Beijing, Philippines spar over South China Sea claims during Munich conference
While Russia's war against Ukraine and a wavering transatlantic alliance drew the world's attention at this year's Munich Security Conference, sparks also flew over claims in the South China Sea as debate involving participants representing Beijing and Manila dug into their positions in the region.
Advertisement
China's former deputy foreign minister Fu Ying said in a panel discussion, titled 'Making Waves: Maritime Tensions in the Indo-Pacific', that Beijing would not accept occupation by the Philippines of new features that the Southeast Asian country has constructed in the South China Sea. Philippine Foreign Secretary Enrique Manalo was part of the panel.
'China cannot agree for the Philippines to occupy Second Thomas Shoal and Sabina Shoal, because that is a violation of the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea,' Fu said, referring to a non-binding document signed by Beijing and Asean countries.
Fu insisted that the document's language – in particular, a pledge to 'not to make more moves' – was watered down at Manila's request to entice the country to sign.
The declaration asks signatories to exercise 'self-restraint' when conducting activities that would 'complicate or escalate disputes', and refrain from building on the sea's uninhabited features.
The presence of a dilapidated but still active Philippine Navy ship BRP Sierra Madre at the Second Thomas Shoal (Ayungin Shoal) in the South China Sea has been denounced as unacceptable by Beijing. Photo: AP
Further actions by Manila, including construction efforts to reinforce the BRP Sierra Madre, a World War II-era tank landing ship
deliberately positioned on the Second Thomas Shoal in 1999, have been denounced by Beijing as unacceptable.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
HKFP
a day ago
- HKFP
Hong Kong's John Lee compares city's int'l trade drive to attracting women
Chief Executive John Lee has compared Hong Kong's economic outreach efforts to attracting women. Amid strong competition, Lee said he was seeking economies that find Hong Kong mutually attractive, with Southeast Asian neighbours being a priority for bolstering trade ties. 'It's like me chasing a girl – you have to ensure there's some kind of attraction between us. So I think ASEAN [Association of Southeast Asian Nations] is our second-largest partner after the mainland the mutual attraction is already there – strengthen it,' the city's leader told SCMP on Sunday. SCMP Managing Editor Yonden Lhatoo took the analogy further, suggesting that girls' families may be focused on preventing such relationships, in an apparent reference to US trade turmoil. 'But there are a lot of girls,' Lee said, adding there are many options such as the Middle East. 'We've already decided to not just singly focus on the US market.' The dating analogy has been employed by senior officials repeatedly over the past year. Last June, Lee said that attracting large-scale events to the city was akin to 'chasing good women.' This March, talent matching efforts were compared to dating by the labour chief. Weeks later, the justice chief said national security education was an ongoing process, comparable to how one treats their spouse beyond Valentine's Day. 'That is Hong Kong' Lee said that there were no plans to enter a tit-for-tat trade war with the US following the imposition of tariffs by US President Donald Trump. Instead, the city would remain a free port, he said. Hong Kong had to primarily focus on national development, but will also foster international connectivity through the One Country, Two Systems framework. 'We continue to be bilingual – and, hopefully multilingual – we continue to maintain our way of life, we continue to maintain zero customs, our own law and also openness.' 'There is no control on capital, no control on people, no control on data – that is Hong Kong.' It comes weeks after it emerged that multiple independent media outlets were facing simultaneous tax audits. Hong Kong has been seeking to reboot its economy after registering annual deficits in three of the past four years. Its economic growth slowed to 2.5 percent last year.
Asia Times
3 days ago
- Asia Times
The tiny Philippine island denying and defying China at sea
LIKAS ISLAND – Philippine Marine Private John Lloyd Lobendino scanned the deep blue waters surrounding Likas, a tiny speck of an island in the West Philippines Sea, while rubber boats carrying visitors from the BRP Andres Bonifacio landed on the pristine beach. While other 21-year-olds are busy with other young adult pursuits, Lobendino went about his task with a seriousness normally associated with veterans who have seen terrible wars waged and blood spilled in the name of national patrimony. Like many of his fellow soldiers assigned to this remote and lonely outpost, Lobendino says he is willing to fight to the end. 'Because this is ours,' he said quietly when asked by Asia Times, which joined a recent maritime patrol operation in the South China Sea to check on the area ahead of the Philippines' Independence Day this week (June 12) He was accompanied by a fellow marine who was also in his 20s. He wore a pair of shades to protect his eyes from the sun's glare that intensely reflected the stretch of fine white sand of Likas (West York Island), the second-largest of the nine Philippine-controlled features in the disputed Spratly island chain. The military took journalists for the first time in patrolling the West Philippine Sea, the name the Southeast Asian country uses to refer to areas in the South China Sea that are within its jurisdiction. A crew member aboard the Philippine Navy's BRP Andres Bonifacio scans the horizon as the ship embarks on a maritime patrol of Manila-controlled areas in the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) on June 5, 2025. Picture: Jason Gutierrez Regularly, troops among the claimants are often in the background, preferring