Xbox Game Pass has been 'damaging the industry for a decade' says Arkane founder
Microsoft's latest round of job cuts has led to studio closures and a slew of game cancellations, but one developer believes there's an unaddressed issue at the heart of the matter.
In a post on X, Arkane Studios founder Raphaël Colantonio, who directed Dishonored and Prey before he left the studio in 2017, highlighted Xbox's subscription service Game Pass as the 'elephant in the room' following the layoffs last week.
'Why is no-one talking about the elephant in the room? Cough cough (Game Pass),' he wrote.
When asked about his thoughts on the subscription service, Colantonio added: 'I think Game Pass is an unsustainable model that has been increasingly damaging the industry for a decade, subsidised by [Microsoft's] 'infinite money', but at some point reality has to hit.
'I don't think Game Pass can co-exist with other models, they'll either kill everyone else, or give up.'
Colantonio, who has since co-founded developer WolfEye Studios, said he is 'fed up with all the BS [Xbox] fed us at first', regarding Game Pass supposedly not having any impact on normal sales, 'only to admit years later that it totally does'.
Sign up to the GameCentral newsletter for a unique take on the week in gaming, alongside the latest reviews and more. Delivered to your inbox every Saturday morning.
He added: 'It's a long game that involves throwing a tsunami at the entire ecosystem of the industry. Only the gamers like it, because the offer is too good to be true, but eventually even gamers will hate it when they realise the effects on the games.'
I think Gamepass is an unsustainable model that has been increasingly damaging the industry for a decade, subsidized by MS's 'infinite money', but at some point reality has to hit. I don't think GP can co-exist with other models, they'll either kill everyone else, or give up. — Raphael Colantonio (@rafcolantonio) July 5, 2025
Microsoft Gaming CEO Phil Spencer claimed Game Pass was profitable during an interview in 2023, but based on available evidence (Microsoft stopped sharing Game Pass subscriber numbers in 2022), spending on the service has only marginally increased over recent years – despite price increases and the addition of Call Of Duty. More Trending
While it's difficult to say whether this lack of growth is the root cause of Xbox studio closures over the past few years, Game Pass has become Xbox's key selling point in its shift towards a multiplatform publisher, so it's certainly a factor.
Microsoft has claimed in the past that Game Pass helps boost game sales, but a document which emerged during the UK Competition and Market Authority's investigation into the company's acquisition of Activision Blizzard says otherwise.
'Microsoft also submitted that its internal analysis shows a [redacted]% decline in base game sales 12 months following their addition on Game Pass,' read the CMA report from 2023.
Microsoft might be trying to avoid stating it outright, but It's clear Game Pass isn't working as well as it hoped. The big question is whether this is the sinking ship for Xbox, or something they can turn around.
Email gamecentral@metro.co.uk, leave a comment below, follow us on Twitter.
To submit Inbox letters and Reader's Features more easily, without the need to send an email, just use our Submit Stuff page here.
For more stories like this, check our Gaming page.
MORE: Games Inbox: What is the best retro video game?
MORE: Best new mobile games on iOS and Android – July 2025 round-up
MORE: As an Xbox fan all I can say is that Microsoft betrayed us – Reader's Feature
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
2 hours ago
- Metro
Switch 2 third party support fails to convince in new Nintendo Direct
The Partner Showcase for the Nintendo Switch 2 has new footage of Hyrule Warriors: Age Of Imprisonment and Octopath Traveler 0. After all the build-up and anticipation, there's no way to describe the latest Nintendo Direct other than a disappointment. It did feature some new games (one of which had leaked earlier) but nothing of any great significance, while big name titles such as Elden Ring and Final Fantasy 7 Remake went unmentioned. What's taking so long is unclear but it now seems unlikely they'll be released this year, which leaves the Switch 2's third party line-up looking relatively underwhelming. There were some major multiformat releases mentioned, including EA Sports FC 26 and a brief nod to Borderlands 4 but the rumours of Assassin's Creed Shadows came to nothing and there's still no sign of any new Xbox games, despite all Microsoft's promises to support the console. The Direct was only 25 minutes long and strangely there was no mention of the new game from Nippon Ichi, which was accidentally announced ahead of time by the publisher. So when that's going to get officially unveiled is now a mystery. Altogether, it was not a particular convincing showcase for third party support on the Switch 2 and while the new console does seem to be fairing better than the Switch 1, at least in terms of Western publishers, the lack of major support from Japanese companies is both surprising and concerning. Technically, there was three games from Square Enix but they all look like something that could've appeared on the original PlayStation. There's a good chance they'll all be good games but they're clearly quite low budget and from a technical perspective do nothing to prove the Switch 2's abilities. Sign up to the GameCentral newsletter for a unique take on the week in gaming, alongside the latest reviews and more. Delivered to your inbox every Saturday morning. Still, here's an overview of everything that was announced, although in some cases it's not entirely clear whether they are Nintendo exclusives or not. Xbox Series X/S, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch 