A Chinese Morgan Stanley is worth an M&A shot
The U.S. bank, now run by Ted Pick, created CICC in 1995 as a joint venture with China Construction Bank (601939.SS), opens new tab. That was two years before the U.S. financial institution agreed to join forces with brokerage Dean Witter, Discover. The earnings diversification and access to a broader pool of investing clients - enhanced over the years by acquiring Citi's (C.N), opens new tab brokerage business and E*Trade - is one reason why Morgan Stanley trades at a premium to arch-rival Goldman Sachs (GS.N), opens new tab.
A CICC-China Galaxy combo would create China's third-largest brokerage with $190 billion in assets and could expect to emulate some of those business benefits. That makes it a different proposition to last year's merger of Guotai Junan Securities (601211.SS), opens new tab and Haitong Securities (600837.SS), opens new tab, which was commonly understood, opens new tab to effectively be a state-mandated bailout.
Not that CICC is sitting pretty. In recent years, regulators throttled the flow of listings in China's onshore markets as well as in Hong Kong, kneecapping the firm's bread-and-butter business. Its earnings are likely to have fallen 13% last year, analysts polled by LSEG reckon; China Galaxy's are forecast to rise 28%.
The diverging fortunes have flipped the script on how a deal might work. Citi analysts were already touting the tie-up a year ago, favouring CICC to be in charge courtesy of its bigger market capitalisation. That has since fallen to 129 billion yuan ($17.7 billion), putting 147 billion yuan China Galaxy into the driver's seat, they point out - just as Dean Witter was 28 years ago.
A deal would ostensibly be part of China's stated goal to produce two to three globally competitive investment banks and 10 leading institutions in the securities sector by 2035. CICC's pedigree suggests its successor entity would be expected to perform on the world stage against the likes of Goldman and Morgan Stanley.
Of course, a single deal will not immediately produce such a champion, especially when Beijing's ambitions lack detail. Independent of that, the standalone benefits of creating a Chinese version of Morgan Stanley makes it worth a shot.
Follow @KangHexin on X
CONTEXT NEWS
State-run investment bank CICC - or China International Capital Corp - is set to merge with broker China Galaxy Securities to create the country's third-largest brokerage with combined assets of $193 billion, Reuters reported on February 26, citing sources.
Both stocks posted double-digit gains in Hong Kong on the report before partly reversing course the following day, after the companies denied any consolidation plans from their top government shareholder Central Huijin Investment.
China's securities regulator announced plans a year ago to develop 10 leading firms and two to three internationally competitive investment banks via mergers, acquisitions and restructuring by 2035.
For more insights like these, click here, opens new tab to try Breakingviews for free.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
4 hours ago
- Reuters
Breakingviews - Figma IPO sketches case for direct listings
NEW YORK, Aug 1 (Reuters Breakingviews) - Precious few of Silicon Valley's self-professed renegades are ready to rebel against Wall Street. The madcap market debut of design-software developer Figma (FIG.N), opens new tab makes a case they should. An abundance of capital is already keeping companies private for longer, changing the rationale for going public. Doing so with the direct listing method, rather than a traditional initial public offering, would be more suitable. Figma sparked a frenzy by selling, opens new tab shares for $33 apiece on Wednesday after twice increasing its planned price range. By Thursday's end, they were trading for $115, giving the company a $56 billion valuation, nearly triple what rival Adobe was willing to pay for it in 2022. On Friday morning, the price hit $125. This mania does little for Figma beyond raising its profile. Having generated, opens new tab more than $200 million of adjusted free cash in the year through March, the 13-year-old firm led by Dylan Field wasn't seeking to raise much money and only sold about a third of the 37 million shares on offer. The rest came from earlier backers such as Index Ventures and Kleiner Perkins. Less than 8% of Figma's stock was available to investors who are, as ever, motivated by the fear of missing out on a fast-growing company. They ascribed a nonsensical valuation of 75 times last year's revenue. The biggest beneficiaries: financial advisers, including Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs, that were paid generous fees to sell the shares, and their clients who received early allocations and an immediate return. Direct listings are better tailored for situations like Figma's. Used previously by Spotify Technology (SPOT.N), opens new tab and Palantir Technologies (PLTR.O), opens new tab, the process enables existing owners to sell straight onto an exchange with fewer restrictions. Market forces also determine the price instead of closed-door roadshows that cede such power to big fund managers and investment banks, whose incentives differ. Although traditional IPOs make sense for many companies, well-capitalized brand-name ventures like financial plumbing provider Stripe are a growing breed. There are more than 1,200 firms worldwide with private valuations of at least $1 billion, according to research outfit CB Insights. Such unicorns, opens new tab increasingly go public so investors can cash out rather than to fund growth. And although the sample size is small, a dozen direct listings have generated, opens new tab a 42% five-year return on average compared to just 9% from thousands of IPOs spanning 1999 to 2021, per University of Florida finance professor Jay Ritter. Figma's buzz will inspire other founders to go public, but they would do well to be more creative. Follow Jeffrey Goldfarb on X, opens new tab and Linkedin, opens new tab.