their respective coast guards – which are technically civilian in nature – to patrol the disputed sea lest a sudden miscalculation triggers outright hostility. But the mission is meant to assert the Philippines' sovereignty and sovereign rights over the waters amid an increasingly assertive China that rejected a 2016 arbitral ruling by an international court in The Hague, which invalidated Beijing's expansive nine-dash line claims in the region. That case was brought by the Philippines, a long-time military ally of the United States and the most vocal Southeast Asian region that has stood up to China in the contested maritime area. The patrol is part of the government's 'transparency initiative' to show the public that the distant shores are vital to the country's interests. Visitors to the island are greeted by weather-beaten green signage that welcomes them to the naval detachment. In the postcard-perfect background, a Philippine flag flutters in the gentle wind. Written on a fading-green board is a reminder of PD 1596, a presidential decree signed in 1978 that formally recognized Likas as part of the Kalayaan island group in the country's map. The 18-hectare island is home to a rotating number of Marines tasked with guarding the paradise island in the middle of the ocean and watched by the People's Liberation Army Navy forces backed by their coast guard and a fleet of militia vessels posing as fishermen. Last year, a Filipino soldier was wounded when China Coast Guard men armed with pikes and machetes violently seized firearms from Filipino supply boats near the Second Thomas (Ayungin) Shoal, called Ren'ai Jiao by Beijing, in another part of the disputed sea. An armed soldier guards the coast of Pag-Asa Island in the West Philippine Sea. Picture: Jason Gutierrez The United States has repeatedly said it is prepared to step in if Manila invoked a 1951 treaty that calls on both sides to defend each other in times of outside aggression, a scenario that could trigger a larger conflict. For now, cooler heads are prevailing despite China's provocations. For corpsman Ibasco, who was recently transferred to the Likas detachment, there was no time to think before he shipped out from home. 'To us, it is a privilege to serve,' said Ibasco, who did not want to give out his first name citing the sensitivity of his post. He said he took his mission to heart, though time can be an adversary. To break the monotony, he swims in the morning and catches fish 'because our provisions are all preserved food.' While a satellite connection allows him to connect with his wife and young daughter at times, much of his free time is spent on self-reflection. Veteran combatant Technical Sergeant Nino Calbog, who has seen action in the strife-torn southern Philippine region against homegrown insurgents, said it was an honor to be on the ground protecting the country from foreign aggressors. A father of two, he said his service is for the country and family. 'I always tell them that my job as a soldier is for them. It is difficult for a soldier to be away from family, but my wife is there explaining to them why I need to be away for three months,' he said. There is an improvised basketball court, where the men shoot hoops beside a garden patch, while two goats roam in the back. They can be slaughtered for food but are considered more like pets. Philippine soldiers hooping in their spare time on the island, June 5, 2025. Photo: Jason Gutierrez Power is provided by a generator and solar generators, although it can be pitch black at night here. Drinking water, however, is shipped on regular resupply missions or is collected through rainfall. 'Our flag is always waving because this island is ours,' said Naval Task Force 42 chief Colonel Joel Bonavente. 'It symbolizes that our troops are here to always guard and defend our territory in the West Philippine Sea.' Isolation, he said, could be the biggest enemy for some, but assured that 'the attitude of our soldiers is well adjusted.' 'They are well-motivated and stand ready to defend our territory,' Bonavente said, adding that protocol requires them to challenge anyone who is passing by nearby. Plans to upgrade the 'hospitability of our patrol base' are in the pipeline, he said. Filipino maritime expert Chester Cabalza said frequent military patrols were necessary to further the country's win in the legal battle in the face of the arbitral ruling that China continues to ignore. 'Frequent maritime patrols exercise our right to use, possess and control all resources in the shoal,' he told Asia Times. 'It also increases familiarity to the maritime domain as a means of readiness to the potential disputes amid flashpoints in the contested islands.' More importantly, Cabalza notes, it ensures that military forces are prepared against all 'unauthorized access that would lead to annexation.' 'The government must fulfill its aspiration of a self-reliant defense posture to sustain its massive military and coast guard operations,' he said, pointing out that Japan has also recently ratified a Reciprocal Access Agreement (RAA) that allows its troops to participate in joint drills with the Philippines, similar to the Americans. 'Beijing will feel a pinch of insecurity in view of this because they view the RAA as an impediment to their bigger goals in securing the entirety of the South China Sea,' he asserted. Jason Gutierrez was head of Philippine news at BenarNews, an online news service affiliated with Radio Free Asia (RFA), a Washington-based news organization that covered many under-reported countries in the region. A veteran foreign correspondent, he has also worked with The New York Times and Agence France-Presse (AFP).
South China Morning Post
5 days ago
- South China Morning Post
Pope Leo XIV at the Vatican, French Open: pictures of the week
Thick smoke and flames erupt from an Israeli airstrike in Gaza City. Photo: AP Thick smoke and flames erupt from an Israeli airstrike in Gaza City. Photo: AP share
