Two cheap supermarket teas beat household names in decaf blind taste test
In the latest edition of Our Verdict, the Money team tested 13 different decaf tea bags, from supermarket-own to luxury brands.
As our national drink, tea elicits strong opinions, and brands can garner devout followings - but strip away the online fan clubs and official merchandise, and do the big names stand up in blind test conditions?
Our test suggests not - with two supermarket own brands leading the way.
In first place was Asda, scoring high marks from every tester for its smooth and malty flavour and sweet notes. At £1.65 for 80 bags, it is also one of the cheapest options.
It beat Lidl into second place, followed by Yorkshire Tea.
At the other end of the table was one of the most popular tea brands in the country, PG Tips.
Here are the full results...
First place: Asda
Price: £1.65 for 80 tea bags
Average score: 8.3
A great builder's brew - and one of the few teas we tried that tasted distinctly of... tea. Malty, smooth and a hint of sweetness in the brew. A great, caffeine-free substitute if you don't want to compromise on flavour.
Second place: Lidl
Average score: 7.3
A strong flavour with chocolatey and malty notes, and a bitter edge that fans of a stern brew might enjoy.
Average score: 6.3
A clean taste - but while our testers thought this was the best of the rest, it was some way behind Asda and Lidl on flavour. "Inoffensive" was a word that came up several times.
Fourth: Twinings
Price: £5.29
Average score: 5.5
A slightly more bitter brew than the rest of the field, but with little aftertaste, our testers thought it was a little forgettable.
Fifth: Tesco
Price: £1.65
Average score: 5.3
Good reddish-brown colour, some sweetness and a pleasant aftertaste, but it didn't hit the classic tea taste profile. Take it or leave it, our testers concluded.
Price: £5.90
Average score: 4.3
This tea did not test well despite the high-end price point. Its initial colour was grey and offputting to several testers even with four minutes of brewing. Watery, lacking any kind of depth and a slight soapy taste.
Price: £1.85
Average score: 4.3
Our testers described this as "very middle of the road" and scored it poorly for its aftertaste. It did have some nice sweet notes to the flavour and brewed an enticing red colour, but it caused a dry mouth feeling that was unpleasant.
Joint sixth: Morrisons
Price: £1.65
Average score 4.3
Some interesting flavours - our tasters picked up chocolate but, again, some were left with a soapy taste in their mouth.
Joint seventh: Aldi
Price: £1.45
Average score: 3.3
The brewing colour was nice, but the flavour was weak other than a touch of bitterness.
Joint seventh: Sainsbury's
Price: £1.65
Average score: 3.3
This tea lacked flavour and was panned by our testers - one described it as "lifeless".
Eighth: Tetley
Average score: 3
Three words to sum this one up from our tasters: watery, bitter and bland.
Ninth: M&S
Price: £3.20
Average score 2.6
A sour nothingness that, like many of the lower scoring teas, left a powdery, dry feeling on the tongue.
Price: £2.68
Average score 2.3
Unlike all the other teas, this one had no redeeming qualities for our testers, who described it as "unpleasant" and "watery".
