Farmer brain drain could be worse than export loss for SA agriculture
Financial and non-financial incentives must be upscaled to all farmers, especially the developing black farmers, to ensure farmers are committed and not persuaded by short-term political promises in the foreign countries, says the author.
Image: File.
While excluding South Africa from the African Growth and Opportunity Act (Agoa) would have dire consequences, the emigration of real Afrikaner farmers would be even more damaging to the agricultural sector and the rural economy. Since the departure of 49 white people, who are supposedly farmers, seeking refuge in the US, the country and the agricultural sector have been concerned with the potential Afrikaners exodus to the US.
Interestingly, the departure of the 49 self-designated refugees to the US coincided with the NAMPO period, the biggest agricultural show in South Africa. For the past 57 years, NAMPO draws attention of farmers, traders, bankers, technocrats, and other service providers to gather in the Bothaville town and celebrate the grain harvest, appreciate new technologies and agricultural equipment, and welcome new research.
The 2025 NAMPO event was particularly unique as it attracted the attention of top public figures and become a diplomatic channel to communicate a message to international communities. President Ramaphosa and Deputy President Mashatile visited the NAMPO event and received a warm and jubilant welcome from true farmers that affirmed their commitment to the country and their devotion to farming. Other prominent public leaders that visited this year's NAMPO event were Minister John Steenhuisen and the Deputy Speaker of the National Assembly, Dr Lotriet.
The common message emanating from these visits was that there is neither ethnic cleansing nor Afrikaner extermination in the country. Essentially, they dispel the US decision to grant special refugee status to white Afrikaners on the basis of imaginary genocides in South Africa.
How Important Is US and Afrikaners to SA Agriculture?
Deducing from the messages of farmers and prominent public and private leaders who attended the NAMPO week, there is a solid consensus that farming communities and South Africans, as a whole, are united behind their rainbow nation flag and are opposed to the deluded decision by the Potus.
While this may breed confidence and resilience that South Africans are well known for across the globe, it is also important to not lose sight of domestic structural and systematic pitfalls that fuel divisional views that subsequently taint the image of the country in the world. First, is the need to review the current agricultural growth strategy that depends on global demand and innovations while negating the need to build local capabilities on technology and research.\
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Agoa is important
Agoa is one of the important trade agreements that enable South African farmers to produce and export products like fruits, nuts, wine, fish, and prepared foods. Without a doubt, access to the US market has been one of the critical growth factors for South African agriculture. The US accounted for 4% of South Africa's agricultural exports in 2024, suggesting it is not the largest destination market for farmers. However, looking at only trade data could be deceiving because the US's influence on South African agriculture goes beyond trade relations.
When the US enacted Agoa in 2000, it aimed to strengthen trade, economic and political co-operation with African states. It is not a coincidence that the biggest companies providing seeds, agrochemicals, and technical services to South African farmers either originate in the US or at least have strong ties with US investors. This illustrates the interconnectedness and high dependency of South Africa's agriculture and food system on the global economy. While thinking global is important but acting local is vital to build resilience, sustainability and inclusivity.
Second, it is the lagging development and transformation in the agricultural sector, which at times causes conflicts and division amongst farmers. On February 18, 2025, Minister Steenhuisen painted a concerning picture where he outlined that 90% of agricultural output is from white farmers.
Slow transformation
Wandile Sihlobo and Johann Kirsten in their book titled, 'The Uncomfortable Truth About South Africa's Agriculture' affirmed these figures and further highlighted the mushrooming divisions amongst farmer organisations. The slow transformation pace tends to portray white farmers, mainly Afrikaners, as the barriers to commercial agriculture which raises frustrations amongst other population groups which are yet to enjoy the full dividends of democracy. Behind these challenges are limited government support to farmers and decaying off-farm infrastructure and stringent market standards that proportionately disadvantaged black farmers.
To resolve these challenges, government and private sector must put their hands on the deck to emulate the South African spirit of unity that was radiating in this year's NAMPO. This means the government must upscale its Comprehensive Agricultural Support Programme and the land reform. Private sector initiatives such as Metropolitan Collective Shapers, Karan Beef Emerging Academy and HortFin by Fruit South Africa, amongst others, must be promoted and encouraged to expand to all provinces in the country.
