Barmaid's family see her alleged killer for the first time at court hearing after the 21-year-old was found dead in house
Grieving relatives of Courtney Angus, 21, were accompanied by a police family liaison officer for the first appearance in crown court of suspected murderer Michael Doherty, 37.
The barmaid, who worked at the Fox and Hounds Pub, in Batley, was discovered dead at the end terrace property on Norfolk Street after odd-job man Doherty had been arrested by police for allegedly shoplifting electrical items from Asda and threatening staff with a knife.
Doherty is also alleged to have threatened two police officers with the bladed weapon.
Doherty - AKA Moore - is charged with the murder of Courtney at his home in Norfolk Street, Batley, West Yorkshire, on 26 July.
Appearing via video link from HMP Leeds, Doherty, 37, wearing a prison issue yellow and green jump suit answered 'no' when asked by the court clerk 'are you Michael Moore?'
Judge Tom Bayliss KC, after being informed by defence barrister Richard Wright KC that he uses another surname, asked him 'Are you Michael Doherty?' - to which he replied 'yes'.
No plea or indication of plea was taken and the case was listed for trial at Leeds Crown Court on 26 January 2026. No bail application was made and Doherty was remanded in custody.
It was the first time her family have been to court as they weren't at his first magistrates court hearing.
District Judge Charlotte Holland told him at the previous hearing on Wednesday that the murder offences and knife matters are too serious to be heard at magistrates' court.
Turning to Courtney's family sitting in the public gallery, Judge Bayliss told them today: 'Thank you very much for your attendance today. It must be a very difficult time for you, indeed.
'I'm sorry that it is so very formal here, but you would expect that, I'm sure.'
No cause of death for Courtney has yet been released.
Earlier this week, Courtney's family paid tribute to her, stating: 'Our lives have been shattered and turned upside down with the news that no parent wants to hear - that our gorgeous daughter and sister is no longer with us.
'Courtney had a beautiful soul. She was a lover of music, socialising and having fun. Her whole family is heartbroken over the loss of such an amazing woman.
'Courtney had many friends and family who loved her. She will be missed so dearly.
'We would like to thank the community and the media for their support, and ask for privacy at this difficult time.'
Staff at the Fox and Hounds also paid tribute, writing: 'We are heartbroken to hear the devastating news about Courtney.
'Though she was only with us at The Fox for a short while, she left a lasting impression - sweet, kind, and always with a warm smile.'
Father-of-three Doherty, who has worked as a labourer and recently started a window cleaning round, is charged with the murder of Courtney Angus on 26 July.
He is also charged with possession of a bladed article, two charges of threatening police officers with a bladed article, affray, shop theft from Asda of electrical items to value unknown, and threatening a member of Asda staff with a bladed article. All charges relate to 26 July.
Police said these charges relate to incidents in Dewsbury on the same day.
Doherty will next appear at Leeds Crown Court on 5 September for a plea and trial preparation hearing.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
4 minutes ago
- The Independent
Live facial recognition to be widened in neighbourhood policing drive
Live facial recognition will be expanded across the country as part of a Government overhaul of neighbourhood policing. The technology will be deployed to catch 'high-harm' offenders, with new rules drawn up to support its use and ensure 'safeguards and oversight', the Home Office said. Some 10 vans equipped with cameras will be rolled out across seven police forces – Greater Manchester, West Yorkshire, Bedfordshire, Surrey, Sussex, Thames Valley and Hampshire – over the coming weeks. Existing rules require checks only to be done against police watchlists of wanted criminals, suspects and those subject to bail or court order conditions like sex offenders. But a Government consultation will launch in the autumn to help 'shape a new legal framework' on its use, taking views on when and how the technology should be deployed. Privacy campaigners have previously voiced concerns about a potential lack of regulation and transparency over the expansion of the technology. The vans will be manned by trained officers and it will be for individual forces to decide how and when they are deployed in their areas, operating within the College of Policing guidance. Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said they would be focused on identifying sex offenders or 'people wanted for the most serious crimes who the police have not been able to find'. 'The algorithm being used in the vans has been independently tested and will only be operated in specific circumstances and with robust oversight,' the Home Office said. Chief Superintendent Tim Morgan of South Wales Police, which is co-ordinating the rollout alongside the National Police Chiefs' Council, sought to reassure the public that the technology would be used 'ethically'. 'We understand the concerns which are raised about the use of live facial recognition technology and we use any new technology ethically and spend time and effort making sure it's deployed in line with all legislation and guidance,' he said. 'It is important to remember that use of this has never resulted in a wrongful arrest in South Wales and there have been no false alerts for several years as the technology and our understanding has evolved.' Lindsey Chiswick, NPCC lead for facial recognition, said live facial recognition had already been used 'to great success, locating thousands of wanted offenders, or others breaching their bail conditions.' 'I am confident that the increased use of this technology will continue to support the safety of communities across the country moving forward,' she said. Forces already deploying live facial recognition have used it to arrest rape, domestic abuse, knife crime and robbery suspects as well as sex offenders breaching their conditions. Meanwhile, the Home Office said every community across England and Wales has now been assigned a 'named, contactable' officer to handle reports of crimes like anti-social behaviour. Their details will be made available for residents on their local force's website, it is understood. The pledge was made as part of the Government's previously announced Neighbourhood Policing Guarantee, under which forces have signed up to a commitment to respond to neighbourhood queries within 72 hours. The Government said the move would help ensure 'the public will have consistent direct links to their local force, with dedicated anti-social behaviour leads and new visible patrols in town centres'. Ms Cooper said: 'Neighbourhood policing has been decimated over the last 15 years, but through our Plan for Change we are turning the corner, starting with town and city centres. 'Within the next year, we will have 3,000 new neighbourhood officers and PCSOs in place, which is a big shift. 'We also want them to have more powers to tackle off-road bikes, shop theft, street theft and other crimes that have blighted some of our town and city centres, so everyone can feel safe in their own town.'
