Palms West beating: Judge denies bail, house arrest for patient arrested in attack on nurse
(This story was updated because because an earlier version included an inaccuracy.)
WEST PALM BEACH — A judge has ordered that the man accused of beating a nurse at HCA Florida Palms West Hospital and fracturing 'essentially every bone' in her face remain in jail without bail.
Stephen Scantlebury, 33, from Wellington, is facing a charge of attempted second-degree murder in the Feb. 18 attack on Leelamma Lal, a 67-year old nurse from Royal Palm Beach who remains in critical condition at St. Mary's Medical Center in West Palm Beach and may lose her eyesight.
The Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office also enhanced the charge to a hate crime saying Scantlebury had "made utterances" about the victim's gender, race or religion but did not specify which one. Lal is of Indian descent.
From the courts: Boca businessman who stole $1.45 million from 'friend' asks judge to spare him from prison
Scantlebury pleaded not guilty during a hearing Tuesday at the county jail, his first court appearance since the attack. His wife and children were also present in the courtroom, said Scott Simmons, his attorney with the Rossen Law Firm.
Circuit Judge Donald Hafele declined Simmons' request that Scantlebury be released on $125,000 bond, placed on house arrest and taken to a treatment facility.
The law firm issued a statement last week describing him as "a hardworking, loving husband, father and son" who is dealing with a form of mental illness it did not disclose. It cautioned that the public "has only heard one side of the story — the side presented by law enforcement" and said "the complete story" will come out in time.
After Hafele ordered Scantlebury remain in custody, Dr. Cindy Joseph, Lal's daughter and a neurologist with a practice in Melbourne, told the judge the family wouldn't feel safe if Scantlebury was allowed to go home and that he was a safety risk for the community.
Flanked by a dozen family members and a group of nurses, Joseph added her mother was intubated and still "fighting for her life."
"If he is released and disappears, justice for my mom will not be served,' Joseph said. 'Because of his actions, our lives will never be the same. We live in fear, constantly looking over our shoulders knowing that someone who's capable of such violence could walk free.'
Hafele on Tuesday directed the court to schedule a pretrial detention hearing for Scantlebury, where the issue of his bail and release could arise again. An initial case conference before Circuit Judge Caroline Shepherd is scheduled for April 10, online records show.
Boynton Beach homicide: PBSO says man accused of killing neighbor acted 'extremely weird' before attack
According to a sheriff's report, Lal was caring for Scantlebury, who had been evaluated at the hospital for mental-health issues under the state's Baker Act. Upon entering his room, Scantlebury jumped on top of Lal and hit her repeatedly with fists fracturing before fleeing the hospital.
Deputies arrested the 33-year-old Wellington resident as he ran along Southern Boulevard.
The beating has alarmed nurses and health care workers across Palm Beach County, many of whom rallied Sunday outside Palms West and at the Jerome Golden Center in West Palm Beach. A 2018 federal Bureau of Labor Statistics study found health care workers suffered nearly 75% of all cases of workforce violence.
A GoFundMe page launched by a friend of Lal's family to raise money for her care had raised nearly $135,000 as of Tuesday afternoon.
Sign up for our Post on Wellington weekly newsletter, delivered every Thursday!
Valentina Palm covers Royal Palm Beach, Wellington, Greenacres, Palm Springs and other western communities in Palm Beach County for The Palm Beach Post. Email her at vpalm@pbpost.com and follow her on X, the platform formerly known as Twitter, at @ValenPalmB. Support local journalism: Subscribe today.
