Criminals Next Door: South Africa raises alarm over United States deportees housed in eSwatini
Image: Jairus Mmutle/GCIS
The South African government has raised 'deep concern' following the recent arrival of convicted criminals deported from the United States in the neighbouring Kingdom of eSwatini.
'South Africa is deeply concerned about the profile of these individuals and the potential adverse impact on South Africa's national security and immigration policy, given the geographical proximity between the two sisterly countries,' said Chrispin Phiri, spokesperson for Minister of International Relations, Ronald Lamola.
Phiri said South Africa has raised concerns with the Kingdom of Eswatini following confirmation by the acting spokesperson of the government, Thabile Mdluli, that the group of dangerous criminals of various nationalities landed in eSwatini.
The United States sent five men it describes as 'barbaric' criminals to the neighbouring Kingdom of eSwatini.
Image: X
The convicted criminals were transported from the United States of America on a special flight, with the potential of more criminals of similar profiles scheduled to follow.
Their arrival was also followed by an announcement from the United States' Department of Homeland Security indicating that this group of individuals from several countries, and some of whom have been convicted of serious crimes, have been deported to eSwatini.
'Dirco, on behalf of the government of the Republic of South Africa, noted the aforementioned statement wherein Eswatini and the USA indicated that they would collaborate with the International Organisation for Migration (IOM) to facilitate the transit of these inmates to their countries of origin,' said Phiri.
The Department of International Relations and Cooperation (Dirso) also noted that the countries of origin of these deportees are unlikely to receive them.
'Whilst respecting the sovereign decision of the government of eSwatini, the government of the Republic of South Africa is deeply concerned about the profile of these individuals and the potential adverse impact on South Africa's national security and immigration policy, given the geographical proximity between the two sisterly countries,' said Phiri.
Last week, IOL reported that seasoned Eswatini human rights lawyer Sibusiso Nhlabatsi has launched a High Court bid to gain access to five "dangerous" convicted criminals deported to the African nation from the United States.
Nhlabatsi is challenging the prison authorities' refusal to allow him to meet and consult with the detained men. According to media reports, the deported men intend to challenge their presence in eSwatini.
IOL previously reported that the deportation of the five hardened criminals, a decision by US President Donald Trump's administration, reportedly took Eswatini citizens and activists by surprise and shock.
Speaking to IOL on Friday, Nhlabatsi said his commentary is limited because the matter is before the courts.
'However, the core of my application is to ask the court to grant me an order to access the deportees. I have been given specific instructions by three US-based attorneys who were representing them back home, and the purpose of my visit is simply to fulfill those instructions,' said Nhlabatsi.
'Last Friday, the prison authorities denied me access, citing that they were still working on facilities or gadgets that would allow the deportees to call home.'
Seasoned eSwatini human rights lawyer Sibusiso Nhlabatsi spoke to IOL on his fight to access the criminals deported from United States.
Image: Supplied
Nhlabatsi argued that the actions of the eSwatini authorities were unlawful.
'In my view, this is unlawful because it denies them legal access and representation which is constitutionally guaranteed,' he said.
IOL reported last week that the move has also sparked outrage in the small landlocked nation, and fears abound that the criminals may end up in South Africa.
The Trump administration announced over a week ago that it would be sending the men who are illegal immigrants from Vietnam, Jamaica, Laos, Yemen and Cuba convicted of child rape, murder, burglary, and being gang members and whose countries refuse to take them back.
Speaking to IOL previously, Bheki Makhubu, editor of the monthly news magazine The Nation, said people of eSwatini feel betrayed.
'Essentially, emaSwati feel they were betrayed by the leadership of eSwatini. This move came as a complete surprise and seems to have been arranged and known by only a select few people. This deal feels like an invasion of our country by the US. We feel our leaders have sold our country to Trump behind our backs,' he said.
'This country is nobody's personal property and therefore we're upset and most importantly, afraid. There's a fear that if this is allowed to continue, and it looks like more prisoners are coming, one day we will wake up and find that we've been annexed by another country behind our backs.'