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
28 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Older workers are being sent to the scrapheap
At long last, Rachel Reeves has an economic success story. One sector in Britain is displaying dizzying growth, with demand soaring year on year: the number of people claiming Universal Credit without work requirements has risen from 2.7 million last July to 3.7 million. While some portion of this growth will be explained by migration between benefits as the Government shifts claimants to Universal Credit, that cannot be seen as exculpatory. Certain claimants moving on to Universal Credit from legacy benefits can do so without a need for any fresh reassessment of their ability to work. While this will help to streamline the transfer and ensure those who need support receive it, it is a missed opportunity to look at the existing group of claimants and to reassess their fitness for work. Such an approach is sorely needed. At the moment, attention is directed towards the flow of new claims for welfare, but relatively little towards tackling the stock of existing claims, and seeing whether some may have left the workforce prematurely. Attention, moreover, does not mean action. The furious row over the relatively minor changes to disability benefits proposed earlier this year resulted in a Government climbdown, and the emboldening of backbench rebels against further potential cuts. As a result, we continue to see the numbers parked on benefits with no requirement to seek work soar, with many older workers now in what appears to be a form of tacit early retirement. This is a waste of their talents and experience that Britain can ill afford, and one which is all the more infuriating given the lay of the land internationally. A little over a year ago, the Minneapolis Federal Reserve Bank published a fascinating analysis on the remarkable shifts in the US workforce, with significant rises in employment rates for the over 55s. Older Americans were better educated and healthier than previous generations, and as a result willing and able to work longer. In Britain, in contrast, we are facing a health and disability benefits bill expected to rise to £100bn a year by the end of the decade, with minimal means of shifting workers off claims once they begin. It would be greatly to the benefit of the nation and the public finances if Westminster could bring itself to learn from Washington in this field.
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
FTSE 100 rises as markets welcome milder US inflation data
Aug 12 (Reuters) - Britain's blue-chip index climbed on Tuesday as equity markets worldwide cheered a milder U.S. inflation print that kept alive hopes for interest rate cuts in the world's largest economy. The blue-chip FTSE 100 (.FTSE), opens new tab edged up 0.2%, while the more domestically focused midcap index (.FTMC), opens new tab was down 0.2%. The latest U.S. consumer price index report painted a mixed picture for investors. While overall price increases moderated in July, a measure of underlying inflation posted its largest gain in six months. Despite the mixed signals, financial markets maintained expectations the Federal Reserve would proceed with an interest rate cut in September. Back home, data showed Britain's jobs market continues to soften, with payrolls declining for a sixth consecutive month and vacancies decreasing further. However, persistent wage growth underscored the Bank of England's cautious approach toward interest rate cuts. In markets, Spirax (SPX.L), opens new tab surged 13%, leading gains on the blue-chip index, after the manufacturing group forecast organic sales growth accelerating in the second half of the year on a strong order book. Among sectors, the aerospace and defence index (.FTNMX502010), opens new tab rose 0.9% in the day. The sector came under pressure since last week after peace efforts by the U.S. to end the Russia-Ukraine conflict gained momentum. Utilities (.FTUB6510), opens new tab, which are often traded as bond proxies, were the biggest drag, down 1.8% as the yields on British government bonds rose after the jobs data. Bellway (BWY.L), opens new tab inched 1.6% higher after it said it expects to build more homes in its new financial year. The outlook lifted the broader UK housing sector index (.FTNMX402020), opens new tab by 0.9%. London-listed Atalaya Mining Copper climbed 9.2% after the miner raised its copper production outlook for the financial year 2025, lifting the broader industrial metal miners index (.FTNMX551020), opens new tab by 1.1%. Earlier in the day, a 90-day extension of the tariff truce between the U.S. and China provided temporary relief to investors about global trade, effectively postponing potentially damaging triple-digit duties on Chinese exports to the United States. Among other stocks, gambling firm Entain (ENT.L), opens new tab dropped 1.9% despite forecasting its annual core profit outlook above market expectations.
Times
an hour ago
- Times
NHS landlord Assura backs takeover by PHP in boost for London
Two large NHS landlords are to merge after shareholders voted to pursue a tie-up rather than selling to KKR, the American private equity group, for £1.7 billion. Assura shareholders had until Tuesday to decide whether to take the cash offer tabled by KKR and Stonepeak Partners, its bidding partner, or merge with Primary Health Properties (PHP) instead. Both sides needed a simple majority to claim victory. Defying expectations of a closer vote, 62.9 per cent backed the PHP merger. KKR and Stonepeak got less than 17 per cent. Andrew Saunders, a real estate industry analyst at Peel Hunt, said it was 'not only a victory for [PHP] but also one for critical UK infrastructure, the UK stock market, the delivery of healthcare in the British Isles and society at large in our view'.
