
Julio Ribeiro: Two books that reflect life In Mumbai
Zende's book Mumbai's Most Wanted reflects the more important investigations entrusted to him in the course of his career. The very first account was of how he brought to book the man who in 1980 murdered a college professor, Shanta Devi, when she was travelling alone in a First Class women-only compartment of a Mumbai local train. Two years after the murder, in 1982, Zende solved the case. The culprit was a petty criminal who operated on trains.
I happened to be the Deputy Inspector General of Police, Railways, when this murder was reported. It created a sensation because the victim was a middle-class South Indian woman. When such an incident occurs, citizens from the same economic bracket as the victim get alarmed.
The case kept me occupied for a month or two till I was transferred to Thane as its first police commissioner in early 1981. Even after I demitted office in the Railways. I kept thinking of this murder as it had remained unsolved. It was only after I was installed as Mumbai police commissioner in February 1982 and Zende was entrusted with this unsolved case by his seniors in the Crime Branch that success was finally achieved.
Zende describes in detail how he solved the case through a combination of persistence, observation, information from petty criminals operating on local trains and, of course, a big dollop of luck. It was only after reading Zende's book that I learnt details of the investigation conducted by his unit.
Zende's book reiterated why the City's Crime Branch is held in esteem by citizens. The skills that have raised the Mumbai Police to a national or even international level are because of its Crime Branch and officers like Madhukar Zende.
Two other officers named by the author come to mind. Arvind Patwardhan and Madhav Gupte fall in this category of extraordinary officers who have contributed a great deal to building the good name of the Mumbai Police. These were officers to whom success in their endeavours and self-esteem mattered above all else.
In a new book, the former ACP of Mumbai Police recalls how he arrested serial killer Charles Sobhraj https://t.co/nonHPQenjC
An excerpt from 'Mumbai's Most Wanted: The Thrilling Case Files of a Supercop', by Madhukar Zende.
— Scroll.in (@scroll_in) May 21, 2025
As commissioner, I was justly proud of having such officers under my command. What is truly worrying is the recent fall in standards following a drop in leadership qualities.
An aspect of Zende's character and mental make-up attracted me tremendously. He believed in service to the people. In pursuit of this principle, he kept contact with citizens in the localities entrusted to him. It served him during times of civil unrest.
In one instance in 1992, when he was assistant commissioner of Police, Pydhonie division, a hostile crowd had surrounded a police vehicle with injured policemen and kept them captive. Zende approached the crowd alone, without other officers accompanying him. Since the people knew him and trusted him, they allowed the vehicle to leave the troubled area without any force being used by the police. Bloodshed had been avoided.
The fact that Zende harboured not an iota of communal bias was known by the people of the area. That really helped.
Those who are addicted to police-related stories and even those who are only marginally interested will like Madhukar Zende's Most Wanted. For young police officers it is a must read. They will appreciate the importance of credibility, earned through integrity, fairness in dealings and justice.
Another book that caught my attention was The Fault with Reality by Anil Kumar Singh. Singh was a young journalist with The Times of India when we first met in the late eighties. What distinguished him from many others in his profession was his persistent curiosity and uncompromising integrity which has guided him throughout his career.
Singh is an authority on the city of my birth. He has spent the better part of his life in Mumbai, where I was born 96 years ago. But his knowledge of happenings and trends in different spheres of development and governance certainly exceeds mine by a distance. There are a few references to police in his book. But he delves also on the city's vanishing trees, pavements and the quality of its roads, encroachment on wetlands which leads to flooding during heavy rains.
Anil Singh's collection of his articles is a veritable judgment on the quality of governance by successive governments and touches on a long list of woes experienced by its residents. I am one such resident whose attention has been drawn to some aspects of civic life that I had not noted carefully previously. For example, the threats the city will face if mangroves and open spaces are utilised for unbridled housing construction as is happening presently.
Singh has named some Indian Police Service officers with a public conscience. A notable omission in his list is of D Sivanandhan who undoubtedly was one of the best the service can boast of. After his retirement he continues to do public service – in his case by setting up Roti Bank, which feeds tens of thousands of poor and hungry children and some needy adults every single day.
The Public Concern for Governance Trust, an NGO founded by the former cabinet secretary BG Deshmukh, leading city pediatrician Dr RK Anand and I send its interns to study how Roti Bank functions. The young students return inspired. Sivanandhan is presently the Chairman of the trust.
It is not because of having been mentioned honourably by this perceptive journalist that I recommend concerned citizens of my city to read The Fault With Reality. They should read it to educate themselves on how well or how shoddily this city is governed.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


News18
3 hours ago
- News18
Tanushree Dutta Makes SHOCKING Allegations, Claims 'Bollywood Mafia Threat Like Sushant Singh Rajput'
Tanushree Dutta shared a video alleging years of harassment at home, claiming a conspiracy by the "Bollywood mafia gang." Tanushree Dutta stunned social media on Tuesday after she shared a disturbing video, alleging that she has been facing harassment inside her own home for years. In an exclusive interview with News18 India, the actress opened up about it for the first time. Just like Sushant Singh Rajput, there are attempts being made to kill me," Tanushree said, warning of a larger conspiracy involving what she describes as the 'Bollywood mafia gang." She went on to say, 'I urge the government to provide me with security. This mafia is huge and dangerous, and I fear for my life just like Sushant must have." Tanushree first made headlines in 2018 when she reignited her allegations of sexual harassment against veteran actor Nana Patekar, becoming one of the earliest voices in India's MeToo movement. She now claims that ever since then, she has been facing 'suspicious activity" around her. 'I've been followed constantly. I've been harassed. A maid was planted in my house to spy on me," she alleged. The actress also revealed that she intends to approach the police regarding recent incidents. 'I will file a complaint tomorrow at the police station," she said. 'I request the authorities not to treat this as a continuation of my previous case but to look at this with a fresh perspective and help me get justice." However, she clarified that she does not wish to reopen her older MeToo case. 'I'm not trying to reopen the old case. I only want action on the new incidents that are endangering my safety," she added. 'Ever since I spoke up against Nana Patekar, I've been followed wherever I go. My career has been destroyed," she concluded. As of now, there has been no official response from the Mumbai Police or any Bollywood figures regarding her claims. First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


