Apartment broker fee ban to begin Wednesday after federal judge nixes suit to stop the new NYC law
The city's new law banning broker fees will go into effect tomorrow, after a federal judge shot down a real estate lobby lawsuit to block the ban.
Judge Ronnie Abrams ruled Tuesday that a federal lawsuit challenging the Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses Act was mostly rooted in policy disagreements — not constitutional questions.
3 A new law banning broker fees starts tomorrow after a federal judge tossed a last-minute effort to pause the ban.
Helayne Seidman
'Plaintiffs' discontentment with the Act, however, stems not from its effects on their constitutional rights, but from a fundamental disagreement with its underlying policy,' Abrams ruled.
Her decision tossed all but one claim from the lawsuit, and denied a request to pause the law as the case plays out.
The FARE Act — passed in City Council with a veto-proof majority of 42-8 on Nov. 13 — prohibits agents representing property owners from charging prospective renters a 'broker fee.'
3 The Real Estate Board of New York and other groups claimed that banning broker fees would 'destroy' the rental market, according to their suit.
Helayne Seidman
The lawsuit, filed a month later by the Real Estate Board of New York, a broker's association and various property groups, claimed that banning broker fees would 'destroy' the rental market.
Abrams said the suit was asking 'the court to act as a 'superlegislature'' to nix laws they disagree with.
'The court declines that invitation,' Abrams wrote, adding that the 'remedy is through the political process, not in court.'
3 Judge Ronnie Abrams said the suit was asking 'the court to act as a 'superlegislature'' to nix laws they disagree with.
Kbarnofsky/Wikipedia
But while the judge said the act could result in higher prices for landlords, they were better positioned to absorb the cost by increasing rents.
'Tenants, by contrast, cannot pass the cost of brokers' fees to landlords,' she wrote.
REBNY President James Whelan said he was 'disappointed' that their motion to pause the law was kiboshed.
'New Yorkers will soon realize the negative impacts of the FARE Act when listings become scarce, and rents rise. We will continue to litigate this case as well as explore our avenues for appeal.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Judge blocks NYC mayor's office from bringing ICE agents onto Rikers Island
NEW YORK — A Manhattan Supreme Court justice on Friday blocked the Adams administration from bringing federal immigration officers onto Rikers Island. The preliminary injunction will prevent agents from Immigration and Customs Enforcement and other federal agencies from setting up shop at the jail complex until the case, filed by the New York City Council against the mayor and his administration, is resolved. 'New York City, which thrives as a global hub due in large part to its reputation as being a welcoming home for immigrant communities from around the world, risks having this goodwill and invaluable reputation irreparably damaged as a result of an Executive Order borne out of Mayor Adams' alleged conflict of interest,' Justice Mary Rosado wrote in her decision. The mayor's top deputy, Randy Mastro, signed an executive order in April to give the green light to federal agents to operate offices on Rikers. The Council filed the suit challenging it a week later, arguing that the order was unlawful and the 'poisoned fruit' of a corrupt deal with the Trump administration. Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, who is currently running for mayor, said in a statement that the decision was a 'victory' that would protect New Yorkers from Trump's immigration 'overreach.' 'New Yorkers are counting on our city to protect their civil rights, and yet, Mayor Adams has attempted to betray this obligation by handing power over our city to Trump's ICE because he is compromised,' she said. 'This attempted corrupt bargain to allow ICE to set up a center on Rikers would only make our city, and all New Yorkers, less safe.' 'We disagree with the judge's decision, and we remain confident we will ultimately prevail in this case,' Mastro said in a statement. 'At no point does the judge dispute that the substance of our executive order fully complies with local law — that's because it does. Furthermore, there is no actual conflict of interest here, and the mayor responded to the appearance of a conflict by delegating this issue to me as his first deputy mayor — whom the judge herself described as an 'accomplished and highly educated attorney' — and I acted entirely independently of the mayor.' Trump's deportation efforts in New York have ramped up in recent weeks, with agents lurking in the city's immigration courthouses to arrest immigrants checking in for routine court proceedings in their asylum cases. The mayor's attorneys have argued that any risks of imminent harm are no more than speculation. The judge wrote that she found that argument 'disingenuous.' 'It is akin to the police telling a 911 caller that they will not assist a victim who calls while a burglar attempts to enter her house but will be helped once the burglar enters her house,' Rosado wrote. The judge also wrote that the Council was likely to succeed in showing that, at the very least, the mayor appeared to be executing a corrupt deal with the Trump administration by agreeing to bring ICE back onto Rikers. The mayor was indicted on bribery charges in September, and was set to go on trial in April until President Trump's Department of Justice ordered the charges dropped, in part because they impeded Adams' ability to help carry out the president's hardline immigration agenda. That directive prompted waves of resignations within Manhattan Federal Court, including that of then-U.S. Attorney Danielle Sassoon — who alleged there was a quid pro quo between Adams and Trump. Murad Awawdeh, the president of the New York Immigration Coalition, said that the ruling would prevent 'thousands' of those in pretrial detention at Rikers from being deported: 'New York City should not be in the business of carrying out Donald Trump's mass disappearance agenda, which is in fact illegal under our local laws,' Awawdeh said. ________
