‘In your hands': Exchange moments before Air India crash
Initial findings from India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) reported that fuel control switches to the engines were moved from the "run" to the "cut-off" position moments before impact.
It also included an exchange in which one of the pilots asked the other why the fuel switches had been moved, without identifying the speakers.
Two sources familiar with the matter claim that earlier in the recording, Captain Sumeet Sabharwal told First Officer Clive Kunder, 'the plane is in your hands,' Italian newspaper Corriere della Sera reports.
It isn't unusual for a First Officer to fly the plane at various points, including take off.
But US pilots who have read the initial findings from the AAIB into the crash were cited in The Wall Street Journal on Thursday as saying Mr Kunder would likely have had his hands full flying the plane when the fuel switches were turned off.
That meant Captain Sabharwal, who was monitoring, would be more likely to have moved the switches.
Captain Sabharwal was a veteran in the industry while Mr Kunder was in his early thirties and still building his career.
Air India flight 171 bound for London's Gatwick Airport, crashed in Ahmedabad just 30 seconds into the flight, killing all but one of the 242 people on board and an additional 19 on the ground.
India's aviation regulator ordered the country's airlines this week to investigate the locking feature on the fuel control switches of several Boeing models.
Air India's inspection of the locking feature on the switches of its existing Boeing 787 aircraft found no issues, an internal communication circulated within the airline said.
The order to investigate came after Boeing notified operators that the fuel switch locks on its jets were safe.
'Over the weekend, our engineering team initiated precautionary inspections on the locking mechanism of Fuel Control Switch (FCS) on all our Boeing 787 aircraft,' the airline's flight operations department said in a communication to its pilots.
'The inspections have been completed and no issues were found,' the communication said, noting that it had complied with the regulator's directives.
It said all of its Boeing 787-8 aircraft had also undergone 'Throttle Control Module (TCM) replacement as per the Boeing maintenance schedule', adding that the FCS was part of this module.
India's AAIB said it was still 'too early to reach any definite conclusions'.
It said the investigation's final report would come out with 'root causes and recommendations'.
'We urge the public and the media to refrain from spreading premature narratives that risk undermining the integrity of the investigative process,' it said in a statement.
– With AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
a day ago
- News.com.au
‘I would cry': Dating clip sparks etiquette debate
Gen Z is a different breed from their elders, but they're also still pretty big on one type of etiquette. A London local, who goes by the username MissingDevon, posted a video of a group of people recently dining out at a restaurant. The dining layout was a classic booth arrangement, where one person sat on a comfortable, lounge-like chair and the other sat on an ordinary dining chair. If you're the person who gets the regular dining chair, you're also the one who has their back to the comings and goings of a restaurant. So waiters and people are constantly strolling past you. The clip showed a group of couples sitting down to eat, and while two of the men sat in the normal dining chairs, giving the women the more comfortable booths, one woman was sitting in a dining chair with her back to the ongoing bustle of a busy restaurant. MissingDevon posted the video with the caption, 'only a girl could tell you what is wrong in this video', and she seems to have been right. The clip amassed 5 million views and the comment section was filled with young women arguing that the woman should be sitting in a comfortable booth. 'Why is she sitting on the chair?' One asked. 'The princess should be on the couch,' someone else argued. 'I would cry if he made me sit on the chair and he took the booth,' another confessed. 'He has taken the comfy cushion seat, making her sit on the wooden chair, and all the other guys are on chairs,' someone else observed. 'Wrong seat, fella,' another criticised. Interestingly, though, it wasn't unanimous, with others arguing men should sit themselves facing the exits. 'It's common etiquette for the man to always be facing the door,' one argued. 'I think that's correct, so the man can see any danger entering the building first,' one argued. While someone else argued the man in the booth was in the right position because he could observe the entire restaurant and 'protect' his date. 'A man wants to see the entry. It's to see potential danger,' another man argued, but a woman replied and said 'there's no danger' in a cocktail bar. 'Why can't a man be comfy?' Another asked. Others argued it isn't 'that deep' and that no one knows their situation and perhaps the woman prefers the wooden chair. Relationship expert Elizabeth Jane told said that there's actually no wrong or right move in terms of who gets what seat in dating etiquette. 'I think that Gen Z men tend to be more emotionally expressive and are more comfortable with fluidity in gender roles, so taking the booth may not be viewed as ill-mannered, as both may view themselves as equals, and who takes the booth becomes quite irrelevant to them,' she said. 'It may come down to more practical considerations as to who takes the booth. The larger person may feel more comfortable in the booth, which may be larger or more sturdy.' Ms Jane argued that Millennial men may still be 'emotionally evolving,' so they are more keen to stick to traditional gender roles. The relationship expert argued that etiquette norms are still a big part of dating for Gen Z but the standards are shifting. 'I wouldn't say that etiquette norms are dying but rather they are transforming or at least adjusting to more relaxed rules on how a man and a woman should behave, gender roles are beginning to merge,' she said. 'They tend not to get lost in gender roles where they are seeking approval from older generations as to how they should act and what they should say'.
