
Seeking asylum: Is Tunisia a 'safe country of origin?'
Over the weekend,
Chaima Issa
, a Tunisian writer and human rights activist, was sentenced to 18 years in prison.
The daughter of a former political prisoner, Issa has been imprisoned in Tunisia since 2023 and is accused of "conspiracy against state security."
She was not alone. Her sentencing came as part of a mass trial of prominent opposition figures in Tunisia last Friday, including politicians, diplomats, lawyers and civil society activists. All had spoken out against Tunisian President Kais Saied and were sentenced to between 13 and 66 years in prison. Some, like Issa, are in jail in Tunisia, while others have fled the country.
"The Tunisian government has been using arbitrary detention and politically motivated prosecutions to intimidate, punish, and silence critics," the international advocacy group Human Rights Watch explained.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Invest $200 in Amazon without buying stocks to earn a second salary
Marketsall
Undo
"The verdict is a travesty of justice and illustrates the authorities' complete disregard for Tunisia's international human rights obligations and the rule of law," the global human rights organization Amnesty International added.
European Union: Tunisia is 'safe'
Just three days earlier, the European Union's (EU) executive body, the European Commission, seemed to come to a totally different conclusion about the state of law in Tunisia.
The EU's new Pact on Migration and Asylum is meant to go into effect June 2026, but the European Commission wanted to move forward with some elements of it earlier, in order to help member states process asylum claims faster. One of those elements is an EU-wide list of "safe countries of origin," which includes Kosovo, Bangladesh, Colombia, India, Egypt, Morocco, and Tunisia.
A "
safe country of origin
" is a country where people are generally considered safe and therefore should not require asylum in the European Union.
According to the European Commission's explanation, part of the reason it considers Tunisia safe is because, "the [Tunisian] constitution provides that the judiciary is an independent function, exercised by judges over whom there is no authority other than the law."
"If it wasn't so tragic, you might think the timing was ironic," Rasmus Alenius Boserup, director of Copenhagen-based advocacy organization EuroMed Rights, told DW, referring to how the heavily-criticized mass trial and the EU designation both happened last week.
There are many human rights violations in Tunisia, Alenius Boserup added. "The judiciary, the political opposition, journalists, human rights defenders and activists of all kinds have been being targeted there for three to four years now," he said. "And Egypt is even worse."
Egypt has around 60,000 political prisoners, and neither the political nor judicial system can be considered free and fair, he explained.
"So, if we're just designating countries like that as 'safe' for the sake of more expedient ways of handling asylum requests, it just doesn't make sense," Alenius Boserup argued.
Potential solution?
The EU itself says a mandatory EU-wide list of "safe countries of origin," or SCOs for short, should speed up the processing of asylum applications. That's because its assumed most applications from SCOs will be unsuccessful.
"Under the new regulation, applications [from SCOs] must be examined in an accelerated examination procedure and completed within a maximum of three months," the EU has stated.
EU countries could also choose to use so-called "border procedures" on irregular migrants from SCOs — that's basically when a person is simply refused entry at the border.
Faster processing times mean EU authorities could then concentrate on asylum applications with a better chance of asylum being granted.
Additionally, many member countries already have their own SCO lists. This can encourage "asylum-seekers to apply for asylum in host countries where the chances of success are higher," a May 2024 EU briefing on the topic explained. A unified EU list would prevent that.
The European Commission's proposal to fast-track an SCO list is yet to be voted on. But if agreed, rights organizations say it could have problematic consequences.
An SCO designation doesn't mean that everyone in the country is safe, or even that all parts of the country are. "Member states [still] need to conduct an individual assessment of each asylum application, … whether a person comes from a safe country of origin or not," the European Commission said this month.
"But this will likely make it more difficult for some asylum seekers to prove they are actually in danger," Alenius Boserup told DW.
Risk of mistakes
"The EU has been trying to be more expedient in its asylum application processing and objectively, that's not a bad ambition. We do need some reform," he conceded. "The problem is if you do it in a way that jeopardizes basic rights. By trying to be faster, the EU might well be undermining the principle it claims to want to defend."
Could a Tunisian opposition politician still successfully claim asylum in Europe, then? Alenius Boserup remains hopeful. "Still, the SCO listing increases the risk they won't," he explained. "We know there is painstakingly detailed work that goes into deciding a credible claim. But when you prioritize expediency over diligence, the risk of a mistake increases."
Rights organizations and lawyers also have serious misgivings about how a country gets on the list of SCOs in the first place.
The European Commission says its SCO list "draws on analysis" from the EU Agency for Asylum, member states, the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, and EU diplomats, among other sources.
