Review into sister's killing in Woodmancote was 'waste of time'
Home Office guidance says these reviews, which make recommendations to help prevent people being killed by partners or family members, should be finished within six months.But BBC analysis has found most are taking years.
A domestic homicide review (DHR) into the death of Ms Fitzgibbons and her daughters was published in 2024, over four years after their deaths. It revealed Needham lied on his shotgun application to police about previous convictions and treatment for depression.Ms Ambler welcomed the review, which made a number of recommendations regarding the gun-licensing process.But she said she now felt that "nothing's changed". "It took over four years for Kelly's review to be published and it's not made one bit of difference," she said."I think they're just filed on a shelf, and nobody takes any notice of them."Ms Ambler is one of a number of bereaved families the BBC has spoken to who have criticised the length of time the reviews take.
Every domestic killing or suicide involving people aged 16 and over in England and Wales is subject to a DHR, recently renamed as a domestic abuse-related death review (DARDR).They examine the role of professionals who had contact with the victim or the perpetrator before an attack, but do not issue blame.
More than 1,200 reviews have been carried out since their introduction in 2011, according to Advocacy After Fatal Domestic Abuse, a charity which supports families affected by domestic homicide.BBC analysis of all reviews in a government library, dating back to 2011, found almost every review was taking longer than it was supposed to. Of the 495 with sufficient data:Only seven were finished within the six-month timeframeOne in six took more than two years to be completedIn the south-east of England, where Kelly, Ava and Lexi were killed, 100% of reviews were not completed within the six-month timeframeReasons given for the delays include the complexities of a police investigation or court proceedings, contact with family members or others to enable them to contribute to the review and safety partnership meetings.
If you are affected by any of the issues raised in this story, support and advice is available via BBC Action Line
Phillips said the reviews were "a really important opportunity for agencies on a local and national level to consider each individual victim, improve their safeguarding practices and ultimately prevent these deaths from happening in the first place"."Every death related to domestic abuse is a devastating tragedy and should not be overlooked," she said.She accepted that more needed to be done to ensure the process was "effective and timely" and that the government was creating a new oversight board with publicly appointed members to make the process of reviewing reports faster.A Home Office consultation last year suggested increasing the timeframe to complete a review from six to 12 months - but no change has yet been made.Even with the extension, BBC analysis suggests most would still miss the deadline - only 18% of the reviews were completed within one year.
Prof Jane Monckton-Smith, a criminologist specialising in domestic homicide who has chaired several reviews, said when done properly they could bring about real change."They have been absolutely crucial in building our knowledge of intimate partner homicides, domestic homicides and suicides," she added.However, she said they could be improved by having fewer people involved and having a chairperson to run the process.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
Enhance your skin with Project E Beauty's LumaLux LED Face Mask
Your daily skincare routine has the potential to be transformed by the addition of advanced beauty technologies such as Project E Beauty's LumaLux Face Mask. This is one of the latest products to feature in the health and beauty market place, a comfortable device aimed at complementing already existing skincare and wellness solutions used in the home. The mask is designed to help empower users to realise their skin's full potential by making it easier to access advanced skincare solutions without needing to book an appointment with a professional beauty expert at a clinic. Priced at £299 and featuring 800 high-grade LEDs, four times as many as any other similar product on the market, Project E Beauty's LumaLux Face Mask represents a great investment in self-care. Many celebrities are among those investing in advanced skincare technologies provided by Project E Beauty. Spice Girl and personality Mel B has described the Ice Roller and Derma Roller as among her beauty 'holy grails' while Lori Harvey is a fan of Project E Beauty's portable high frequency wand. The LumaLux LED mask has truly changed my life! Having struggled with acne for years, I've finally found a solution that really works. Within just a few weeks, I noticed incredible results: reduced redness, pimples disappearing quickly, and a much brighter, more even complexion. It has become an essential part of my skincare routine. I highly recommend it! It's an amazing investment for anyone looking to take care of their skin effectively. Noa - Project E Beauty customer review How does LED light therapy work? LED light therapy is a non-invasive beauty treatment used to rejuvenate and improve the appearance of the skin of all types. Different colours of LED light have been scientifically proven to have a positive impact on the skin. Red LED light is known to stimulate collagen production as part of a skincare routine. Skincare is unique for each individual but LED face masks such as the LumaLux Face Mask have been developed to provide a wide range of users with different needs with visible skincare benefits. Do I need eye protection with LED light therapy? Yes, it is necessary to use eye protection during LED light therapy sessions to ensure the safety of your eyes. Light therapy is safe but to maintain peak eye health, using goggles or shields can safeguard you against potential harm to ensure worry-free treatment. Do I need to use serum before or after using the mask? Apply your preferred serum after your LED light therapy session to make the most of your LED light therapy session. Exposure to LED light prepares your skin by the cells and making them more receptive to the nourishing ingredients in serums as well as moisturizers. By applying serum afterwards, your skin will be ready to absorb it for the best possible results. Why choose the Project E Beauty LumaLux Face Mask Many individuals want their skin care routines to be as simple as possible while simultaneously accessing the latest beauty technologies. Like Project E Beauty's other projects, this Project E