These private and public programmes will encourage all farmers to work together to build a sustainable and growing agricultural sector. Through these collaborations, real Afrikaner farmers who may be considering emigrating to the US, would be able to realise that they will be foregoing centuries of hard work and investment in agriculture, thus making them to stay.
Financial and non-financial incentives must be upscaled to all farmers, especially the developing black farmers, to ensure farmers are committed and not persuaded by short-term political promises in the foreign countries. Agriculture will strive through partnerships.
Sifiso Ntombela is an agricultural economist.
Image: Supplied
Dr Sifiso Ntombela is the President of the Agricultural Economics Association of South Africa. He served as the Special Adviser to the former minister Thoko Didiza in the Department of Agriculture, land Reform and Rural Development. Contact details: sifiso@igrodeals.co.za
BUSINESS REPORT
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Eyewitness News
an hour ago
- Eyewitness News
Parliament's finance committee approves fiscal framework, revenue proposals underpinning budget
CAPE TOWN - Parliament's standing committee on finance has approved the fiscal framework and revenue proposals that underpin the 2025 budget, setting the scene for the less contentious adoption of its report in the National Assembly than was the case in March. Following two days of deliberations, the African National Congress (ANC), Democratic Alliance (DA) and ActionSA voted in favour of the report. However, the uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party and Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) dug in their heels saying the fuel levy is an unnecessary inclusion that will impact the poor. Wednesday's joint meeting of the finance committees of both houses was far less tense than when it considered an earlier version of the budget framework, which contained a value-added tax (VAT) increase that split the Government of National Unity (GNU). ALSO READ: Main opposition parties reject Treasury's assertion of pro-poor budget However, opposition parties took issue with the increase in the fuel levy, which was included in this third version of the budget tabled by the finance minister two weeks ago. The MK Party's Brian Molefe said other means could have been found to raise R4 billion in a R2 trillion budget. "The fuel levy is regressive and it is not pro-growth, because the fuel levy dampens consumption, expenditure, and it is inflationary as well." After losing Tuesday's court case on the matter, the EFF's Omphile Maotwe made one last appeal for the committee to retract the increase. "If we can stand up and say we reject the fuel levy, that's something we can give the people of South Africa." But with no support to force the finance minister's hand again, both opposition parties rejected the fiscal framework and the committee's report, which will be put to a house vote next Wednesday.
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
How are undersea cables repaired? A look inside the WACS operation
Major internet issues have South Africans across the country following reports of undersea cable failures. Image: Unsplash Don't send angry emails to your ISPs just yet, because if your internet connection has been feeling a little slow, it might be because the West Africa Cable System (WACS) has been offline since June 1. WACS is a key internet artery linking South Africa to Europe and is reportedly offline due to emergency maintenance expected to last over two weeks. The issue is a faulty branching unit near Swakopmund, Namibia, which supplies power to sections of the cable, resulting in slower speeds and connectivity issues, particularly in parts of the Western Cape, as providers reroute traffic through alternative routes like Seacom and EASSy on the East Coast. Emergency maintenance began at 2am on June 1 and is scheduled to end by 8am on June 16, weather permitting. During this time, the affected stretch of WACS is offline, meaning no data traffic can flow through it. After replacement, engineers must run post-repair signal tests from South Africa to Lisbon and onward to London before declaring the system operational. It's worth noting that the cable didn't break, but it's still useful to know how these fixes are done How are undersea cables repaired? Do you know how, when you have a problem with your laptop, you call IT and they tell you to switch your device off and on again? While this may work for computers and laptops, the same thing cannot be said for undersea cables. Submarine cable repairs are high-stakes, logistically intense operations, as these cables can stretch thousands of kilometres across oceans, which makes repair work highly specialised, time-consuming, and dependent on good weather. This is how it goes down, according to One Step Power. 1. When a cable goes down, engineers first use signal tests to identify the break. A pulse of light is sent through the fibre. Under normal circumstances, the light travels uninterrupted, but when there's a break, the light reflects. From this, engineers can pinpoint the problem area. For power cables, they sometimes use remotely operated vehicles (ROVs) with fault detection tools. 