Singleton family agree to judgment in favour of Nine in landmark court battle
Had the NSW Supreme Court case proceeded to a hearing, the decision would have had implications for all Australian media outlets. The litigation was expected to involve a fight over the scope of a fair dealing exception in copyright laws, which allows images and video to be used for 'the reporting of news'.
Singleton's fiance, NSW police officer Ashley Wildey, and her mother, Julie Singleton, filed the lawsuit in April before Nine's 60 Minutes aired an interview with her father, former adman John Singleton.
Their claim was later expanded to include the publishing companies behind Nine-owned newspapers including the Herald, The Age and The Australian Financial Review.
Shortly before the trial, which was expected to run for two days from Tuesday, the parties agreed to orders entering judgment in favour of the Nine entities. The Supreme Court made the orders on Monday afternoon. The parties will bear their own legal costs.
Loading
The copyright claim centred on Nine's use of two videos and five photos from Dawn Singleton's public social media accounts.
Wildey and Julie Singleton had asked the court to make a declaration that the Nine outlets had infringed their copyright in the videos and photos, an order permanently restraining them from using the films and images, and damages.
In a written defence filed in court, the Nine entities admitted that 'there exists a practice within the Australian media of sourcing photos … and videos … from publicly available social media pages and using those photos and videos for the purpose of, or associated with, the reporting of news'.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
8 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Prosecutors to argue Australian brothers were killed in ‘robbery gone wrong' while surfing in Mexico
Mexican prosecutors will argue in court this week that the execution-style deaths of two Australian brothers last year was a robbery gone wrong, with no indication local drug cartels were involved. The bodies of Callum Robinson, 33, his brother Jake, 30, and their American friend Jack Carter Rhoad, 30 were found dumped in a well with gunshot wounds to the head in early May last year near Santo Tomas, in Baja California, one of Mexico's most violent states. About a week earlier, on April 27, the trio had travelled south from Ensenada to a remote beach, Punta San José, which is popular with local surfers during the summer months. The friends set up camp that afternoon in the area, which has limited electricity and phone signal, and the state attorney-general's office says they were robbed the same day, by a criminal gang that wanted the tyres on their pick-up truck. The vehicle was also later found burnt-out in Santo Tomás. Three Mexican men – identified as Jesús Gerardo, aka 'El Kekas', Irineo Francisco, and Ángel Jesús – have been arrested over the deaths and charged with aggravated homicide and robbery, robbery with violence and car theft. The attorney-general's office says the men do not have any affiliation with local drug cartels. They will appear before a judge in Baja California State Court in Ensenada on Thursday. A spokesperson for the attorney-general said there was sufficient evidence to proceed with legal action against all three men on the homicide and robbery charges, as well as on a charge of forced disappearance, which is similar to kidnapping. Chief prosecutor Miguel Ángel Gaxiola Rodríguez told the ABC that he would pursue the theory that the deaths were a robbery gone wrong when the men appear in court.
The Age
8 hours ago
- The Age
Prosecutors to argue Australian brothers were killed in ‘robbery gone wrong' while surfing in Mexico
Mexican prosecutors will argue in court this week that the execution-style deaths of two Australian brothers last year was a robbery gone wrong, with no indication local drug cartels were involved. The bodies of Callum Robinson, 33, his brother Jake, 30, and their American friend Jack Carter Rhoad, 30 were found dumped in a well with gunshot wounds to the head in early May last year near Santo Tomas, in Baja California, one of Mexico's most violent states. About a week earlier, on April 27, the trio had travelled south from Ensenada to a remote beach, Punta San José, which is popular with local surfers during the summer months. The friends set up camp that afternoon in the area, which has limited electricity and phone signal, and the state attorney-general's office says they were robbed the same day, by a criminal gang that wanted the tyres on their pick-up truck. The vehicle was also later found burnt-out in Santo Tomás. Three Mexican men – identified as Jesús Gerardo, aka 'El Kekas', Irineo Francisco, and Ángel Jesús – have been arrested over the deaths and charged with aggravated homicide and robbery, robbery with violence and car theft. The attorney-general's office says the men do not have any affiliation with local drug cartels. They will appear before a judge in Baja California State Court in Ensenada on Thursday. A spokesperson for the attorney-general said there was sufficient evidence to proceed with legal action against all three men on the homicide and robbery charges, as well as on a charge of forced disappearance, which is similar to kidnapping. Chief prosecutor Miguel Ángel Gaxiola Rodríguez told the ABC that he would pursue the theory that the deaths were a robbery gone wrong when the men appear in court.