NDTV
4 hours ago
- NDTV
Tanushree Dutta To NDTV: "No Scope Of Justice In Maharashtra, Molesters Hobnob With Politicians"
Actor Tanushree Dutta, who was at the forefront of India's #MeToo movement, has claimed that she is being stalked, harassed, and psychologically targeted for years, and has not received any help from authorities. On late Tuesday night, the former Miss India Universe posted a disturbing video of her crying on Instagram, alleging that she has been "harassed at my own home" for the past five years, so much so that her "health has deteriorated". Tanushree Dutta told NDTV in an exclusive interaction that she has been facing relentless harassment and intimidation over the past few years, both in public and private spaces, and has been left disillusioned with the system meant to protect her. Speaking in the wake of her distressing Instagram video she posted, the actor claimed to have noticed a pattern of incidents that she said have taken a toll on her mental and physical health. "My experience with the Mumbai Police during the 2018 MeToo movement left a very bitter taste in my mouth," she told NDTV. "They encouraged me to file an FIR back then. I spent four to five hours at the station, gave a detailed statement, and kept following up and nothing came of it. In Maharashtra, these molesters and harassers are often hobnobbing with politicians. They're protected. So, there's no real scope of justice." Tanushree Dutta, known for films such as Aashiq Banaya Aapne, Chocolate, Bhagam Bhag, and Dhol, also alleged that her ordeal hasn't stopped since. She said she suspects that even hotel staff and insiders may have been complicit in stalking and intimidation during her travels. "Whenever I raised the issue at hotels during my pilgrimages, I was either stonewalled or met with excuses. I didn't want drama. I had gone to pray, meditate, and heal. But the incidents followed me everywhere." She claimed food deliveries would arrive tampered with, groceries would be misplaced or opened, packages would be meddled with and there seemed to be a deliberate attempt to destabilise her. "It's psychological warfare," she says. "They're trying to scare me. And it's been happening since I came back from one trip so unwell that I was diagnosed with Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, triggered by prolonged stress and anxiety." According to Tanushree Dutta, in multiple cities, at different hotels, someone would use a spare key to enter her room. "Whether I was in the room or not, they'd come in, move small things, steal just enough to make me notice. They wanted me to know I wasn't safe even in what should be a private, protected space." Now, she said, the pattern has reached her Mumbai home. "People bang on my door at odd hours. They've left foul-smelling substances outside. I've reported it to my building society many times. Yesterday, when it happened again and no one responded to my calls I broke down. I called the police. They came, spoke to the watchman, but it was all vague, everyone blaming each other. They asked me to visit the Oshiwara Police Station and speak to a senior officer. I said I will but only if they are willing to act. I won't waste more years chasing justice that never comes." Tanushree Dutta's 2018 allegations against veteran actor Nana Patekar helped spark the #MeToo movement in Bollywood. The actor has been away from the world of films since the 2010 movie Apartment, but has kept fans and followers updated about her life through her Instagram page. The latest series of alleged revelations made by the actor, however, indicate that the aftermath of that decision and the fight for accountability is far from over.


Indian Express
5 hours ago
- Indian Express
Miscreants go on rampage in Pune's Dhankawadi, vandalise 25 vehicles, including school vans
A group of miscreants allegedly vandalised at least 25 vehicles, including school vans, in the Dhankawadi area of Pune in the early hours of Wednesday. The local police and the Crime Branch have launched a coordinated search for the suspects. The alleged vandalism occurred at three locations—Keshav Complex, Sarasvati Chowk, and Navnath Nagar—between 1 am and 1.30 am, according to the Sahakar Nagar police. Initial investigations suggest at least three suspects on bikes caused the damage, primarily shattering the glass windows with the weapons they were carrying, said a police officer, adding that they targeted locations within 500 metres of each other. The police said the damaged vehicles included 15 auto rickshaws, three cars, two school vans, a tempo and some bikes. 'We have obtained the CCTV footage from the area and will soon nab the suspects,' said Vitthal Pawar, Senior Inspector of the Sahakar Nagar police station. This incident is part of a concerning rise in vehicle vandalism in Pune, with the number of cases increasing from 35 in 2022 to 53 in 2023 and then to 89 in 2024. This had prompted the Crime Branch to conduct a thorough analysis of these cases based on data. One of the first results of the study was identification of key hotspots for the cases of vehicle vandalism. The police found that of the 89 cases reported in 2024, the majority came from Sahakar Nagar, Parvati, Yerawada, Hadapsar, Kondhwa and Wanawadi police jurisdictions. Of the 156 accused identified in 89 cases of 2024, 52 were minors, accounting for a third of the total perpetrators, the police said. The police also found that 95 per cent of these minors had no criminal records before the vehicle vandalism cases for which they were booked. Further, of all other adult accused, only 25 per cent had prior criminal records. The authorities initiated a series of policing and sensitisation efforts in these areas in response to the study's findings. The police also intensified action against these miscreants under the Maharashtra Prevention of Dangerous Activities of Slumlords, Bootleggers, Drug Offenders and Dangerous Persons Act, 1981, also known as the MPDA or Goonda Act.