logo
How an email error sparked a secret scramble to bring thousands of Afghans to Britain

How an email error sparked a secret scramble to bring thousands of Afghans to Britain

Arab News17-07-2025
LONDON: British governments past and present face allegations of avoiding scrutiny and undermining democracy after the revelation that thousands of Afghans have been resettled in the UK under a program that was hidden from the media, the public and lawmakers in Parliament.
Key information was also kept from the Afghans themselves, who had assisted UK forces and whose personal details had been disclosed in a huge data leak. Many plan to sue the British government for putting them in danger from the Taliban. Some are left in Afghanistan as the current British government says the resettlement program will end.
Here's what happened in an extraordinary chain of events.
An email error with huge consequences
The saga was triggered by the chaotic Western exit from Afghanistan in August 2021 as the Taliban, ousted from power 20 years earlier, swept across the country, seized Kabul and reimposed their strict version of Islamic law.
Afghans who had worked with Western forces — as fixers, translators and in other roles — or who had served in the internationally backed Afghan army were at risk of retribution. Britain set up a program, known as the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy, or ARAP, to bring some to the UK.
In February 2022, a defense official emailed a spreadsheet containing the personal information of nearly 19,000 ARAP applicants to someone outside the Ministry of Defense. The government says the individual thought they were sending a list of about 150 names, not the whole set.
The British government only became aware of the leak when a portion of the data was posted on Facebook 18 months later by someone who threatened to publish the whole list.
The government sought secrecy
The leak sparked alarm among British officials who feared as many as 100,000 people were in danger when family numbers of the named individuals were added. The then-Conservative government sought a court order barring publication of the list.
A judge granted a sweeping order known as a super injunction, which barred anyone from revealing not only information about the leak but the existence of the injunction itself.
Super injunctions are relatively rare and their use is controversial. Most of the handful of cases in which they have come to light involved celebrities trying to prevent disclosures about their private lives. This is the first known case of a super injunction being granted to the government.
Former Defense Secretary Ben Wallace said Wednesday that he sought the legal order to gain 'time and space to deal with this leak, find out whether the Taliban had it' and protect those at risk.
Wallace said he asked for an ordinary injunction — not a super injunction — for a period of four months. The gag order remained in place for almost two years.
A secret program sparked a legal battle
The government began bringing to Britain the Afghans on the leaked list who were judged to be most at risk. To date, some 4,500 people — 900 applicants and approximately 3,600 family members — have been brought to Britain under the program. About 6,900 people are expected to be relocated by the time it closes, at a cost of 850 million pounds ($1.1 billion).
In all, about 36,000 Afghans have been resettled in the UK since 2021.
Meanwhile, several news organizations had learned of the leaked list but were barred from publishing stories about it. They challenged the super injunction in court, and a judge ordered it lifted in May 2024 — but it remained in place after the government appealed.
The government finally came clean
Britain held an election in July 2024 that brought the center-left Labour Party to power. Prime Minister Keir Starmer and his Cabinet learned of the injunction soon after taking office and grappled with how to proceed.
In January, the government ordered a review by a former senior civil servant. They found little evidence that the leaked data would expose Afghans to a greater risk of retribution from the Taliban. The review said the Taliban had other sources of information on those who had worked with the previous Afghan government and international forces and is more concerned with current threats to its authority.
Given those findings, the government dropped its support for the super injunction. The injunction was lifted in court Tuesday, and minutes later Defense Secretary John Healey stood in the House of Commons to make the saga public for the first time.
Many questions remain unanswered
Healey said the secret settlement route was being closed, but acknowledged Wednesday that 'the story is just beginning,' and many questions remain unanswered.
Immigration critics including Reform UK leader Nigel Farage are demanding to know what screening was done on the people who came under the secret program.
Lawyers for Afghans on the leaked list want to know why the information was kept from them. Adnan Malik, head of data privacy at UK legal firm Barings Law, said he was assembling a class-action lawsuit by hundreds of former translators, soldiers and others.
Lawmakers and free speech advocates say the use of a super injunction is deeply worrying. They ask how Parliament and the media can hold the government to account if there is such stringent secrecy.
Judge Martin Chamberlain, who ruled that the injunction should be lifted, said Tuesday at the High Court that the super injunction 'had the effect of completely shutting down the ordinary mechanisms of accountability.'
Healey acknowledged that 'you cannot have democracy with super injunctions in place,' and said the government had acted as quickly and safely as it could.
'Accountability starts now,' he told the BBC.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

UK's Keir Starmer condemns Israel in strongest terms yet as pressure mounts for Palestine recognition
UK's Keir Starmer condemns Israel in strongest terms yet as pressure mounts for Palestine recognition

Arab News

time4 minutes ago

  • Arab News

UK's Keir Starmer condemns Israel in strongest terms yet as pressure mounts for Palestine recognition

