‘They can't do this': NRL has ‘officially lost the plot' after controversial penalty
Watch your team in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership. Stream every round LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play, on Kayo Sports. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer.
The incident in question came with the game still well and truly in the balance, although fortunately the Sharks were unable to capitalise on the penalty and turn it into points.
Regardless, Moses was left visibly frustrated and had plenty of support in the commentary box after Simonsson looked to initially be contesting the ball before grabbing at the jersey of Mulitalo as he came down with the ball.
'Oh my God come on now,' former Sharks and Warriors halfback Shaun Johnson said.
'They can't do this. This happens so fast. Stop watching it in slow-mo.
'This is a contest for the ball,' added Andrew Voss.
'Our game is not there is it?
'We are not going penalty try are we?'
They weren't, with the Bunker ruling out the possibility of a penalty try given Mulitalo had 'too much to do to get the ball to the ground'.
But that explanation left Johnson even more confused.
'My question is if it is a penalty in the air, how can you not consider a penalty try?' he said.
Referee Peter Gough said the Bunker ruled Simonsson 'grabbed the arm' and deemed it a 'tackle in the air', leaving Moses fuming.
'What do you want him to do but he has got his back to him?' the Eels halfback asked.
'I understand you don't agree, but that's the decision and I'm just letting you know,' Gough replied.
'But where do you want him to go?' Moses continued.
'What do you want him to do?'
'I can't answer that question right now,' Gough said.
'You can't answer it, so it should not be a penalty,' Moses concluded.
— Josh Mansour (@Josh_Mansour) May 2, 2025
We have officially lost the plot #NRL
— Jamie Soward (@sowwowofficial6) May 2, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
Simon Goodwin speaks out on sole reason for ‘shock' sacking
Premiership coach Simon Goodwin has opened up on his exit from the Melbourne Football Club for the first time since last Tuesday's shock announcement to sack him after nine years at the helm. While the Demons' struggles in season 2025 were well-documented up until his departure, the board's decision to axe the 2021 flag winner took the vast majority of people by surprise. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. Goodwin, who is one of just four people to ever lead the Demons to a V/AFL flag, spoke to Fox Footy's AFL 360 eight days on from his departure at Melbourne. 'It was a shock, there's no doubt about that. I was disappointed that they'd come to that decision — but you accept that position,' Goodwin began. 'Do I 100% think that I was the right person to carry this team forward? Yes, because I've done it before ... but that's the decision the board made, and I accept that decision. 'They need a new voice, they want a new voice, and they're going to get one.' When probed by hosts Gerard Whateley and Garry Lyon as to whether there was any other rationale for his sacking beyond the club's 'need' for a new voice, Goodwin responded: 'I had a standard board meeting the week before, and didn't have an inkling at that point. But as I said, I'm sure the board went through a thorough process.' 'That was the (only) reason I got; that they needed a new voice.' The two-time Adelaide premiership player had a decorated career across his 275-game career, and has now spent well over a decade as a coach in the AFL system — making him a prime target for all clubs looking ahead to 2026. Seven's Mitch Cleary revealed on Wednesday evening that GWS have reached out to Goodwin in regards to a role next year. Speaking on any future plans in the industry, Goodwin noted he right now feels open to anything. 'I've spent some time up in Sydney, and I'm going to catch up with a whole range of different people,' Goodwin continued. 'I'm open-minded to doing any thing in football. I love the game, I love coaching. I want to get away, have a spell ... (but) coaching's never complete, you want to get better. And I know with the experience and everything that's I've gone through, with some PD (personal development), I'll come back even better.' Melbourne's off-field imperfections before Goodwin's departure are well-documented, leaving the 48-year-old with an extra layer of difficulty when trying to maintain the club's success year-on-year. It includes  report last October that some board members and those within the club's corporate circle held concerns over former chief executive Gary Pert and his handling of a player's trade negotiation — as well as separate worries over the management of superstars Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver. Goodwin agreed when questioned as to whether his tenure while coaching without a CEO led to a level os misalignment at the club. 'I think clearly. Clearly, you need alignment for success. You look around the great sporting organisations around the world in business and sport, alignment is critical. It's critical because it builds trust, and you can make some really great decisions that you need to moving forward,' Goodwin said. 'There's certainly been challenges, and things that all football clubs need to work on — and Melbourne's no different. But if you walk through the doors at training at Casey Fields with those players, the environment's healthy, alive and well ... and that's the biggest part of your program to get right. 'For the next coach, I think it's set-up incredibly well. I'd be incredibly excited by the group that they've got available to them.'