Beauty LumaLux Face Mask has been carefully developed with concepts such as power density, wavelength precision, energy absorption, comprehensive coverage, and bulb placement at the forefront. The mask's top features include: Comfort and safety Developed with 100% soft silicone, the face mask offers great comfort for users alongside a safety guarantee. Its built-in eye protection is cushioned to provide the wearer with maximum light exclusion. Three minute treatments Project E Beauty aims to make skincare routines easier by only taking up a small amount of time within a busy day's schedule. The LumaLux Face Mask embodies this ambition by offering visible results with three minute daily treatments. Most LEDs on a silicone face mask With 800 high-grade LEDs, Project E Beauty's product features four times as many as the industry average to offer enhanced skincare results. Infrared technologies The technologies the Lumlax Face Mask utilises are leading the way in skincare treatments. New deep infrared light therapy penetrates deep into the skin to support advanced phase collagen production for more later signs of aging. Red infrared and deep infrared are clinically proven to be the most powerful anti-aging combination on the market 8 unique treatment modes The mask offers a variety of different treatment modes to support full skin rejuvenation and combat every common skin concern. It boosts collagen, smooths fine lines, treats acne, balances hyperpigmentation, reduces redness and inflammation, and soothes irritation, all with the clinically backed power of light. With this range of solutions, it means users can tailor their skincare needs to their own self-care routine. As an accessible home skincare treatment, Project E Beauty LumaLux Face Mask is leading the way with its advanced yet easy to use solution.
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
How long can overstretched Met Police cope if Palestine Action protests continue?
In 2024, a total of 248 people were arrested in Britain for terrorist-related activity. Within a matter of hours on Saturday, the Metropolitan Police arrested more than double that as 522 protesters were handcuffed under terror laws for holding placards declaring: 'I oppose genocide, I support Palestine Action.' Half of those arrested – who face up to 14 years in prison if they are convicted under the Terrorism Act for supporting a proscribed organisation – were over 60 years old, including 15 octogenarians. Many were applauded by onlookers as they were hauled away by officers. The scale of the challenge forced the Met to use a 'street bail' system to prevent police stations from being overwhelmed by what was described by organisers as a 'momentous act of collective defiance' in Parliament Square. The force used two processing points in Westminster to deal with 320 protesters, who were asked to confirm their details before being released and ordered to appear at a police station at a future date. A total of 212 were transported to police custody, likely because they refused to confirm their identity or were already on police bail. The Met said they were aware of online photos and footage suggesting some people returned to Parliament Square after being released on bail, but conceded it would be 'entirely unrealistic' to recognise these individuals. Over the coming weeks, officers from the Met's Counter Terrorism Command will work to put together case files and secure charges against those arrested. In some instances, charges will also require approval by the Attorney General Lord Hermer. But the threat of arrest and prison appears to be doing little to deter supporters who have vowed to continue to defy home secretary Yvette Cooper's controversial decision to ban the direct-action group with monthly protests, organised by Defend Our Juries, ahead of a High Court legal challenge November. The Met says they proved they can respond to 'significant protest' requiring many arrests, adding: 'We will do so again if we are required to.' However, the toll of hundreds of terror arrests on a force already grappling with a £260million funding shortfall, a staff recruitment crisis and regular large-scale rallies linked to the Israel-Gaza conflict, should not be underestimated. Paula Dodds, chairman of the Met Police Federation, warned 'tiredness is setting in' for officers. 'Officers are overstretched, rest days are being cancelled,' she told The Independent. 'Leave may be cancelled in the coming weeks as we try to ensure that we have resources to police protests as well as business as usual to keep London safe. 'We will need to call on more mutual aid officers to assist if these protesters continue to come out in numbers. It has just been relentless, and I think we are going to see that for a while yet.' She warned the workload of processing arrests, investigating offences and building files to be passed to the CPS increases demand across all departments at a time when the force is already under strain. In the coming weeks alone, officers face the threat of more anti-migrant protests at hotels housing asylum seekers, the restart of the football season and managing Notting Hill Carnival. She said 'only time will tell' if the resulting pressures result in increased levels of sickness or more officers leaving the force. Saturday's protest comes on the back of 221 similar arrests across the country, including dozens in London, in the weeks since Palestine Action was banned after activists broke into RAF Brize Norton in Oxfordshire and sprayed two military planes with red paint. Last week, the first three people were charged for flouting the ban. They are due to appear at Westminster Magistrates' Court in September. Ms Cooper has continued to defend proscribing the direct-action group, repeating claims that an assessment found evidence of 'ideas for further attacks' which cannot be reported due to ongoing legal proceedings. 'Many people may not yet know the reality of this organisation, but the assessments are very clear - this is not a non-violent organisation,' she said. 'UK national security and public safety must always be our top priority.' Palestine Action co-founder Huda Ammori claimed the latest demonstration was 'humiliating' for Ms Cooper and would 'go down in our country's history as a momentous act of collective defiance of an unprecedented attack on our fundamental freedoms'. She said the fact most of those arrested at the protest were 'given street bail and allowed to go home' proved the current ban was 'unenforceable'. 'It's clear that more and more ordinary people appalled by this anti-democratic, authoritarian ban will defy it en-masse and it is simply not possible to arrest them all,' she added.
