Perth and Kinross councillor calls for urgent review of national planning policy on retail developments
The Planning and Placemaking Committee convener believes the current policy on retail developments "lacks coherence" and risks "stifling competition"
Perth and Kinross Council's (PKC) planning convener has written to the Scottish Government saying there is an "urgent need" for a review of national planning policy regarding retail.
SNP councillor Ian Massie - who wrote to Public Finance Minister Ivan McKee on behalf of PKC's Planning and Placemaking Committee - said the current policy "lacks coherence" and "will not strengthen town centre High Streets".
Cllr Massie's committee requested he write the letter after councillors approved a new Lidl supermarket on Perth's Crieff Road, going against the council officers' recommendation of refusal which was based on national policy.
On Wednesday, March 12 councillors voted by nine votes to two to grant Lidl permission to invest £10 million building a second Perth store and creating over 30 jobs.
They rejected council officers' recommendation to refuse the application, arguing the development would give residents "more choice" and supported the National Planning Framework 4's (NPF4) 20-minute neighbourhoods.
The only objector to the application was Tesco, which has a store on the other side of McDiarmid Park from the proposed Lidl site.
At the March meeting, convener Ian Massie pledged to write to Scotland's Public Finance Minister raising the committee's concerns about the conflicting national planning policy.
In response to a request from the Local Democracy Reporting Service, PKC this week shared both Cllr Massie's letter and the response he received from Ivan McKee MSP.
In his letter, Cllr Massie said the current policy could result in "stifling competition".
Referring to the committee's decision over the Lidl application, he wrote: "The officers' recommendation was for refusal on the grounds that it did not meet Policy 28: (a) and (c) as it was not located in an existing city, town or local centre, nor was it in an edge of centre area, or an allocated site within the LDP; (b) was not applicable as it did not meets the terms of (a); and also (c) Small scale neighbourhood development because the proposal could not be classed as small scale.
"Whilst the committee agreed the criteria for Policy 28 (a) and (c) had not been met they went against officers' advice and granted permission stating that the application should be supported because it would provide over 30 jobs in the local area, help families on limited income afford more with what income they have and aligns with the Scottish Government's approach to 20-minute neighbourhoods , as outlined through Policy 15 of NPF4."
He called for planning policy to meet the "specific needs of our communities". The Perth City North ward councillor added: "Currently, the framework for Policy 28 lacks coherence on several crucial aspects, including the balance between High Street regeneration, out-of-town developments, and the promotion of sustainable practices within retail. However fundamentally, there is the lack of a specific reference to what floorspace thresholds should be deemed to define what is small scale neighbourhood development. "Unless there is an early review of the retail policy of NPF4 the likelihood is that the current policy will result in the planning system in Scotland stifling competition in this sector. This will favour those operators who secured consents for out-of-town centre sites over the last 20 years to the detriment of newer and possibly more innovative operators. It will not strengthen town centre High Streets. This is not 'good planning'. "
Ivan McKee thanked Cllr Massie for his letter and said the intent of the national planning policy was "to encourage, promote and facilitate retail investment to the most sustainable locations that are most accessible by a range of sustainable transport modes".
The Minister for Public Finance said there were a "range of factors" which need to be considered in planning assessments and there were no plans to review the policy.