The Advertiser
a day ago
- The Advertiser
Death toll rises to 27 in Bangladesh air force crash
At least 27 people have been killed after a Bangladesh air force training jet crashed into a college and school campus in Dhaka, officials say, with 88 people, including children, being treated in hospital. The aircraft crashed soon after it took off from an airbase in the capital on a routine training mission. The military said the plane experienced a mechanical failure. Sayedur Rahman, special assistant to the chief adviser on health, told reporters that 27 people had died and 88 were admitted to hospital with burn injuries after the crash on Monday, local time. The government announced a day of mourning, with flags at half-mast and special prayers at all places of worship. The pilot was among those killed in the incident, the military said, adding that a committee had been formed to investigate what happened. The jet, a F-7 BGI, is the final and most advanced variant in China's Chengdu J-7/F-7 aircraft family, according to Jane's Information Group. Bangladesh signed a contract for 16 aircraft in 2011 and deliveries were completed by 2013. The crash comes weeks after an Air India plane crashed into a medical college hostel in Ahmedabad in neighbouring India, killing 241 of the 242 people on board and 19 on the ground in the world's worst aviation disaster in a decade. At least 27 people have been killed after a Bangladesh air force training jet crashed into a college and school campus in Dhaka, officials say, with 88 people, including children, being treated in hospital. The aircraft crashed soon after it took off from an airbase in the capital on a routine training mission. The military said the plane experienced a mechanical failure. Sayedur Rahman, special assistant to the chief adviser on health, told reporters that 27 people had died and 88 were admitted to hospital with burn injuries after the crash on Monday, local time. The government announced a day of mourning, with flags at half-mast and special prayers at all places of worship. The pilot was among those killed in the incident, the military said, adding that a committee had been formed to investigate what happened. The jet, a F-7 BGI, is the final and most advanced variant in China's Chengdu J-7/F-7 aircraft family, according to Jane's Information Group. Bangladesh signed a contract for 16 aircraft in 2011 and deliveries were completed by 2013. The crash comes weeks after an Air India plane crashed into a medical college hostel in Ahmedabad in neighbouring India, killing 241 of the 242 people on board and 19 on the ground in the world's worst aviation disaster in a decade. At least 27 people have been killed after a Bangladesh air force training jet crashed into a college and school campus in Dhaka, officials say, with 88 people, including children, being treated in hospital. The aircraft crashed soon after it took off from an airbase in the capital on a routine training mission. The military said the plane experienced a mechanical failure. Sayedur Rahman, special assistant to the chief adviser on health, told reporters that 27 people had died and 88 were admitted to hospital with burn injuries after the crash on Monday, local time. The government announced a day of mourning, with flags at half-mast and special prayers at all places of worship. The pilot was among those killed in the incident, the military said, adding that a committee had been formed to investigate what happened. The jet, a F-7 BGI, is the final and most advanced variant in China's Chengdu J-7/F-7 aircraft family, according to Jane's Information Group. Bangladesh signed a contract for 16 aircraft in 2011 and deliveries were completed by 2013. The crash comes weeks after an Air India plane crashed into a medical college hostel in Ahmedabad in neighbouring India, killing 241 of the 242 people on board and 19 on the ground in the world's worst aviation disaster in a decade. At least 27 people have been killed after a Bangladesh air force training jet crashed into a college and school campus in Dhaka, officials say, with 88 people, including children, being treated in hospital. The aircraft crashed soon after it took off from an airbase in the capital on a routine training mission. The military said the plane experienced a mechanical failure. Sayedur Rahman, special assistant to the chief adviser on health, told reporters that 27 people had died and 88 were admitted to hospital with burn injuries after the crash on Monday, local time. The government announced a day of mourning, with flags at half-mast and special prayers at all places of worship. The pilot was among those killed in the incident, the military said, adding that a committee had been formed to investigate what happened. The jet, a F-7 BGI, is the final and most advanced variant in China's Chengdu J-7/F-7 aircraft family, according to Jane's Information Group. Bangladesh signed a contract for 16 aircraft in 2011 and deliveries were completed by 2013. The crash comes weeks after an Air India plane crashed into a medical college hostel in Ahmedabad in neighbouring India, killing 241 of the 242 people on board and 19 on the ground in the world's worst aviation disaster in a decade.
