logo
Erin Patterson trial: Mushroom cook found guilty of poisoning four members of husband's family with beef wellington lunch

Erin Patterson trial: Mushroom cook found guilty of poisoning four members of husband's family with beef wellington lunch

News.com.au6 days ago
After nine weeks of trial in the country Victorian town of Morwell, it took jurors seven days to return unanimous verdicts finding Erin Patterson guilty of three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder.
'Guilty,' the forewoman said after each charge was read.
Erin appeared in court dressed in a paisley top, and appeared nervous as the courtroom packed out ahead of the bombshell verdict.
She tried to meet the eyes of the jurors as they entered the room about 2.16pm, but not one met her gaze.
She remained expressionless as the forewoman softly said 'guilty' in response to each charge.
There were soft gasps from some members of the public as the first verdict was read, and one supporter of Ms Patterson was seen shallow breathing and staring at the ceiling.
Outside the court, about 200 people were gathered.
The case had centred around a lunch Patterson hosted on July 29, 2023, at her Leongatha home about a 45 minute drive southwest of Morwell.
At the lunch were her estranged husband's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, and his aunt and uncle, Heather and Ian Wilkinson.
At the meal, the five people present ate individually-portioned beef wellington parcels Patterson had modified from a RecipeTin Eats recipe.
During the trial, jurors were told by Patterson's defence that it was not disputed that death caps were in the lunch, but the key question was whether she had deliberately poisoned her guests.
The trial was told Patterson invited her husband, Simon Patterson, to the lunch as well, however he pulled out the night before via text.
Each of the guests fell critically ill after the lunch, with Don, Gail and Heather dying of multiple organ failure caused by death cap mushroom poisoning in early August.
Ian, the pastor of the Korumburra Baptist Church, recovered after spending about a month and a half in hospital.
The jury heard the four family members began experiencing gastrointestinal symptoms about 12 hours after the lunch and were taken to hospital the following morning on July 30.
The two couples' conditions rapidly declined and each were in induced comas by August 1.
Conversely, the jury heard, Patterson told others she began experiencing loose stools the afternoon following the lunch and suffered diarrhoea regularly through the night.
She attended the Leongatha Hospital the morning of July 31, two days after the lunch, was taken to Monash Medical Centre in Melbourne and released on August 1.
Doctors found no clinical or biochemical evidence of amanita (death cap) poisoning, although an intensive care specialist said her medical records were consistent with a diarrhoeal illness.
Prosecutors argued the evidence could prove she intentionally sourced and included the deadly fungi while defence maintained it was an accidental poisoning.
In her closing remarks, Crown prosecutor Nanette Rogers SC pointed to five 'calculated deceptions' she said sat at the heart of the case against Patterson.
These allegedly were; a fake cancer diagnosis used as pretence for the lunch, that a lethal dose of death caps were 'secreted' in the meal, Patterson faking the same illness as her guests, a 'sustained cover up' and, untruthful evidence given from the witness box.
Dr Rogers argued Patterson's actions in the days following the lunch could only reasonably be explained by her knowing the guests were poisoned with death caps while she was not.
Jurors were told these included dumping a dehydrator on August 2 that was later found to contain death cap remnants and lying to police by claiming she had never foraged for mushrooms or owned a dehydrator.
It was also alleged she lied about feeding leftovers from the meal, with the mushrooms scraped off, to her children the night after the lunch as an effort to deflect suspicion.
Dr Rogers said, on the evidence, the jury could 'safely reject any reasonable possibility that this was a terrible accident' and allow them to find she committed each of the crimes.
'We say there is no reasonable alternative explanation for what happened to the lunch guests, other than the accused deliberately sourced death cap mushrooms and deliberately included them in the meal she served them, with an intention to kill them,' she said.
She pointed to evidence Patterson had previously used the website iNaturalist to look up death cap sightings in May 2022 and her phone records to suggest she deliberately sought out the poisonous mushroom in April and May 2023.
One iNaturalist post on April 18 identified them growing in Loch while a second post on May 21 located death caps in Outtrim.
'This evidence tends to show that the accused had the opportunity to source death cap mushrooms at a time approximate to the lunch,' Dr Rogers said.
The prosecutor also pointed to an image found on a Samsung tablet of mushrooms on a dehydrator tray that an expert said was 'consistent' with death caps.
Dr Rogers also submitted lunch survivor Ian Wilkinson's testimony of Patterson eating from a different plate to her guests as a 'striking piece of evidence'.
'That choice to make individual portions allowed her complete control over the ingredients in each individual parcel,' she said.
'It is a control, the prosecution says, that she exercised with devastating effect.'
Turning to Patterson's time in the witness box, including when she claimed to have been foraging for mushrooms for years, Dr Rogers urged the jury to reject her account.
'You should simply disregard this new claim that this was a horrible foraging accident, as nothing more than an attempt by the accused to get her story to fit the evidence that the police compiled in this case,' she said.
'She has told too many lies and you should reject her evidence.'
Patterson's defence, led by barrister Colin Mandy SC, argued the prosecution had worked back from the belief she must be responsible for what happened and cherry picked evidence that supported this.
He sought to paint the case against his client as 'illogical' and 'absurd', highlighting that there was no identified motive for what Patterson had allegedly done.
Mr Mandy said the evidence in this case showed Patterson loved her in-laws and had a mostly positive relationship with Simon Patterson since their separation in 2015.
'Why on earth would anyone want to kill these people?' he asked.
'There's no possible prospect that Erin wanted in those circumstances to destroy her whole world, her whole life. Surely it's more likely that her account is true.'
Mr Mandy pointed to Patterson's testimony from the witness box, where she said she was feeling isolated from her support network by Simon and the lunch was a proactive effort to keep the family in her and her children's lives.
He argued her account was far more likely than the prosecution's 'convoluted' theory Patterson planned for these murders months out.
Patterson told the jury she'd always loved eating mushrooms and developed an interest in foraging wild mushrooms during the early Covid lockdowns of 2020.
She maintained what she told health authorities after the lunch was true, that she used fresh button mushrooms from Woolworths and added a packet of dried mushrooms purchased from an Asian grocer in Melbourne earlier that year.
But Patterson said she now believed she may have added dehydrated wild mushrooms to the same Tupperware container she stored the purchased mushrooms in her pantry.
Mr Mandy told the court his client admits she lied to police and tried to hide the dehydrator, explaining it as the actions of a woman who believed she would be wrongly blamed.
'You heard the accused say that she regrets telling lies, but that's what she did,' he said.
'She's not on trial for being a liar.'
The defence barrister argued the evidence his client had previously looked up death caps on iNaturalist had an innocent explanation – that a novice forager would want to see if the deadly mushroom grew in her area.
He pointed to Patterson's account of binge eating cake and vomiting after the lunch as a possible explanation for why she did not get as sick as her guests.
But Mr Mandy also said the expert evidence in the case was that two people, eating the same meal containing death caps, could experience different severity of illness based on a range of personal factors.
Patterson will return to court at a later date.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Midday News Bulletin 13 July 2025
Midday News Bulletin 13 July 2025

