logo
Minibuses make sense on rural routes

Minibuses make sense on rural routes

The Guardian13-06-2025
Your article (Almost a fifth of England's rural bus services have vanished in the past five years, 7 June) didn't cover the costs of operation or the purposes of rural (and suburban) bus services. Different from urban areas, the bulk of their use is by those on low incomes, particularly pensioners, most of whom cannot afford a car or are unable to drive one. Over 20% of UK households do not have access to a car. Passenger demand for such services is relatively low in terms of numbers, but for those who do use them it is usually the only way they can get to the shops, go to the doctor, see friends etc. I have heard many describe their local bus service as a lifeline.
The problem in terms of cost – but also in terms of image – is that a large standard bus, carrying six or seven passengers much of the time, is hugely expensive to operate and, for the onlookers in their cars, a 'wasteful' use of council tax.
The better, much cheaper option is to use 16-seater minibuses. Obviously these have a much lower capital cost, but also much lower running costs, particularly the cost of drivers as they are not required to have public service vehicle licences but merely, if under 70, a normal driving licence. They are also more manoeuvrable down country lanes or around housing estates. The local nature of the service means the regular passengers know the regular drivers and, of course, each other, which creates a friendly and supportive environment. Often the experience is so important for someone living alone.
At the moment, virtually all the minibuses in passenger operation are converted vans. If the government recognises that minibuses are the most cost-effective solution for rural bus services then there is an opportunity here for entrepreneurs – or perhaps the government – to build minibuses specifically for passengers.Mike ParkerDirector general, Nexus (Tyne & Wear Passenger Transport Executive), 1994-2006; chair, West Oxfordshire Community Transport, 2023-24
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Gloucestershire Highways warn of 'tsunami' of 20mph requests.
Gloucestershire Highways warn of 'tsunami' of 20mph requests.

BBC News

time27 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Gloucestershire Highways warn of 'tsunami' of 20mph requests.

Bids to reduce speed limits in towns and villages across Gloucestershire could overwhelm council officers, a meeting has Spivey, the leader of Gloucestershire County Council, pledged to bring in the speed zones to improve "road safety" and make residents feel more "comfortable". But at a recent meeting, the council's economy and environment chief Colin Chick said he feared the idea would lead to a "tsunami of requests"."We are completely overwhelmed at the moment," Mr Chick told the meeting, adding detail on the complication of getting a speed limit changed. "The difficulty is going to be dealing with it. And having the resources available while continuing to do our everyday work," Mr Chick added."We are absolutely struggling to keep our heads above water."To then have this, I think it will be a tsunami of requests coming in."Each one will require a site visit and we'll have to look at the accident data. No small job, those two alone."Every single one will require a traffic order to be made."One of the areas under proposal for a 20mph zone is the A4135 in Dursley between Cedar Drive and Henlow resident Mike Softley, 72, said it wasn't needed as "people don't have time to get to 30mph" driving through Dursley. Green Party Councillor Dr Richard Dean, representing Dursley, said he is a "big supporter of the 20mph speed reductions".He said there had been 12 road incidents in Dursley since 2020 - five of them serious - but urged the council to include the area around Rednock School. "There are these hidden effects of traffic on mental health including sleeplessness, anxiety and depression which leads into physical illnesses, this should be taken into account when thinking about traffic regulations," he Dursley Town Council said it has "raised a number of concerns" over the proposals and could not support it in its current form. Ms Spivey said after the local elections in May 2025 that she wanted to consult with town and parish councils to find areas where 20mph limits were welcomed.