2, and PC The showcase kicked off with a new entry in a franchise that is going to be of little interest to anyone in the West, and that's ignoring the recent collapse of interest in Monster Hunter Wilds. The Monster Hunter Stories spin-off series started as a 3DS exclusive – a relatively traditional turn-based role-playing game set in the Monster Hunter universe, with a much greater emphasis on story than the mainline entries. This new sequel is multiformat and due out next year, but with no exact release date. Nintendo Switch It's not yet clear if this new Katamari Damacy sequel is multiformat or not, but that's all that's been announced so far. Series creator Keita Takahashi has long since left Bandai Namco, but they've kept making new games anyway, despite the concept clearly not being that malleable. As the recent remasters proved, the originals are still a lot of fun and while the time travel gimmick for this new one doesn't sound like it'll add up to much the thought of online co-op and a brand new soundtrack is certainly appealing. It'll be out on October 24 but only for the original Switch, with no sign of a Switch 2 specific version. Nintendo Switch and Nintendo Switch 2 Also leaked before the Direct, and rumoured for some time now, this seems to be a Switch exclusive, although that's slightly surprising as the franchise has no special history with Nintendo formats. It's a remake of the original tower defence game from 2009 and as the trailer makes obvious (but presumably wasn't trying to) it still looks almost exactly the same, just in HD. It has new local co-op and competitive modes though, which is always good, and it'll be out on October 23. Xbox One, PlayStation 4, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X/S, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch 2, and PC Considering the two companies have never got on well before, EA is proving to be one of the biggest supporters of the Switch 2, especially in terms of Western companies. There was only a brief look at EA Sports FC 26 and NFL Madden 26, but both were implied to be on par with other formats in terms of features – although that won't necessarily be true of the Switch 1 version. FC 26 is out on September 26, with no delay for the Switch versions. Also from EA, a new Switch 2 version of Apex Legend is arriving on August 5, along with the new season of the free-to-play game. PlayStation 4, Nintendo Switch, Xbox Series X/S, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch 2, and PC Although the continued absence of Final Fantasy 7 Remake is a concern, Square Enix did up its support for the Switch 2 considerably in this Direct, with two brand new games and this remake of the PS1 tactical role-playing classic. The new version will be fully voiced, with new difficulty options and other features, even though it looks more or less the same. It's out on September 30 for all formats. This was only included on a technicality as while it's published by Nintendo in the West, and is a spin-off from The Legend Of Zelda, it is published by developer Koei Tecmo in Japan. The new footage, including what seems to be Mineru's Construct from Tears Of The Kingdom, looked fine but while the previous games were good by Dynasty Warriors spin-off standards this new one is still likely to be very shallow. It's presence in the showcase was particularly surprising because there was still no confirmation of when it'll be released, as the promise of 'winter' could easily mean January or February next year. Xbox Series X/S, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch 2, and PC Although this seems to be developer Windup Games' first title this new AA indie game looked quite intriguing. Seeming to take some cues from Pikmin, you play as the mouse familiar of a sick witch, as you gather materials to help her recover. It's described as involving a 'cosy journey', which implies it won't be terribly difficult, but the four-player co-op seems fun. It's out sometime next year. Nintendo Switch 2 More Trending So far this seems to be a Switch 2 exclusive and while it looks like another Octopath Traveler game there's no indication it has any connection to the series, beyond them both using the HD-2D graphics engine. The big difference here is that The Adventures Of Elliot is an action role-player, rather than being turn-based, which brings to mind Secret Of Mana rather than Final Fantasy. Whether it'll be quite that good remains to be seen but there's a demo out today and a co-op mode with Elliot's fairy pal. There's no release date for the full game though, just sometime next year. Nintendo Switch and Nintendo Switch 2 This also hasn't been confirmed for any other formats yet, although there's a good chance it'll be ported to them sooner or later, like the first two games. For now though, it seems to be a Switch exclusive and will be out on December 4. It's not clear exactly what's going on in terms of the story but 'restoration' appears to be a major theme, with what looks like the ability to build and upgrade your own villages. The combat still seems to be turn-based but beyond that it was hard to discern much of what was going on in the trailer. Other games mentioned in the Direct include Just Dance 2026 Edition, Dragon Ball: Sparking! Zero, Pac-Man World 2 Re-Pac, Persona 3 Reload (out on October 23), Chillin' By The Fire (out today), Star Wars Outlaws, Cronos: The New Dawn, Yakuza Kiwami 1 and 2, Goodnight Universe, NBA Bounce, Hello Kitty Island Adventure – Wheatflour Wonderland, Romancing SaGa 2: Revenge Of The Seven, Shinobi: Art of Vengeance, and Borderlands 4. Email gamecentral@ leave a comment below, follow us on Twitter. To submit Inbox letters and Reader's Features more easily, without the need to send an email, just use our Submit Stuff page here. For more stories like this, check our Gaming page.