Scottish Sun
6 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Legendary car brand pulls out of country forever as it shuts massive engine factory in move to rival Tesla
The carmaker is shifting its focus to electric vehicles KICKED TO KERB Legendary car brand pulls out of country forever as it shuts massive engine factory in move to rival Tesla A LEGENDARY car brand has called it quits in one of the world's biggest automotive markets, shutting down a major factory and ending local production for good. The firm has officially pulled out of China after decades of operations, closing its joint engine venture and handing over its factory to a domestic rival as it pivots towards electric vehicles. 2 Mitsubishi's relationship with China stretches back to 1973, when it began shipping mid-sized vehicles to the market Credit: YouTube / Mitsubishi Motors Europe SAME, which began producing engines in 1998, supplied not only Mitsubishi vehicles but also powertrains for a host of Chinese automakers. It will now operate under a new name: Shenyang Guoqing Power Technology Co., Ltd. Mitsubishi said it has: "terminated its engine business operation at Shenyang Aerospace Mitsubishi Motors Engine Manufacturing Co., Ltd. (hereinafter, SAME) in China and has terminated the joint venture partnership. "Established in August 1997, SAME began engine production in 1998 and has played a key role in China's expanding automotive market by supplying engines not only to Mitsubishi-branded vehicle manufacturers, but also to numerous Chinese automakers. " However, in response to the rapid transformation of China's automotive industry, Mitsubishi Motors has reassessed its strategy in the region and has decided to terminate its participation in the joint venture." Mitsubishi's relationship with China stretches back to 1973, when it began shipping mid-sized vehicles to the market. At one point in the early 2000s, its engines powered nearly 30 per cent of cars built in the country. But as China's car industry turned sharply toward new energy vehicles (NEVs), demand for traditional engines plummeted. In 2012, Mitsubishi joined forces with Guangzhou Automobile Group (GAC) and Mitsubishi Corporation to launch GAC Mitsubishi. The joint venture saw strong early success, especially with the Outlander SUV, which pushed sales to 144,000 units in 2018. But it didn't last - sales crashed to just 33,600 vehicles by 2022. Nissan 'on brink of collapse' after Renault deal falls through By the following year, Mitsubishi shut down local production and, in 2024, exited the market entirely. GAC has since taken over the plant and turned it into a production base for its EV brand, Aion. Industry analysts say Mitsubishi's retreat is just the latest in a broader trend. Foreign carmakers are losing ground in China as homegrown brands surge ahead in the electric vehicle market. GAC-FCA, a joint venture with Fiat Chrysler, also folded under similar pressures. Mitsubishi says the decision is part of a strategic shift as it focuses on electrification and more competitive global markets. But in China, the brand that once powered nearly a third of the country's cars is now just a memory. The collapse of its Chinese business is a blow for the brand, which had hoped to hold on in the world's biggest car market. But with EV start-ups popping up at lightning speed and government backing for green tech, Mitsubishi simply couldn't keep up. The factory closure also means job losses for hundreds of local workers, with some fearing they'll struggle to find work in an industry moving away from fossil fuels. One former worker said: 'We saw the writing on the wall last year. EVs are the future, and we weren't part of that plan anymore.' It's a bitter end for a brand once considered a key player in Chinese motoring. Now, it's packing up — leaving behind empty factories, lost jobs and a name that once meant something on Chinese roads. The Sun has approached Mitsubishi for comment. Iconic car brand 'on brink of collapse' as 'bosses warn company has just 12 months to survive' ONE of the world's largest car manufacturers reportedly could go under within 12 months if it doesn't receive support. The firm is looking to sure up its future by growing a partnership