Windfarm campaign calls for planning inquiry on Skye
These developments, said Andrew Robinson, a spokesperson for Skye Windfarm Information Group, said could 'massively change Skye's landscape and cause untold damage both to the local environment, and to tourism, the island's key industry".
'The Scottish Government,' he said, 'have the power to initiate planning inquiry commissions. These are when you look at a big, strategic plan. Three times we've written to Gillian Martin, the energy minister, to say that we think on Skye because of its unique nature they should have a planning inquiry commission to look at what it's appropriate to build here. But they refused that. They just said that the existing planning process is enough.'
Skye, one of Scotland's top tourist destinations, currently has two windfarms, but there are a further eight at various stages of planning and scoping. These include Edinbane, Ben Aketil, Glen Ullinish, Glen Ullinish II, Ben Sca, Balmeanach and Breakish.
One of these applications, for an extension at Ben Aketil, in which nine turbine will be removed and substituted with 200m high replacements, is now at the desk of the Scottish Government reporter following an objection by the Highland Council, and will be the subject of a local public inquiry on the island this week.
Scottish Windfarm Information Group campaigners (Image: Vicky Allan)
In a previous letter to the Scottish Government, Robinson said: 'There is an urgent need to take a strategic look at all of the plans proposed for Skye. At present residents are overwhelmed by the individual planning applications they face, and may wish to object to.
'The paperwork for each application is huge. Communities are expected to comment and respond to each application yet we have no resources. The developers, usually funded by overseas private equity companies, have access to consultants, PR and marketing experts and endless legal and planning advice.
'The proposed plans will be overwhelming. They can not be justified on basis of need as Scotland stands to more than meet its renewable energy targets if the current consented wind farms across the country are built. The plans will cause untold destruction to Skye's fragile and beautiful habitat.'
Read more:
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'Ministerial powers to refer certain planning questions to a Planning Inquiry Commission apply to cases where there are considerations of national or regional importance and a proper evaluation of them cannot be made unless there is a special inquiry for the purpose; and that the technical or scientific aspects of the proposed development are of so unfamiliar a character as to jeopardise a proper determination of that question unless there is a special inquiry for the purpose.
'There are however existing and well-established consenting procedures for renewable and grid infrastructure, including for the consideration of any cumulative impacts arising. Therefore, we have no plans to constitute a Planning Inquiry Commission.
'The Scottish Government has an ambition, as set out in our Onshore Wind Policy Statement, for 20GW of Onshore Wind by 2030 and we are working with the onshore wind industry to ensure that the delivery of this ambition supports our regional and national economies, communities and nature. The UK Government's Clean Power Action Plan respects the Scottish Government's onshore wind ambitions for 2030.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
an hour ago
- Scottish Sun
I should've ordered Covid shame Catherine Calderwood to quit on spot after flouting lockdown laws, says Nicola Sturgeon
The pair gradually became pals following the scandal in 2021 TONE DEAF I should've ordered Covid shame Catherine Calderwood to quit on spot after flouting lockdown laws, says Nicola Sturgeon Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) NICOLA Sturgeon admits she was wrong not to order her Chief Medical Officer to quit on the spot after she flouted Covid lockdown laws with trips to her seaside holiday home. The ex-First Minister also said Dr Catherine Calderwood deserves 'credit' for resigning 24 hours after the scandal broke — despite her initially insisting privately that she would try to 'ride it out'. 3 Catherine Calderwood broke lockdown rules by travelling to her holiday home in Earlsferry, Fife 3 Nicola Sturgeon at the launch of her new memoir, Frankly But amid an explosion of anger across the country, Ms Sturgeon changed her mind after realising her credibility would be 'fatally undermined' if she allowed the top medic to stay in place. Dr Calderwood, from Edinburgh, was exposed by The Scottish Sun on Sunday for two 88-mile round trips to her second home in Earlsferry, Fife, at the height of the pandemic. The scandal saw her axed from telly ads telling people to stay in their own house to avoid spreading Covid and forced to resign from her £120,000-a-year government role amid hypocrisy claims. In Ms Sturgeon's book, Frankly, released on Thursday, she writes: 'With hindsight, I should have told her immediately that resignation was necessary and inevitable.' The Scottish Government at first brushed off the revelation when contacted by The Scottish Sun on Sunday on the evening of Saturday, April 4, 2021. But the next afternoon the then First Minister was bombarded with questions at a bruising TV press conference. She stood by the CMO, despite her undermining lockdown orders she had fronted for those with second homes not to travel to them to reduce the risk of spreading the disease. In her memoir, Ms Sturgeon argues that she thought losing Dr Calderwood would have 'severely disrupted' attempts to tackle the Covid crisis. She wrote: 'Losing an experienced Chief Medical Officer at this juncture was in no one's best interests. However, as I quickly came to realise, to a country in which emotions were raw and running high, it must have seemed the worst kind of politician response — detached and tone deaf.' We also revealed last year how Dr Calderwood WhatsApped fellow UK CMOs over the trips backlash saying she would 'ride it out'. Timestamps on the text suggested she sent it at around the time of the TV briefing where she stood beside the First Minister. Nicola Sturgeon backs apologetic CMO Catherine Calderwood after she was caught flouting lockdown rules Her resignation, after talks with Ms Sturgeon, was announced just before 10pm that night. The ex-SNP leader admitted in her book she was 'stunned and, initially, disbelieving' after our bombshell exclusive went live online on the Saturday night. Hoping for a rational explanation', she wrote: 'I called Catherine immediately to get her side of the story. She was shaken and apologetic, but there was no getting round the fact the essence of The Sun's claim was accurate. She had gone with her family over that weekend to her second home. 'It later transpired she had gone there the previous weekend too. 'She had interacted with no one other than her family unit. 'No one had been at any risk as a result of her actions. 'But there was no doubt she had broken the rules.' She defended the CMO at a press conference where she was 'pummelled' by journalists. But Ms Sturgeon said she slowly came to the realisation that Dr Calderwood had to go. She wrote: 'As I mulled it all over on my journey home later that evening, I knew in my gut that I was in the wrong place. I also knew if I stayed in that place, it wasn't just Catherine's credibility that would be shot. My own would be fatally undermined too. By the time I got home, I knew Catherine had to resign. 'When I spoke to her, she had reached the same conclusion. She could have dug her heels in, as I had no actual power to sack her. 'She accepted responsibility and did the right thing, in a way other senior figures caught breaking the rules didn't. This is to her credit. 'After the Covid restrictions lifted, we would catch up occasionally for coffee or a drink, and gradually became pals.'
