Decorated Australian soldier loses war crimes defamation appeal
One of Australia's most decorated soldiers has lost a legal bid to overturn bombshell court findings that implicated him in war crimes while serving in Afghanistan.
In 2018, newspapers unearthed allegations that former SAS commando Ben Roberts-Smith took part in the murder of unarmed Afghan prisoners.
His multi-million dollar bid to sue three Australian newspapers for defamation failed in 2023, with a judge ruling the bulk of the journalists' claims were "substantially true".
The 46-year-old suffered another setback when Australia's Federal Court dismissed his appeal.
Justice Nye Perram withheld the reasons for the decision, saying there were national security implications the government must consider before they are released.
A published summary said there was sufficient evidence to support findings Mr Roberts-Smith had "murdered four Afghan men".
Mr Roberts-Smith said he would now fight to clear his name in Australia's High Court - his last avenue of legal appeal.
"I continue to maintain my innocence and deny these egregious spiteful allegations," he told local media in a statement.
"We will immediately seek to challenge this judgment in the High Court of Australia."
Mr Roberts-Smith argued in his appeal that the judge "erred" in the way he assessed some of the evidence.
Perth-born Roberts-Smith had been Australia's most famous and distinguished living soldier.
Decorated soldier
He won the Victoria Cross - Australia's highest military honour - for "conspicuous gallantry" in Afghanistan while on the hunt for a senior Taliban commander.
In a series of reports, The Age, The Sydney Morning Herald and The Canberra Times reported that he took part in the murder of unarmed Afghan prisoners in 2018.
The papers reported Mr Roberts-Smith had kicked an unarmed Afghan civilian off a cliff and ordered subordinates to shoot him.
He was also said to have taken part in the machine-gunning of a man with a prosthetic leg, which was later brought back to an army bar and used as a drinking vessel.
The 2023 court ruling ultimately implicated Mr Roberts-Smith in the murder of four unarmed Afghan prisoners.
Civil court matters such as defamation have a lower standard of proof than criminal trials.
Mr Roberts-Smith has not faced criminal charges.
Australia deployed 39,000 troops to Afghanistan over two decades as part of US and NATO-led operations against the Taliban and other militant groups.
A 2020 military investigation found special forces personnel "unlawfully killed" 39 Afghan civilians and prisoners, revealing allegations of summary executions, body count competitions and torture by Australian forces.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
At least 12 people shot dead by Israeli soldiers near Gaza aid hubs, health officials say
Israeli fire killed at least 12 people and wounded others as they headed towards two aid distribution points in the Gaza Strip run by an Israeli and US-backed group, Palestinian health officials and witnesses said on Sunday.
The Journal
8 hours ago
- The Journal
Colombian presidential contender has successful surgery after assassination attempt
A PROMINENT COLOMBIAN right-wing presidential candidate who was shot during a campaign event in Bogota has successfully undergone initial surgery, the city's mayor said Sunday. Thirty-nine-year-old Senator Miguel Uribe was speaking to supporters in the capital when a gunman shot him twice in the head and once in the knee before being detained. A security guard managed to detain the suspected attacker, a minor who is believed to be 15-years-old. Uribe was airlifted to hospital in 'critical condition' and underwent a 'neurosurgical' and 'peripheral vascular procedure,' the Santa Fe Clinic in Bogota confirmed. He 'overcame the first surgical procedure,' Mayor Carlos Fernando Galan told media, adding that he had entered 'the critical hours' of recovery. Uribe's wife, in an audio recording shared with media, said 'he came out well from the surgery.' 'He fought the first battle and fought it well. He is fighting for his life,' she is heard saying. Images from the scene of the shooting showed Uribe slumped against the hood of a white car, smeared with blood, as a group of men tried to hold him and stop the bleeding. The suspect was injured in the affray and was receiving treatment, said police director Carlos Fernando Triana. Two others – a man and a woman – were also wounded, and a Glock-style firearm was seized. 'Our hearts are broken, Colombia hurts,' Carolina Gomez, a 41-year-old businesswoman, told news organisation AFP as she lit candles and prayed for Uribe's health. People hold flags of Colombia as they march to the clinic where Colombian Senator Miguel Uribe Turbay is being treated after an assassination attempt. