Top public servant urges ‘more doing, less reviewing' after 70 inquiries in Labor's first term, FoI papers reveal
One of the nation's most respected public service chiefs has told Labor to stop commissioning so many government reviews, warning the costly and time-consuming inquiries risk swamping bureaucrats and unduly heightening public expectations.
The secretary of the Department of Health, Disability and Ageing, Blair Comley, has urged the health minister, Mark Butler, to allow public servants to adopt a more implementation and less analysis mindset in the coming term of parliament, after more than 70 reviews were commissioned, consulted-on or published in Labor's first three years in office.
In advice included in a brief to the re-elected Albanese government, Comley said official reviews could cost more than $25m each, absorbing significant departmental resources and adding to 'an already crowded agenda'.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
'We have a stock of completed reviews that have consulted widely and include significant recommendations,' Comley said in documents released to Guardian Australia under freedom of information rules.
'I would suggest that 'Even more doing, less reviewing' would be a good mindset for this term.
'With each review, stakeholder expectations continue to rise. There is an expectation that government will adopt all recommendations of these reviews.'
He pointed to the government's health technology assessment review, which included 50 recommendations for reform alone, many with significant implementation costs. Other major reviews included the Medicare review, the private hospitals financial health check and the review of the national disability insurance scheme.
Similar incoming ministerial briefs are prepared by department and agency bosses across the public service after an election.
The Albanese government appointed Comley to lead the health department in 2023. Tony Abbott sacked him as the climate change department boss a decade earlier.
A highly respected policy mind, he has also worked as a consultant and lead the New South Wales premier's department. Comley was speculated as a possible candidate to head Anthony Albanese's Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet, after the departure of Glyn Davis after the 3 May election. That job went to the Treasury boss Steven Kennedy.
In his advice to Butler, Comley said delivering on findings of more government reviews might have to be drawn from spending on Labor's election commitments, including Medicare reform, cheaper medicine prices, addressing workforce challenges and improvement in mental health care and Indigenous health.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The challenges come amid a tight fiscal environment, and health spending remains one of the key pressures on the federal budget. Comley said the department was delivering fiscal discipline and cost minimisation, and was preparing for a 6% to 10% decrease in internal resourcing from the government from 1 July, with further decreases expected in 2026-27.
Significant productivity growth is being achieved through efficient service delivery, according to the advice, including in the treatment of cancers. But fewer gains have been achieved in improving the quality of life for patients.
'The work of the first term gives a strong foundation of robust information, a strong mandate for reform, and the time has come to deliver on priority commitments,' Comley said.
'There will be reviews that make sense where there is a compelling case due to one or more of the three motivations, but the bar should be set high.'
The department's incoming government brief was handed to Butler on 13 May. His office declined to comment on Sunday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
33 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Donald Trump 'doesn't like' Kevin Rudd - and Anthony Albanese needs to do something about it before it's too late, warns GOP pollster
A prominent Republican pollster has claimed Donald Trump does not like Australia's ambassador to the United States, Kevin Rudd, and has warned Anthony Albanese to sack him if he wants to secure a tariff exemption. Brent Buchanan, a GOP pollster and messaging strategist, said that Australia needed to replace Rudd in Washington DC if it hoped to secure a carve out from Trump's punitive 'Liberation Day' tariffs. 'Donald Trump needs to find an Australian that he likes or Australia needs to find an Australian that Donald Trump likes and let that person take point because so much with Donald Trump is personal relationships,' Mr Buchanan told Sky News. Host Laura Jayes asked whether Trump didn't like Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, who is yet to secure a face-to-face meeting with the US President. 'I think he doesn't like the current ambassador and that's one of the biggest issues,' Mr Buchanan responded. Rudd, a former Prime Minister, was appointed as Australia's ambassador to the US by Albanese in March 2023. He enjoys cross-party support in Australia, but his position has been under threat since past negative comments he has made about Trump came to light. In November, shortly after Trump's historic election win, Daily Mail Australia revealed how Rudd never envisioned his comeback, calling his first term a period of 'episodic craziness'. In November, shortly after Trump's historic election win, Daily Mail Australia revealed how Rudd never envisioned his comeback , calling his first term a period of 'episodic craziness' 'Never take a backwards step in saying we're allies with the United States,' Rudd said in June 2022, nine months before he would be appointed as Australia's man in Washington. 