Economists are as confused as Trump about taxing the rich
If you want to put a policymaker on the spot, ask them what the top rate of income tax should be. The question befuddles everyone. Last month, Donald Trump broke with decades of Republican convention when he reportedly urged Mike Johnson, the speaker of the House of Representatives, to increase America's highest federal levy on incomes from 37 per cent to 39.6 per cent, where it stood before the president's own reforms in 2017. Trump then took to social media to announce that although he would 'graciously accept' such a change 'in order to help the lower and middle income workers', Republicans in Congress 'should probably not do it'. He is nevertheless 'OK if they do'.
This is usually the point at which to compare Trump's haphazard argument with the staid advice of economists. But they seem just as confused as the president. Their research on the best level for the top rate of income tax can include statements such as: 'alternative parameter values give a range of -26 per cent to 50 per cent' (you read that right: a negative tax for top earners may be best). Other economists recommend rates as high as 70 per cent or more, once taxes at all levels of government and income are included.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AU Financial Review
an hour ago
- AU Financial Review
Trump and Xi speak on phone with tensions edging up
Chinese President Xi Jinping spoke by phone with US President Donald Trump on Thursday, Chinese state media reported, as tensions between the two countries over trade resurfaced. The call came in the wake of renewed accusations between Washington and Beijing over violations of a trade deal struck weeks earlier in Geneva. The agreement, aimed at easing tensions, included a 90-day mutual tariff reduction that Trump described as a 'total reset.'
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Xi and Trump have spoken by phone: Chinese reports
Chinese President Xi Jinping has held talks with US President Donald Trump by phone, China's state-run news agency Xinhua reports, as bilateral relations have been strained by trade disputes. The phone talks were at Trump's request, Xinhua said, without providing further details about the leaders' conversation. The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The highly anticipated call comes amid accusations between the United States and China in recent weeks over critical minerals in a dispute that threatens to tear up a fragile truce in the trade conflict between the governments of the two biggest economies. The countries struck a 90-day deal on May 12 to roll back some of the triple-digit, tit-for-tat tariffs they had placed on each other since Trump's January inauguration. We call on the U.S. to uphold the market principle of fair competition, stop politicizing trade issues, and provide a fair, just and non-discriminatory environment for Chinese and other foreign will do what is necessary to defend Chinese businesses' legitimate… CHINA MFA Spokesperson 中国外交部发言人 (@MFA_China) June 5, 2025 Although stocks rallied, the temporary deal did not address broader concerns that strain the bilateral relationship, from the illicit fentanyl trade to the status of democratically governed Taiwan and US complaints about China's state-dominated export-driven economic model. Since returning to the White House in January, Trump has repeatedly threatened an array of punitive measures on trading partners, only to revoke some of them at the last minute. The on-again, off-again approach has baffled world leaders and spooked business executives, who say the uncertainty has made it difficult to forecast market conditions. China's decision in April to suspend exports of a wide range of critical minerals and magnets continues to disrupt supplies needed by car makers, computer chip manufacturers and military contractors around the world. China's government sees mineral exports as a source of leverage - halting those exports could put domestic political pressure on the Republican US president if economic growth sags because companies cannot produce mineral-powered products. The 90-day deal to roll back tariffs and trade restrictions is tenuous. Trump has accused China of violating the agreement and has ordered curbs on chip design software and other shipments to the country. China rejected the claim and threatened counter-measures. Trump has long pushed for a call or a meeting with Xi but China has rejected that as not in keeping with its traditional approach of working out agreement details before the leaders talk. Trump had declared one day earlier that it was difficult to reach a deal with Xi. "I like President XI of China, always have, and always will, but he is VERY TOUGH, AND EXTREMELY HARD TO MAKE A DEAL WITH!!!" Trump posted on Wednesday on his social media site. The US president and his aides see leader-to-leader talks as vital to sort through log-jams that have vexed lower-level officials in difficult negotiations. with AP
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
Xi and Trump have spoken by phone: Chinese reports
Chinese President Xi Jinping has held talks with US President Donald Trump by phone, China's state-run news agency Xinhua reports, as bilateral relations have been strained by trade disputes. The phone talks were at Trump's request, Xinhua said, without providing further details about the leaders' conversation. The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment. The highly anticipated call comes amid accusations between the United States and China in recent weeks over critical minerals in a dispute that threatens to tear up a fragile truce in the trade conflict between the governments of the two biggest economies. The countries struck a 90-day deal on May 12 to roll back some of the triple-digit, tit-for-tat tariffs they had placed on each other since Trump's January inauguration. Although stocks rallied, the temporary deal did not address broader concerns that strain the bilateral relationship, from the illicit fentanyl trade to the status of democratically governed Taiwan and US complaints about China's state-dominated export-driven economic model. Since returning to the White House in January, Trump has repeatedly threatened an array of punitive measures on trading partners, only to revoke some of them at the last minute. The on-again, off-again approach has baffled world leaders and spooked business executives, who say the uncertainty has made it difficult to forecast market conditions. China's decision in April to suspend exports of a wide range of critical minerals and magnets continues to disrupt supplies needed by car makers, computer chip manufacturers and military contractors around the world. China's government sees mineral exports as a source of leverage - halting those exports could put domestic political pressure on the Republican US president if economic growth sags because companies cannot produce mineral-powered products. The 90-day deal to roll back tariffs and trade restrictions is tenuous. Trump has accused China of violating the agreement and has ordered curbs on chip design software and other shipments to the country. China rejected the claim and threatened counter-measures. Trump has long pushed for a call or a meeting with Xi but China has rejected that as not in keeping with its traditional approach of working out agreement details before the leaders talk. Trump had declared one day earlier that it was difficult to reach a deal with Xi. "I like President XI of China, always have, and always will, but he is VERY TOUGH, AND EXTREMELY HARD TO MAKE A DEAL WITH!!!" Trump posted on Wednesday on his social media site. The US president and his aides see leader-to-leader talks as vital to sort through log-jams that have vexed lower-level officials in difficult negotiations. with AP
