Ian Murray accused of 'hypocrisy' after UK Government keeps 'damaging' post-Brexit law
Ian Murray has been accused of "hypocrisy" after the UK Government said it was keeping a post-Brexit law which he had previously said should be removed.
Labour's Scottish Secretary said in 2020 that the Internal Market Act was "bad and damaging" and undermined devolution. He also voted against it while in opposition.
The law was introduced to create a single market across the UK after Brexit. But it has since allowed UK ministers to override the Scottish Parliament.
This happened with the Deposit Return Scheme, where the Tory Government refused to exclude it from the act.
SNP MP Stephen Gethins has written to Murray asking him to "repeal and replace" the law.
The Arbroath and Broughty Ferry MP said: "The Internal Market Act has stripped powers from the Scottish Parliament and has undone the work of its principal architect, Donald Dewar.
"I am old enough to remember when Ian Murray stood against Brexit and voted down the Act which he described as damaging and that undermined the devolution settlement.
"It is complete hypocrisy that now he has his feet under the cabinet table he now backs this legislation and endorses Brexit - picking apart the powers of Scotland's parliament.
"This is yet another promise broken by the Labour Party and it is another blow to the devolution settlement - any politician from Scotland worth their salt must fight tooth and nail to see the Internal Market Act repealed."
Holyrood twice voted against the Internal Market Act. Labour MSPs backed the most recent motion to scrap it in 2023.
The UK Government published its review of the act on Tuesday.
UK trade minister Douglas Alexander promised "improvements" to the law but made clear ministers have not considered scrapping it.
He said "the review has not considered repeal of the Act or any of its provisions" because the UK Government has 'been explicit about the need for businesses to have certainty'.
The UK Government is promising changes to the law, including the introduction of exclusions to the legislation.
As well as considering economic impacts, issues of environmental protection and public health will also be looked at for exclusions – with the UK Government saying this ensures a 'balance of factors is considered'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
19 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Investors need certainty to build the homes Scotland needs
We must unlock the investment that would deliver new housing, says Colin Brown Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... In May 2024, the Scottish Parliament declared a national 'housing emergency' with some councils also declaring a housing emergency in their areas. The announcement of the emergency came two months after the Scottish Government laid the Housing (Scotland) Bill before the Scottish Parliament. The Bill continues to work its way through Holyrood and is expected to come into force later this year. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Observers in the world of institutional investment and those working in the sector have been watching the progress of the Bill with interest. Of particular concern to investors are proposals around rent controls. Colin Brown is a Partner at TLT To give one example that has occurred recently – a London-based investment firm, was about to commit many millions of pounds to its first Scottish investment before discovering that a committee considering the Bill had voted to include purpose-built student accommodation as subject to statutory rent controls. All of the financial appraisals the firm had undertaken in making the decision to invest in Scotland were potentially being ripped up by MSPs and they had no power to do anything about this. In this situation, the Scottish Government moved quickly to make clear it would not support rent control for purpose-built student accommodation. Whilst the project is now starting to come out of the ground it remains to be seen whether they consider Scotland a safe haven for future investment. The rental income which institutional investors derive from their investments in bricks and mortar helps to fund many individuals' pensions. The investors need to understand that in exchange for making their money available they will get a return on their investment and this return has generally been left to market forces – the law of supply and demand. The housing emergency should make investment in new build housing in Scotland a win-win. The country gets much-needed new housing to alleviate the emergency, and the investment funds get to deploy their capital to deliver housing and make a return on their investment. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In the UK in the first quarter of this year £1.2 billion was invested in private rental accommodation with the potential for £6bn to be invested by the end of the year. 76 per cent of this investment is being directed outside London, with Manchester, Birmingham, and Leeds leading the way. Every penny of this investment creates new housing and sustains and creates job opportunities. The fact that Scotland has not been able to open the investment tap when cities in England are seeing private rental accommodation expand, could be seen as a missed opportunity. In launching the latest consultation, the Social Justice Secretary acknowledges that rental properties are a crucial element of the efforts to tackle the housing emergency. Government policy has slowed investment into the sector in recent years and resulted in lower investor confidence in providing much-needed housing. Rent caps and controls are of course not universally despised and a balance must be struck between protecting tenants and unlocking the investment that delivers the new housing. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The latest consultation on exemptions for certain types of properties from rent control closed earlier this month. There will be investors with capital looking for a home waiting to see if the legislative and political environment in Scotland means they should be deploying more of this in Scotland or continuing to explore opportunities which guarantee a better return elsewhere.
