Trump's team wanted Kilmar Abrego Garcia to face ‘American justice.' He could be deported again before trial
Federal prosecutors want to bring his smuggling case to trial as soon as possible. But if he's released from pretrial detention, immigration officials intend to arrest and deport him before a trial even begins, according to government lawyers.
Abrego Garcia has pleaded not guilty, and his trial is set to begin January 27, 2026. He could be in another country by then.
The administration spent weeks insisting Abrego Garcia would never be allowed back to the country after admitting he was wrongfully deported in March. Yet he was abruptly flown back to the United States from El Salvador last month to face a criminal indictment in Tennessee. At a press conference announcing his return, Attorney General Pam Bondi said Abrego Garcia would face 'American justice.'
In recent court hearings in two different states, where judges are presiding over a criminal case and his wrongful removal lawsuit, Justice Department lawyers said they would only move forward with his criminal prosecution if he remains in custody while awaiting trial.
If he is released on bail, they would let Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents arrest him and send him out of the country, again.
Maryland District Judge Paula Xinis hauled Trump administration officials to court this month to understand what, if anything, the government intends to do with Abrego Garcia when he's released from pretrial custody.
Department of Homeland Security officials admitted that ICE intends to arrest him, but they don't yet know where he will be deported. Government attorneys had previously announced plans to deport him to a 'third country' instead of his native El Salvador.
'There's been no decision made, as he is not in ICE custody,' Thomas Giles, assistant director for ICE enforcement and removal operations, testified last week.
ICE intends to take custody of Abrego Garcia 'as soon as possible,' Giles said.
Where he will await his removal from the country will depend on available space in immigration detention centers, according to Giles.
Last month, Magistrate Judge Barbara Holmes determined there is no legal basis to keep him in pretrial detention. She set potential conditions for his release, including wearing an ankle bracelet and living with his brother in Maryland.
The federal judge overseeing his criminal case will decide next week whether to uphold that ruling.
On July 16, Tennessee District Judge Waverly D. Crenshaw Jr. said his decision will not be determined by what ICE wants to do. 'Frankly we don't know what is going to happen to him in that regard,' the judge said.
But he said he was 'having a hard time understanding' arguments from federal prosecutors that there were no conditions under which Abrego Garcia — who does not have a criminal record — could be out of jail while awaiting trial.
Holmes also appeared to reject the government's characterization of Abrego Garcia as a dangerous MS-13 gang member, human trafficker and serial abuser following claims from administration officials and government attorneys that 'defy common sense.'
Under cross examination from defense attorney Sean Hecker, Homeland Security Investigations Special Agent Peter Joseph admitted that he did not know that one of the government's central informants in the case gave conflicting statements about Abrego Garcia's alleged gang ties in several interviews with federal agents.
He also testified that he didn't know that the informants were in contact with other potential cooperators — at least three of whom sought deals with the government to legally remain in the United States in exchange for their testimony.
Three of the witnesses are related, and Joseph admitted it was 'always a possibility' that they coordinated their stories to secure a better deal for themselves.
'They're family,' Crenshaw shot back. 'Family talk.'
But it won't be Crenshaw's decision that decides whether Abrego Garcia walks free.
That will be up to Judge Xinis in Maryland. She is expected to decide whether to block the Trump administration from deporting him a second time.
Xinis has signaled that she will order the government to give him at least two days' notice, should the judge overseeing his criminal case release him from pretrial custody.
Abrego Garcia was 16 years old when he fled gang violence in El Salvador and illegally entered the United States in 2011.
Abrego Garcia, now 29, was living and working in Maryland with his wife and child, both American citizens, and two children from a previous marriage, when ICE agents arrested him in March.
After government lawyers admitted in court documents that he was removed from the country due to a procedural error, federal judges and a unanimous Supreme Court ordered the Trump administration to 'facilitate' his return. A 2019 order from an immigration judge had blocked his removal to El Salvador over humanitarian concerns, and Supreme Court justices unanimously agreed the Trump administration had 'illegally' defied that order.