News.com.au
13 hours ago
- News.com.au
Christian Petracca slammed as damning act exposed during loss to Western Bulldogs
Demons superstar Christian Petracca has been slammed for his poor body language as rumours swirl that he is plotting an exit. Just five days after Melbourne axed premiership coach Simon Goodwin, the Demons fell by six points to the Western Bulldogs. It was an incredible effort given the tumultuous time at the club, but concerning vision of club leader Petracca exposed a damning truth. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. On two separate occasions, the midfielder was seen flapping his arms about after not receiving the ball and even looked genuinely disappointed when he was overlooked for another option that worked out. It led to AFL great Luke Hodge launching a scathing attack on the Demons star on Tuesday night, stating Petracca has made it clear that he is more concerned with his own stats than what is best for the team. 'You've got Christian Petracca here letting him (Langford) know … he's put the arms up, he hasn't followed in. But the worst part is what comes after,' the three-time premiership skipper said on Channel 7's The Agenda Setters. 'That results in a goal. Yes, he is bypassed, lets him know, lets everyone know. But where's the reaction? Do you go to the young kid and say, 'Hey, good kick to the top of the goalsquare?' 'Do you go down to Kozzy Pickett, pat him on the back, or do you walk around? He's not going to anyone, he hasn't clapped, hasn't looked across at Langford, who didn't pass it to him, didn't say anything, (he just) turned around. 'That's a person who's worried about his own stats. So if you're looking as a coach coming into this Melbourne football club, the first thing I'll be doing is getting to the leaders and saying play like leaders, react like leaders, and support your younger teammates.' On another occasion, Petracca gave his teammates a gobfull after being closely marked inside the forward 50. After not receiving the ball, Petracca threw his head back and looked genuinely furious. His body language has only fuelled speculation that he is searching for an exit as a rift in the playing group following the sacking of Goodwin becomes clear. The 2021 Norm Smith Medallist appears to be on the lookout for a new club, with several potential destinations emerging for the star midfielder. Hawthorn appears to be the obvious new home for Petracca if he wants the exit bad enough. The Hawks desperately need another goalkicking midfielder, and their attempts to poach Harley Reid out of West Coast are expected to fall short. While Melbourne needs a key forward desperately, and the Hawks have no shortage of them, making a swap deal very feasible. Hawthorn has Mabior Chol, Mitch Lewis, Calsher Dear and Jack Gunston all fighting for three places, and it would make sense for one to give way, especially if it results in them snaring Petracca. Collingwood and Carlton, who both voiced interest in Petracca at the end of last season, also could provide the 29-year-old with an exit plan. But Hodge says, regardless of whether or not he is there next year, Petracca needs to fix his attitude. 'Maybe he may not be there (next year). (But) Wherever he goes, his body language needs to get better,' Hodge continued. 'It's not all about him. It's about the team and how the team is moving forward.' However, it isn't just Petracca who could be itching to leave following Goodwin's exit. Speculation about the playing futures of Bayley Fritsch and Judd McVee is still rife, and they may try to follow Petracca out the door. While the future of captain Max Gawn is also up in the air, with the veteran big seeing Goodwin as a father figure, and he is understood to be furious with the club's decision to sack him. In the meantime, the Demons will face the Hawks on Saturday afternoon, in a clash sure to provide plenty of fireworks.
