St Stephen's Green Shopping Centre Dome saved as planning permission for €100m redevelopment refused
This follows An Coimisiún Pleanála (ACP) refusing planning permission to contentious plans for the €100m redevelopment of St Stephen's Green Shopping Centre in Dublin.
Advertisement
The refusal by ACP overturns a grant of permission made to DTDL Ltd issued by Dublin City Council in December 2023.
The largest component of the new scheme was to be office use providing for 35,043 sq metres of offices and ancillary spaces and the applicants increased the level of retail and Food & Beverage space after the Council expressed concerns.
In its refusal, ACP concluded that the scheme "lacks a strong sense of original aesthetic and would not achieve a sufficiently high standard of placemaking, urban design and architecture at this key city centre location".
As a result, ACP has concluded that the scheme would be contrary to a number of policies in the area of High Quality Architecture, Architectural Design and Brownfield, Regeneration Sites and Large Scale Development of the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028.
Advertisement
ACP states that these policies 'aim to encourage innovative, high quality urban design and architectural detail in all new development proposals, that positively contribute to the city's built and natural environment and incorporate exemplar standards of high-quality, sustainable and inclusive urban design and architecture befitting the city's environment and heritage'.
ACP concluded that the proposed development would, therefore, be contrary to the proper planning and sustainable development of the area.
The board of ACP upheld a recommendation by its own inspector in the case to refuse planning permission.
However, in its order, the board of ACP included a note that it did not share the view expressed by the inspector that the existing shopping centre represents an exemplar twentieth century building.
Advertisement
Opening the door for a new application in the future, ACP concluded that the replacement of the existing façade, including the existing external trellis detailing and dome, would not contravene the Dublin City Development Plan 2022-2028, subject to an appropriately high quality design solution for this key city centre location.
The appeal came before ACP following three third party appeals by An Taisce, former Environment Editor at The Irish Times, Frank McDonald and St Stephen's Green Shopping Centre trader, Emmett Rogers.
In his appeal, Mr Rogers told the appeals board that if the redevelopment proceeds 'I see Dublin losing another bit of its unique identity to developers'.
Mr Rogers has been operating the Tribe outlet at the St Stephen's Green shopping centre since 1992.
Advertisement
In the appeal, Mr Rogers stated that he was 'horrified' that the Council had granted planning permission to the mixed use scheme.
The An Taisce appeal, jointly signed off by Dublin City Planning Officer, Kevin Duff and Heritage Officer, Ian Lumley, stated that the predominantly large office development 'lacks architectural sensitivity towards St Stephen's Green and results in the loss of an impressive naturally lit space'.
In his appeal, Frank McDonald told the appeals board that what is proposed to replace the existing St Stephen's Green shopping centre 'is simply not good enough and does not qualify as a building of 'exceptional design and outstanding architectural quality'.
In recommending a grant of permission, a 51 page City Council planner's report concluded that "the proposed reductions to the scale and massing of the building significantly reduces the visual impact on this sensitive environment'.
Advertisement
The planner's report acknowledged that the existing shopping centre is a local landmark but this was not due to the quality of its architecture and stated that the shopping centre is not a Protected Structure.
An architectural design statement drawn up by architects for the ambitious plan, BKD architects stated that since opening in 1988, the St St Stephen's Green Shopping Centre has faced many difficulties in attracting sustainable retailers.
The report stated that these include that most unit sizes are too small and the smaller shop units particularly those at the upper levels trade poorly and can operate only on short term leases.
Planning consultants for the scheme, John Spain & Associates told the Council that the existing building "has become outdated" and the proposal seeks to enhance a high quality shopping centre and office facility on a centrally located site.
Plans were first lodged in January 2023 and Mr Spain argued that the proposal represents a significant rejuvenation of a key site at the gateway to Dublin's south retail core.