The Independent
4 minutes ago
- The Independent
Drivers caught behind wheel of unroadworthy vehicles up 52% in a year
The number of motorists caught driving unroadworthy vehicles jumped by 52% last year, new figures show, sparking fears that law-abiding road users are being put at 'serious risk'. A total of 13,109 British drivers were convicted of the offence in 2024, official data obtained by the RAC revealed. This is up from 8,614 during the previous 12 months. The Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency statistics, released in response to a freedom of information request, show the number of penalty point endorsements issued for driving vehicles with defective brakes, tyres, steering or other problems. The offence attracts three penalty points which stay on drivers' licences for four years. As the figures only reflect those caught, the RAC believes they represent the 'tip of the iceberg' when it comes to the number of unroadworthy vehicles being used. RAC mobile servicing and repairs team leader Nick Mullender said: 'The steep increase in drivers receiving points on their licences for unroadworthy vehicles is a cause for alarm, as it could indicate more drivers are running the gauntlet and driving unsafe vehicles – although it's also possible more drivers are being caught by the police. 'Whether it's brakes, tyres, steering or something else, every mechanical component in a vehicle plays a critical role in ensuring it can be driven safely and confidently. 'By getting behind the wheel of vehicles that are defective, a minority of drivers are needlessly putting the law-abiding majority at serious risk. 'For every person caught there will doubtless be more who are knowingly in charge of unroadworthy vehicles that could be involved in completely avoidable collisions in the future. 'We strongly urge drivers to keep on top of routine maintenance and get any issues checked by a well-qualified mobile mechanic or reputable garage.' Chief Superintendent Marc Clothier, part of the portfolio for roads policing at the National Police Chiefs' Council, said: 'These figures are shocking. 'If you are driving an unroadworthy vehicle with defects such as tyres or brakes, you are not only putting yourself at risk but you are putting the lives of other road users at risk too. 'Ensuring your vehicle is roadworthy and safe to drive is your responsibility and we would encourage everyone to routinely check their vehicle before getting behind the wheel.'
Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Tragic photo of girl, 4, 'coldly executed in back seat of car' by Target shooter after watching grandpa shot dead
A crazed gunman allegedly shot dead a little girl in front of her grandmother seconds after murdering her grandpa in a rampage through a Target. Adam Chow, 65, and his four-year-old granddaughter were gunned down in the parking lot, along with Target worker Hector Leopoldo Martinez Machuca, 24. Ethan Blaine Nieneker, 32, was subdued by police tasers as he ran naked out of a 'porta potty' after he fled the store in northern Austin on Monday. Chief Lisa Davis alleged at a press conference on Tuesday that Nieneker first 'randomly' shot Machuca about 2.15pm as he collected trolleys. The Hawaiian shirt-wearing gunman then fired at a black jeep that tried to evade his shot, before turning his gun on Chow's grey Toyota 4-Runner. Chow was shot in the driver's seat, then Nieneker fired into the back seats - hitting the granddaughter Astrid, Davis alleged. The mortally wounded grandfather's wife Doris tried to carry the girl to safety, when Nieneker pushed them out of the car and drove away. Austin homicide detective Nathan Sexton said Nieneker chose his victims 'completely randomly' and used a handgun given to him by a family member. 'He said that he was Jesus and there was no real reason whatsoever given,' he said. About 2.20pm he pulled up next to a water truck parked by the side of the Mopac Expressway, allegedly bashed its driver, and pulled him out of the vehicle. Nieneker tried to drive the truck away but wasn't able to, instead chasing the truck driver away with his pistol before returning to the Toyota. Five minutes later he crashed into a Volkswagen before landing on top of an Infiniti SUV, then allegedly attacked and carjacked the Volkswagen driver. Nieneker only drove that car until 2.34pm when he tried to steal a Waymo car, but failed and got back in the Volkswagen. Minutes later, a church acquaintance of Nieneker claimed a brick came flying through the window of his house on La Casa Drive after the gunman threw it. Nieneker's alleged rampage continued until 2.58pm when he was spotted walking naked through a backyard down the street from the one he bricked. He was seen running into a 'porta potty', then running away again before police found him, still nude and holding a Bible, and demanded he surrender. When he refused, police fired their tasers and he was arrested at 3.06pm. 