Still, the government spent weeks battling court orders while officials publicly said he would never step foot in the United States as they characterized him as a serial abuser and criminal gang member.
But emails and text messages provided to members of Congress appear to show Trump administration and government lawyers were sympathetic to his wrongful removal and made efforts to get him out of El Salvador before the case made headlines causing major headaches for the White House.
Erez Reuveni, a 15-year veteran of the Justice Department who was working in the Office of Immigration Litigation, was closely involved with several high-profile immigration cases in the first months of Donald Trump's presidency when he was fired in April.
He supplied members of the Senate Judiciary Committee with a massive trove of internal messages showing the lengths the administration was taking to label Abrego Garcia a member of MS-13 as they tried to figure out if they were violating court orders by keeping him in El Salvador.
Before the case exploded into a national story at the center of the president's anti-immigration agenda, administration officials spent several days discussing the feasibility of returning Abrego Garcia or ensuring that he would be protected from the gang violence he fled as a teenager.
The messages also revealed simmering tensions between Justice Department attorneys who worked the cases in court and lawyers for Homeland Security who were directed to advance the president's agenda, regardless of legal risks.
Meanwhile, Abrego Garcia was , according to his legal team. His attorneys alleged he experienced 'severe beatings, severe sleep deprivation, inadequate nutrition, and psychological torture' while locked up inside.
'Last time they put Kilmar Abrego Garcia on a plane, he didn't know where that plane was going until it landed at the airport in El Salvador,' his attorney Simon Sandoval-Moshenberg told reporters last week. 'That's more or less what they want to do again, and that's what we're here to stop.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
UN agency calls for global pause on deportations back to Taliban-ruled Afghanistan
All countries should stop forcibly sending vulnerable Afghan nationals back to their homeland under the Taliban regime, the UN's mission in Afghanistan said today, as it warned about the threat of arrest, torture and abuse these citizens face. The United Nations Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (Unama) said it had documented evidence that forced returnees, deported against their will in large numbers by countries including Iran and Pakistan in recent months, have been targeted by the Taliban regime and face serious human rights violations. The report came just three days after the Trump administration lifted legal protections for Afghan nationals that prevented them being deported from the US. The Unama report, shared with The Independent, found that women and girls, journalists and activists and former security or government officials were at the highest risk of reprisals from the Taliban upon their return to the country. More than 1.4 million people have returned or been forced to return to Afghanistan this year alone, including over one million from Iran. Millions of Afghans fled their homeland in July and August 2021 as the Nato-backed government fell and Taliban militants swept to power in Kabul. The UN said the rapid pace and volume of Afghans being sent back from other nations was creating a multi-layered human rights crisis. With Afghanistan's formal economy almost non-existent under the Taliban, returnees are living in NGO-run camps and forced to rely on humanitarian aid to survive. Although the Taliban has previously offered an amnesty to those from the Nato-backed government and said it would not hunt them down, the new report shows that it continues to target its critics from the previous administration with arbitrary detention, physical assault and torture tactics such as mock executions and waterboarding. 'Nobody should be sent back to a country where they face risk of persecution on account of their identity or personal history,' UN human rights chief Volker Türk said. 'In Afghanistan, this is even more pronounced for women and girls, who are subjected to a range of measures that amount to persecution on the basis of their gender alone.' Unama noted that sending people back to a country 'where they are at risk of persecution, torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, enforced disappearance or other irreparable harm, is in violation of the principle of non-refoulement and a serious breach of international law'. Some of those already forcibly returned to Afghanistan told UNAMA about the abuse they had faced. Two months after Abdul*, a former government official, returned to Afghanistan in late 2023, he was arrested by Taliban militants and was subjected to vicious torture that culminated in his leg being broken. He was arrested on his way to a grocery store and detained in a house for two nights where he was beaten with sticks, cables and wood. Abdul said the Taliban officials cut off his hair and he was forced to watch a 'mock execution', mimicking the killing of those arrested by the de facto officials. He said he was also subjected to waterboarding. A former female journalist who was sent back to Afghanistan told UN officials she was 'effectively under house arrest' as the Taliban authorities have banned women from public spaces, job opportunities and moving around without a male guardian. 