'For all the American pre-disposition to episodic craziness... Look at Trump: how did that happen? That was a walk on the wild side for all of us.' In other, since deleted comments, Rudd has labelled Trump a 'village idiot', a 'traitor to the West' and 'the most destructive president in history'. But Mr Buchanan, founder of Cygnal Polling and Analytics, said Trump placed a lot of emphasis on personal relationships and would be open to cutting a deal with the right person. 'Donald Trump's a deal maker and so if you bring a deal, he's going to talk through it,' he added. Australia is facing 10 per cent tariffs on goods exported to the US and - like every US trading partner except the UK - has been hit with 50 per cent tariffs on aluminium and steel sent to America. The deadline for the higher reciprocal tariffs to come into effect is 9 July. On Monday morning, Albanese said his government was continuing to push for the tariffs to be removed. 'We'll continue to put our case forward that it shouldn't be 10 (per cent). It should be zero. That is what a reciprocal tariff will be,' he told reporters in Canberra. The Australian government has repeatedly called the trade measures an 'act of economic self-harm'. Foreign Minister Penny Wong is heading to Washington this week for 'Quad' talks with her counterparts from the US, India and Japan. She is expected to hold one-on-one meetings with US Secretary of State Marco Rubio where tariffs are expected to be high on the agenda.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Jacinta Allan rubbishes claims Queensland GST revenue is keeping Victoria's ‘hospital lights on'
A war of words has broken out between two state governments over GST revenue, after Queensland's treasurer claimed his state was keeping Victoria's 'hospital lights on'. The Victorian premier, Jacinta Allan, hit back with blunt language on Monday morning, rubbishing the claims as 'just bullshit'. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email In a speech in Brisbane on Monday the Queensland treasurer, David Janetzki, declared the sunshine state was 'stripped of $800m to reimburse New South Wales and Victoria for Covid-19 policy failures, five years after the fact'. Changes to the allocation of tax revenues had left Queensland $5.3bn worse off over three years, he said, the 'largest redistribution' in the 25-year history of the GST. 'Queensland, with its own newly re-established Productivity Commission, is doing the heavy lifting on productivity; our gas is solving the southern states' energy crisis; and our GST revenue is going to Victoria to keep their hospital lights on,' he said. Victorian premier Jacinta Allan said the complaints were 'nonsense'. 'Well, perhaps let me put it in language and in a way that the Queensland treasurer can understand – it's just bullshit, right?' she said, arguing that Victoria had historically been a net contributor. 'The Queensland budget's black hole – their $8bn-plus black hole – has got nothing to do with the circumstances here in Victoria. Now look, I don't want to quibble with another state. I don't want to quibble with the Queensland treasurer.' Janetzki handed down his first budget last week. It forecast the state's total debt to top $200bn for the first time, partly due to a reduction in the state's GST allocation and declining coal revenue. The Queensland treasurer said GST was being increasingly misallocated away from Queensland, partly due to a judgement that southern states had 'no or limited ability' to levy revenues from the gas industry. 'Every other state and territory gets a bigger share,' he said. 'Queensland's GST revenue in 2025–26 is only 28% higher than it was in 2015–16. 'In comparison, New South Wales, Victoria and Western Australia are up 58%, 118% and 317%.' Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion Due to its lower population density, Brisbane is assessed as needing 'only a small fraction of the public transport infrastructure of Sydney and Melbourne', but the higher cost of delivering services in a more decentralised state is not taken into account, he said. 'They effectively assume the cost of serving a resident in Ballarat, 113km from Melbourne, is the same as the cost of serving a resident in Mackay, 968km from Brisbane,' Janetzki said. Allan said it was wrong to compare Victoria and Queensland's public transport networks. 'If you want to compare public transport services, our world-class public transport service here in Melbourne, our huge network of buses, trains and trams is nothing compared to the public transport services you'll find in Brisbane,' she said. 'So I think this just shows what nonsense that claim is and we shouldn't be distracted by this nonsense. I'm not distracted by this nonsense that's coming from the Queensland treasurer, because I'm focused on making the investments in the infrastructure that matter'. Janetzki made the speech at a Committee for Economic Development of Australia lunch in Brisbane, in South Bank. He has been treasurer of Queensland since the Liberal National party won government at last October's election. He also argued that Victoria's premier should be replaced by either him or Queensland premier David Crisafulli as the representative of states at a productivity roundtable in August called by the federal treasurer, Jim Chalmers. 'I'm putting forward the case that it should be me or our premier which is at the table,' he said.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
The grip secret: it could be the key to a long and healthy life – here's how to improve yours