The report stated that the St Stephen's Green Shopping Centre 'is currently underperforming in its retail function and the proposal through the provision of medium sized units, which are currently in demand by higher order retailers, has the potential to significantly improve the retail offering in the area.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Notorious Kinahan drug cartel introduces McDonald's-style franchise system to flood the streets of Ireland with cocaine
Ireland's notorious Kinahan drugs cartel has introduced a fast-food-style franchise system in its efforts to continue dominating the cocaine trade. The drugs syndicate has muscled its way back to being the dominant force in the Irish cocaine scene in recent months, reasserting itself as the main supplier to almost all major criminal organisations across the country again. Such is their stranglehold on the trade, that many of the gangs who filled some of the holes left by the mobsters when they fled to Dubai in the mid-2010s to exploit the lack of extradition agreement between the UAE and the EU, are also now back on board. Representatives from narcotics networks in Dublin and beyond are believed to have travelled to Dubai to meet high-ranking members of the Kinahan cartel to arrange future shipments directly from them. Those said to have travelled to the Middle East are a Clondalkin gang known as 'The Family' as well as another group who operate from Cabra, who have long been involved in major drug trafficking operations, according to The Times. It is reported that this power play by the Kinahans will now see them operate like a franchise, flooding cocaine to gangs through the streets of Ireland akin to how fast-food suppliers deliver produce to stores in an attempt to eliminate competition. The move may explain the recent decrease in gangland feuds and murders across Ireland, with the street price of the Class A drug also remaining at a stable level after a sharp increase last year. The Kinahan's new network structure is believed to be a repeat - or is at least similar - to how the cartel up bulked itself up during its original network before a series of global law enforcement operations targeted its leadership. Drugs kingpin Thomas 'Bomber' Kavanagh, who ran the UK arm of the Kinahan catrel, is one of the major players to be brought down in recent times. He was jailed for 21 years at Ipswich Crown Court in March 2022 after pleading guilty to conspiring to import class A and B drugs and money laundering offences in July 2020. Fearing the same fate, the cartel's leader Christy 'Dapper Don' Kinahan, 68, and his two sons Daniel, 48, and Christopher Jr, 44, have already devised a contingency plan should the gardai attempt to extradite them from their base in Dubai. The Irish government signed two treaties with UAE representatives which allowed them to extradite suspected organised crime accomplices last October - a move which now has the Kinahans on red alert. Security sources also told The Times that 'Dapper Don' now travels with a bodyguard when in public, such is his paranoia about being snared. Author Mark Galeotti, an expert on multi-country crime, told the publication that the cartel's move to seemingly become a drugs conglomerate made sense - for them. The three are said to have already devised a contingency plan should the gardai attempt to extradite them from their base in Dubai He said: 'If you've got all the architecture, the pipeline, the infrastructure in order to move the drugs and you know where the markets are, why would you abandon that? Isn't it better to trade that out to others who are going to be your proxies in effect?' The Kinahan's global clients are said to include Mexican cartels, Hezbollah and Iran's intelligence services. It is believed that the gang have assets worth around $1.5billion hidden in offshore accounts and in hidden international investments. The cartel was previously headed-up by Liam Byrne, who relocated to Dubai when Garda drug teams began closing in. He was arrested in June 2023 while holidaying in Mallorca and was later extradited to the UK. Byrne, a close friend of 'Dapper Don', was convicted of firearms offences by Britain's National Crime Agency and was released on licence in January. In April 2022, the US Department of State placed up to $5million in rewards for information that leads to each of the arrests and prosecution of 'Dapper Don' and his two sons, branding them the heads of a major international drugs cartel.
BBC News
10 hours ago
- BBC News
Donegal man who swapped job seeking for jet-set life shearing sheep
What makes a dream job? The chance to travel the world? A workplace in the great outdoors as opposed to a stuffy office? Honing a skill to a competition-worthy level?Sounds pretty good – which is why County Donegal man Aaron Magee has no regrets for swapping his pharmaceutical degree to become a globetrotting sheep shearer for he relishes life on the road – from Ireland to Scotland, to the mountains of Europe, the pastures of New Zealand and the Australian outback – with his shearing ability providing a reliable source of income from across the world every year."You could shear a sheep every day of the year if you wanted to, and chase the seasons," he said. It's an unusual career move and one that fewer and fewer people are making - but it was driven by left the University of Limerick with a degree in Pharmaceutical and Industrial Chemistry during the Covid-19 pandemic and struggled to find a he had a skill to fall back on having been taught the trade by his father on the family farm in Raphoe, County Donegal. And a new career path said it was "the lifestyle of the shearing that attracted it to me" even if he admits he didn't think he'd still be shearing five years later."I'm only 26 and I've been shearing in Liechtenstein, I never even knew that was a country until I saw Ireland playing them in football."It's the traveling for me and meeting people." And when Aaron wants a break from the grind of shearing flocks, he usually takes "a holiday" attending and entering competitions in both hemispheres, including the Balmoral Show, the Royal Highland Show and Clonmany Show. It's not all globetrotting and going for gold, of course."It's work hard, play hard," says Aaron."Shearing's quite social too. But, obviously, then there's days when a farmer could have 300 or 400 sheep and you just have to put the head down."Your back gets sore some nights but you go through the rough days and look forward to the handy days." How much does sheep shearing pay? And then there's the travel.A typical shearing circuit for Aaron could see him in Northern Ireland and the Republic in May to June; then Scotland for the rest of the summer before heading to Norway from September to November - a country he visits so regularly he now says he's "fairly fluent" in the then that he'll get on a plane for Australia and New Zealand, in time for the southern hemisphere summer, and stay there until February, before spending March and April in the likes of Norway, Switzerland and Austria. That's a lot of air miles - and cost, which Aaron said has increased since he decided to chase the sheep shearing seasons across the while the industry may not offer the same financial security as a job in the pharmaceutical industry, there's still money to be made. "We get paid by the sheep, the more sheep you can do the more you get paid."In Ireland, if you're getting €2 per sheep, it doesn't sound like a lot - but if you can do 200-300 a day you can make great money each day." Aaron believes the Covid lockdown and Brexit travel arrangements have inadvertently helped him build contacts and pick up shearing work across Europe at the expense of his shearing colleagues from the UK."It's gave us more job opportunities…definitely the visa thing has been a bit of a struggle for them guys." Hip pain, hernias and life on the road Still, while travelling is a perk, a career on the road - and the physical demands of sheep shearing - has taken its toll."I'm not sure how many years I have left shearing full-time, I'll have to see how my body holds up."I started probably a little bit young at fourteen. I had a hernia operation last year and my hips give me a little bit of bother. I'm lucky my backs strong as an ox."The physical toll is partly why not a lot of people make the same career choice Aaron Harkness-Bones, from the Ulster Wool Depot, which collects wool from farmers and sells it on their behalf, told BBC News NI that "each year fewer and fewer people are making a real go of it"."Your family needs to support your decision," she added. Aaron said he's "just taking every day as it comes" with the shearing, but in the meantime, he plans to skip his return trip to Norway and head straight back to New Zealand as soon as possible."The World Championships is on next March and I'd like to try to be down and get a bit of practise and see how we get on in that competition."Long-term, he'd like to settle in New Zealand but keep the hills of Donegal not too far in the horizon."I'd love to keep coming home and doing a little bit in Ireland and Scotland during the summer months."It may be tough work but, for now, Aaron's sticking with his career philosophy: have shears, will travel.