Part of the decision about countries' SCO status is also based on the percentage of rejected European-wide asylum applications a particular country has. For example, only 4% of Tunisians applying for asylum in the EU are successful in their claims.
However as Baya Amouri, a legal researcher at the European University Institute in Italy, wrote for the Refugee Law Initiative in February, because the reasoning behind SCO status is so vague, there's potential for manipulation "based on diplomatic relations or political considerations rather than on a rigorous, objective evaluation of conditions."
"If you're going to use an SCO list, then at least do it correctly," Alenius Boserup agreed. "The criteria used to declare a specific country safe or not safe seems, at best, vague and under-documented." For instance, he continued, Morocco's status as an SCO could be debated. "But it's not even a discussion when you talk about Egypt and Tunisia."
DW asked the European Commission whether, given the long sentences handed out to members of Tunisia's political opposition last Friday, it still agreed with its earlier assessment about the Tunisian justice system being "independent"?
A spokesperson from the Commission did not offer a clear answer. They repeated that not everyone in a SCO is safe, and that member states still have to carry out "individual assessments." Additionally they said, "the Commission will monitor the EU list on a regular basis. Where the Commission finds that there is a significant change for the worse … it can suspend the designation."
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
Crimes by ‘outsiders' trigger protests in Uttarakhand, locals demand stringent checks
Dehradun: A series of violent crimes involving individuals from outside Uttarakhand — including the recent murder of a 25-year-old local man by a poclain machine operator — have led to widespread anger among residents and prompted authorities to tighten background checks. The incidents occurred over the past week in different parts of the state, including Dehradun and Pauri Garhwal. The poclain operator, accused of murdering the youth in Pauri Garhwal, remained absconding. In another case, Dehradun police on Saturday arrested three men from Haryana and Delhi for allegedly attacking a car belonging to a Dehradun-based merchant navy officer after his vehicle overtook theirs on a busy road on May 30. Meanwhile, seven men from Punjab were arrested for allegedly assaulting locals with swords in Srinagar, Pauri Garhwal, after being asked not to create a disturbance. Residents of Dehradun and surrounding areas blamed inadequate background checks for the rising violence. "What is happening in the past few days in the city and other parts of the state is completely unacceptable. We never have any problems with tourists visiting our state, but the kind of activities they are indulging in against the locals can never be tolerated. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn IC Markets Đăng ký Undo There needs to be a crackdown on such behaviour and strict action is needed against them," said Umesh Dhyani, a resident of Dalanwala, Dehradun. Responding to the public outcry, inspector general of Garhwal range Rajeev Swaroop told TOI that all district police units in the division had been instructed to intensify verification drives and act firmly against the accused. "Acting to curb such incidents in the Garhwal division, police launched Operation Lagaam (control), an ongoing campaign, to check road rage and related violent incidents, which have also seen a rise recently. The state is known as Devbhoomi — abode of gods — and we will not allow anyone to disturb its peaceful environment," Swaroop said.


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
'Informed the police after...': Sonam Raghuvanshi's brother reveals key details of call with sister
Following Sonam Raghuvanshi's surrender in the Meghalaya honeymoon murder case in Ghazipur, Uttar Pradesh, her brother Govind Raghuvanshi on Monday has refrained from commenting further. "When she called me, I got emotional, and later informed the police. Until I meet her (Sonam), I cannot say anything. For the last 72 hours, I have been awake. It's been 20 days since I met her," Govind said. Sonam Raghuvanshi, wife of the late Raja Raghuvanshi , was located near a dhaba on the Varanasi-Ghazipur highway, a senior Uttar Pradesh Police official confirmed on Monday. So far, four individuals have been arrested in connection with the case — Vishal Chauhan, Raj Kushwaha, and Akash Rajput among them. Meanwhile, Meghalaya Police are en route to Ghazipur to formally arrest Sonam. The Indore-based woman accused of hiring men to get her husband killed during their honeymoon in Meghalaya surrendered before Uttar Pradesh Police in Ghazipur, while another man was arrested from Lalitpur district, an officer said on Monday. Live Events Meghalaya DGP I Nonrong, earlier in the day, said Raja Raghuvanshi, an Indore-based transport businessman whose body was found a week back in Meghalaya, was allegedly killed by men hired by his wife, Sonam. Apart from Sonam, police have arrested three more men — Akash Rajput from Lalitpur and two others from Indore. A total of five people have been arrested in the case so far. Raghuvanshi and his wife had gone missing while vacationing in the Sohra area in Meghalaya's East Khasi Hills district on May 23. Raghuvanshi's body was found in a gorge near Weisawdong Falls on June 2. Sonam, 24, had been missing