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Oak Park Heights announces new mayor, available council seat
The city of Oak Park Heights announced Wednesday that Chuck Dougherty will be taking over the position of Oak Park Heights mayor after the death of Mayor Mary McComber in May. McComber served as mayor from 2012 to 2025. 'Mayor McComber left some big shoes to fill, but in this time of transition, I am committed to providing steady leadership and ensuring continuity for our community,' Dougherty said in the announcement. 'I look forward to continuing to serve our community with dedication, working alongside our Council, staff and residents.' Dougherty previously served as deputy mayor and has had a seat on the Oak Park Heights City Council since 2013. He and his wife also own the Water Street Inn and the Cover Park Manor Bed & Breakfast. The city council is accepting applications for Dougherty's vacated council seat through Thursday, July 3, according to the announcement. Dougherty and the new council member will serve in these roles until November 2026, when a special election for the positions will occur. Both special elections would be for a two-year term to finish the remaining terms of McComber and Dougherty. Applications for Oak Park Heights City Council can be found on the city's website at or at City Hall at 14168 Oak Park Blvd. N. As mayor, Dougherty will help plan for the 2028 closure of the Allen S. King plant in Oak Park Heights. The plant currently provides close to 28 percent of Oak Park Heights' tax base. When running for city council in 2024, Dougherty said one of his priorities was coming up with a plan to minimize the effects the tax base loss will have on Oak Park Heights residents. Obituary: How a bridge got Mary McComber, mayor of Oak Park Heights, into local politics U of M researchers are planting 'survivor' trees in hopes of defeating Dutch elm disease State fund helps Oak Park Heights plan for PFAS treatment Oak Park Heights state of emergency declared to deal with water main break Four Stillwater teachers suspended for cheating on training program
Yahoo
31 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Watertown council to vote on lifting residency requirement for city manager, others
Jun. 13—WATERTOWN — After it came up more than a year ago, City Council members will finally deal with passing a local law that would allow City Manager Eric Wagenaar to continue to live in Chaumont. The issue was first brought to the public's attention last month when Watertown resident Robert Avallone questioned why council members had failed to act on a local law that would not require Wagenaar to live in the city. On Monday night, council members will be asked to pass the ordinance that would not require Wagenaar, Public Works Superintendent Brian MacCue, City Engineer Tom Compo and City Assessor Kimberli Johnston to live in Watertown. During three subsequent council meetings in recent weeks, Avallone brought up the subject. "It's not a good look to leave a breach of contract," Avallone said. "I'm glad they're addressing it." He wasn't blaming Wagenaar for the situation. Mayor Sarah V.C. Pierce, City Attorney Kristen Smith and council members should have acted on it long before Monday's meeting, Avallone said. On Dec. 23, 2023, the City Council approved the contract to hire Wagenaar with the stipulation that he'd move into the city within six months. Under the contract, Wagenaar was given until June 29, 2024, to make the move, with a possible six-month extension until last December. About a year ago, council members discussed the issue during an executive session, but took no action. Councilwoman Lisa A. Ruggiero said Friday that the city attorney wrote up a resolution to address it on May 20, 2024. In an email, Pierce told council members she would review it. There it sat, the councilwoman said. So Ruggiero sent out an email to Smith asking about it on May 20, 2025 — exactly a year after the city attorney had penned the ordinance — and then forwarded the email to Pierce and council members, she said. "Eric is doing an excellent job," Avallone said. "He's an asset for the city. I'm glad he's on board." On Monday night, council members will consider adopting a local law to create an exception to the residency requirement under Section 3 of the state's Public Officers Law for the city manager and the three other appointed city officials. Pierce, who could not be reached for comment, and council members Cliff G. Olney III and Ruggiero were on council when Wagenaar was hired. Council members Robert O. Kimball and Benjamin P. Shoen have served on council during Wagenaar's tenure as city manager. Wagenaar replaced former City Manager Kenneth A. Mix, who retired at the end of Decembers 2023. Mix lived in Champion before moving to Watertown to become city manager.