Mr McKee said: " There is no scheduled review of NPF4 at this time, however it is helpful to have your input on the effectiveness of NPF4 policies and I am grateful to you for sharing your thoughts and experiences with us."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
an hour ago
- STV News
Reform ‘can't win' Hamilton and SNP do not deserve to, Sarwar says
Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar said that Reform UK 'can't win' the Hamilton by-election, and the SNP does not deserve to. In an open letter to voters in the Daily Record, the party leader rejected claims that Thursday's vote will come down to the parties led by John Swinney and Nigel Farage, claiming Labour was in a 'two-horse race' with the SNP. The claim was made in a similar letter in the same newspaper this week, in which the First Minister said the race was a 'straight contest' between his party and Reform, accusing Farage of being a 'clear and present danger to our country.' 'Reform's poison won't win here,' the Scottish Labour leader wrote. 'The SNP deserve to lose.' He added: 'Don't believe the spin and the nonsense of John Swinney – this by-election is a two-horse race between Scottish Labour and the SNP.' After the June 5 vote was called following the death of Scottish Government minister Christina McKelvie in March, Labour and the SNP were the frontrunners, but Reform's surge in the Hamilton, Larkhall, and Stonehouse seats has propelled the party into the mix. Accusing the SNP leader of using Reform as a 'mask for his failure,' Sarwar criticised Farage's party's tactics. A Facebook ad from the party showing a speech given by Sarwar encouraging more people of Pakistani origin to enter politics has been roundly criticised. Sarwar said: 'Throughout this by-election campaign, Reform have tried every dirty trick in the book to drive a wedge to divide this community – but I know you will see right through it. 'They know they can't win – they don't care about beating the SNP, all they care about is getting attention. 'Nigel Farage is a poisonous, pathetic, and toxic little man who doesn't understand this community or our country. 'He and his cronies in Reform have spent thousands of pounds spreading bile, misinformation and racial slurs. 'Scotland is my home. I was born here.' The Scottish Labour leader also touted his party's candidate Davy Russell, who has himself been criticised for a perceived lack of appearances in the media. Russell, he said, is the only candidate in the race who can 'beat the SNP'. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The Sun
an hour ago
- The Sun
Lidl is selling a £14.99 garden toy perfect for keeping kids entertained as temperatures heat up this weekend
LIDL is selling garden slide for £14.99 and it's perfect for keeping kids entertained as temperatures soar this weekend. The Playtive Shark Arch Water Slide is currently available to buy in stores. The toy comes with a sprinkler arch that can spray water from a connected garden hose. The inflatable garden slide also comes with a bodyboard with 2 handles for your little one. The product is part of the bargain stores "Middle of Lidl" offers, which land in stores every Thursday and Sunday. The items are usually sold at a low price and only available while stocks last. Lidl's garden toy costs £14.99 or £19.99 if you do not have membership. Lidl Plus is a free loyalty app that offers discounts on food, drinks, and household items from Lidl. The slide could be a perfect way to keep children entertained as temperatures heat up this weekend or even over the summer holidays. It is important to compare prices to ensure you are not missing out on the best deal. B&Q is selling a similar water slide for £20, while Argos has also slashed the price of its Double Slide Racer from £16 to £12. But if you are keen to shop Lidl's deal you will need to do so in person as the store does not do online delivery. 40 Day Health Challenger shares healthy weekly Lidl shop You can find your nearest Lidl by vising And it is not the only bargain on the discounter shelves. Shoppers have been going wild for the stores dupe for the pricey Sol De Janeiro spray. Costing just £3.99, the Lidl copy of Sol de Janeiro is scented with pistachio and salted caramel. Another version is scented with jasmine and dragon fruit. Shoppers have also raved about its £10.99 Whispering Angel dupe. How can I save money when shopping at Lidl? Lidl reduces items at the start of the day, and the best deals can be found between 7am and 8am, when most stores open. Shoppers can often find cooked meats, salmon fillets and breads reduced by 30% or more. Not only does Lidl have its own range of reasonably priced alcohol, it also has its own knock-offs of branded favourites – so say cheers to its bargain booze. Everyone knows about the "Middle of Lidl" – it's here where you'll find a load of random stuff you didn't realise you needed, at decent prices. But if you are hoping to avoid spending more than you planned, you can check what will be in the "Middle of Lidl" on the supermarket's website in advance. The Middle of Lidl is refreshed every Thursday and Sunday. Shoppers can also keep tabs on what's appearing in the "Pick of the Week" section on the Lidl website. The discounts happen every Thursday and are usually on fruit, vegetables, and meat. How to bag a bargain SUN Savers Editor Lana Clements explains how to find a cut-price item and bag a bargain… Sign up to loyalty schemes of the brands that you regularly shop with. Big names regularly offer discounts or special lower prices for members, among other perks. Sales are when you can pick up a real steal. Retailers usually have periodic promotions that tie into payday at the end of the month or Bank Holiday weekends, so keep a lookout and shop when these deals are on. Sign up to mailing lists and you'll also be first to know of special offers. It can be worth following retailers on social media too. When buying online, always do a search for money off codes or vouchers that you can use and are just two sites that round up promotions by retailer. Scanner apps are useful to have on your phone. app has a scanner that you can use to compare prices on branded items when out shopping. Bargain hunters can also use B&M's scanner in the app to find discounts in-store before staff have marked them out. And always check if you can get cashback before paying which in effect means you'll get some of your money back or a discount on the item.
