MPs condemn Montreal Pride organizers for barring Jewish LGBTQ+ group from parade
In a joint letter, the MPs said they were 'deeply troubled' by the move to bar Ga'ava from Sunday's march. They said the decision goes against the values of inclusion and solidarity Pride is meant to uphold.
'Ga'ava, Canada's oldest Jewish LGBTQ+ organization, has long provided a vital space for queer Jews to express both their sexual and religious identities with pride,' they wrote. 'Its exclusion from this year's parade is especially troubling, as it sends a message that Jewish identity is not welcome in LGBTQ+ spaces.'
The letter was signed by Liberal MPs Anthony Housefather, Leslie Church, Alexandra Mendès, Annie Koutrakis and Sherry Romanado.
It also criticized the exclusion of CIJA, the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs, calling it the representative body for Canada's mainstream Jewish communities.
'By excluding this organization, Montreal Pride is effectively telling the vast majority of Montreal's Jewish community, which has been an important part of this city for almost 300 years, that it is no longer welcome at Pride,' the MPs wrote. 'This is entirely unacceptable.'
Accusations of 'hate speech'
Fierté Montréal confirmed Thursday that Ga'ava had been barred from the parade after a complaint was made about the group. The decision was taken by the event's ombudsperson, according to board secretary Marlot Marleau.
Carlos Godoy, president of Ga'ava, said the group was informed Wednesday it would not be allowed to march. He said in an interview organizers accused the group of using 'hate speech' by describing opponents of their participation as 'pro-terror' and 'pro-Hamas.'
'I've never heard such an outlandish and ludicrous statement in my professional life,' Godoy told The Gazette.
A CIJA representative said the organization was also barred, though Fierté declined to confirm that publicly.
The controversy follows Quebec singer-songwriter Safia Nolin's withdrawal from a Pride performance in protest of Ga'ava's planned inclusion. Nolin criticized the group's support for Israel and said the presence of Israeli flags at the event would be 'unacceptable.'
Wider political context
It also comes just as Prime Minister Mark Carney announced Canada's intention to recognize a Palestinian state under certain conditions — the third G7 country to signal sit would do so — citing Israel's military action in Gaza that has killed 'tens of thousands.'
The war in Gaza began after Hamas launched a deadly attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, killing about 1,200 people and taking hundreds hostage.
Marleau told The Gazette that Fierté Montréal has adopted the terminology of several human rights groups in describing Israel's actions as 'genocide.'
The MPs are calling for a meeting with Pride organizers and for both Ga'ava and CIJA to be reinstated in this year's parade.
With files from The Gazette's Jack Wilson
This story was originally published August 1, 2025 at 8:03 PM.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Calgary Herald
3 hours ago
- Calgary Herald
Tens of thousands march on Sydney Harbour Bridge to support Gaza
Article content (Bloomberg) — Tens of thousands of people participated in a rare march across Sydney's iconic Harbour Bridge on Sunday in support of Gaza, calling on the Australian government to increase pressure on Israel to alleviate the humanitarian crisis. Article content The march began at 1 p.m. local time as demonstrators crossed the 1.1 kilometer (0.7 mile) bridge and back again, raising concerns among authorities of a crowd crush. While the police estimated a crowd of 90,000, organizers said the number may have been more than three times higher. Article content Article content Article content 'We've sent an enormous message to the world,' the Palestine Action Group said in a post on Instagram. 'Today the people spoke, and they said stop starving kids to death! Stop massacring people desperately seeking food!' Article content Article content It's a rarity that the famous landmark — a major arterial road connecting Sydney's central business district to the city's north — is closed, and traffic diverted, for a rally. In 2023, it was blocked for seven hours when an estimated 50,000 people marched in support of equality for the LGBTIQ+ community. In 2000, some 250,000 people marched over the bridge in support of Indigenous reconciliation. Article content Despite heavy rainfall that has caused flooding elsewhere in the state, orderly protesters dressed for wet weather and carried Palestinian flags, banners and signs as they swarmed the bridge. Wikileaks founder Julian Assange, former foreign minister Bob Carr, ex-Socceroos captain Craig Foster and Greens senator Mehreen Faruqi were among those in attendance. Article content Article content The United Nations World Food Program has warned for weeks that Gaza's population of more than 2 million people faces crisis levels of food insecurity, with scores of aid groups reporting widespread starvation. Israel blocked all aid from entering the enclave for 11 weeks from March 2 to May 21. Article content Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has repeatedly said there is no starvation or policy to deprive people of food in Gaza. He has blamed Hamas for stealing and blocking the distribution of aid, as well as the UN for failing to distribute it. Article content Photos of emaciated children in Gaza that have been circulating in recent weeks have prompted some world leaders to ratchet up pressure on Israel to alleviate the humanitarian crisis. Pressure has been mounting on Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese to follow in the recent footsteps of France, the UK and Canada, whose leaders have announced or signaled plans to recognize a Palestinian state in September.