LONDON: UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer has condemned Israel with his strongest comments yet, as pressure mounts within and outside the government for Britain to formally recognize a Palestinian state. Starmer's remarks came after French President Emmanuel Macron said his country would recognize a Palestinian state, and as the two leaders, along with Germany's Friedrich Merz, were set to hold an emergency call on the issue. 'The suffering and starvation unfolding in Gaza is unspeakable and indefensible. While the situation has been grave for some time, it has reached new depths and continues to worsen. We are witnessing a humanitarian catastrophe,' the UK prime minister said. For the first time with reference to Israel, his statement failed to mention the country's right to defend itself, or the hostages held by Hamas and other militant groups. Starmer 'appeared to have lost his patience with Benjamin Netanyahu's Israeli government,' The Independent said, adding that the PM 'appeared to be on the cusp of being prepared to recognize a Palestinian state.' The political movement among major European countries is taking place as Israel faces mounting global anger over its actions in Gaza. Starvation in the enclave has reportedly surged in recent weeks, with at least 113 hunger-related deaths being recorded, including 82 children, according to Palestinian health officials. The Israeli military has also killed scores of Palestinians queuing for food at designated aid sites operated by the controversial Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, a US charity backed by Israel that is attempting to supersede Gaza's existing UN-operated aid system. Starmer added in his statement: 'I will hold an emergency call with E3 partners tomorrow, where we will discuss what we can do urgently to stop the killing and get people the food they (Palestinians) desperately need while pulling together all the steps necessary to build a lasting peace. 'We all agree on the pressing need for Israel to change course and allow the aid that is desperately needed to enter Gaza without delay.' Starmer has faced significant pressure this week from within his own Labour Party, including Cabinet ministers, as well as from trade unions and academics, to recognize a Palestinian state. He added: 'We are clear that statehood is the inalienable right of the Palestinian people. A ceasefire will put us on a path to the recognition of a Palestinian state and a two-state solution which guarantees peace and security for Palestinians and Israelis.' Justice Secretary Shabana Mahmood said yesterday that recognition would lead to 'multiple benefits' and send a 'strong message' to the Netanyahu government. She is one of several government ministers who have privately urged Starmer to recognize a Palestinian state in recent months. The issue has also been raised at regular Cabinet meetings. Mahmood, the most senior Muslim politician in the UK, told The Times that though pushing for a ceasefire in Gaza was 'the most urgent thing of all,' Palestinian statehood represented the 'best mechanism to get us through a peace process.' In its manifesto for last year's general election, the ruling Labour Party pledged to recognize Palestine once in office. Labour's Sadiq Khan, the mayor of London, also urged the government to follow France's lead. He warned that there could be no two-state solution — a longtime policy target of British governments — if 'there is no viable state left to call Palestine.' Another Labour politician, Emily Thornberrry, chair of the foreign affairs select committee, also urged Starmer to act. The UK's actions in relation to the Israel-Palestine conflict have 'time and time again … come too little, too late,' she wrote in an opinion piece for The Independent on Friday. Thornberry highlighted the potential of the major joint Saudi-French conference on the two-state solution, set to begin in New York next week. After addressing Parliament on a visit to London last week, Macron met Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas on Thursday, delivering a letter that said he would formally recognize Palestine at the UN General Assembly in September. The French president was 'right' to do so, Thornberry said. 'A unified move by the signatories to the secret Sykes-Picot agreement which carved up the Middle East more than a century ago would demonstrate our sincere commitment to a two-state solution,' she added. 'The natural reaction of the British public to the scenes of starvation and death in Gaza is to call on their politicians to do something. The challenge for politicians is to ensure that what they do makes a real difference. 'The recognition of Palestine as part of a renewed commitment by the UK to work with others to build a peace process would be just that.'

UK fears new summer of unrest, year after Southport riots
UK fears new summer of unrest, year after Southport riots