Anyone who has ever dropped their phone in the toilet – and isn't that all of us? – knows something about the importance of a good strong grip. We come into the world ready to grasp anything placed in our hands, and if we are lucky we leave it the same way. In between, grip lets us cling to our parents, hold our lovers, rock our babies. The morning I wrote this, before I was even dressed, it enabled me to strap on my watch, lock the kids out of the bathroom, wash my hands, insert my contact lenses, strip, shower, brush my teeth, take my medicine and check my phone. A few hours later, as I hung upside down on some gymnastics rings, it stopped me slipping off and cracking my head on the floor. But you know what? This just scratches the surface. Not only does grip help you work, play and pull your trousers on in the morning; it offers an immediate insight into your health. To put it bluntly, the weaker your grip, the more likely you are to die early. Find that hard to swallow? A study of 140,000 adults in 17 countries found that a weak grip went hand in hand with a higher risk of heart attack and stroke, and was a better guide to 'all-cause mortality' than blood pressure. It is associated with osteoporosis, diabetes, rheumatoid arthritis, fall risk and obesity, as well as cognitive decline. Unsurprisingly, perhaps, it is also linked to age-related muscle loss, or sarcopenia. For all these reasons and more, doctors often use grip strength as a quick measure of a patient's health, including their ability to recover from surgery or live independently. 'It's a really easy thing to test,' says physiotherapist Sarah Milner. 'You don't need to hook someone up to a machine, you don't need to look at their muscle mass, you don't need to take their weight …' The only real drawback is that it focuses on upper-body strength, which is why patient assessments often combine a grip test with a sit-to-stand, which gauges lower-body strength. Grip strength reliably reflects 'total body strength, neuromuscular coordination and cardiovascular resilience', in the words of Delhi GP Ramit Singh Sambyal. He says that patients in their 50s with a surprisingly weak grip often report fatigue, slower recovery after minor illnesses and a higher percentage of body fat. Conversely, those with a stronger grip tend to have better functional fitness and recover more quickly. To be clear, no one is saying a weak grip will kill you directly, in the way that heart failure will. But it usually indicates problems far beyond your hands and wrists. We don't yet have the scientific studies to back this up, but it seems reasonable to assume that anything that improves it will also improve your overall health. It will certainly improve your quality of life. Some weakening of the grip is inevitable as we get older. 'From about 50, muscle mass and nerve function gradually decline,' says Samantha Shann, occupational therapist at Oak Tree Mobility and the president of the World Federation of Occupational Therapists. 'But staying active – particularly with meaningful and hands-on tasks – helps slow the process.' Actually, we should be talking about grips rather than grip. As well as crush grip, which lets us shake a hand or hold a dumbbell, we mostly rely on pinch grip (think of turning a key or holding a plate) and support grip (to carry something like shopping), though there are enough subcategories to make your head spin. The more precise types may need to be trained with more delicate exercises, but in general what strengthens one grip also benefits the others, by working the flexor muscles that clench our fingers and thumbs, and the extensor muscles that straighten them, as well as our wrists and forearms and sometimes our upper arms and shoulders, too. How do you know whether all this needs attention? Sometimes looking is enough. Lucy Joslin teaches calisthenics, which features a lot of dangling from rings or pull-up bars, and handstands, where often the only thing keeping you balanced is the way your hands grip and flex against the floor. Every class begins with exercises for the hands, wrists and shoulders – bending them, stretching them, putting weight on them, frequently in quite uncomfortable positions. 'I look at people's hands all day long,' she says. 'You can tell unconditioned hands from conditioned hands – the people who are in touch with their fingertips and the people who are not. And then they go to grip a pull-up bar and it's like their hands can't close properly. And as for hanging off the bar, which is something I take for granted … no. And it's not just because they don't have the strength in their shoulders.' Milner, meanwhile, says her job has given her 'monkey grip'. As a result, 'I like doing bar hangs. That for me, is like, 'Where's my grip strength at?' And I know that if I'm fatigued my bar hang is a piece of shit.' On a good day she can hang for 90-120 seconds. When she told me this, I thought I'd see how long I could manage. Thanks to almost a year of calisthenics I made it to 90 seconds – but the last 45 were pretty unpleasant. There are gentler ways of testing, though. 'You can do it by squeezing a tennis ball and seeing how long you can hold your tightest grip,' Milner suggests. Do that regularly and you'll be able to track whether your grip is improving or deteriorating. 'I encourage clients to notice how they manage everyday tasks,' says Shann. 'Can they open a tight jar, wring out a cloth or carry a kettle comfortably? These are all functional ways of assessing grip.' For a more formal measurement, you'll normally squeeze (all right, crush) a device known as a dynamometer. You can get one of these for less than £20, though it may not be as accurate as medical-grade equipment. 