The Herald Scotland
2 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
How PSG got rid of the GOAT and became Champions League contenders
When Rothen claimed the presence of Messi, Neymar and Kylian Mbappe at the Parc des Princes was preventing the Ligue 1 champions from fulfilling their vast potential in Europe, many fans asked if he had drunk one too many glasses of Chateauneuf-du-Pape. However, somebody at Qatar Sports Investments, who had turned PSG into one of the wealthiest clubs in the world game when they had bought a majority shareholding in them in 2011, was clearly paying attention to the one-time Scottish title winner. Read more: There has been a definite shift away from the superstar-centric strategy since. Messi, Neymar and Mbappe, who had cost in excess of €400m, have all been allowed to depart. There has been a move towards a more collective mindset. The change has worked wonders. Paris Saint-Germain are, having swatted aside Manchester City, Liverpool, Aston Villa and Arsenal in Europe this year, favourites to beat Inter Milan in the Champions League final in the Allianz Arena in Munich tonight and win the competition for the first time. Rothen, who has covered Les Parisiens' exploits on the continent for RMC Sport in France this term and who will be cheering on his boyhood heroes this evening along with millions of others around the globe, has been proved emphatically correct in his assessment. 'Managing Messi, Neymar and Mbappe was complicated,' he said ahead of the eagerly anticipated encounter between Luis Enrique's team and Simone Inzaghi's side. 'They also had to pay huge sums to cover their salaries, which were very high. I thought it was a bad idea to renew their deals. 'Messi in particular made no attempt to engage with the club or with the fans when he was here. It looked like he was only interested in his image rights. He never waved to the fans or acknowledged their backing. I thought it was best for him to go. The money they have saved since he has gone has allowed them to improve the squad.' (Image: Nick Potts) Enrique, the former Barcelona, Real Madrid and Spain midfielder and Roma, Celta Vigo, Barcelona and Spain manager who took over from Christophe Galtier in the summer of 2023, has transformed PSG from show ponies into work horses during his two year tenure. His charges have run for 117.94 kilometres on average in every game in the Champions League this season, far more than any other side in the competition. In addition, they have completed more passes, created more scoring chances and had more shots on goal than any other team. They have been nothing short of relentless in the past five months. John McGinn, the Scotland midfielder and Villa captain, was helpless to prevent his Premier League outfit from slumping to a 5-4 aggregate defeat against them in their last eight double header last month. However, he claimed that he and his team mates could be satisfied of how they acquitted themselves against opponents he rated highly following the final whistle. 'We should be proud that we turned the game around against one of the best teams in the world and fought to the very end,' he said. 'PSG are the best team I've ever played against. I definitely wouldn't want to face them every week.' Enrique, whose team recorded just one win during their first five Champions League league phase games and at one stage looked set to miss out on qualification for the knockout rounds, has made important tactical changes as well as an inspired signing. He moved Ousmane Dembele from the right wing to striker, deployed Vitinha as a holding midfielder and gave right-back Achraf Hakimi the freedom to move upfield and infield. Read more: On top of that, he landed Khvicha Kvaratskhelia from Napoli for €60m in January. The wide man has established himself as a regular starter alongside Dembele, Desire Doue and Bradley Barcola in his front three. Enrique's insistence that PSG attack together and defend together – something which did not happen when Messi, Mbappe and Neymar formed the forward line – has impressed Rothen. 'Everything has gone well this year,' he said. 'There are no problems with the team, no problems behind the scenes, no problems in the media. That is unheard of at PSG. They have won a lot in previous years, but there was never the same atmosphere. 'It hasn't been perfect. They switched off against Aston Villa after scoring two early goals and allowed their opponents to come back into the game. They fell asleep. But they have been a blessing in disguise because they will know now they can't afford that sort of slackness. But everything has gone well for the club. All of the planets are aligned.' Inter, who beat Barcelona 4-3 after extra-time in the second leg of the semi-final in the San Siro last month to complete a remarkable 7-6 aggregate triumph, can certainly be crowned European champions for a fourth time in Germany this evening. They, too, have an abundance of talent in every area of the pitch. But if Paris Saint-Germain scale the heights they are capable of they should prevail and make history.