Derby student goes from stables to start-up garage
Derby student goes from stables to start-up garage

BBC News

time40 minutes ago

  • BBC News

Derby student goes from stables to start-up garage

When the Covid pandemic shuttered her studies in horse care, Storm Rogers-Davies said discovering a new path was a "sliding doors" in 2020, the "very practical course" was swapped for online lessons due to the outbreak, making her want to ditch it Rogers-Davies then got work on the assembly line of Toyota's factory in South Derbyshire - after getting a taste for working on cars from her 24-year-old, who now runs a business servicing cars from her home, said: "When an engine light comes up on my car I now know what I'm doing, compared to five years ago when I knew nothing." Reminiscing how it all started, Ms Rogers-Davies said as a child she used to sit by the living room window, watching her dad work on cars."In particular his Renault 5 Turbo, that was one of my favourites," she dad, Simon, worked as an electrician on the London Underground but would also help friends fix their cars.A few years went by and he let his daughter help with his Rogers-Davies, from Mackworth, Derby, said: "I would say I was fascinated with how parts of a car are put together and to me it looked like a jigsaw puzzle."Let's say putting brakes on a car, you have to follow certain steps the same as you would a jigsaw."When I left Toyota I thought I want to learn more and see how far I can take this." Ms Rogers-Davies then enrolled on a level two light vehicle maintenance and repair course at Derby completing the next level of the course, she went on to setting up her own business - Platinum Garage - where she is servicing cars from her training also came into play when her uncle Donald called her after he got a puncture on the A38, that she went out to and fixed."I still watch horse racing and I see the big change I have made, but I am proud of the change because it is going to help people in the future," she Rogers-Davies said her dad would be surprised and also "more than proud" of her career change."I feel like my future is much much clearer now compared to when I left school," she said. Ms Rogers-Davies's tutor at Derby College, Paul Etherington, said her passion for automotives has "certainly helped" her get through the course following the career change."Its always a big step to make a career change," said Mr Etherington."I was a mechanic for 20 years and it was very nerve-wracking for me to go into teaching because I didn't know if I would enjoy it, but I've never looked back."I think as long as you change careers for something you enjoy, you won't look back either."

Is the new Range Rover Electric worth £170,000? I drove it to find out
Is the new Range Rover Electric worth £170,000? I drove it to find out