This article originally appeared on Palm Beach Post: Palms West beating: Judge denies bail for patient in attack on nurse
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
4 hours ago
- USA Today
Viral Newark airport video sparks outrage, US Embassy says visiting not a right
Hear this story AI-assisted summary A person was detained at Newark Airport, prompting the U.S. Embassy in India to reiterate that visiting the U.S. is a privilege, not a right. A witness recorded the incident and shared it on social media, alleging the detainee, possibly an Indian student, was treated harshly. The Consulate General of India in New York is investigating the situation and is in contact with local authorities. The U.S. Embassy in India is reminding travelers that visiting the U.S. is not a right, days after images surfaced of a person being pinned to the ground at New Jersey's Newark Liberty International Airport. 'The United States continues to welcome legitimate travelers to our country. However, there is no right to visit the United States,' the embassy posted across social media platforms on Tuesday. 'We cannot and will not tolerate illegal entry, abuse of visas, or the violation of U.S. law.' While the statement wasn't tied to a particular incident, it comes on the heels of video shared by Kunal Jain, a longtime U.S. resident and self-described Indo-American social entrepreneur who moved back to India last year, according to his profile on X, formerly Twitter. 'I witnessed a young Indian student being deported from Newark Airport last night— handcuffed, crying, treated like a criminal. He came chasing dreams, not causing harm,' Jain posted on X on Sunday, along with videos and photos that have amassed more than 1.7 million views. In interviews with India's NewsX and NDTV, Jain said he was preparing to board a United Airlines flight to New Delhi, when he spotted the person in custody. Need a break? Play the USA TODAY Daily Crossword Puzzle. 'Initially that boy was sitting on the chair, but then later on what he started doing is he started (hitting) his head to the wall, and that's when I think these authorities realized that he may hurt himself or he may do something crazy,' Jain told NewsX. 'They have pinned him down on the floor and they sit on him, and that's when he started yelling and screaming.' Jain added that authorities wanted to board the person on the plane, but the pilot said, 'No, I cannot allow as of this moment because he's violent and he could be a threat to the existing passengers.' Jain added that he and a doctor offered to speak to the person in Hindi, but were not allowed. He doesn't know what happened next, but he and others on social media have called on the Indian government to step in and bring the person 'home.' On Monday, the Consulate General of India, New York shared on X, 'We have come across social media posts claiming that an Indian national is facing difficulties at Newark Liberty International Airport. We are in touch with local authorities in this regard. The Consulate remains ever committed for the welfare of Indian Nationals.' A State Department official said they've also seen the reports but don't have any additional information and referred USA TODAY to local authorities. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, which oversees the airport, referred USA TODAY to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, which has not yet replied. While it's unclear if the person in custody was a student, the Trump administration has been cracking down on international students and on entering the U.S. in general. Additionally, President Donald Trump's latest travel ban, which took effect Monday, bans or heavily restricts travel to U.S. by foreign nationals from nearly 20 countries – though India is not one of them. Coming to America? What happens if you're denied entry into the US 'They don't want any foreigners unauthorized illegal foreigners to come into the country and take the advantage of the resources,' Jain told NDTV, calling that a 'great policy.' However, he added that even with foreign students legally allowed in the country, 'They are becoming more and more watchful, and every act is being monitored.' Jain has said he isn't trying to get into politics or legal matters, but wants to see justice and human dignity.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Commerce man sentenced in death of 10-week old baby
TULSA, Okla. — A Commerce man was sentenced to 20 years in a federal prison for the beating death of a 10-week-old girl. Michael David Gregory, 30, pleaded guilty in March to reduced charges of voluntary manslaughter and assault resulting in serious bodily injury, in the death of 10-week-old Amaya Mae Robison and the assault of her twin sister, both in Indian Country. Robison, of Vinita, died Dec. 3, 2022, from blunt force trauma to her head, according to her autopsy. The other twin sister also had a small brain bleed; however, she has made a full recovery, court documents show. U.S. District Judge Sara E. Hill sentenced Gregory to three years of supervised probation following his release. The girls were two of four children whose mother had abandoned them. Child Protective Services took one daughter, according to court records, the other girls were left with a neighbor and Gregory's girlfriend at the time, Shanna Kimbro. The twins were just 10 days old when the mother left them with Gregory and Kimbro, court records show. Court records show Gregory 'had no idea how to care for a baby, much less two of them.' In his plea agreement, Gregory said he was responsible for the twin infants while his girlfriend went to work. Gregory confessed, 'I was often forceful when I picked up or laid down' the twin girls, 'which is not proper care for newborn infants.' On Dec. 1, 2022, he called his girlfriend, saying one of the infants had stopped breathing. Gregory is not a member of a federally recognized tribe. However, the apartment in which Gregory cared for the twins is located on the Quapaw Nation reservation, and both infants are considered 'Indian persons' because they are eligible for membership in the Choctaw Nation. Gregory will report to the United States Bureau of Prisons facility on July 22, court records show. Online court records show the biological mother has not been charged. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Forbes
