Govt cannot insist toilets in petroleum retail outlets be opened for public: HC
The Kerala High Court has issued an interim order stating that the government cannot insist that toilets in private petroleum retail outlets be allowed for use by members of the public.
The order came on a petition filed by the Petroleum Traders Welfare and Legal Service Society and five retailers challenging the move of the government and local bodies to convert these toilets as public toilets.
They contended that private toilets they maintained at their retail outlets for emergency use by customers were often being forced to be opened for public use. The Thiruvananthapuram Municipal Corporation and many local bodies even pasted posters in some of the retail outlets, giving the impression that these were public toilets.
Many members of the public and even those who arrived in tourist buses were thus seeking access to the toilets, disrupting regular functioning of the outlets and sometimes leading to altercations within the high-risk premises.
Citing protection under Article 300A of the Constitution, the retailers contended that toilets they built within their premises were private property.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
10 hours ago
- Time of India
Kerala amends rules to empower non-IAS officers as ex-officio secretaries
1 2 T'puram: The latest amendment to Kerala's Rules of Business has triggered alarm bells within the state's administrative circles, with senior bureaucrats warning of its far-reaching implications for the structure and integrity of govt functioning. At the heart of the unease is the formal recognition and empowerment of non-IAS officers — including retirees — as ex-officio secretaries with full authority to issue govt orders. Although Kerala recently permitted a couple of hand-picked individuals heading statutory or quasi-govt bodies to be merely called ex-officio secretaries, the latest changes — now embedded in the constitutional Rules of Business — go a step further by codifying this power and placing them on par with regular IAS secretaries. Senior officials privately state that the amendment could have been avoided altogether. "The Kerala Secretariat Manual, not the Rules of Business, should have been the place to define the procedural authority of ex-officio secretaries. Instead, the govt invoked Article 166(3) to amend the very rules that define executive power in the state. That's a line rarely crossed," said one senior officer. The move amends two crucial provisions. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Trading CFD dengan Teknologi dan Kecepatan Lebih Baik IC Markets Pelajari Undo Rule 2 now explicitly includes ex-officio secretaries in the definition of a 'Secretary to Govt'. More significantly, Rule 12 has been rewritten to allow them to authenticate govt orders — essentially granting them signing power. These powers were traditionally restricted to those appointed under the IAS cadre or promoted through established bureaucratic channels. Critics argue the amendment could be a slippery slope. "If the only requirement is that someone heads a statutory body, then what's to stop a future govt from appointing any private individual to that role and thereby making them secretary to govt?" said another official. "There is no clear appointment framework or eligibility yardstick now." The govt's justification, as outlined in the notification's explanatory note, leans on the Central Secretariat Manual of Office Procedure, which allows ex-officio secretaries to issue govt orders. However, critics argue that even if the central manual allows something, Kerala does not need to make a constitutional-level change (ie, amend its Rules of Business under Article 166 of Constitution) just to reflect that practice. "Instead, a simpler method (like issuing a govt order [GO] or updating Kerala Secretariat Manual, which is a procedural guide — not a constitutional rulebook) could have sufficed. Why go to the extent of amending a foundational governance rule, when a procedural clarification would have been enough?" a source asked. Beyond legal semantics, the concern is deeply structural. Observers note that until now, three guardrails protected against the arbitrary expansion of secretary-level authority: Rule 2 (definition of secretary), Rule 12 (who may issue orders), and the IAS cadre strength regulations. With two of these guardrails now redefined, institutional checks on political appointments to top bureaucratic positions may weaken. In departments like planning, science & technology and finance (infrastructure) — where several non-IAS heads currently operate — this change could translate into a parallel power structure, bypassing traditional scrutiny mechanisms. For instance, a pay revision ordered by the KIIFB CEO acting as ex-officio secretary may no longer require vetting by the finance department. "This isn't just about turf. It's about protocol, accountability and democratic checks. A single GO in the Secretariat Manual could have clarified the issue. Instead, we've formalised a backdoor route that may prove difficult to reverse," said another senior officer. A section of the bureaucracy believes the development marks a turning point in the role and relevance of IAS in Kerala. "This is not a case of exclusion by political pressure. This is a self-engineered exit from crucial policy and financial command centres. The service must seriously introspect," the officer said. Calling for a broader dialogue, a senior official suggested that the IAS Association in Kerala should meet and deliberate on the issue. "This affects the very idea of institutional governance and violated the cadre rules as well. It can't be left unchallenged."
