic of Iran for its nuclear weapons development programme," Trump wrote. The most recent US assessment, presented to Congress in March by Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, said Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, had not ordered the restarting of a nuclear-weapons effort shuttered in 2003. A source with access to US intelligence reports told Reuters last week that the March assessment had not changed. Iran insists that its nuclear programme is for peaceful uses. President George Bush justified the invasion of Iraq in 2003 by saying intelligence showed the country had weapons of mass destruction. This was later discredited and prompted a political backlash. Trump first cast doubt on intelligence about Iran's nuclear programme last week, when he repudiated the assessment that Gabbard delivered to Congress. "I don't care what she said. I think they were very close to having one," Trump told reporters, referring to a nuclear weapon. Gabbard herself on Friday disputed media accounts of her March testimony, saying on X that US intelligence showed Iran could make a nuclear weapon "in weeks to months" if it chose. According to unclassified US intelligence reports compiled before the strikes, Iran closed a nuclear weapons programme in 2003 — a conclusion shared by the UN nuclear watchdog — and has not mastered all of the technologies required. But Tehran does have the expertise to build a warhead at some point, according to the reports. The US attacked three Iranian nuclear sites — Natanz, Isfahan and Fordow — on Sunday. It hit deeply buried Fordow, where advanced centrifuges could produce low-enriched uranium for nuclear reactor fuel and highly enriched uranium for warheads, with "bunker busting" bombs. Trump and other top officials said the sites were obliterated. But a preliminary US intelligence assessment found the attack set back Tehran's programme by only months, three sources with knowledge of the matter told Reuters on Tuesday. A US official who read the assessment said it contained a number of caveats and a more refined report was expected in the coming days and weeks. [[nid:719454]]
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Indian air-safety audit finds multiple lapses at airlines, hubs
India's aviation safety regulator found multiple aircraft-maintenance lapses in an audit of airlines and airports ordered after the crash of Air India flight AI171, including recurring defects that indicate inadequate monitoring and correction. The Directorate General of Civil Aviation also found unserviceable ground-handling equipment such as baggage trolleys in its surveillance of airports in New Delhi and Mumbai, as well as maintenance procedures such as tool controls and work-order instructions that were not being followed. 'All the findings observed during the surveillance have been communicated to the concerned operators for taking necessary corrective actions within seven days,' the regulator said in a statement. The findings point to an aviation safety culture that has not kept up with the industry's rapid growth in India. Among the failings: Aircraft maintenance engineers ignored safety precautions and reported snags to be rectified, and defect reports generated by the aircraft system were not being recorded in technical logbooks. One domestic flight had to be held due to worn tyres observed by the inspectors, while a flight simulator at one facility was not set up to match with the aircraft's configuration, and its software had not been updated to the current version. The surveillance – part of the special audit announced after the June 12 crash in Ahmedabad – covered flight operations, airworthiness, ramp safety, air traffic control, communication, navigation and surveillance systems, and pre-flight medical evaluations, the DGCA said. All but one of the 242 people onboard the Boeing 787 Dreamliner died, as well as several dozen on the ground after it crashed into the student hostel of a medical college. The DGCA said that at one of the two airports – it did not say which – obstruction-limitation data had not been updated for three years, and no survey has been performed despite significant new construction near the airport. Since the Ahmedabad crash, India has proposed a law to demolish buildings that exceed height regulations. BLOOMBERG Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