8 hours ago
- Forbes
The Future Of Healthcare Is Collaborative—And AI Is The Catalyst
Collaboration and AI in Indian health care A quiet revolution is underway in the heart of a radiology lab at Apollo Hospitals in Chennai, India. Artificial intelligence is scanning high-resolution images, flagging anomalies, reducing the time for diagnosis, and improving accuracy. But what makes this advancement so powerful isn't just the algorithm behind it. It's the collaboration between a hospital, a tech company, and a university that makes AI innovation sustainable, scalable, and relevant to India's complex healthcare landscape. Across India, a new model of digital health transformation is emerging, one where partnerships are as crucial as platforms. For a country grappling with massive disparities in healthcare access and delivery, this shift couldn't be more timely. These are the observations and conclusions from my peer, Dr. Priyanka Shrivastava, who is a Professor of Marketing & Analytics at Hult International Business School and an Executive Fellow at The Digital Economist. India's healthcare system faces deep challenges: a rapidly growing population, stark urban-rural divides, a chronic shortage of medical professionals, and overstretched public infrastructure. While the proliferation of health-tech startups has brought promise, much of the innovation remains confined to urban pockets or pilot projects. AI detects disease, streamlines diagnosis, and personalizes treatment. Tools like AI-powered nutrition coaches (HealthifyMe's Ria) and automated diagnostic assistants (such as those used by Aindra or Columbia Asia Hospital) are transforming the delivery of healthcare. Yet, these tools often encounter barriers due to a lack of interoperability, fragmented data systems, regulatory uncertainty, and resistance from overworked staff who fear that AI might be more of a disruption than an aid. Technology alone cannot fix healthcare. But technology plus collaboration just might. In a recent study, Dr. Shrivastava and her colleagues surveyed 300 healthcare professionals across 50 institutions and held in-depth interviews with doctors, technologists, and policymakers. The results were striking: institutions with strong cross-sector collaborations consistently showed higher and more sustained AI adoption. Three core insights emerged: Urban hospitals often have access to advanced technology and data, whereas rural clinics often lack even basic diagnostic capabilities. But when these entities partner via telemedicine links, shared platforms, or co-funding arrangements, AI can extend its reach. For example, Apollo's AI systems, when linked with satellite clinics, enable faster referrals and better triage in underserved regions. Resistance to AI isn't irrational—it often stems from a lack of understanding. The study found that joint workshops, where doctors and engineers co-learned and co-created, built buy-in from healthcare workers. When staff are trained with the tools and understand how they were developed, they are far more likely to embrace them. AI isn't plug-and-play. It requires regular updates, feedback loops, and cultural alignment. Institutions that formalized collaboration through MOUs, shared R&D labs, or co-published studies were more likely to sustain AI programs over the long term. Apollo's AI-driven radiology initiative in Chennai is a textbook example. Faced with long diagnosis times and overburdened radiologists, the hospital sought a solution. Instead of simply buying an off-the-shelf AI tool, Apollo co-developed one with a university, providing algorithm expertise, and a startup delivering the technical infrastructure. Doctors and developers worked side by side. The result? Diagnosis time dropped by 30%, and accuracy improved by 15%. Radiologists weren't replaced—they were enhanced, with AI acting as a second pair of eyes. Continuous training and feedback ensured the system evolved with practice. This wasn't a one-off deployment. It was an ecosystem. And that made all the difference. While Apollo represents a private success, the public sector isn't far behind. India's eSanjeevani platform, which added AI-supported teleconsultation features during the pandemic, saw a 40% increase in rural usage. This shows that with the right support and scale, AI can democratize access to care. The National Digital Health Mission is another promising initiative. If executed well—with strong data privacy frameworks and open APIs—it can offer a common layer for innovation. Startups can plug into public records; government hospitals can access AI-enabled diagnostics; researchers can draw insights from anonymized data. But for this to happen, policymakers must prioritize collaboration frameworks just as much as digital infrastructure. As India enters a defining decade for health innovation, here are four actionable takeaways from the research: Tax breaks, innovation grants, and pilot funding for joint ventures in AI health can catalyze adoption. Startups gain credibility and scale; public hospitals get access to frontier tech. Set up AI literacy programs for frontline health workers. Encourage interdisciplinary training so doctors, nurses, and tech teams speak a common language. A national framework on health data interoperability is overdue. Without this, AI solutions cannot scale beyond one institution. Build trust through consent-driven, encrypted data-sharing norms. Mandate impact audits for all health AI deployments—measuring not just tech efficiency, but patient outcomes, staff satisfaction, and system-level equity. The most inspiring part of this story? AI in Indian healthcare isn't being driven solely by top-down mandates or Silicon Valley imports. It's being shaped organically by Indian doctors, engineers, policy thinkers, and entrepreneurs who are joining forces. This pluralistic model with many voices but one mission could well become a template for emerging economies around the world. In a landscape where access to a doctor can mean the difference between life and death, AI's potential is undeniable. But its success will depend on something far more human: our ability to collaborate. The most transformative technology for health care is not an algorithm. It is the alignment of purpose, people, vision, and AI through collaboration.