'Grip strength varies with age and gender,' says Shann, but broadly speaking here's how much force you should be able to exert: Age 18 to 25 Women 27-31kg, men 46-52kgAge 26 to 35 Women 26-30kg, men 44-50kgAge 36 to 45 Women 25-29kg, men 42-48kgAge 46 to 60 Women 20-28kg, men 35-47kgAge 61 to 75 Women 18-26kg, men 30-45kgOver 75 Women 16-20kg, men 25-40kg 'While everyone's baseline differs,' Shann says, 'these numbers can highlight the need for support or intervention. It could mean a person is at risk of frailty, especially if combined with fatigue or reduced mobility.' Remember what I said about accuracy? Naturally, I had to try a dynamometer myself. The first one I bought gave me a reading of 39.1kg, which as a 61-year-old I should have been happy with. It still felt a little low given how much time I spend hanging from things. So I got another and squeezed it all the way to 46.6kg. I'm not sure which reading is more realistic, but I know which is better for my ego. Still, to put both into proportion, the world-record squeeze is more than 170kg. But what can you do if you're not happy with your result? 'I often recommend turning everyday activities into opportunities for strengthening,' says Shann. 'Tasks like cooking, gardening or carrying laundry all challenge grip in a natural and functional way. Structured exercises can be added in when more support is needed, such as a tennis ball squeeze (hold for three seconds, release, and repeat 10 times per hand, daily) or a towel twist (roll a towel and twist it in opposite directions, for one or two minutes a few times a week). I usually tell clients they can expect to notice small improvements in four to six weeks if they're consistent.' And those little gadgets where you try to force two handles together with your hand, against the resistance of a spring? I've somehow accumulated five of them, rated all the way from 50lb (23kg) to 250lb (113kg). I can barely make that last one move. Forget them, says Milner. What originally attracted me to them – that it's so easy to crank out squeeze after squeeze after squeeze – is also what makes them dangerous. 'They're terrible,' she says. 'People start using them and they give themselves some form of tendinopathy [tendon damage] from overloading. That repetitive gripping is awful.' Better to take a less direct, more holistic approach. 'When it comes to strengthening,' she says, 'it's really important to talk not just about your hand and your forearm, but about the whole kinetic chain.' This is the physios' way of saying that everything is linked; no muscle is an island; the toe bone's connected to the foot bone … 'The shoulder and the scapula – the shoulder blade – are intrinsically linked to grip strength,' Milner says. 'So I would do things like full-body strength training or functional strength training.' Imagine you're in a push-up position, say. 'If you've got your hands on the floor, and you're weight-bearing with a flat palm, or you start doing different types of grip on the floor, you're already strengthening your palm muscles and your forearm muscles, and you're loading up the shoulder blade. And then you can play with taking one hand off the ground and doing shoulder taps, or doing down dogs or a high plank. 'That's going to strengthen your wrists and hand muscles, but it's also going to hit you higher up the chain. It will also train your proprioception, which is basically knowing where your wrists and finger joints are in space, as well as your elbow and shoulder. And that is massively linked to strength, because if you have no idea where anything is, you're going to really struggle to be strong in that area.' Train your grip, in other words, by training things that aren't obviously your grip. And throw away those squeezy things. Six ways to improve your grip, by physiotherapist Sarah Milner At home Push-ups These come in many variations, so if they seem intimidating, you can adjust the difficulty by changing the angle, the position of your hands and the distribution of your weight. Start standing with your hands on the wall for a simple push exercise and progress this to the classic horizontal version on the floor. You can make this more challenging by playing with the position of your hands (wider, more narrow) and where your weight goes through (fists, just fingertips). Wet towel wrings Soak a towel in water, then grip and twist it to wring it out. Use both hands, and twist in both directions to improve the strength of your forearm and hand flexor muscles. Pinch grip holds Find the heaviest book in your house and take it between your fingers and thumb in a classic 'pinch grip' position. See how long you can hold it. You can play with the position of your arm (by your side, out in front of your body, above your head) and how bent or straight your elbow joint is. In the gym Dead hangs Try to hold on to a bar as long as your grip will allow you. You can change your hand position to challenge different hand and forearm muscles (neutral, supinated or pronated). This is a great exercise that helps activate your shoulder muscles, which are so important for grip strength. (Confused about those hand positions? If you stand with your arms by your sides, thumbs facing forwards is neutral. Palms facing forwards is supinated. And palms facing back is pronated.) Barbell bent-over rows This is a great multi-muscle exercise; the heavier you go, the harder your arm muscles, shoulders, shoulder blades and core have to work. Make sure you progress the weight steadily, and get a professional to guide you if you're concerned about your form. You can use either a pronated or a supinated grip. Reverse kettlebell above-head shoulder press. Hold on to the handle of an upside-down kettlebell (the ball part should be at the top and handle at the bottom). Try to keep your wrist in a neutral position (and straight) as you complete a strict above-head shoulder press. Try to move slowly and avoid the kettle collapsing down. This will challenge all of your arm and hand muscles as well as improving joint control and stability through the shoulder, elbow and wrist.