SBS Australia

time41 minutes ago

  • SBS Australia

Midday News Bulletin 13 July 2025

TRANSCRIPT New South Wales Police throws its support behind officers who fatally shot a Western Sydney man. The Prime Minister launches a tourism campaign in China. Australian sprinter Kaden Groves comes his closest yet to a stage win at the Tour de France. New South Wales police has voiced staunch support for the officers involved in the shooting death of a man at a Western Sydney car park yesterday. Police say officers were called to a brawl that reportedly occurred between a group of women in Mount Druitt, before the partner of one of the women allegedly approached the group with a machete. Police say the man was shot by officers when he failed to put down his weapon. Assistant Commissioner Gavin Wood has surveyed footage from the incident and says he is confident in the actions of both detectives, who stood between the machete-wielding man and the women. "The investigation will be subject to scrutiny as it should be, but their actions were brave. I spoke to both police last night and the enormity of what had happened was starting to sink in. We will put our arms around those police, as we do and they deserve that. But they are good people, and good police officers. They did not come in to work yesterday knowing they would have to shoot somebody." Chinese actor Yu Shi will spearhead a new campaign, aimed at luring Chinese travellers to Australia. The campaign is being launched by the Prime Minister, who is in Shanghai today as part of a six-day visit to China. The push comes after Beijing put Australia back on its approved destination list for organised tour groups, In the year to March 2025, 860,000 trips were taken to Australia from mainland China, contributing $9.2 billion to the local economy. While Mr Albanese has told reporters the visit is focused on the economy, there are regional security concerns that will likely be the substance of meetings behind closed doors. The Prime Minister will meet with President Xi Xinping in Beijing later this week. Palestinian hospital officials say 31 Palestinians have been fatally shot on their way to an aid distribution site in the Gaza Strip. Israeli airstrikes have also reportedly killed at least 28 Palestinians, including four children. The reports follow two days of meetings between US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, with no signs of a breakthrough in ceasefire talks. President Trump had previously said he was closing in on an agreement between Israel and Hamas that would wind down the war. Meanwhile, thousands of Israeli protesters have taken to the streets in Tel Aviv, calling on their government to end the fighting. Maayan Sherman is the mother of former hostage Ron Sherman. "After 34 days in captivity, he was killed by IDF bombing. I'm here to remind everybody that there are 50 more hostages that must come back to Israel, must come back to their families." New South Wales police are investigating the alleged shooting of a child on a hunting trip this weekend. Police are inquiring after a nine-year-old boy with a gunshot wound to his right leg, was treated in hospital on Friday night. The incident allegedly occured during a group hunting trip in Bourke. Police have spoken with five men and four children aged between 9 and 15, all of whom are from Victoria. An inquiry is underway into the group's firearm licenses after 17 weapons - including air rifles, rifles and a shotgun were seized. An ancient indigenous rock art collection in Western Australia's Pilbra region has been listed as a UNESCO World Heritage Site. Traditional owners travelled to Paris for the decision, where member nations unanimously voted-in the Murujuga Cultural Landscape, despite threats from nearby gas projects. The engravings pre-date anything found in ancient Egypt or the Roman empire. Peter Jeffries is from the Murujuga Aboriginal Corporation (MAC), which has led the twenty year campaign to have the area- just outside of Karratha -internationally recognised. "It's been in motion now for two or three decades, and we've lost a lot of our old elders in the process. So this is also in recognition of their support, as well." In cycling, Aussie sprinter Kaden Groves has made the podium for the first time at this year's Tour de France. Scoring third place, the Australian team led the pack in the last kilometre of a mostly-flat eighth stage. Groves went early and couldn't hold off Italian Jonathan Milan, who claimed victory. Speaking with S-B-S on the ground, Groves says it was a difficult fight, but he was pleased to have a place on the podium. "These final roundabouts were quite interesting. I almost crashed in the last one. So yeah, super hard. If you weren't in position there you were out of the sprint. In the end we went a bit early, but super happy with the team." Reigning champion Tadej Pogacar has held onto the overall tour lead, retaining the yellow jersey.