with its former rival after the reported collapse of a three-way alliance. Nissan was one-third of a strategic deal with Mitsubishi and Renault to share financial backing and expand all their markets in Europe, Japan and the US. The agreement dates back to 1999 but now could be on the brink of collapse. A report from the Financial Times cites two anonymous "senior officials" at the firm suggesting that Renault is looking to reduce its financial stake in the Japanese carmaker. The withdrawal of funding means, according to the same sources, that Nissan could require support from the Japanese or US governments within the next year just in order to stay afloat. One of the officials said: "We have 12 or 14 months to survive. "This is going to be tough. "And in the end, we need Japan and the US to be generating cash." Nissan has already cut 9,000 jobs across its global operation, while its CEO Makoto Uchida took a 50% pay cut in an economy drive. The business is working through an emergency recovery plan, which will see it cut output by 20% and slash around £2bn in costs. Its struggles have partly been blamed on the lack of a strong hybrid lineup, which has helped rivals like Toyota and Honda through the global collapse in EV sales. In a press conference earlier this month, Mr Uchida said: "This has been a lesson learned and we have not been able to keep up with the times. "We weren't able to foresee that hybrid electric vehicles and plug-in hybrids would be so popular."
The Herald Scotland
9 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Historic Scottish bus firm puts Falkirk factory on market
The site has been described as "an excellent housing opportunity" which could provide space for nearly two hundred homes. Alexander Dennis announced plans to consolidate operations and relocate to Scarborough in June, sparking concern from leading Scottish politicians. Alexander Dennis plans to move its Scottish operation to England. (Image: PA) The firm, which manufactures single decker and double decker buses, said the decision was made amidst rising competition from Chinese electric bus manufacturers. At the time, managing director Paul Davies said: 'We must take significant action to drive efficiency to allow our operating model to be competitive. "It is extremely regrettable that as part of this, we must place jobs at potential risk of redundancy and propose to cease manufacturing operations at some of our facilities." In July, The Herald exclusively revealed that the firm had received £90m in subsidies from the Scottish Government over the last five years, despite plans to reduce its workforce by a third. While operations at the Camelon factory are to cease with immediate effect, the firm's sister factory in Larbert is to remain open until current contracts are completed. A consultation of affected workers is ongoing. Earlier this week, the Scottish Government expressed optimism that the firm would remain in Falkirk. Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes said: 'We are hoping there is a package there which Alexander Dennis have indicated would satisfy their requirements to retain the jobs and retain the sites. "When I have discussed that with the unions and the company themselves, it is the one they feel most optimistic about. "We are very conscious that we're two weeks before the consultation ends, but our hope is that the consultation might be extended in order for us to work on potential solutions." Read more: How buying Chinese engulfed public funding row over Scots bus jobs going to England Swinney got year-long warning England-bound bus firm was 'reconsidering' Scotland FM in funding row as £90m public cash for Scots jobs given to firm going to England An Alexander Dennis spokesperson said: "This does not represent a foregone conclusion and a final decision has not yet been made. 'We have been honest with stakeholders about the need to address the condition of the Falkirk site for some time, which is why significant investment was made to expand our Larbert site for vehicle manufacturing during 2023 and 2024. 'Alexander Dennis continues to engage with governments in good faith and the company remains committed to exploring all possible outcomes at this time."