Makhubu added that he understood that the dangerous criminals are set to spend only a year in eSwatini.
jonisayi.maromo@iol.co.za
IOL News Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
17 minutes ago
- IOL News
POLL: Should Minister Gayton McKenzie resign over the K-word controversy?
Amid growing calls for Sports Minister Gayton McKenzie to resign from his Cabinet position after a series of racist tweets where he used the k-word in the past, the Patriotic Alliance leader has said he will not resign. The likes of celebrated media personality Sizwe Dhlomo and the Economic Freedom Fighters, are among those who have called for McKenzie to step down over the controversy wherein a series of k-word calling tweets, most at least 10 years old, were uncovered. McKenzie had vocally came out in defence of the Coloured community when a group of young young Black African podcasters from the Open Chats Podcast made vile, regressive and racist comments about the Coloured community recently. They have since apologized, but they too are now subject of a formal complaint to the Human Rights Commission, while McKenzie's political party, the Patriotic Alliance, formally opened criminal cases with the SA Police Services through its Joburg councillor Liam Jacobs. McKenzie has been vocal in speaking out against the racist comments made by the podcasters, saying they needed to be taught a lesson, but in so doing, he hosted a Facebook Live wherein he repeatedly made use of the K-word. This led some social media users to turn the attention on the minister, unveiling a series of equally denegrating and racist comments from McKenzie, who at the time was not a politician, but an ordinary South African. In an attempt to address the K-word comments, the minister hosted another Facebook Live session speaking to his Patriotic Alliance constituency on Sunday evening. He apologized for being a troll and stupid, cringed at the remarks he had made and apologized on that aspect, however, he vehemently denied he was a racist, saying his mother was Black African and he also had children with a Black African woman. McKenzie firmly denied ever calling anyone by the K-word slur and dared any victim to come forward, labeling the allegations a politically driven 'campaign' orchestrated by the EFF and social media influencers. He also accused the ActionSA of using the saga to get its foot in the Government of National Unity at the expense of the PA. McKenzie challenged critics to produce concrete proof, arguing that without a specific victim or direct quote, claims of racism against him were baseless. McKenzie also reiterated his lifelong fight for equal treatment of Black African and Coloured South Africans, calling any suggestion to the contrary 'hilarious.'
The South African
2 hours ago
- The South African
Major dagga bust, arrest highlights zero tolerance for SA's dealers
This zero-tolerance policy was evidenced by a major dagga bust in Fisantekraal, Western Cape over the weekend. On Saturday, 9 August, Metro Police officers arrested a suspect after seizing more than four kilograms of dagga (marijuana) from a private residence. Officers acted on a tip-off and were granted permission to search the premises, where they discovered a black bag containing 3.39 kilograms of dagga, a 221-gram parcel, 92 'bankies,' 93 dagga cigarettes, and an undisclosed amount of cash. The homeowner was arrested on charges of dealing in dagga. This arrest was part of a broader crackdown: the City of Cape Town's enforcement services made 241 arrests and issued over 62 000 fines for traffic and by-law violations in the past week alone. Metro Police accounted for 42 of those arrests and issued 2 129 fines. 'The devastating impact of drugs on our communities continues long after we've taken the dealers off the streets,' said Mayco Member for Safety and Security, Alderman JP Smith. 'Not only are families destroyed, but drugs fuel many other crimes and illicit dealings.' During the search, a black bag containing 3.39 kilograms of dagga was seized. Image: CoCT South Africa's cannabis laws have evolved significantly since the Constitutional Court's landmark 2018 ruling, which legalised the private use and cultivation of cannabis for adults. The Cannabis for Private Purposes Act, passed in 2024, formalised this right – allowing individuals to possess and consume cannabis in a personal capacity. However, selling, buying, or distributing cannabis remains illegal. Earlier this year, The South African reported on a beloved nursery in Cape Town that was selling cannabis plants to the public. This story highlighted a 'loophole' in the legislation, as the Act does not explicitly ban the sale of cannabis seeds or seedlings. Medicinal marijuana meanwhile was legalised in South Africa in 2017. To that end, the nursery's offering addressed a range of ailments. In March the South African government did a quick U-turn on banning the sale, importation and manufacture of food products containing hemp and cannabis. Local laws claim to draw a firm line between personal use and commercial activity. Anyone caught dealing – especially with large quantities or packaged products – faces criminal charges, fines, and potential imprisonment. This latest bust is a reminder that while private use is protected, authorities maintain a zero tolerance approach to cannabis dealing, viewing it as a gateway to broader criminal networks and social harm. 'Despite arrests, the suspects are often back on the street a few days later, to continue their criminal dealings,' Smith added. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