News.com.au
16 hours ago
- News.com.au
Fallout from Mitch Moses spray at teammate exposes NRL ‘hypocrisy'
COMMENT Everyone will ultimately remember where they were when Mitch Moses verbally blasted Tallyn Da Silva. Mainly because whether you were in Parramatta or Paris, you were still close enough to be deluged in the spittle. Debate has simmered since Sunday over the Eels halfback's venomous tirade, with every man and his dog offering their take on where his rant fell on the intersectional graph between business and bile. FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Join now and get your first month for just $1. For those who missed it, Da Silva was dressed down by Moses on multiple occasions after a mosaic of rank decisions at CommBank Stadium that culminated in the dying stages with a dart on the fifth tackle that was held up over the line. With the game in the balance and tensions running high, Moses saved his best for last with a burst of language at the former Tiger so forceful it set off every car alarm inside the 25km blast radius. Was the halfback out of line for hammering Da Silva so furiously? Would his behaviour be tolerated in any other workplace? Or has rugby league gone fully vegan? The answer is simple. Moses' demon-possessed screed on Slanderous Sunday was not only bloody excellent, it was the most heartwarming use of the 'F' and 'C' words since Chris Heighington went full Gordon Ramsay after the 2005 grand final. Yet instead of celebrating Moses' touching gesture, there are still puritans standing under cold showers crossing themselves while righteously posting about the evils of his swears. So why was Moses spot on to give Da Silva the industrial blowtorch? Not only because the hooker endured a forgettable afternoon of shovelling up dung, but also because it finally returned to modern rugby league what it thought it had lost: a footballer who genuinely gives a toss. But instead of chairing Moses off like a Kaiser and shoving a mic in his face in the hope of a second burst, we've seen a fallout that has again exposed rugby league and its turgid hypocrisy. Not only is a cranky halfback a non-event in rugby league as commonplace as a training ground spat or a Craig Bellamy aneurysm, it's also something Parramatta players would be rigidly conditioned to after years playing with Clint Gutherson. But more importantly, Moses going off deluxe was a rare exhibition of raw passion in a game that has gone so milky you can get suspended for liking a post or wetting a ball. Think about it: we're always whinging about modern players being spoon-fed prodigies and soulless mercenaries lusting for the shiny penny. We hate how they'll switch allegiances in a heartbeat and laugh it up with the opposition at full time after copping a thrashing instead of stewing on it until they develop a stomach ulcer. So when we see a fighter like Moses hankering for victory with such drive that it manifests in a few naughty cuss words, we can't have our bake and eat it too. In simple terms, Moses is everything you want in a footballer: tough, street smart, and completely and utterly psychopathic. But he's not a bully consumed by malice or some kinda rogue employee, he's just a fearsome competitor whose only drawback is he needs a bib when he screams. This is a bloke who'd kill a coyote with his bare hands just to get a repeat set, a man solely responsible for Parramatta's bright late-season progress. And if he was on your team, you'd feel a burst of fire in your pantaloons that someone cared so much about two competition points in a lost season. If anything, the rest of the comp could learn a thing or two from Moses feeding Da Silva these chilli-infused home truths. Adam Reynolds is an affable chap, but maybe if he tore strips off Reece Walsh every once in a while he'd stop throwing so many forward passes? Imagine how proud Cowboys fans and Todd Payten would've been if Tom Dearden slagged off one of his many teammates slacking off again in their rudderless operation? Yes, Moses gets up people's noses. But anyone who thinks he's a negative influence on their kids obviously doesn't want their child to become an elite kick-ass competitor. And those claiming 'you wouldn't tolerate it in the workplace' have lost the plot too by comparing apples to oranges because they're lemon sour. Of course, this would never happen in your workplace — but that's only because you don't work in a job where you bust your gut in front of 15,000 people every weekend for a company that hasn't finished a job in almost 39 years. Sadly, this kinda hypocrisy in rugby league nowadays is like screen addiction, because it's automatic, almost unconscious, and full of RSI from so much finger wagging. These people would be better served directing their abuse at someone more relevant, like the trainers. Instead of berating Moses and demanding he spend time in the June Dally-Watkins Institute of Decorum, we should be celebrating the bloke for tackling adversity in a manner that doesn't involve demanding a release. — Dane Eldridge is a warped cynic yearning for the glory days of rugby league, a time when the sponges were magic and the Mondays were mad. He's never strapped on a boot in his life, and as such, should be taken with a grain of salt.