Winnipeg Free Press
3 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Israel minister who led prayers at a controversial holy site has a record of provocative actions
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israel's far-right national security minister led prayers on Sunday at Jerusalem's most sensitive holy site, drawing international condemnation and escalating tensions as Israel faces strong criticism over the war in Gaza. Itamar Ben-Gvir has frequently visited the contested Jerusalem hilltop compound during the war in Gaza. Jews revere the site as the Temple Mount, where the biblical temples once stood. It is the holiest site in Judaism. Today, it is home to the Al Aqsa Mosque, the third-holiest site in Islam. Tensions at the compound have frequently spilled over into violence over the years. It was the latest act of defiance by the 49-year-old ultranationalist settler leader who transformed himself over the decades from an outlaw and provocateur into one of Israel's most influential politicians. Here is a closer look at Ben-Gvir: Why was the visit considered a provocation? Since Israel captured the site in 1967, Jews have been allowed to visit but not pray there. Palestinians consider the mosque a national symbol and view visits by Jewish leaders as provocative and as a potential precursor to Israel seizing control over the compound. Most rabbis forbid Jews from praying on the site, but there has been a growing movement in recent years of Jews who support worship there. Ben-Gvir has long called for greater Jewish access to the holy site. Ben-Gvir was visiting to mark the Jewish holiday of Tisha B'Av, a day of mourning and repentance when Jews reflect on the destruction of the First and Second Temples, key events in Jewish history. Visits like Ben-Gvir's are legal. Israeli media said the visit was the first time that a sitting minister actively and vocally led prayers. Ben-Gvir also called for Israel to conquer and declare sovereignty over all of the Gaza Strip and encourage 'voluntary' migration from Gaza in order to end the war and bring the hostages back. Palestinians say the migration plan is a disguise for forced expulsions. In response to Ben-Gvir's visit, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the status quo at the site had not changed and would not change to allow Jewish prayer. Run-ins with the law Ben-Gvir has been convicted eight times for offenses that include racism and supporting a terrorist organization. The army banned him from compulsory military service when he was a teen, deeming his views too extreme. Ben-Gvir gained notoriety in his youth as a follower of the late radical rabbi Meir Kahane. He first became a national figure when he broke a hood ornament off then-Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin's car in 1995. 'We got to his car, and we'll get to him too,' he said, just weeks before Rabin was assassinated by a Jewish extremist opposed to his peace efforts with the Palestinians. Two years later, Ben-Gvir took responsibility for orchestrating a campaign of protests, including death threats, that forced Irish singer Sinead O'Connor to cancel a concert for peace in Jerusalem. Moving to the mainstream The political rise of Ben-Gvir was the culmination of years of efforts by the media-savvy lawmaker to gain legitimacy. But it also reflected a rightward shift in the Israeli electorate that brought his religious, ultranationalist ideology into the mainstream and diminished hopes for Palestinian independence. Ben-Gvir is trained as a lawyer and gained recognition as a successful defense attorney for extremist Jews accused of violence against Palestinians. With a quick wit and cheerful demeanor, the outspoken Ben-Gvir also became a popular fixture in the media, paving his way to enter politics. He was first elected to parliament in 2021. Ben-Gvir has called for deporting his political opponents. In an episode in 2022, he brandished a pistol and encouraged police to open fire on Palestinian stone-throwers in a tense Jerusalem neighborhood. In his Cabinet post, Ben-Gvir oversaw the country's police force. He used his influence to encourage Netanyahu to press ahead with the war in Gaza and recently boasted that he had blocked past efforts to reach a ceasefire. As national security minister, he has encouraged police to take a tough line against anti-government protesters. Controversial minister Ben-Gvir secured his Cabinet post after 2022 elections that put Netanyahu and his far-right partners, including Ben-Gvir's Jewish Power party, into power. 'Over the last year I've been on a mission to save Israel,' Ben-Gvir told reporters before that election. 