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
Brothers jailed after rioting outside asylum seeker hotel
Two brothers have each been jailed for three years for their part in rioting outside a hotel housing asylum seekers last summer. Scott and Jason McGuire were at the forefront of the disorder which engulfed the Holiday Inn Express near Rotherham, on August 4, 2024, Sheffield Crown Court heard on Monday. The brothers were jailed along with two others men – Keethan Reeve-Lawson and Daniel Kazemi. This is understood to have brought the total number of people sentenced for the Rotherham violence to 104. Judge Jeremy Richardson KC outlined how the McGuire brothers were at the forefront of the 'mob' during the most serious part of the disorder on that Sunday afternoon. The judge has heard over dozens of hearings how the hotel was besieged for around 12 hours. Police officers and the hotel itself were pelted with missiles as more than 200 asylum seekers and 22 staff were trapped inside. At one point, the rioters smashed their way into the building and a burning wheelie-bin was pushed against a fire door. A total of 64 officers were injured in the violence along with police horses and a dog. Judge Richardson said it was his 'misfortune' to have sentenced most of those arrested after the disorder and said he was very familiar with video footage of the violence shown in court. He said: 'Each time I see this exceptionally serious disturbance represented in the footage of these events I feel, as I'm sure many others feel, profound shame that such shocking disorder should occur in this country.' The judge said: 'The venom of racism and racially motivated violence suffuses the events from first to last.' Judge Richardson told the defendants: 'Several hundred people were intent on mob rule. That will never be tolerated in this country.' And he added: 'All of those police officers are deserving of the highest praise for the way in which they resisted provocation and handled an immensely challenging situation with bravery, professionalism and skill.' Judge Richardson described how Scott McGuire was captured arriving at the scene with what appeared to be his partner and a child in a pushchair. He was later pictured in the mob at various times during the disorder and is seen dismantling safety barriers in front of the riot police as well as kicking items which were then thrown at the officers by others. The judge said: 'You were involved in fierce attacks on police officers close to the hotel. 'You were well to the fore and your participation was of a high order.' Judge Richardson said Jason McGuire was filmed throwing missiles at officers and a police van as well as at the hotel building, while wearing a mask. He was also filmed tearing down fencing which was used by others to throw at the police lines and fuel the fire which was set outside the building. The judge said: 'Your involvement was well to the fore in the most serious aspects of the episodes that afternoon.' The court heard how Jason McGuire was jailed for four years in 2015 for a drugs offence and for 10 years in 2018 for a machete attack. Judge Richardson jailed Reeve-Lawson and Kazemi for 22 months each after hearing how they were involved in later incidents once police had managed to push the mob away from immediately outside the hotel. Kazemi was filmed throwing a can of beer at officers, which smashed against their shields, and the judge noted that he was 'visibly happy' when another man threw a metal bar at police. Richard Barradell, defending Kazemi, said 'like many others' his client joined in 'once the pack mentality started'. He said: 'He cannot for the life of him explain why.' Mr Barradell said his client was 'bitterly embarrassed' and wanted to apologise to everyone involved. Scott McGuire, 35, and Jason McGuire, 31, both of Schofield Street, Mexborough; Reeve-Lawson, 22, of Mount Vernon Road, Worsbrough Common, Barnsley, and Kazemi, 35, of Edna Street, Bolton-upon-Dearne, all admitted violent disorder at a previous hearing.