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
16 hours ago
- Business Standard
Toilets at petrol pump cannot be used as public facilities, says Kerala HC
The Kerala High Court has temporarily barred the state and local bodies from turning toilets at privately run petrol pumps into public conveniences, LiveLaw reported. Justice CS Dias issued the order while hearing a writ petition filed by the Petroleum Traders Welfare and Legal Service Society and five individual retailers. The petitioners argued that officials from the state government and Thiruvananthapuram Municipal Corporation were pressuring them to let everyone use their restrooms. Posters had even been pasted on some pumps, creating 'the impression that the toilets are public toilets', they told the court. 'Public use disrupts daily operations' According to the petition, large groups — including tourists from passing buses — now arrive expecting free access. This crowds petrol-pump premises, causes arguments and, the retailers say, raises safety risks in an area where fuel is handled. The dealers maintain the washrooms were installed only for customers who stop to refuel and need them in an emergency. Allowing unrestricted entry would 'impede and even endanger the functioning of petrol pumps', they said. 'Hence in light of the impending threat and disastrous consequences which might ensue due to usage of such toilets by general public at large; it is essential that requisite directions may be passed by this Honourable Court to restrict usage of such toilets only to customers who come for refuelling their vehicles and that too only in emergency situations,' the petitioners submitted, as quoted by LiveLaw. Court seeks Swachh Bharat guidelines Earlier, the court directed the Thiruvananthapuram Municipal Corporation to produce any guidelines issued under the Swachh Bharat Mission that could justify opening private toilets to the public. The retailers have also asked for a declaration that their toilets are private property safeguarded by Article 300A of the Constitution, and that no law allows authorities to re-designate them as public facilities under the Petroleum Act or its 2002 Rules.
New Indian Express
21 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Kerala HC says no to opening toilets at private petrol pumps for general public use
KOCHI: The Kerala High Court has directed the state government and local self-government institutions not to require that toilets in private petroleum retail outlets in Kerala be opened for public use. The court issued the order on a petition filed by the Petroleum Traders Welfare and Legal Service Society, an association of 300 retail outlet dealers, against a government order to convert their private toilets into public facilities. The petitioners contended that they were being forced to open the private toilets maintained by them at the outlets for the emergency needs of customers to the public. They also alleged that the Thiruvananthapuram corporation, as well as certain other local bodies, had pasted posters in some of the retail outlets to give the impression that the toilets are public toilets. The petitioners said treating toilets in private petroleum retail outlets, which are classified as high-risk zone, as public facilities would lead to unauthorised access. Also, chances of fire breaking out and other catastrophe are very high when a large number of people access the retail outlets in an unauthorised manner. Suman Chakravarthy, the standing counsel for the Thiruvananthapuram corporation, submitted that it is the duty of the dealers at the petrol pumps to ensure neat and safe toilet facilities for the public, and it is the duty of the LSG department to ensure that the dealers complied with it. In 2013, the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways had issued a circular stating that drinking water and toilet facilities at such outlets shall be accessible to the public around the clock. Recently, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Pathanamthitta, had ordered a petrol pump owner to pay Rs 1.65 lakh as compensation to a teacher for not letting her use the toilet on the premises. The complaint was lodged by C A Jayakumari, a resident of Ezhakulam in Pathanamthitta, against the owner of the filling station in Payyoli, Kozhikode.