The Herald Scotland
11 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
New fund to support Gaelic culture announced by John Swinney
He says the North Uist Historical Society's renovation of Carinish Old School will receive £360,000 from the Scottish Government. The funding will create two exhibition spaces and the extension of the collections resource centre. The nearby heritage centre will then offer the chance to see artefact collections, research facilities, and offer Gaelic learning. An additional £200,000 will help deliver the second phase of work at Cnoc Soilleir, a centre for traditional culture and arts in South Uist. The First Minister said: 'Safeguarding the Gaelic language, preserving local heritage and giving culture the chance to flourish are all central to the future success of Scotland's remarkable islands. 'Our investments in Carinish Old School and Cnoc Soilleir underline the Scottish Government's commitment to Gaelic and the communities to which it gives life. Read More 'Projects like North Uist Historical Society's renovation of Carinish Old School are key not only to the language's revitalisation, but to the growth of rural island economies. 'We see this happening across the islands, local people coming together to preserve historical assets and bring them back into use – we need to do what we can to support their efforts. 'I am greatly looking forward to returning to Cnoc Soilleir to see the progress since my last visit. 'It is one of the recognised Gaelic success stories of recent times, providing in South Uist a guiding light for traditional culture and arts. 'It draws in people from the local community, but also visitors from elsewhere, perfectly illustrating the close connection between Gaelic revival and economic growth.'
Scotsman
14 hours ago
- Scotsman
Prisoners who break jail rules 'should be barred from early release'
The Scottish Tories made the call amid a rising number of incidents Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Prisoners have broken rules in jail almost 100,000 times since the start of 2022, prompting calls for inmates who do so to be exempt from early release. New figures have revealed the number of inmates who broke the rules increased from 6,017 in 2022 to 6,659 the following year, and reached a peak of 6,904 in 2024. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad In the first seven months of this year alone, 4,556 prisoners have broken the rules, according to figures obtained by the Scottish Conservatives under under Freedom of Information laws. The number of Scottish prisoners who have broken prison rules has increased every year since 2022 | PA Meanwhile, the number of individual rule breaks increased by 44 per cent between 2022 and 2024, rising from 22,318 in 2022 to 30,926 the following year, before increasing again to 32,128 in 2024. With the data also showing a further 14,618 rule breaks in the first seven months of 2025, there has been a total of 99,990 rule breaks over the period January 2022 to July 2025. One individual prisoner is responsible for 143 rule breaches, the statistics showed, with other inmates having accrued 111 and 105 breaches while in custody. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Meanwhile, 60 of the 312 prisoners who were freed early in February and March this year as part of Scottish Government efforts to tackle overcrowding were reported to have broken prison rules during their time in jail. Holyrood last year passed legislation to change the release point for those criminals serving prison sentences of under four years, so they will be freed after 40 per cent of their sentence, down from 50 per cent. Scottish Conservative justice spokesman Liam Kerr said: 'No inmate who is found breaking prison rules should be considered for early release. At least somewhere in the justice system criminals need to realise that actions have consequences. 'These alarming figures are symptomatic of a prison system being utterly failed by a complacent SNP government making up policy on the hoof. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'If prisoners are willing to break the rules in the controlled environment of a prison, then they will have no problem breaking the law and endangering communities when they are back on the streets. 'The rising number of rule breaches shows clearly that prisoners feel emboldened to do whatever they want behind bars, knowing their actions won't impact on their prospects of early release under a government desperate to cover its long-term failures with short-term, knee-jerk responses. 'Victims will feel that justice isn't being served but this also shows that the SNP aren't even equipping our prisons to properly rehabilitate offenders.' A Scottish Prison Service spokesperson said: 'Our population, which is already extremely high and complex, continues to rise rapidly. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'This has an increasingly destabilising effect on our establishments, with staff unable to do the critical work of building relationships and supporting rehabilitation, and prisoners frustrated by the impact on their daily lives and the opportunities available to them. 'We need to see a reduction in our population, so we fully support people in our care, reduce their risk of reoffending, and help build the safer communities we all want to see.' A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'The rising and increasingly complex prison population remains a major challenge as it does across the UK and we are taking sustained action to reduce it.