2024 Melbourne Cup-winning jockey Robbie Dolan suspended
2024 Melbourne Cup-winning jockey Robbie Dolan suspended

The Australian

timean hour ago

  • The Australian

2024 Melbourne Cup-winning jockey Robbie Dolan suspended

Melbourne Cup-winning jockey Robbie Dolan has copped a 13-day suspension for careless riding from an incident at Doomben on Saturday. Queensland stewards suspended Dolan after he restrained his mount She Ours to a position behind Estrondo when 'insufficiently clear' of Chief In Charge (Damien Thornton) in the final race of the meeting. The stewards' report stated that Chief In Charge had to 'severely check to avoid the heels of She Ours', the $2.70 favourite which finished runner-up to Noble Decree. • PUNT LIKE A PRO: Become a Racenet iQ member and get expert tips – with fully transparent return on investment statistics – from Racenet's team of professional punters at our Pro Tips section. SUBSCRIBE NOW! The Matt Hoysted-trained Chief In Charge placed 11th out of 12 runners in the $85,000 3YO Handicap (1350m). Dolan, who stunned the nation after winning last year's Melbourne Cup on $91 roughie Knight's Choice, pleaded guilty to the careless riding charge. His suspension will start next Sunday and he will be free to return to riding on Saturday, August 2. Irish jockey Dolan steered the Kris Lees-trained gelding Hawker Hall to victory in Saturday's opening race, a Class 3 over 1110m. He has been booked for six rides at the Sunshine Coast on Sunday, including two for Eagle Farm trainer Robert Heathcote.

Macca's worker's unhinged rant day before stabbing boss
Macca's worker's unhinged rant day before stabbing boss

News.com.au

timean hour ago

  • News.com.au

Macca's worker's unhinged rant day before stabbing boss

Just days before a McDonald's employee allegedly stabbed her manager to death, she posted an unhinged rant on Instagram about her 'bully' boss. Afeni Muhammad, 26, has been charged with murder after she allegedly stabbed her manager, Jennifer Harris, 39, at least 15 times at a McDonald's in Detroit, Michigan, on Thursday. Two days earlier, she took to social media to vent her anger over being sent home for her performance two days in a row. 'I got sent home early yesterday. I got sent home early today by the same person,' Muhammad said in the Instagram reel, posting from her account @officialrisenphoenix. 'I'm telling you, she's a bully. This sh** isn't funny … She needs to understand that just because she's a mother and got children, that doesn't mean she can come in the store disrespecting people, talking like everybody is beneath her. She has no respect and it isn't funny at all.' Muhammad's alleged victim was a single mother of six who had been working at McDonald's for 15 years. 'Like, seriously, man, I got sh** I need to take care of and she keeps sending me home early … she's playing games,' Muhammad continued her foul-mouthed rant. She then claimed her boss played 'racial sh**', spread negative energy and gossiped about people, before saying, 'That sh**s gonna have to stop'. 'Then she tell me I am snapping on people. No, no, no, that's false, I don't snap on people. I don't go doing that. No, I make peace. I've been creating peace,' she added. After Ms Harris apparently sent Muhammad home again a second time, police say she told her boss, 'I'll be back,' before she went to her car and retrieved a kitchen knife. When she re-entered the fast-food restaurant, witnesses say she was wearing a mask. A drive-through customer witnessed the attack and fired a shot into the air to try to stop it, police reported. Muhammad reportedly tried to escape but was stopped by the customer before her arrest by police. The alleged murderer appeared in court on Friday and is held on a $25 million ($A38 million) bail. She is charged with first-degree murder and unlawful possession of a dangerous weapon with intent. The McDonald's franchise owner stated: 'We are deeply saddened by this tragic incident, and our hearts go out to the victim's family and loved ones. 'Violence of any kind is unacceptable in my restaurants, and we are taking this matter extremely serious, as the safety and wellbeing of our employees and customers is our top priority. We are fully co-operating with law enforcement as they conduct their investigation, and the restaurant will remain closed until further notice.' Muhammad's lawyer said that she is a high school graduate currently taking online physical therapy classes. She is also an aspiring rapper.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store