Mail & Guardian
2 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
Africa-Japan: Reflections on Tokyo International Conference on African Development
Japan went through a process of transforming from a country with a weak agricultural base to the success that it is today. Photo: File The Japanese have a saying: 'Shippai wa seiko no haha.' It translates as 'Failure is the mother of success.' In other words, never give up! Next week, African leaders will assemble in Japan for the 9th Tokyo International Conference on African Development (TICAD) — 32 years after its birth. This is therefore a good time to reflect on how the political and economic experience of The most essential lesson Africa can learn from Japan is political, because what Africa needs most today is peace and stability, which can only be achieved in the political realm. It is important to note that, unfortunately, Africa's level of conflict was the Conflict resolution In my judgment, politics in Japan has at least four interrelated dimensions. First, there is the widespread perception that politics is not a zero-sum game. The best way to achieve a compromise is to ensure that today's political loser can be tomorrow's winner. This eliminates the need to resort to any means necessary to usurp power or cling to it until forcibly removed. The unwritten rule of politics in much of Africa today seems to be different — one loses a political contest, often a violent and sometimes bloody contest, then that marks the end of that person's political career, or even of his life. In such a contest, one, therefore, has two choices: either to win and exterminate his opponent or to lose and be exterminated. As the Kenyan scholar Ali Mazrui once put it: 'In many African countries, presidential power is a zero-sum game. Either one is head of state or a figure of fun and derision, if not vulnerable to imprisonment or death. This state of affairs encourages some heads of state to cling to power indefinitely. They have everything to lose by giving up the state house.' The second dimension of politics in Japan pertains to the phenomenon of political recycling, the idea that politicians, especially those holding higher offices, should expect to be called back to service after their term of office ends. The premise is that the old order need not be wiped clean by a new order. The net effect of this approach in Japan has been to institutionalise a positive-sum game of politics, foster the desire among political contestants not only to be good losers but also gracious winners and, above all, to induce the desire to cooperate. In Africa, it is fair to say that political recycling is almost unknown. Third, there is, in Japan, the idea of the victor without the vanquished. I was a young graduate student from Africa in Japan in the 1990s. In that decade, the country changed its prime ministers nine times, needless to say, always peacefully. Both the winner and the loser could continue to co-exist. It is not a coincidence that Japan today has 11 former prime ministers, who are aging gracefully, some of whom, possibly, may also be waiting in the wings for another call to service. And finally, there is the notion that an effective politician is one who can successfully make a compromise in the face of conflicting positions. The origin of this win-win approach can be traced back to the Meiji period and beyond. In 1877, a regional lord named Saigo Takamori rose against the Meiji reformers in a rebellion that ultimately claimed thousands of Japanese lives. The rebellion itself grew out of the disaffection of those whose influence was declining as a result of the reform. After the conflict ended, Takamori came to be described by the victorious reformers as a 'misguided patriot' and, years later, was officially elevated to the position of a 'national hero'. The reformers did not doubt the genuineness of Takamori's concerns for the welfare of his fellow Japanese, even though his vision of how it was to be achieved differed from theirs. A statute was subsequently erected in Takamori's name, which stands to this day in Tokyo's Ueno Park. In a sense, Takamori may be more remembered in Japan today than the Meiji reformers themselves. He was also the inspiration behind the 2003 popular American film, The Last Samurai . Serious political disagreements do arise in contemporary Japan, too, but they never lead to mutual annihilation. The Japanese have learned how to flexibly accommodate each other and change their