2. Once the damage is located, a specialised cable repair ship is sent to the area. These ships are fitted with dynamic positioning systems that keep them steady in rough seas. They're also stocked with replacement cable that is usually around 5–10 km. Newer vessels can carry up to 9,000 km. 3. In shallow water, ROVs with cameras and robotic arms can grab the cable and bring it up. However, in deep water where pressure is too high for ROVs, a deep-sea fishing hook called a grapnel is used to cut and haul the cable ends to the surface. These ends are either brought onboard or floated with buoys until the ship can complete the fix. Once on board, the cable is moved into a repair room, where engineers clean, splice, and test it. The process can take up to 16 hours. The repaired section is then lowered back down, often in a hairpin or omega loop to accommodate the extra cable length needed for the operation. In this case, Openserve confirmed that a repair ship successfully located and recovered the faulty branching unit. Engineers onboard confirmed that the cable itself is intact. How WACS works and why it matters WACS is a 14,530-km-long submarine fibre optic cable that runs from Portugal to South Africa. It has landing points in 11 countries, including Namibia, Angola, and Ghana. It has a design capacity of 14.5 Tbps and includes dedicated express lanes, which are direct high-speed links between South Africa and Europe, making it a vital resource for ISPs and content delivery networks (CDNs). When WACS is compromised: Traffic must be rerouted, often through longer or more congested paths. Latency increases, especially for international content. Regional imbalances emerge — Cape Town ISPs are more affected than Gauteng-based ones, due to routing differences. Once the faulty branching unit is replaced, it will be sent to the supplier for analysis to determine what went wrong. While the cause remains unclear, operators hope no further complications arise during testing. If all goes well, normal traffic should resume by Sunday. IOL
IOL News
2 hours ago
- IOL News
Broos must use these friendlies to decide Bafana Bafan's No 2
Bafana will play Tanzania at the Peter Mokaba Stadium on Friday at 7.30pm and follow up with neighbours Mozambique at Loftus Versfeld on Tuesday night. WHILE it may go a long way to calming nerves for Bafana Bafana debutants, coach Hugo Broos' statement about giving all the players some minutes in the upcoming friendlies against Tanzania and Mozambique, must not apply to goalkeepers. Congratulations to Nkosinathi Sibisi, who has been named Bafana Bafana captain for the next two matches 👏 Back to Broos' squad, which is cautiously missing Mamelodi Sundowns players as they are preparing for the 2025 Fifa Club World to be played in the US from the 17th, there are three goalkeepers competing to start in the two friendlies - Orlando Pirates' Sipho Chaine, Sekhukhune United's Renaldo Leaner and SuperSport United's Ricardo Goss. These matches should not be confused with those of the A-side, also formerly known as Ama-Binneplaas, which is competing in the Cosafa Cup against Mozambique on Wednesday afternoon, Zimbabwe on Saturday and Mauritius on Tuesday. This is Bafana Bafana. They represent South Africa, and whenever they play, we as South Africans are always fully behind them….. With Ronwen Williams on Club World Cup duty, the door is open for these goalkeepers to elevate themselves to the national team's trusted number two shot stopper. But with the Belgian mentor quoted this week saying: 'It is a great opportunity for the new players and also the young ones, there is no pressure. We are playing friendly matches, so the results are not that important. From my side, I will give every player the same playing time.' Therein lies the problem. This approach will not help the coach and his technical team in zoning into who should be Williams official lieutenant. A good thing is that he himself, Broos understands this approach is quite tricky with goalkeepers, as he continued to say: 'It is a little bit difficult for goalkeepers, but even for them, we will try every keeper to play the same minutes and have a good camp.' A free piece of advice to Broos is that he must not attempt this 'giving every player the same playing time' when it comes to goalkeepers. They must compete for the jersey and the best one of the bunch should start the first match, hands down. There is a downside to letting players know that they share playing time; no one will ascend the top spot. Yes from a common sense point of view, Chaine is supposedly the deputy to Williams currently, simply because of his performances with Pirates and his travels in the Caf Champions League. But the 28-year-old has actually only played one match out of his eight in the Bafana matchday squad. Goss on the other hand, has more experience with the national side, considering that he has even played in the Cosafa Cup and was part of the age group sides as a youngster. So, as much as there is not so much of a debate as to who is the better performing shot stopper between Goss and Chaine at the moment, competition for Williams' deputy is still very much wide open and giving out caps like Christmas presents will not help the Bafana cause. Having a settled and trusted number two will help even Williams to up his game, or better yet, it will prevent head-scratching during those times when he is not available for unavoidable reasons such as injuries. Broos must just have balls and start whoever shows more hunger among the three.