since then. Ghazipur Superintendent of Police Iraz Raja said that Sonam was nabbed in the night at 'Kashi Dhaba' on the Varanasi-Ghazipur main road. She was sent to Sadar Hospital for initial treatment and then kept at a one-stop centre, which provides assistance to women in distress, as well as medical and legal aid. A dhaba employee told reporters that Sonam had asked for a phone to call her parents in Indore, which led to the Madhya Pradesh Police to trace her location. Later, UP Police were contacted and Sonam was held. Meanwhile, around 6.30 PM on Monday, a team of Meghalaya Police took Sonam into custody from the one-stop centre she was admitted to. The process to procure a transit remand for her is underway, the officer said. Although she was collected from the eatery, police said Sonam surrendered at the Nandganj Police Station in Ghazipur district. Earlier in the day, Govind, her brother, also reached Ghazipur from Meghalaya. "If she is guilty, she should be hanged. Whatever the government decides, we will accept it," he told reporters. Asked if had spoken to Sonam, Govind said, "I don't know anything for now. I have no idea. I have not met her. I have not slept for 17 days, I have been searching for her with the police in Meghalaya." Rajput was apprehended Sunday night from Chauki village in the Mahrauni Police Station area of Madhya Pradesh's Lalitpur, Superintendent of Police Md Mustaque said. "Meghalaya Police is interrogating Rajput and we are extending help to them. Further legal action will be taken by the concerned state police," he said. Earlier, Nonrong said one person was picked up from UP in connection with Raghuvanshi's death and another two from Indore by a Special Investigation Team. "The operation is still continuing in Madhya Pradesh to catch some more persons involved in the crime," she said. After their marriage on May 11, the couple left for Meghalaya on May 20 for honeymoon. They reached Mawlakhiat village in the northeastern state on May 22 on a rented scooter. On May 24, the scooter was found abandoned outside a cafe along the Shillong-Sohra road, following which a search for them began. A Meghalaya Police SIT, headed by an SP and assisted by four DSPs, is probing the matter.


Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Canada plans to hit NATO spending target early, reduce US defence reliance, Carney says
Toronto, Canada will meet NATO's military spending guideline by early next year and diversify defence spending away from the United States, Prime Minister Mark Carney said Monday. Carney said Canada will achieve NATO's spending target of 2 per cent of gross domestic product five years earlier than it had previously planned. 'Our military infrastructure and equipment have aged, hindering our military preparedness," Carney said. "Only one of our four submarines is seaworthy. Less than half of our maritime fleet and land vehicles are operational. More broadly we are too reliant on the United States." According to NATO figures, Canada was estimated to be spending 1.33 per cent of GDP on its military budget in 2023, below the 2 per cent target that NATO countries have set for themselves. Canada previously said it was on track to meet NATO's spending target by the end of the decade. 'Our goal is to protect Canadians, not to satisfy NATO accountants,' Carney said. The announcement of increased spending came as Canada is about to host a summit of the Group of Seven leading industrialized nations in Alberta on June 15-17, and before the NATO summit in Europe. It also comes as NATO allies are poised to increase the commitment well beyond the 2 per cent target. NATO Secretary-General Mark Rutte said last week that most US allies at NATO endorse US President Donald Trump's demand that they invest 5 per cent of gross domestic product on their defence needs and are ready to ramp up security spending even more. Carney has said that he intends to diversify Canada's procurement and enhance the country's relationship with the EU. 'We should no longer send three quarters of our defence capital spending to America,' Carney said in a speech at the University of Toronto. 'We will invest in new submarines, aircraft, ships, armed vehicles and artillery, as well as new radar, drones and sensors to monitor the seafloor and the Arctic.' Canada has been in discussions with the European Union to join an EU drive to break its security dependency on the United States, with a focus on buying more defence equipment, including fighter jets, in Europe. Carney's government is reviewing the purchase of U.S. F-35 fighter jets to see if there are other options. Carney said that the US 'is beginning to monetize its hegemony: charging for access to its markets and reducing its contributions to our collective security.' 'Middle powers compete for interests and attention, knowing that if they are not at the table, they will be on the menu," Carney said. Trump's calls to make Canada the 51st US state have infuriated Canadians, and Carney won the job of prime minister after promising to confront the increased aggression shown by Trump. Carney said that the long-held view that Canada's geographic location will protect Canadians is becoming increasingly archaic. European allies and Canada have already been investing heavily in their armed forces, as well as on weapons and ammunition, since Russia launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine on February 24, 2022. GRS GRS This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.