Scotsman
19 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Swinney: New work for bus maker Alexander Dennis being explored
The First Minister said details remain commercially sensitive Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The Scottish Government is actively exploring a package which could deliver new work to the troubled Alexander Dennis bus maker, John Swinney has said. The First Minister said he could not provide further details due to 'commercial sensitivity'. He has asked the company to consider an extension to its consultation period while the package is developed. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad General view of the Alexander Dennis site at Camelon, near Falkirk | PA Last month, Alexander Dennis announced it was proposing to consolidate its UK operations at a single site in Scarborough, North Yorkshire. The decision puts 400 jobs at risk at its facility in Falkirk in another blow to the Forth Valley, which has already seen more than 400 jobs go at the Grangemouth refinery this year. Mr Swinney said: 'Scottish ministers place the utmost importance on the presence of Alexander Dennis in Scotland and the retention of its highly skilled manufacturing workers. 'The Scottish Government has committed to exploring any and all viable options throughout the consultation period to allow the firm to retain its skilled employees and manufacturing and production facilities. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'While I cannot provide details due to commercial sensitivity at this time, I hope this update provides the workforce and local community with further assurance that the Scottish Government remains wholly committed to supporting the future of bus manufacturing in Scotland. 'We will undertake this work in tandem with every other short, medium and long-term opportunity we continue to explore in close collaboration with the company, Unite, GMB, Scottish Enterprise, Transport Scotland and the UK Government.' Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes will meet with the unions GMB and Unite today to update them on the proposal. Labour previously accused Holyrood ministers of overlooking Scottish industry in favour of ordering buses from China. Mr Swinney argued state aid regulations – in the form of the UK-wide Subsidy Control Act – prevent the Government from directly procuring from a single supplier like Alexander Dennis. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Speaking to The Scotsman last month, Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said: "They [the Scottish Government] have to look themselves in the mirror. But they should be leaving no stone unturned about how we can keep this bus company open."
Scotsman
19 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Water can do a power of good in our green energy mix
Derek McCulloch says engaging public and political support is the key if we are to achieve a just transition Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Water, essential for life on this Earth, is one of our most precious resources. In the energy mix, water power has been used for thousands of years to mill grain, dye clothing, for processing in industry and since 1878, to produce hydroelectricity which is renewable, reliable and clean. Representing 14 per cent of global generation, hydropower is also an export target for Scottish and UK expertise and is a useful asset in balancing the grid. Water is a flexible resource. In 1789, the ability to separate hydrogen gas and oxygen gas from water by electrolysis was developed. However, hydrogen as an energy fuel or processing gas (for example, for ammonia) has historically been less expensive if extracted from greenhouse gases (methane) using power sourced from cheaper fossil fuels. In phasing out fossil fuels, we are now on the brink of a revolution in electrolysis, driven by renewables, splitting hydrogen from water for use as clean green power in our everyday home and industrial energy mix including transport on land and sea. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In the transition from fossil fuels, the national grid system of transmitting electricity across Great Britain must evolve to meet the significant change in locations of energy generation, and the unprecedented increase in demand for electrification of energy needs over the next 25 years. The growing reliance on intermittent green energy sources such as wind and solar, requires greater attention and resources to balance the grid's supply and demand, operating within a narrowly defined transmission frequency. Fossil fuel power stations were able to react instantly to such demands, but intermittent renewables do not have the same speed or nature of reaction, consequently driving an imperative for industrial-scale batteries to store renewable power when reacting to pricing and to critical grid demands. The Cruachan Power Station – also known as the Cruachan Dam – is a pumped-storage hydroelectric power station in Argyll and Bute with enough capacity to power almost one million homes (Picture: John Devlin) Both hydrogen and water as sources of power generation can be stored. Since the 1960s, four large systems of pumped storage hydropower have been developed to act as a form of battery, storing up power on demand when needed and is a proven technology, and more are planned. Pumped storage hydro comes at a high capital cost to build, but a relatively low cost to run as a mega battery. The published Coire Glas proposal in the Great Glen, for example, aims to offer 1.3GW of electricity at a moment's notice, an estimated equivalent of 3 million homes. These crucial assets require assistance from policies that spread high capital costs and allow funding to be serviced. Hydrogen has the flexibility to be transported, stored or piped but, without scale and dedicated infrastructure, still at relatively high costs of production, transport and storage. Positively, industries already using fossil fuel sourced hydrogen will be able to decarbonise once sufficient green hydrogen is available. Overall, hydrogen has several hurdles still to climb, including public perception, lack of infrastructure, and in developing supportive governmental policies and regulations to provide confidence in the consents process, and appetite of major consumers.