'The investigation shows that Nieneker conducted these violent offenses of shooting at multiple victims, killing three victims, and destroying multiple vehicles, in the span of less than one hour,' police said. Chow was pronounced dead at the scene at 2.39pm and his granddaughter at. 2.50pm. Doris only suffered minor injuries. Nieneker was charged with two counts of capital murder for Chow and his granddaughter first-degree felony murder of Machuca. His booking photo at the Travis County Jail showed him staring straight at the camera with several fresh cuts on his face. Sexton said Nieneker gave no motive for the shooting and his state of mind at the time was still being investigated. 'We're still looking into the drug portion of it. He could have been under the influence of narcotics, it might not necessarily be all attributed to mental illness, so we're still investigating all of that,' he said. Davis admitted there were failures by authorities to follow up on mental health callouts, which may have prevented the shooting. 'This man had some serious issues, and I think about the systems that failed... there were some serious failures here,' she said. Nieneker had two emergency mental health detentions of up to 72 hours in 2018, but was not committed either time. How Nieneker got the gun, which he left in Chow's car, from a relative is being investigated, and could lead to charges against his family. 'Where does someone with this capacity to do this get a weapon and when does a family members feel comfortable giving someone with these issues a weapon?' Davis said. Nieneker lived alone and worked at a nearby restaurant, police said. Davis said police received calls about the shooting 15 minutes after it began and rushed to the scene within four minutes. Social media photos of Nieneker showed him grinning with friends at social events, posing while wearing a Covid-style mask by a trash bin, and posing beside a fireplace. Another Facebook image showed the alleged gunman holding a large brown leaf in front of his face and creepily peering over it, and a fifth photo had Nieneker wearing an American flag as a bandana. Davis told reporters on Monday evening that Nieneker has a history of mental illness and a prior criminal history. Records obtained by the Daily Mail showed he was arrested numerous times since 2011, serving short stints in jail for some of them. Nieneker began with two days in jail for marijuana possession in 2011, then two years probation (which was later revoked) for felony criminal mischief. Just five weeks later, he was jailed for 120 days for a DWI, and two family violence charges were dismissed. The next year he faced court for felony domestic assault, which was reduced to misdemeanor with a deferred adjudication in a pela deal. But he couldn't stay out of trouble so he served 45 days in jail and two years of probation for that crime. Two months later, in July 2016, he was jailed for 60 days for breaching a protection order, and another 90 days from May 2017 for a second DWI. Finally, in 2019, a felony domestic assault charge - which could have led to a long sentence as a repeat offender - was abandoned in 2022 when the victim couldn't be found. He spent time in jail for skipping bail during the case. Relative calm followed and Nieneker didn't pick up another charge before his alleged Target rampage, and friends thought he may have turned a corner. 'I went to high school with Ethan. Hung out with him on the 4th of July this year, first time seeing him in a few years,' a friend shared online. 'Used to see him every now and again at this popular swimming spot in Austin. I was pretty optimistic about him when I saw him on the 4th. 'He had become sober and we talked for a while about him wanting to learn more technical things and try to build a technical career working with circuitry and wiring. Overall normal and positive interaction. 'Blew my mind seeing this news today.' Shoppers and employees at Target said they ran for cover when they heard gunshots ring out in the parking lot. 'I was inside the store, but then I hear on the radio like shots fired, so then they just told us 'active shooter...' so we just ran outside, we told guests to get out,' Target employee Freyen Sagastume told KXAN. 'I thought that this only happened like in the news and stuff and then like I kind of just froze at first, but then I saw everyone running.' Meanwhile, at the nearby Jiffy Lube, employees hunkered down and locked the store's doors when they became aware there was a shooting outside. One mechanic, Paul Smith, told Spectrum Local News he saw people running from their cars in the parking lot in a panic. 'I had just gotten back from the Target like a minute before,' he said. Target said it would provide counseling to staff struggling with witnessing the shooting. 'We are devastated by the violence that occurred today at our store in Austin, Texas. Our hearts are with the families and loved ones of those who lost their lives, our team in Austin and all those impacted by this tragedy,' the company said. 'We are working with law enforcement as they conduct their investigation and are grateful to the first responders who acted quickly at the scene. 'In the days ahead, we will continue partnering with law enforcement and will be providing support resources, including grief counseling, to our team.'