Arab News

time34 minutes ago

  • Arab News

UK fears new summer of unrest, year after Southport riots

EPPING: Concern is mounting in Britain that recent violent anti-immigrant protests could herald a new summer of unrest, a year after the UK was rocked by its worst riots in decades. Eighteen people have now been arrested since protests flared last week outside a hotel housing asylum seekers in the town of Epping, northeast of London, and seven people have been charged, Essex police said. In one demonstration, eight police officers were injured. The unrest was 'not just a troubling one-off,' said the chairwoman of the Police Federation, Tiff Lynch. 'It was a signal flare. A reminder of how little it takes for tensions to erupt and how ill-prepared we remain to deal with it,' she wrote in the Daily Telegraph. • Anti-migrant sentiments have been amplified by inflammatory messaging on social networks, fueled by far-right activists. • Almost exactly a year ago on July 29, 2024, three young girls were stabbed to death in a frenzied attack in northwestern Southport. • The shocking killings stoked days of riots across the country after false reports that the killer was a migrant. During the demonstrations, protesters shouted 'save our children' and 'send them home,' while banners called for the expulsion of 'foreign criminals.' Cabinet Minister Jonathan Reynolds urged people not to speculate or exaggerate the situation, saying 'the government, all the key agencies, the police, they prepare for all situations. 'I understand the frustrations people have,' he told Sky News. The government was trying to fix the problem and the number of hotels occupied by asylum seekers has dropped from 400 to 200, he added. The issue of thousands of irregular migrants arriving in small boats across the Channel, coupled with the UK's worsening economy, has triggered rising anger among some Britons. Such sentiments have been amplified by inflammatory messaging on social networks, fueled by far-right activists. Almost exactly a year ago on July 29, 2024, three young girls were stabbed to death in a frenzied attack in northwestern Southport. The shocking killings stoked days of riots across the country after false reports that the killer — a UK-born teenager whose family came to the country from Rwanda after the 1994 genocide — was a migrant. Nearly 24,000 migrants have made the perilous journey across the Channel so far in 2025, the highest-ever tally at this point in a year. The issue has become politically perilous, putting pressure on Labour Prime Minister Keir Starmer's center-left government, as the anti-immigrant, far-right Reform UK party rises in the polls. The Epping protests were stirred after a 38-year-old asylum seeker, who only arrived in Britain in late June, was arrested and charged with three counts of sexual assault. Images from the protests have gone viral on social networks, mirroring what happened last July. But Epping residents have maintained that the protests are being fueled by people from outside the community. 'These violent scenes ... are not Epping, and they are not what we stand for,' the Conservative MP for Epping, Neil Hudson, told parliament Monday. While calm was restored to Epping, a middle-class suburban town with a population of 12,000, tensions remain palpable. 'This is the first time something like this has happened,' one local who lives close to the Bell Hotel said, asking not to be named. 'The issue is not the hotel, but extremists applying a political ideology,' he added. Late on Thursday, the hotel, cordoned off behind barriers, was again the center of a protest involving dozens of people, with police making one arrest. With another protest expected on Sunday, the local council voted through a motion to demand the government no longer house asylum seekers at the hotel. The UK is 'likely to see more racist riots take place this summer,' said Aurelien Mondon, politics professor and expert on far-right and reactionary discourse at Bath University. Anti-immigrant protests have already erupted elsewhere, with demonstrations in the southeastern town of Diss in Norfolk outside a similar hotel on Monday. Last month, clashes flared for several days in the town of Ballymena in Northern Ireland after two teenagers with Romanian roots were arrested for the alleged attempted rape of a young girl. 'It is well documented that many of the protests we are witnessing are not the result of grassroots, local movements,' Mondon said. 'Social media plays a role and facilitates coordination among extreme-right groups,' but it is 'also crucial not to exaggerate' its power, he added.

Swinney to raise Gaza crisis with Trump during landmark Scotland visit
Swinney to raise Gaza crisis with Trump during landmark Scotland visit

Arab News

time3 hours ago

  • Arab News

Swinney to raise Gaza crisis with Trump during landmark Scotland visit

LONDON: Scottish First Minister John Swinney has vowed to raise the 'unimaginable suffering' in Gaza when he meets Donald Trump during the US president's four-day visit to Scotland this weekend. Describing the trip as 'a landmark moment' in US-Scottish relations, Swinney said the visit provides a key platform for Scotland to express its views on pressing global issues. 'As we welcome the president of the United States, Scotland will be showcased on the world stage,' Swinney said. 'This provides Scotland with a platform to make its voice heard on the issues that matter, including war and peace, justice and democracy. 'As first minister, it is my responsibility to advance our interests, raise global and humanitarian issues of significant importance, including the unimaginable suffering we are witnessing in Gaza, and ensure Scotland's voice is heard at the highest levels of government across the world.' Trump said on Friday that he was 'looking forward' to meeting Swinney during the trip. Swinney is facing increasing pressure from within the Scottish National Party to adopt a strong stance on the Gaza conflict. On Wednesday, his predecessor and former First Minister Humza Yousaf and his wife Nadia El-Nakla, who has family in Gaza, issued a direct plea via social media. 'Millions in Gaza are being deliberately starved while Israel withholds food mere kilometres away. Words are not enough,' they wrote. 'Force Israel to open the borders and allow aid to flow in.' El-Nakla, who also convenes the SNP Friends of Palestine group, told The Times that the Trump meeting represented 'a critical opportunity to raise, directly and unequivocally, the ongoing genocide in Gaza.' She said: 'Time is not on the side of the people there. As I speak, my family — like millions of others — is starving. The first minister must demand that Trump use his influence to compel Israel to end the starvation and ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people.' While highlighting the humanitarian issues at stake, Swinney also noted the wider benefits of the visit in terms of showcasing Scotland's tourism and investment potential. He expressed confidence that planned protests would remain peaceful and respectful. He said he believed demonstrators would 'do Scotland proud' and act 'peacefully and lawfully.' Rallies are being organized by the Stop Trump Coalition in Edinburgh and Aberdeen, with others expected near Turnberry and Menie, where Trump owns resorts. Trump is expected to stay at Turnberry over the weekend before meeting UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer there on Monday. He will then travel to Aberdeenshire to mark the opening of a new golf course named after his mother. Although the visit is private, a joint press conference with Trump and Starmer is expected. Police have warned that the scale of the operation could stretch resources, with the Scottish Police Federation stating it may double response times elsewhere.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store