WA hermit crab exporter Merv Cooper rejects exploitation claims
Rockingham-based store owner Merv Cooper is one of five operators with a commercial fishing licence in WA's only hermit crab fishery, which spans more than 1,500 kilometres from Exmouth Gulf in the Pilbara to Kununurra in the Kimberley.
For almost 50 years, from an idea that came to him when he was a Broome pearl diver, Mr Cooper has distributed Coenobita variabilis, land crabs in Australia and overseas, with international export numbers on previous permit declarations capped at 20,000 crabs per year.
But his international export licence, which expired in December, is up for renewal by the federal Department of Climate Change, Energy, Environment and Water (DCCEEW).
The store owner's proposal was open for public consultation for four weeks and caught the eye of conservation groups and the Animal Justice Party.
They say Mr Cooper is exploiting the species and the proposal should be rejected.
Mr Cooper said the criticism was unfounded.
Mr Cooper said claims he was exceeding crab collection limits were wrong.
"It's just the fact we've been operating for so long," he said.
"There're three or four people in Perth that want to bring it to light that we've taken too many crabs from the places we go to.
"There are millions of crabs.
Mr Cooper said during a two-night trip, he could collect about 2,000 crabs in one location and only took crabs a "few times" a year for exporting.
Total harvest numbers are not published due to the limited number of operators in the hermit crab fishery.
Mr Cooper's proposal stated that if approved, he "could" take an average of 30,000 crabs a year, but would need to access new locations.
The low price, about $5 for a small crab, makes them an ideal first pet for children and families.
The Animal Justice Party (AJP) and WA's Conservation Council said not enough was being done to monitor crab numbers.
AJP MP Amanda Dorn said she was firmly against the proposal, despite past international export approvals.
"We think this is ecologically irresponsible and ethically indefensible," she said.
"The underrated hermit crab has been largely ignored for many years ... (they are) being used as a 'throw away pet'.
Conservation Council WA executive director Matt Roberts said Mr Cooper's proposal should be rejected because it increased the number of crabs he wanted to export.
"It is a substantial increase and that would have a material impact on some of those ecosystems," he said.
Broome resident Taryn Ryan operates education seminars and walking tours to find and identify shells on Kimberley beaches.
She wants fauna studies into the impact on the region.
"How are we going to know if the taking of hermit crabs is going to affect the crab population? We don't," she said.
"[We could] even use this as an education opportunity.
"Maybe we can participate and make sure it's done in the safest way possible."
The Department of Primary Industry and Regional Development, which grants the commercial fishing licences, said there were no "identified risks" to the crab population.
"There is also a prohibition in place to limit the number of fishers and restrict the method to hand collection only," principal fisheries management officer Graeme Baudains said.
Mr Baudains said the department monitored catch numbers and trends.
"There is no identified need for a dedicated population survey, given the very low level of take, comparative to the observed population," he said.
Mr Cooper's Wildlife Trade Operator proposal is under assessment, with no timeline for a decision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
16 hours ago
- News.com.au
What impact will Chris Bowen's gas review have on ASX explorers?
WA's 15% gas reservation policy has kept local prices lower for nearly two decades The federal government now plans to apply a similar model to the east coast What impact will this have on ASX gas players on the east coast? We tap MST Access energy analyst Saul Kavonic to give us a breakdown of possible scenarios Gas reservation – the retention of a percentage of a gas development's reserves for domestic use – has been a feature of Western Australia's energy picture for nearly two decades and the federal government, via Minister for Climate Change and Energy Chris Bowen, is now looking to do the same in the eastern states. The policy has been credited with ensuring comparatively lower gas prices in WA, which had required offshore fields to set aside 15% of their gas for domestic use. While wholesale gas prices in the state have increased significantly since 2020 when the state government allowed onshore fields to export gas, it remains lower than over in the east with Santos (ASX:STO) reporting realised prices of about $8.24 per gigajoule during the first quarter of 2025. This compares with the average gas price of $13.26 per gigajoule on the east coast during the same period, according to the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO). Anthony Albanese's Labor government is now hoping that a similar gas reservation scheme could increase domestic gas supplied as it stares at the potential for shortfalls in 2029. Gas policy shake-up For ASX small cap gas players operating on the east coast, implications will vary depending on the details of the reservation policy and how it is executed. Speaking to Stockhead, MST Access energy analyst Saul Kavonic said that if the government simply introduces a forward-looking gas reservation policy for new fields, it's unlikely to shift the dial much for the east coast gas market. But if the government goes down the more aggressive pathway, applying the policy retrospectively to existing projects, Kavonic said it would artificially push more gas into the domestic market for a period of time. 'And that would put some downward pressure on pricing,' he said. 'Even in that scenario, we are still likely looking at double digit gas prices at the very low end, so for the small east coast producers, both the demand and the pricing outlook still appears like it will remain supportive. 'What it will do for those domestic players is drastically limit their market routes by cutting off export of the volumes as an option, and particularly for those players where exports would be the most natural market, that could potentially reduce the availability capital and joint venture approvals for them to proceed.' Another potential benefit for small-cap producers on the east coast is if the policy is structured to incentivise domestic gas development by allowing new gas supply to offset reservation obligations, Kavonic said. 'The policy could open up opportunities for small-cap producers, as LNG players may look to support their projects in order to secure the domestic gas volumes required under the new framework,' he added. 'The risk lies in the government calling it a prospective policy, but then defining it to include new fields, expansions, and third-party supply in a way that effectively makes it retrospective – impacting existing assets and operations. 'I think the government wants to pursue this in a way which encourages more supply, which is in line with the Future Gas Strategy and the statements being made by the Prime Minister,' Kavonic said. 'If they get the settings right, it could see a boost for small independent suppliers as the LNG projects would be incentivised to support and fund them.' But if the government doesn't get the policy right, it could end up doing more harm than good, discouraging new gas supply and making the market situation worse. Testing trade relations Over the past few years, the Australian government's intent to increase supply has tended to backfire. Since 2022 when the Labor government introduced its gas policy, relations with our international trading partners – including Japan – have been impacted. Now, the Albanese government's move to consider an east coast gas reservation is adding even more fuel to the fire, and reportedly causing concern in Japan – a country where securing LNG supply is a national security. WA Premier Roger Cook has flagged serious trade concerns from Japanese stakeholders over the potential east coast gas reservation policy, following meetings with senior government and industry officials during a recent visit. Gas thirst could fuel growth Regardless of what happens in regard to the reservation policy, the hunger for gas supplies could be a benefit for Advent Energy – an unlisted company that's 36% owned by BPH Energy (ASX:BPH). Advent continues to maintain that its PEP 11 permit in the offshore Sydney Basin is in force with respect to matters such as reporting, payment of rents and the various provisions of the Offshore Petroleum and Greenhouse Gas Storage Act 2006 and is currently seeking a judicial review. PEP 11 could host multiple trillion cubic feet of gas, which could go a long way towards meeting east coast gas demand.