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo 'Day of pain' A large investigative team is working on determining the motive for the attack, Defense Minister Pedro Sanchez said Sunday. Earlier he had offered a roughly US $725,000 reward (around €635,000) for information about who was behind the shooting. Advertisement Leftist President Gustavo Petro condemned the violence as 'an attack not only against his person, but also against democracy, freedom of thought, and the legitimate exercise of politics in Colombia.' The shooting was similarly condemned across the political spectrum and from overseas, with US Secretary of State Marco Rubio calling it 'a direct threat to democracy.' But Rubio also pointed blame at Petro, claiming the attack was the 'result of the violent leftist rhetoric coming from the highest levels of the Colombian government.' 'President Petro needs to dial back the inflammatory rhetoric and protect Colombian officials,' the top US diplomat said. Venezuela, which has a longstanding border conflict with Colombia, also denounced the shooting, with the foreign ministry saying: 'Venezuela strongly condemns the attack' on the senator. Uribe, a strong critic of Petro, is a member of the Democratic Center party, which announced last October his intention to run in the 2026 presidential election. Authorities said there was no specific threat made against the politician before the incident. The country is home to several armed guerrilla groups and powerful cartels, and has a long history of political violence. Opposition Senator Miguel Uribe, right. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo Shot 'from behind' Uribe is the son of Diana Turbay, a famed Colombian journalist who was killed after being kidnapped by Pablo Escobar's Medellin Cartel. One of his grandfathers was president Julio Cesar Turbay, who led the country from 1978 to 1982. Supporters gathered outside the Bogota hospital, lighting candles and clutching crucifixes as they prayed for Uribe's recovery. The leader of Uribe's party, former president Alvaro Uribe – who is not related to Miguel – described the shooting as an attack against 'a hope for the country.' Miguel Uribe has been a senator since 2022. He previously served as Bogota's government secretary and city councilor. He also ran for city mayor in 2019, but lost that election.
RTÉ News
19 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Colombian presidential candidate shot and wounded
A prominent Colombian right-wing presidential candidate was shot and gravely wounded during a campaign event in Bogota yesterday, authorities said. Senator Miguel Uribe, 39, was speaking to supporters in the west of the capital when a gunman shot him twice in the head and once in the knee before being detained. Images from the scene showed Mr Uribe slumped against the hood of a white car as a group of men tried to hold him and stop the bleeding. A security guard managed to detain the suspected attacker, a minor who is believed to be 15 years old. Police director Carlos Fernando Triana said the suspect was injured in the affray and was receiving treatment. Two others - a man and a woman - were also wounded, and a Glock-style firearm was seized. The motive for the attack is not yet publicly known, and Colombia's minister of defense vowed that the military, police and intelligence services would deploy "all their capabilities" to find out what happened. The minister, Pedro Sanchez, also announced a roughly US$725,000 reward for information about who was behind the shooting. The attack was condemned across the political spectrum and from overseas, with US Secretary of State Marco Rubio calling it "a direct threat to democracy". Mr Rubio pointed blame at Colombia's leftist president Gustavo Petro, claiming the attack was the "result of the violent leftist rhetoric coming from the highest levels of the Colombian government". "President Petro needs to dial back the inflammatory rhetoric and protect Colombian officials," the top US diplomat said. Mr Petro "categorically and forcefully" condemned the attack. "This act of violence is an attack not only against his person, but also against democracy, freedom of thought, and the legitimate exercise of politics in Colombia," the presidency said in the statement. Mr Petro was due to address the nation late yesterday evening. Mr Uribe, a strong critic of Mr Petro, is a member of the Democratic Center party, who announced last October his intention to run in the 2026 presidential election. Authorities said that there was no specific threat made against the politician before the incident. Like many public figures in Colombia, Mr Uribe had close personal protection. The country is home to several armed guerrilla groups, powerful cartels and has a long history of political violence. Mr Uribe is the son of Diana Turbay, a famed Colombian journalist who was killed after being kidnapped by Pablo Escobar's Medellin Cartel. One of his grandfathers was former Colombia president Julio Cesar Turbay, who led the country from 1978 to 1982. Shot 'from behind' Mr Uribe was airlifted to Santa Fe Clinic where he was said to be receiving intensive care. Supports gathered outside the facility, lighting candles and clutching crucifixes as they prayed for his recovery. Mr Uribe's party said in a statement yesterday that an "armed individual" had shot the senator from behind. The party leader, Colombia's influential former president Alvaro Uribe, described the shooting as an attack against "a hope for the country". Miguel Uribe himself has been a senator since 2022. He previously served as Bogota's government secretary and city councilor.