positions when circumstances dictate. Africa, too, could perhaps take a leaf out of Japan's book. Sustained economic development On balance, Japan's experience in economic modernisation reveals that it successfully pursued three strategies: diversification, domestication and indigenisation. First, Japan's Meiji reformers proclaimed in 1868 that 'knowledge shall be sought throughout the world', and absorbed Western skills and adopted Western institutions from as many and diverse sources as possible. The second strategy was what the Japanese economic anthropologist Keiji Maegawa called translative adaptation, the making of foreign products, institutions and ideas more relevant or more useful to local needs. It is worth noting that the Japanese were less concerned about whether what was modified had or did not have a close resemblance to the original. Third, Japan pursued indigenisation, the fuller use of its human and material resources. This process also entailed the use and idealisation of what was indigenous. Japan's modernisers never sought to transform their culture radically. Instead, they successfully indigenised modernity. In each of the above areas, Africa's experience was decidedly different. In general, why does Africa appear to be a less efficient learner? We can refer to a scene from Mazrui's The Africans, the internationally acclaimed documentary, to illustrate this point. Holding in his hand a crude homemade gun that the liberation fighters in East Africa had used in the 1950s, Mazrui says in This issue takes us to another matter Africa has to come to grips with. Technological self-reliance Let us consider Mazrui's comment above in connection with the observation made by the American historian, George Basalla. It was about what happened in the 16th century when Portuguese adventurers brought to Japan two handguns made in Europe. At the time, guns were unknown in Japan. Basalla wrote: 'The Japanese were so impressed by these primitive firearms that they purchased them on the spot and set their swordsmiths to work duplicating them. Within a decade, gunsmiths all over Japan were turning out firearms in quantity.' Far from Japan, the Portuguese also took the same objects, guns, to another place in almost the same period, and introduced them to another group of people in Africa. The new weapon also had a similar practical appeal to the Africans as the Japanese. The idea of making guns spread rapidly in one society (Japan), as indicated above. In the other, however, the idea did not gain any traction. For the succeeding centuries, in the latter, the spear continued to play its traditional role in warfare. The place in question is 16th-century Ethiopia, at the time a Northeast African Christian kingdom in the Northern part of present-day Ethiopia. Even long before Mazrui and Bassalla, the prominent Meiji-era intellectual Yukichi Fukuzawa wrote in 1899: 'It was not until 1853 that a steamship was seen for the first time [in Japan]; it was only in 1855 that we began to study navigation from the Dutch in Nagasaki; by 1860, the science was sufficiently understood to enable us to sail a ship across to the Pacific. This means that about seven years after the first sight of a steamship, after only about five years of practice, the Japanese people made a trans-Pacific crossing without help from foreign experts.' What, then, explains the difference? Why did Africa and Japan react to contacts with the West so differently? The answer to this question is complex, for sure. But it would have also to include the divergence in the way the challenges of modernisation were perceived in the two societies, as urgent and stark in one case and less so in the other. In the case of Meiji Japan, the need to catch up with the West was framed in existential terms — as a matter of survival of the nation. With the persistent threat from the major powers of the time, and with the country open to seeing and interacting with the external world, Japan realised that it was lagging behind these powers in some areas and that it must catch up with them if it was to safeguard its national security. At this crucial moment in history, the belief that national improvement was achievable through determined effort also became widely and firmly accepted in Japan. In Africa's case, the question of catching up with the West, as vital as it was, was never framed in this way, as a matter of 'do or die'. It was probably not a coincidence that Ethiopia, under Emperor Tewodros in the 19th century, should be the only African country to seek Western weapon technology, though unsuccessfully, as it was seen as essential for the country's survival. All in all, there is a key takeaway from a comparative examination of the political and economic experience of Meiji Japan and postcolonial Africa. Japan can offer valuable lessons to Africa on what to learn, how to learn and how to learn quickly. And, why to never give up. Dr Seifudein Adem is a research fellow at JICA Ogata Research Institute for Peace and Development in Tokyo, Japan.