'There are no job opportunities, no freedom of movement, and no access to education, either to learn or to teach, for women and girls,' she said. Another woman sent back to Afghanistan against her wishes told Unama that she is now dependent on a family that is not her own and has no financial means to support herself. 'I live with my uncle's friend. My uncle from Kabul sends them 3000-4000 Afghanis (£32-£42) for my expenditures. But I never get to see the money. I am completely hidden, without any support, any assistance… I cannot travel anywhere. I do not have a mahram (male guardian). This is the biggest dilemma and challenge for me, that my sister and I are without any male companion. So we cannot move,' she told Unama. In its message to the international community, Unama said: 'Member States should refrain from returning Afghan migrants and refugees to Afghanistan in the absence of an individualised assessment to ensure their return is not a violation of their human rights.' Officials at the UN agency told The Independent the outlook for returnees was 'extremely negative' given the state of Afghanistan's economy and a humanitarian crisis exacerbated by natural disasters such as cyclical droughts and floods. They also pointed to a loss of aid support for the agencies dealing with these crises since the US and other Western nations announced cuts, with one Unama source noting that there were not enough 'resources available to fulfil basic health functions, whether that's maternal health or whether that's health across the population. To add to that, the UN and other international NGOs have been hit by a significant decrease in funding.' The Taliban's foreign affairs ministry, interior affairs ministry and its intelligence wing rejected the allegations of ill-treatment and prison torture presented by Unama in their report. 'No former military or civilian individual has been arrested solely because of their previous affiliation,' the foreign affairs ministry said, according to their response to the report seen by The Independent. Foreign ministry officials in Iran and Pakistan have defended their policies for returning Afghan citizens, saying this was done so with humanitarian principles kept in consideration.
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Appeals court rules on Trump's birthright citizenship order
A federal appeals court, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit, has ruled that Donald Trump 's executive order aiming to end birthright citizenship is unconstitutional. The court stated that the order contradicts the plain language of the Fourteenth Amendment, which grants citizenship to all persons born in the United States. This ruling prevents the Trump administration from enforcing the order, which would deny citizenship to children born in the U.S. to parents who are in the country illegally or temporarily. The judges fully agreed with a previous lower-court decision that had blocked the order nationwide. This decision moves the issue, concerning the redefinition of citizenship, closer to potentially being reviewed by the Supreme Court.
The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Three men who went missing while fishing found dead in Mississippi River
The bodies of three men, reported missing while fishing and swimming on a Mississippi River sandbar, have been found dead near Memphis Tennessee, authorities confirmed on Wednesday. Search and rescue teams from the Shelby County Sheriff's Office and other Memphis-area agencies began looking for the men on Tuesday evening after they were reported missing near a boat ramp at Meeman-Shelby Forest State Park. The search, which included aircraft, rescue boats, and sonar, was suspended on Tuesday night due to darkness. It resumed on Wednesday morning, the sheriff's office said. The first two bodies were recovered about 11 a.m. and the third about 12:45 p.m., the sheriff's office said. A cause of death will be determined by the medical examiner. The three men were described as Hispanic, ranging in age from their 20s to their 50s, the county fire department said. Officials say the area has become increasingly popular for recreation at the state park in Shelby Forest, located north of Memphis. But the river is treacherous, with several hazards present, including strong currents, submerged items, branches and debris. 'There are eddy currents that can pull an Olympic swimmer under. You can be drawn into the channel and find yourself staring at a 24-unit barge that's the size of a skyscraper on its side coming straight at you with no way for the barge crew to have any idea that you are there,' the fire department said on Facebook. Authorities are investigating what happened to the men.