SBS Australia
a day ago
- SBS Australia
Dozens killed or injured as plane crashes into school in Bangladesh
The mood is sombre in the Bangladeshi capital of Dhaka, where the country's worst aviation disaster in decades has killed at least 20 people. On Monday, a Bangladeshi fighter jet crashed into the Milestone School and College. Many of the victims were young students, let out of class just moments before a mechanical failure caused the plane to collide with the two-storey building. Muhammad Yunus is the Head of Bangladesh's Interim Government. He says everyone must support each other through this tragedy. "I have no words. I don't know how to begin. None of us ever imagined it. It wasn't within anyone's expectations. But we had to suddenly accept this unbelievable reality. We extend our deepest sympathies to the parents, families, and loved ones. Every child in Bangladesh is your child. Please try to find comfort among yourselves. We are all trying to comfort one another. What a tremendous tragedy this is. We are with you. The entire nation stands with you." The Bangladeshi military says that the aircraft, a Chinese-made F-7 BJI aircraft, encountered a mechanical failure. Located north of the city's international airport and military base, the Milestone School and College is a well-known private school that teaches kindergarten through high school. The military says the pilot, who died in the crash, attempted to divert the aircraft away from the densely populated area. Officials say the cause remains under investigation. One student at the school says many were still in class when they heard a huge blast. 'Most of the students were in class — it was probably break time, so a few students were coming out, but the majority were still in class. There was a lady teacher with me who said that the lady teacher in the next room had one side of her face completely burned. Even when I arrived here, there was a teacher with me — the side of his back, his face, and his hands were severely burned. His condition was really bad." As grieving and fearful relatives flowed through the hospitals, dozens lined up to donate blood to the injured. With some bodies yet to be identified, families searched frantically for their relatives. Soldiers at the crash site used megaphones to control the panicked crowds, complicated further by the area's dense population, a nearby train station and surrounding businesses. A father who was looking for his daughter rushed to the school on hearing the news of the crash. "The plane crashed in the building where my daughter was. My wife called me but I was praying so I could not pick up. After finishing payers, I called her and she said crying that a plane has crashed into a building where my daughter's class is. I did not know what to do and then left, and when I came here I saw there was a huge fire. There was a dead body of a child." The father, who went only by Jewel, says he had been looking for about 20 minutes when he got the call. "I could not get any news of my daughter. But after about 20 minutes, she called me and told me that she is fine, don't be tense. My daughter went (from the school) to her friend's home with her mother. In the meantime, I saw many injured (people), skin peeling off the injured." As well as the at least 20 people killed in the crash, more than 170 people were injured, most aged between eight and fourteen years old. Witnesses say the collision caused a major blast, shaking the building before catching fire. Rescued from the smouldering two-storey building, many suffered burns and were taken away in helicopters, motorised rickshaws and the arms of firefighters and parents. Harunur Rashid is a resident surgeon at the Dhaka Medical College Hospital. 'Most of the patients are children. Less than 12 years (old). This is the age group of the patients. Critical patients are also them (children). But one person, her age is 40 years old, she is a servant (staff) of that school, she is also admitted in our hospital.' Just last month, a commercial aircraft crashed in neighbouring India, killing 260 people. Despite strained relations between India and Bangladesh, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi says he is deeply shocked and saddened at the news. In a statement, he writes that India stands in solidarity with Bangladesh and is ready to extend all possible support. The crash was the worst aviation accident in Bangladesh since 1984, when a plane flying to Dhaka crashed and killed all 49 on board. Dr Asif Nazrul, a law advisor in the Interim Government, says tomorrow will be a day of mourning. 'The hospital authorities and the National Burn Unit have informed us that they have completed all the necessary preparations for treatment. Even then, if needed, doctors will be brought in from abroad. If necessary, the students currently in the burn unit will be sent abroad for treatment. There will be no shortage in treatment or rehabilitation. However, no matter what is done, nothing can compensate for the loss we have suffered today. Tomorrow has been declared a day of national mourning, and the national flag will be flown at half-staff.'