Telegraph

timean hour ago

  • Telegraph

Is the new Range Rover Electric worth £170,000? I drove it to find out

It's finally here. Sort of. The Range Rover Electric will not be available until 2026, despite initial suggestions of an on-sale date in the latter half of this year. Nothing more precise than that, with no indication of prices either. But prototypes and pre-production cars exist on the world's testing facilities as well as on the roads around Land Rover's Solihull base. And I have driven one of these prototypes, during the Goodwood Festival of Speed, to see how it measures up. The rumoured cost is about £170,000 – roughly equivalent to the V8 petrol version, which was the benchmark for this newcomer since gestation and during development. The Range Rover line-up starts at £105,675. Despite the lack of hard figures, Range Rover says that it has a 'client waiting list' of 62,000 souls. What we do know is that the battery is a 118kWh (useable) item. There's 550PS (542bhp) and 850Nm (627lb ft) of torque, with a range in the region of 300-330 miles and a 0-62mph sprint time of about 4.5 seconds, although no performance figures have been announced yet. 'It's a Range Rover first, an EV second,' can be heard a lot; all the engineers and development drivers have been well versed in this mantra. Test drive My all-too-brief introduction to the Range Rover Electric was to demonstrate its abilities over a series of daunting obstacles of the type used during development. Essentially the aim was for the EV to do everything the existing combustion models can – and perhaps a little more, since careful calibration of the torque delivery allows the electric drivetrain to 'talk' to existing electronic systems such as Hill Descent Control. The first is a series of crazy-looking ramps to simulate crawling over massive boulders, which pitch one (sometimes two) wheels in the air while balancing precariously. As with all off-roading, smooth and gentle is the key to progress (the desire not to prang a development car also prompts caution). Suffice to say that the car was more composed than its driver, imparting a feeling of stability and control via a zillion calculations monitoring progress. It's called Integrated Traction Management and ensures that the prodigious torque doesn't overwhelm the amount of grip. The second test is a ramp, which doesn't look that steep until you start to drive up it and can see only the sky. Fortunately the car's surround camera system displays images of ahead and below for guidance. Gently over the top, then let the car demonstrate its seamless integration of single-pedal driving and Hill Descent Control. How so? Simply take your foot off the accelerator and let the car creep its way down. The third is a simple-looking diagonal crossing of an obstacle, once again with the low-speed Rock Crawl setting engaged. The surprise comes as the vehicle's weight makes it tip, forcing the electronic systems to prevent it rolling off. It would have been interesting to do the same course in a V8 Range Rover for direct comparison, although the development engineers insist that the fast-responding electric drive units provide greater ease of use and improved control (compared with the complex sequence of sucking and pumping inherent in a combustion engine). JLR claims that in detecting and managing wheel slip, the EVs set-up is 100 times faster than the combustion cars. It's all about the calibration – a phrase that occurs frequently throughout the afternoon. What's all the fuss about? For those who still believe that electric cars should have futuristic, quasi-spaceship styling to emphasise their cutting-edge technology, the greatest surprise about this EV Range Rover is how normal it looks. Extra charging flap aside, they are identical. It's the same story inside. Land Rover has even retained its traditional capstan gearlever, although it performs different functions than it does in the combustion-engined cars; the S is for single-pedal driving (with regenerative braking) rather than Sport mode. It all emphasises that the Range Rover Electric is an alternative to the existing line-up, not a replacement. Electric drivetrain The advantages of battery power are a linear response to the accelerator along with effortless torque delivery. Initial rumours had suggested the Range Rover Electric might have three or even four drive motors, yet in the final set-up there are only two, one at each end of the car. It's four-wheel drive, obviously, with a slight rearward bias in the power delivery. The battery and control electronics were developed in-house and are currently produced in Wolverhampton, which has the added benefit of bolstering Land Rover's credentials for Britishness. Chief engineer Simon Fairbrother explained that the 118kWh battery has 344 cells using NMC chemistry, in two decks of 172, made possible by the vehicle's height. With a 350kW charging capability (assuming you can find any such super-fast chargers in the UK), charging the battery from 10 to 80 per cent is claimed to take only 20 minutes. The clever bit is the thermal management, so that heat can be directed to where it is needed (to warm the electric motors or optimise charging in cold weather, for instance). Range Rover claims that its Thermal Assist system is so sophisticated that it can recover heat even when the external temperature is minus 15 degrees centigrade. It's a claim that's hard to dispute, but impressive none the less. In reverse, the system channels excess heat within the battery pack to the atmosphere via a system of radiators and vents. Electric always planned The current Range Rover, which has the internal designation L460, was designed to be an EV from the outset. Hence it can be built on the same production line as the existing models. Currently, the combustion cars have the engine, gearbox, mechanical four-wheel-drive gubbins and associated subframes lifted in the bodyshell. In the EV, the battery and electric motors are raised instead (obviously there's no longer a mechanical linkage between engine and driveshafts). The only difference is that it takes slightly longer to 'marry' the EV drivetrain, as there are more bolts to tighten. Fairbrother added that the frame around the battery pack improves the torsional stiffness of the car, while the centre of gravity is also lowered compared with a combustion model. The suspension has twin-chamber air springs as standard, to better manage pitch and squat under acceleration and braking, which are potentially more pronounced in this version than in the current combustion cars due to the virtually instantaneous torque delivery. Do you want one? Although Jaguar announced long ago that it's going to be an all-electric brand, this Range Rover is in fact parent company JLR's first battery-powered production car. Lessons learnt during its ongoing development will no doubt inform Jaguar's controversial electric GT. Range Rovers have always featured V8 engines, so the concept of a battery-powered version is still alien to some. For that tranche of buyers, there will still be petrol, diesel and hybrid options. But in truth the silence and smoothness of an electric powertrain suits a luxury car; the improvements in these areas (not that combustion-engined Range Rovers are particularly bothersome) ensure the electric version complements the existing line-up. We'll have to see when we drive the finished car, but on the evidence thus far the Range Rover Electric might just be the best of the bunch.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store