Glasgow Times
3 hours ago
- Glasgow Times
Spotify age verification checks could see accounts deleted
New laws are now in place that are intended to protect young people on the internet, particularly on sites that have pornographic content. It means that the Online Safety Act could put users accounts at risk of being deleted if they fail to verify their age. Will Spotify require age verification? The music streaming app announced in partnership with Yoti, a digital identity company, that age verification will be carried out via facial recognition or the use of ID documents. Your Spotify account is getting deleted unless you do age verification — Calgie (@christiancalgie) July 30, 2025 Those who chose not to disclose their age via this process will have their accounts deactivated, with the option of reinstating their account within 90 days by completing the process via a link sent to their email. Spotify says: 'You may be presented with an age check when you try to access certain age restricted content, like music videos tagged 18+. Some users will be asked to perform an age check when accessing certain age restricted content. 'You can do this by going through our facial age check. If this shows inaccurate results, you can always correct that with an ID verification. 'If you cannot confirm you're old enough to use Spotify, your account will be deactivated and eventually deleted.' How do I confirm my age on Spotify? In the UK, Spotify users must be 13 or over. If the age verification checks confirm the user is under 13, they will have their account deleted. Spotify, which has a staggering 696 million users worldwide, has stressed Yoti will delete users' data once the verification process is complete. What have people said online about the new age checks? Disgruntled Spotify users took to social media to share their thoughts. One said on X: 'The time for quitting Spotify is now. Who's with me?' 'Age verification on Spotify is insane - time to leave,' another said. While a third added: 'Age verification for pornographic material is what it was sold as. 'It's turned into age verification for Spotify, Xbox…it's got nothing to do with protecting children.' Others also felt that now was the time to re-visit old iPods and CDs for music, instead of streaming apps, with one person commenting: 'Age verification on Spotify?!? Time to buy physical music again!' Does Xbox have age restrictions? Xbox have said that they are also 'investing in technologies and tools to ensure players have age-appropriate experiences on their platform', while sending notifications to UK users to verify their age. Via a statement on their website, the gaming brand said that from the beginning of next year, age verification will be required to have 'full access' to the console's social features, such as voice or text communication and game invites. Tips to Spot Fake Online Reviews Recommended Reading: Does the UK require age verification? Age verification under the Online Safety Act came into force in the UK on July 25. Since then, websites face being fined up to £18million if they do not check users are aged over 18 before letting them access potentially 'harmful' material.
The Herald Scotland
3 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Spotify age verification checks could see accounts deleted
It means that the Online Safety Act could put users accounts at risk of being deleted if they fail to verify their age. Will Spotify require age verification? The music streaming app announced in partnership with Yoti, a digital identity company, that age verification will be carried out via facial recognition or the use of ID documents. Your Spotify account is getting deleted unless you do age verification — Calgie (@christiancalgie) July 30, 2025 Those who chose not to disclose their age via this process will have their accounts deactivated, with the option of reinstating their account within 90 days by completing the process via a link sent to their email. Spotify says: 'You may be presented with an age check when you try to access certain age restricted content, like music videos tagged 18+. Some users will be asked to perform an age check when accessing certain age restricted content. 'You can do this by going through our facial age check. If this shows inaccurate results, you can always correct that with an ID verification. 'If you cannot confirm you're old enough to use Spotify, your account will be deactivated and eventually deleted.' How do I confirm my age on Spotify? In the UK, Spotify users must be 13 or over. If the age verification checks confirm the user is under 13, they will have their account deleted. Spotify, which has a staggering 696 million users worldwide, has stressed Yoti will delete users' data once the verification process is complete. What have people said online about the new age checks? Disgruntled Spotify users took to social media to share their thoughts. One said on X: 'The time for quitting Spotify is now. Who's with me?' 'Age verification on Spotify is insane - time to leave,' another said. While a third added: 'Age verification for pornographic material is what it was sold as. 'It's turned into age verification for Spotify, Xbox…it's got nothing to do with protecting children.' Others also felt that now was the time to re-visit old iPods and CDs for music, instead of streaming apps, with one person commenting: 'Age verification on Spotify?!? Time to buy physical music again!' Does Xbox have age restrictions? Xbox have said that they are also 'investing in technologies and tools to ensure players have age-appropriate experiences on their platform', while sending notifications to UK users to verify their age. Via a statement on their website, the gaming brand said that from the beginning of next year, age verification will be required to have 'full access' to the console's social features, such as voice or text communication and game invites. Tips to Spot Fake Online Reviews Recommended Reading: Does the UK require age verification? Age verification under the Online Safety Act came into force in the UK on July 25. Since then, websites face being fined up to £18million if they do not check users are aged over 18 before letting them access potentially 'harmful' material.