SBS Australia
a day ago
- SBS Australia
Protesters rally against 'climate catastrophe' coal mine plan
Protesters have rallied outside a court opposing what is set to be one of Australia's biggest coal mines, saying the multibillion-dollar proposal will contribute to a "climate catastrophe". Several dozen people gathered on Monday to object to Whitehaven's Winchester South open-cut mine, comparing it with a 1960s proposal to dredge up the Great Barrier Reef to produce fertiliser. It came as the Land Court in Brisbane began hearing an objection against the proposal, which would extract 17 million tonnes of coal from the Bowen Basin each year. Who is opposing the mine proposal? Australian Conservation Foundation's Adam Beeson compared the proposed mine with reef dredging and oil drilling, ideas blocked by the courts decades ago as he addressed protesters outside. "What really is the difference between excavating coral and digging up coal, increasing the global temperature which causes coral bleaching and coral death?", Beeson said. He said his foundation along with the Mackay Conservation Group would tell the court the mine's return was "not worth this impact". Mackay Conservation Group climate campaigner Imogen Lindenberg said Winchester South could be the nation's biggest new coal mine. "If this mine goes ahead, it will create more pollution than Australia produces in one year," she said. "We are already living in a time of climate catastrophe. "Many folks' homes have been flooded, there are bushfires - it's not just us, it's all the beautiful threatened species." What has Whitehaven said? Barrister Saul Holt KC, acting for Whitehaven, said in his opening address that the Winchester South project would bring significant economic benefits. He said the mine had widespread community support and would bring $696 million in state royalties and 500 new jobs during construction and operations. "It's the right project, in the right place, by the right miner at the right time," he said. Holt said Winchester would also support manufacturing that was vital for Australia's transition to renewable energy.
SBS Australia
a day ago
- SBS Australia
Migrant to mogul: How Vikas Rambal built a billion-dollar empire in Australia
More than two decades later after migrating from India, Rambal has been ranked the 31st richest person in the country on the 2025 Australian Financial Review Rich List. He says this is just the beginning. 'When I was asked about number of cars in India, it hit me hard because it made me realise that Indians had not yet made a strong mark here," Rambal, the Managing Director, Founder and Chair of Perdaman Group, said. Vikas Rambal (second from R) with his wife Megha (second from L) and two sons during his early years in Australia. Credit: Perdaman's Office "That's when I decided I needed to establish myself.' Rambal migrated to Australia in 2000 and has since been passionately involved in developing and expanding chemical manufacturing facilities in the country. Today, he is known for his project to develop a multi-billion-dollar fertiliser plant on the Burrup Peninsula in Western Australia's far north-west. His net worth is estimated at $4.98 billion. But, he says his focus lies beyond just accumulating wealth. Perdaman chairman Vikas Rambal Credit: Supplied by Vikas Rambhal's office "Wealth isn't my primary focus—it's growth that drives me. My goal is to create more millionaires, and I believe that path will naturally lead me to becoming a billionaire," Rambal said. 'I initially came here with the idea of building a solar farm, but I believe manufacturing is the future for Australia and that's what I have been working towards," Rambal said. Perdaman secured a $6 billion urea project which kicked off a few years ago and according to Rambal, it would be Australia's largest fertiliser manufacturing project. Vikas Rambal with WA Premier and others. Credit: Supplied by Perdaman Group office The plant will convert natural gas from Woodside's Scarborough Gas Project into an estimated 2.3 million tonnes of urea per annum, for both domestic and international consumption. Recalling his initial struggle to establish his Indian identity, he said he has since been actively working to build a bridge between India and Australia. LISTEN TO SBS Hindi 13/07/2025 06:47 Hindi 'Many Indians who've migrated overseas have, by and large, acquired existing businesses, but we built projects from the ground up,' he says. 'But when I approached Australian lenders with my business proposals soon after I arrived here, they travelled to India just to verify my credentials." "I believe what we lack as a community is a strong identity, despite all the hard work we've put in here.' He now aims to create a pool of talent especially young and empower others to follow in his footsteps and become wealth creators in their own right. "In my view if I am able to create more millionaires, I will improve my ranking as a billionaire automatically. And that's my vision for my future" he adds. LISTEN TO SBS Hindi 07/05/2025 12:02 Hindi Find all our podcasts here at: SBS Hindi Podcast Collection.