Sydney Morning Herald
9 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
‘I won't shake his hand': In a sport full of confected hate, SBW-Gallen feud is very real
The news comes as no surprise to Williams. 'He said he isn't going to shake my hand and I couldn't give two flying f's, to tell the truth,' Williams counters. 'I don't have hate for anyone, I'm a pretty cruisy guy. But at the end of the day, it is what it is. I'm one to stand up for myself and what I believe in, 150 per cent. That's my path. 'You don't want to shake my hand, I don't give two damns. But I'm going to win this fight.' After more than a decade of false starts, Williams and Gallen will finally enter the ring at Sydney's Qudos Bank Arena on Wednesday night. The fight will be held over eight two-minute rounds – another point of contention – with each expected to walk away with an even split of about $1 million each. The one thing the former footballers agree on is that this will be their final fight; one last hurrah before retiring. Already they have registered low blows, delighting in digging up each other's drugs dramas: Gallen's involvement in Cronulla's peptides scandal, dubbed the 'blackest day in Australian sport'; Williams' admission that he dabbled in illicit substances early in his league career. Their first face-off will be at a press conference on Monday, although both have thrown barbs from afar. When Williams finally gets the chance to stare down his opponent, what does he expect to see? 'I see a fraud, that's what I see,' he says. 'I see a guy who would argue with a five-year-old kid to prove his point. We just don't mix; he's not my cup of tea. He never has been, never will be. 'The only difference is he has a track record of making it personal with every fight he's had. For me, it's the first time it's felt like a real fight, not a sports event. 'I've got to get through the next couple of days, listen to him talk trash, say things to try to rile me up. But the reality is the one who has been riled up the most is him. He doesn't like the facts that have been pointed out that the media cover up. This guy is a drug cheat. 'He's in the NSW hall of fame. What for? For the longest losing streak? [A reference to his stint as NSW Origin skipper]. 'This is not a good human being, and he's the one trying to come to me and give a moral lesson. No thank you. 'The next few days can't pass fast enough. I just want to get to fight night and show him how limited he is.' Both men have been able to parlay their feats and notoriety into a mammoth payday. Neither pretends to be world-class, but both can hold up their hands. Williams was once the New Zealand heavyweight champion and briefly a WBA titleholder, while Gallen's only losses, against the credentialled Justin Huni and Kris Terzievski, gained him the most respect from the purists. Their boxing legacy will be bringing new eyeballs to a sport, with promoters hoping that record numbers will tune in when their stoush is shown live and exclusively on Stan which, like this masthead, is owned by Nine Entertainment. To date, Gallen's most famous punch was delivered on the footy field, to the head of Nate Myles during the 2013 State of Origin series. It remains to be seen whether he can land a more memorable blow on Williams. 'That would be nice,' Gallen says. 'I'm not proud of that [Myles punch]. I'd much rather have won the series than throw a punch.' Some bookmakers haven't been able to split the pair. At 39, Williams is four years younger and has a decided reach advantage. Gallen's challenge will be finding enough time within the allotted 16 minutes to get close enough to land meaningful blows from close range. 'I win because I have the better skill set, and I've gone a long way in correcting what happened last fight,' Williams says of the only blemish on his professional record, a KO loss to Mark Hunt. 'What the bloke in the last fight had, this bloke doesn't have – true knockout power. Paul doesn't have that.' There will be no secret to Gallen's approach. Just like he did on the footy field, the former NSW and Cronulla skipper will keep marching forward. Loading 'Sonny Bill and his coaches would have gone into games hoping he would play well, hoping he would find a flick pass or make a break or score a try,' Gallen says. 'My coach never had to worry about that, they always knew what they were going to get. That's what is going to happen in this fight. He knows I'm going to be in front of him. There's no secret to this fight, what I'm going to do, how I'm going to fight. He knows I'm going to be there. 'Is he good enough to knock me out? I don't think he is. I'm going to be relentless and I'll wear him out.'