BBC News
16 hours ago
- BBC News
Claire's was glitz 'heaven' for kids before Shein and TikTok came along
For Beth Searby, a Saturday as a teenager wasn't complete without going to Claire's with her that tweenage rite of passage looks uncertain as the future of the chain hangs in the and her friends would use their pocket money in the late noughties to buy magnetic earrings, badges and toe rings from the accessories brand."You never went home empty-handed," says Beth, now 30. Shopping there was like an "analogue Temu," she says."You could go in with your bits of change that you had left from buying your McDonald's or your Burger King and you could pick up a pair of earrings or a necklace or a badge to put on your school bag and you'd be spending 50p, £1, £2." Claire's has appointed administrators in the UK and Ireland after battling with falling sales and high competition. It said its 278 shops in the UK and 28 in Ireland would continue trading while it considered "the best possible path forward", but it's stopped online a US brand, Claire's opened its first UK store in the mid-90s and quickly became a mainstay among tweens who flocked there for affordable hair ties, glittery butterfly clips, matching friendship necklaces and lip gloss. "It was the ultimate shop for young people," says Ella Clancy, 29. She remembers using her pocket money to buy earrings, scrunchies and Lip Smacker lip balms from Claire's as a teenager. Particularly memorable are the so-called "nerd glasses" she and her friends got there - glasses with chunky, dark frames and no shops were always "super pink and colourful and girly," she says."When you're a little girl, it's sort of like heaven," says Vianne Tinsley-Gardener, 23. She would go to the Claire's stores in Braintree, Essex, to buy keyrings, earrings and shops were full of "unique little knick-knacks", she lucky dips bags - where you didn't know what you were getting - and multibuy offers like its five items for £10 deal turned shopping there into a treasure hunt and catered to tweens' was a staple for young people getting their ears pierced, too - and it often had special deals. But many Claire's shoppers found that some point during their time at secondary school, the brand just stopped being cool. They turned to places like Accessorize, Topshop and Primark was the case for Ceara Silvano, 23. She remembers it became too "kiddish" when she was about 13 and she started shopping at Primark instead."You do just grow out of stuff like that," Ceara says - though she still returned later to have her ears pierced at Claire's. Al Thomann loved Claire's when they were younger because of its use of bright colours, glitter and floral designs. But as they grew up, they too started to see the brand as "childish" and stopped shopping there."You start to feel like you're a young adult, and all around me, most of the adults were not shopping at Claire's," Al, now 25, says. "Aspiring to be an adult meant rejecting that sort of childlike, colourful, rainbow, unicorn whimsy." How young people shop is changing Back in the 2000s and 2010s, young people bought things because they liked them, rather than because they were trendy, says Constance Richardson, who owns the personal styling business By Constance thanks to rising use of social media, young people are keeping up-to-date with what's stylish online."Shein can spot a trend on TikTok and have that live within days, often for much less money" than Claire's, says Georgia Wright, a reporter at Retail a Chinese online fast-fashion giant, sells a huge range of items including clothes, accessories and stationery for low prices. Claire's, in comparison, doesn't pounce on trends as quickly, Ms Wright it can't compete on price, Miss Richardson says. "They're still selling novelty products at a non-novelty price." Another factor is that young people are often influenced by creators on social media who are much older than them - and don't shop at Claire's."Kids are growing up faster than ever," says Ms Wright. "You've got 11 year olds with five-step skincare routines."At the other end of the spectrum to Shein, they're turning to more premium brands like Sephora, Space NK and Astrid and Miyu, she "just doesn't deliver the same excitement," Ms Wright says. But the brand still holds a special place in many people's says she feels nostalgic about shopping at Claire's and wishes she'd kept some items as mementoes. Whenever Ella walks past Claire's stores, "it brings a little smile to my face".And some people say they still enjoy shopping at the brand. "As I started university and started thinking about my own sexuality and gender identity and how I wanted to present myself, the sort of items that Claire's sold once again came back into my field of knowledge," Al says. "All of the really beautiful, very unique earrings and necklaces, bracelets, flower crowns, those kinds of things, were almost instruments to display my own identity in a way that was visible."