'Millions of citizens are waiting for a real right-wing government. The time has come to give them one.' Ben-Gvir has been a magnet of controversy throughout his tenure — encouraging the mass distribution of handguns to Jewish citizens, backing Netanyahu's contentious attempt to overhaul the country's legal system and frequently lashing out at U.S. leaders for perceived slights against Israel. Sundays Kevin Rollason's Sunday newsletter honouring and remembering lives well-lived in Manitoba. Resignation and return to Netanyahu's cabinet Ben-Gvir temporarily resigned from Prime Minister Netanyahu's cabinet earlier this year to express his disapproval of the Gaza ceasefire deal. The ceasefire ran from Jan. 19 to March 1. Hamas released 25 Israeli hostages and the bodies of eight others in return for nearly 1,800 Palestinian prisoners, including senior militants serving life sentences for deadly attacks. Israeli forces pulled back to a buffer zone, hundreds of thousands of Palestinians returned to what remained of their homes, and there was a surge of humanitarian aid. Ben-Gvir's resignation did not stop the ceasefire, but it did weaken Netanyahu's governing coalition. Ben-Gvir rejoined the cabinet when Israel ended the ceasefire and returned to active combat in Gaza in March 2025. Last week, the Netherlands banned Ben-Gvir and far-right Finance Minister Betzalel Smotrich from entering the country. Britain, Australia, Canada, New Zealand and Norway imposed financial sanctions on the two men last month.
Canada News.Net
4 hours ago
- Canada News.Net
Targeting the last lifeline': Israel strikes Red Crescent compound
The International Red Cross's affiliated Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS) has accused Israeli forces of deliberately targeting its headquarters in Khan Younis in a nighttime attack on Saturday, violating international humanitarian law. In an official statement shared on X, the PRCS reported heavy shelling of its compound. Three separate strikes all but destroyed the Red Crescent buildings, killed one worker, and wounded two others. The strikes triggered a widespread fire in the compound. A civilian who was helping extinguish the fire was wounded as well when Israeli forces struck again, for the third time. "The repeated strikes during evacuation and rescue operations clearly demonstrate that the shelling was deliberate and systematic," the PRCS statement said. "Despite being clearly marked with the internationally recognized Red Crescent emblem, the building was deliberately tageted by Israeli forces," the statement reaffirmed. The society not only blamed the Israeli military for the attack, but the world for its silence over what is going on in Gaza. "PRCS holds the international community fully responsible for its continued silence in the face of ongoing violations targeting its personnel, facilitirs, and ambulances, despite the emblem's clear proitection under law," the PRCS statement said. The Red Crescent worker killed on Saturday night, named as Omar Isleem, was the 51st staff member or volunteer killed since the Israeli attacks began on 7 October 2023, following the Hamas-led attacks in Israel on that day. The International Federation of Red Cross (IFRC) condemned the attack on its Red Crescent headquarters. "I am outraged and devastated by the horrific news from Gaza," IFRC President Kate Forbes said Sunday in a statement. IFRC Secretary General, Jagan Chapagain, said: "I am horrified and appalled by news of this attack. I cannot stress enough that humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected. It's a moral and legal imperative." For almost two years, the PRCS has been providing ambulance services and critical healthcare under relentless and extremely dangerous conditions in Gaza, caring for the many wounded amidst continuous hostilities. With the healthcare system on the brink of collapse and medical resources nearly depleted, PRCS teams remain a lifeline for civilians in desperate need of life-saving support. Any attack on their facilities or personnel is an attack on humanitarian assistance itself, the IFRC statement said. This incident is a stark reminder of the dire and unacceptable conditions facing humanitarian workers and civilians in Gaza, the statement added. Saturday night's attack coincides with intensified Israeli operations in Gaza and follows the UN's warning of "full-blown famine" in the enclave. Human rights groups accuse Israel of using starvation as a weapon of war—a charge Israel denies. Historical Parallel: "Cast Thy Bread" and the Policy of Starvation The current humanitarian crisis in Gaza has drawn comparisons to lesser-documented atrocities during the 1948 Nakba, including Operation Cast Thy Bread. Declassified Israeli archives reveal that biological warfare units poisoned water wells in Palestinian villages and bread supplies in Gaza, sickening thousands to force mass displacement. Historians like Benny Morris (The Birth of the Palestinian Refugee Problem) and research by Haaretz (2013) confirm these acts, though they remain excluded from mainstream Israeli narratives.
